The Gadfly Guys

The Gadfly Guys

By Jeremy dePriscoSociety & CultureTechnology
Download on the App Store

All The Gadfly Guys episodes

  • Babel, Chinese Rooms, and Wittgenstein

    Jeremy and Kurt start from Yuval Noah Harari’s use of the Tower of Babel to frame AI. They then work through Searle’s Chinese room and Wittgenstein on private languages, ending on institutions and Harari’s bureaucracy example. Kurt opens by clarifying that the show tests philosophical arguments and does not always state the hosts’ own views.

    Resources:

    AI is hacking the code of civilization | Yuval Noah Harari

    More about us:

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    1 hr 12 min
  • How to Think About AI

    Gadfly Guys hosts Jeremy dePrisco and Kurt Smith discuss the Netflix documentary “AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocalyptimist”, assessing its balance and the philosophical questions it leaves open. They examine whether present-day choices can harm future generations, how induction shapes AI predictions, and why debates about AI need ethical and political perspectives alongside technical expertise. Kurt and host Jeremy use classic philosophical puzzles and game theory to examine rational action, justice, cooperation, and the incentives shaping AI businesses. Their discussion connects Aquinas’s response to the omnipotence paradox with current concerns about competitive AI development, trust, regulation, and claims about future populations.

    Key topics

    * Jeremy dePrisco and Kurt Smith compare the documentary’s more balanced approach with the more sensationalized *AI Gone Wild*.

    * Smith argues that technical expertise does not automatically qualify someone to answer philosophical questions about what makes a good future.

    * Using Socrates’ idea of *techne*, Smith distinguishes specialized know-how from broader reasoning about ethics and public good.

    * The hosts explore whether future people can be harmed before they exist, using past technology harms and social media as grounds for inductive concern.

    * Smith explains David Hume’s problem of induction: we project past patterns onto the future, but experience cannot non-circularly prove that this projection is reliable.

    * They question conflicting AI promises: entrepreneurs will solve the technology’s problems, yet AI may also eliminate the need for work.

    * dePrisco describes precarious data-labeling and AI-training work, including low-paid or delayed-paid jobs and human labor used to train systems.

    * The hosts challenge the concentration of ownership and power, and consider whether doom and utopian narratives serve investment incentives.

    * Smith distinguishes whether AI can do something from whether it should, calling for humanities and philosophical voices in technology debates.

    * They discuss how films such as *The Matrix* can make difficult philosophical questions accessible without jargon. Kurt Smith explains how Aquinas reframes the stone paradox by questioning whether the request to lift a stone occupying all space is meaningful.

    * The speakers distinguish solving a philosophical problem from dissolving it by exposing a faulty concept or assumption.

    * Kurt outlines goal-directed rational action and applies it to game theory: choose actions likely to achieve your aim within the rules.

    * Using a farmer-and-chicken-rancher contract, they compare mutual cooperation with selfish defection and discuss trust in repeated interactions.

    * The conversation relates Thrasymachus’s view of justice as the “advantage of the stronger” to markets and competitive business behavior.

    * Kurt argues that AI companies may act as if they are in a one-turn, profit-maximizing game, rather than a repeated, collaborative game requiring trust.

    * Jeremy discusses companies relying on multiple AI systems and the risks of building products and infrastructure around those providers.

    * They consider whether users are customers or products, drawing a comparison to Facebook’s monetization and changing limits on business links.

    * Kurt challenges a documentary’s argument that slowing technology would prevent vast numbers of future people from existing, questioning its mathematical framing.

    Key frameworks

    Socratic techne: specialized, informed expertise and its limits outside its field

    Hume’s problem of induction: projecting patterns from past experience into the future

    The distinction between whether technology can do something and whether it should Goal-directed (teleological) rational action

    Repeated-game cooperation and trust

    Thrasymachus’s account of justice as the advantage of the stronger

    Takeaways

    The very case itself ... has ruled out the meaningfulness of the concept of lifting.

    The philosopher then doesn’t solve the problem ... Rather, it shows you that such a question is already doomed to backfire on us.

    To act rationally then on this model is to choose those actions ... that would likely bring about your intended goal.

    What’s rational to do will vary depending on the game and how it’s set up.

    If this is a multi-turn game ... you have to build trust, you have to be reliable and credible.

    What’s rational to do in a collective is very different than what it’s rational to do when you’re by your onesies.

    The business model ... is incompatible with the social collaborative model.

    We are the product, not the person receiving the product.

    I just don’t think that’s how you project into the future by ... giving what looks to be a scientific proof.

    Sound bites

    “You’re not born a thinker.”

    “We are the product.”

    Resources:

    The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt39150120/

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    1 hr 26 min
  • Marketing AI Doom

    In this episode, Jeremy and Kurt analyze the sensationalized Netflix documentary ‘AI Gone Wild’ and explore the broader implications of AI in media, marketing, and society. They discuss how AI is portrayed, the marketing of fear, and the reality of AI capabilities today. In this episode, Jeremy and Kurt explore the philosophical and ethical dimensions of AI, including consciousness, morality, and the influence of human character on technology. They discuss how AI reflects human values and the potential dangers of misperceiving AI as conscious or moral agents.

    Key Topics

    * Analysis of Netflix’s ‘AI Gone Wild’ documentary

    * The role of marketing in AI fear-mongering

    * How media sensationalizes AI threats

    * The reality of AI capabilities today

    * Historical parallels with media coverage of major events

    * The influence of marketing on public perception of AI

    * The intersection of AI, society, and privacy

    * The future of AI regulation and safety measures The influence of human morality on AI development

    * How AI models collective human language and experience

    * The philosophical debate on AI consciousness and personhood

    * The role of presentation and formatting in AI perception

    * The impact of human character traits on AI behavior and ethics

    * The potential dangers of misattributing consciousness to AI

    * The analogy between brain plasticity and AI adaptability

    * The influence of media and social narratives on AI perception

    Sound bites

    “The media doesn’t know any other way to present this material.”

    “They are pretending to be just like every other cable news program.”

    “There’s no privacy in any of this ultimately.”

    Resources:

    Instadocs: AI Gone Wild (Official Trailer)

    Open AI Alignment - Self-generated prompt injections in compaction summaries

    https://alignment.openai.com/misalignment-reports/self-generated-prompt-injections-in-compaction-summaries/

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    1 hr 33 min
  • Mo Gawdat's AI Utopia

    In this episode, The Gadfly Guys analyze Mo Gawdat’s utopian vision of AI, exploring philosophical claims, the performative nature of talks, and the implications of AI surpassing human intelligence. They delve into the nuances of scientific paradigms, the ethics of AI, and the cultural narratives shaping our future with technology.

    Key topics

    * Mo Gawdat’s utopian vision of AI

    * Philosophical claims about absolute and relative truth

    * The performative nature of AI talks and speeches

    * Scientific paradigms and geometry as models of reality

    * The ethical implications of AI surpassing human intelligence

    * Cultural narratives of utopia and dystopia in AI discourse

    * The arms race in AI development between the US and China

    * The role of family resemblance in scientific theories

    * The influence of media and media narratives on AI perception

    * The law of diminishing returns in iterative processes

    Sound bites

    “There’s nothing wrong with abundant intelligence.”

    “AI will create a utopia for humanity.”

    “The performance of talks is more of a spectacle.”

    Resources:

    Mo Gawdat (former Google exec, author)

    Central message: “There’s absolutely nothing wrong with abundant intelligence. There is a lot wrong with the value set of humanity in the age of the rise of the machines.”

    “If we all join together, AI will create a utopia for humanity that solves every problem that humanity’s stupidity has created.”

    When IT Become Smarter Than Us, What Happens Next? | Gladiator Summit II

    The Future of Intelligence: Chasing Utopia

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    1 hr 2 min
  • AI & Ways of Knowing (Part 2)

    This episode explores the complex relationship between AI, human consciousness, and philosophical perspectives on understanding and experience. Jeremy dePrisco and Kurt Smith delve into ideas from McGilchrist, Descartes, and Wolfram, examining what distinguishes human lived experience from machine processing. In this episode, Jeremy dePrisco and Kurt Smith explore complex topics including the nature of reality, the limitations of computational models, the concept of AI personhood, and the historical context of legal personhood for corporations and individuals. They delve into philosophical questions about perception, the universe, and the future of AI in society.

    Key topics

    * The distinction between information and understanding as discussed by McGilchrist

    * The role of lived experience and consciousness in human understanding

    * The philosophical debate on dualism and the soul from Descartes to modern neuroscience

    * The limitations of AI in replicating human qualities like wonder, humility, and compassion

    * The concept of the brain as two organs—front and back—and its implications for understanding consciousness

    * The Moloch trap and the Prometheus myth in the context of AI development

    * The computational universe and the limits of machine replication of natural phenomena

    * The importance of lived, informed experience over raw data in human cognition The analogy of decks of cards representing cells and relationships in the brain

    * The improbability of shared perceptions of the sun from different locations

    * The concept of the Ruliad and bounded existence

    * The philosophical debate on AI personhood and legal status

    * Historical context of corporate personhood and its implications for AI

    Key frameworks

    * Deck of Cards Analogy

    * The Ruliad Model

    * Legal Personhood Evolution

    Resources

    * AI and the Battle for the Soul with Iain McGilchrist - Lecture 1: Information is Not Understanding -

    * AI and the Battle for the Soul with Iain McGilchrist - Lecture 2: Cognitive Freedom in the Age of AI -

    * AI and the Battle for the Soul: Whom Does AI Serve? Jonathan Pageau on the Forces Shaping Technology -

    * Is Everything a Mechanism? Stephen Wolfram and Iain McGilchrist Debate The Nature of Reality -

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    1 hr 10 min
  • AI & Ways of Knowing (Part 1)

    Key topics

    * Differences between human and AI knowledge

    * The distinction between knowing that and knowing from experience

    * Historical philosophical views on mind, soul, and body

    * The evolution of species and patterns of life

    * The role of epistemology and metaphysics in AI debates

    Takeaways

    * AI systems may only ‘know that’ and lack experiential understanding.

    * Historical distinctions like “knowing that” versus “knowing how” are crucial in understanding AI.

    * Philosophical debates about mind and soul date back to Socrates, Aristotle, and Descartes.

    * The evolution of species can be seen as patterns of activity and organization.

    * Concerns about AI’s agency and morality reflect deep philosophical questions.

    Resources

    * AI and the Battle for the Soul with Iain McGilchrist - Lecture 1: Information is Not Understanding -

    * AI and the Battle for the Soul with Iain McGilchrist - Lecture 2: Cognitive Freedom in the Age of AI -

    * AI and the Battle for the Soul: Whom Does AI Serve? Jonathan Pageau on the Forces Shaping Technology -

    * Is Everything a Mechanism? Stephen Wolfram and Iain McGilchrist Debate The Nature of Reality -

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    1 hr 10 min
  • Plato, Socrates, and the Techne of Writing

    Key Topics:

    Plato’s views on writing and dialogue

    The Socratic method and elencos as a technique

    The concept of techne in ancient and modern contexts

    How AI systems relate to human communication and knowledge

    The evolution of writing and its impact on learning and philosophy

    The role of technology in shaping human understanding and expression

    Resources:

    Plato Warned Us About ChatGPT (And Told Us What to Do About It)

    By Elay Shech

    https://www.templeton.org/news/plato-warned-us-about-chatgpt-and-told-us-what-to-do-about-it

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    59 min
  • Abstraction

    Key Topics

    * The concept of abstraction in consciousness and its relation to reality

    * How the mind constructs social and personal identity through abstractions

    * The distinction between concrete experience and abstract thought

    * The role of the subconscious and unconscious in shaping perception

    * The influence of Buddhist and Hindu philosophies on understanding consciousness

    * The debate between materialist and idealist views of the mind

    * The analogy of computer systems and programming in understanding mental processes

    * The concept of qualia and sensory experience as forms of abstraction

    Takeaways

    * Thought and consciousness are both abstractions from the concrete experience.

    * Abstraction allows us to focus on specific elements while ignoring others, shaping perception.

    * The mind constructs reality through layers of abstraction, which can be both useful and misleading.

    * Understanding the role of abstraction can help clarify debates about the nature of consciousness.

    * Philosophical and spiritual traditions offer insights into the primacy of consciousness over matter.

    For more info see:

    Space Cake - https://substack.com/@kurtsmith2

    Jeremy -

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/

    New Thinking Aloud - The Abstract Mind with Chris Niebauer

    Affiliate Links

    https://www.jeremydeprisco.com/affiliate-links.html



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    40 min
  • Why Study Philosophy?

    Philosophy helps us question the basic assumptions underneath everyday thinking—about time, self, science, rights, and consciousness—and spot when language or ideas stop making sense. In the video, Kurt argues that philosophy matters because it reveals the “framework” that makes knowledge and society possible, which science itself has to presuppose.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thegadflyguys.substack.com
    3 min