Some nuh really waah si di world as it is
So dem get caught wit all di tings weh dem a build
Foundation fi set we got to do it quick
Ah hope ah guy nuh vex there aint nuh easy way about dis
Some side step, some come fi trick
Dem wrong concept a devil dem a worship
—Sizzla Kalonji, “Make It Secure”
Think about the scale of the machinery it takes to convince Black people we are living inside a system that values justice and honesty. Think about the number of institutions, textbooks, news cycles, and classroom hours required to maintain that fiction. The machinery does not rest. It runs every morning before you open your eyes and hums through every headline you read before bed. It is so thorough that the people it harms defend it against their own witness.
But Black people cannot afford to not see things as they are. In some cases, what you refuse to see is the difference between life and death.
Ida B. Wells understood that. Born in Holly Springs, Mississippi, in 1862, she lost both parents and an infant brother to the yellow fever epidemic of 1878. At sixteen, she kept her remaining siblings together by working as a teacher. She did not wait for the world to explain itself to her. She went and looked.
In 1892, three of her friends were lynched in Memphis. Thomas Moss, Calvin McDowell, and Henry Stewart owned a grocery store called the People’s Grocery Company. Their business competed with a white-owned store across the street. White men attacked them. When they defended their property, they were arrested, dragged from jail, and murdered. Wells investigated. What she found destroyed the lie white America had told itself about lynching: that it was punishment for Black men assaulting white women. She published the evidence. The white establishment in Memphis burned her newspaper office and ran her out of the city. She kept writing.
What Wells built was a record no one could deny. Southern Horrors: Lynch Law in All Its Phases in 1892. The Red Record in 1895. She traveled to England twice to speak about the epidemic of lynching because the American press refused to print the truth. She did not wait for consensus. She documented the killing, named the killers, and published what she found. The record survived because she made it survive.
Garvey recognized what Wells was doing. He wrote about the crisis in Black journalism with a precision that still cuts. The Black press, he said, had no constructive policy. The news published reflected the worst of the race’s character. He called for “crusaders in journalism who will not seek to enrich themselves off the crimes and ignorance of our race, but men and women who will risk everything for the promotion of racial pride, self-respect, love and integrity” (Garvey 1923, 55). Wells was the crusader Garvey was calling for, years before he wrote the words.
Her truth-telling directly affected Garvey’s trajectory. Garvey came to America in March 1916 with the intention of raising funds, lecturing across the country, and eventually returning to Jamaica to build a school modeled on Booker T. Washington’s Tuskegee Institute. Washington had invited him. However, Washington died before Garvey arrived. Garvey visited Tuskegee anyway, then embarked on a speaking tour across thirty-eight states. He saw the racial condition of Black America with his own eyes.
The East St. Louis massacre of July 1917 changed everything. White mobs, aided by police and the National Guard, slaughtered Black men, women, and children. Wells traveled to East St. Louis and conducted her own investigation. She published The East St. Louis Massacre: The Greatest Outrage of the Century, documenting what she found through interviews with survivors, and her story caught Garvey’s eyes. He gave his speech, “The Conspiracy of the East St. Louis Riots,” on July 8, 1917, six days after the massacre. He called it “one of the bloodiest outrages against mankind.”
As a result, Garvey did not go back to Jamaica. He stayed and built the Universal Negro Improvement Association into the largest mass movement in Black history. The East St. Louis massacre, and the failure of the established Black leadership to match the scale of the violence with the scale of their response, convinced him that the work had to happen here. Wells had already shown him what truth-telling looked like when it cost everything. Her example is written into the DNA of what Garvey built.
The community still needs truth-tellers. People like Marvin Dunn, who has spent decades doing in Florida what Wells did across the South. A professor emeritus at Florida International University, Dunn wrote Black Miami in the Twentieth Century and co-authored The Miami Riot of 1980: Crossing the Bounds, documenting the killing of Arthur McDuffie by police and the uprising that followed when the officers were acquitted. He has led the excavation of Rosewood, the Florida town where, in January 1923, a white mob burned every building and killed an unknown number of Black residents after a white woman lied about being attacked by a Black man. Nobody investigated. Nobody was charged. Dunn purchased five acres of land in Rosewood, becoming the only Black person to own property there since 1923.
His white neighbor tried to kill him for it. David Emanuel shouted racial slurs at Dunn and nearly ran his truck into a group that included Dunn’s adult son. Emanuel was convicted on six counts of federal hate crimes in 2023. Dunn went back. He keeps going back.
When Florida began restricting how Black history could be taught in schools, Dunn started his “Teach the Truth” tours, taking students and their parents to the sites of racial violence across the state. In April 2025, he sat under a tree on the FIU campus and taught the Rosewood massacre to anyone willing to listen. He called it the Black History Learning Tree. He said most of his colleagues were too vulnerable to join him. He did not blame them. He sat under the tree anyway, building a twenty-first-century hush harbor.
Dunn teaches under a tree because the classroom has been compromised. The curriculum has been sanitized. The truth has been declared too uncomfortable for the state to allow. So he does what Black people have always done when the institution fails them. He finds a clearing and teaches.
Wells built a record. Garvey built a movement. Dunn builds a living testimony. The method is the same. Go where the truth is buried. Dig it up. Tell it to anyone who will listen. Pay whatever it costs. The machinery of the lie depends on silence, on compliance, on the exhaustion of the people it harms. Truth-telling is the disruption that the machinery cannot absorb.
Who are the truth-tellers in your community? Not the ones on television. Not the ones with the largest platforms. The ones who go to the site. The ones who buy the land. The ones who sit under the tree. The ones who keep the record when keeping the record is the most dangerous thing you can do.
Wells died in 1931. The record she built outlived every institution that tried to bury it. Garvey’s movement reached six million people because he refused to look away from what Wells had already shown him. Dunn is eighty-five years old and still teaching under a tree in a state that wants him to stop.
The machinery of the lie is enormous. It is funded, staffed, and protected by law. The truth-teller has a pen, a voice, and the willingness to stand where the record demands.
That has always been enough.
References
Garvey, Marcus. 1923. Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey, or, Africa for the Africans. Compiled by Amy Jacques Garvey. New York: Universal Publishing House.
Hill, Robert A., ed. 1983. The Marcus Garvey and Universal Negro Improvement Association Papers. Vol. 1. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Wells-Barnett, Ida B. 1892. Southern Horrors: Lynch Law in All Its Phases. New York: New York Age Print.
Wells-Barnett, Ida B. 1895. The Red Record: Tabulated Statistics and Alleged Causes of Lynching in the United States. Chicago: Donohue and Henneberry.
Wells-Barnett, Ida B. 1917. The East St. Louis Massacre: The Greatest Outrage of the Century. Chicago: The Negro Fellowship Herald Press.
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Get full access to The Garvey Classroom at geoffreyphilp.substack.com/subscribe