Built in the 1800s and tucked away in rural Hinsdale, NY, this house has become one of the most talked-about paranormal hotspots in the state. From the terrifying experiences of the Dandy family in the 1970s — including poltergeist activity, shadow figures, and strange chanting from the surrounding woods — to decades of paranormal investigations, the Hinsdale House has earned its reputation as one of the most haunted places in New York.

In this episode, Billy and Joey dig into the missing pieces of its history, share their theories on why the house remains so active, and talk about their plans to visit in person to conduct their own investigation.

Spooky season is in full swing — catch this episode of the Say What Again Billy Podcast and kick off your season of scares the right way!