What is purgatory, and are Catholics and Protestants actually closer on salvation, sanctification, and purification than we often think?
In this episode of The John Lockwood Show, I sit down with Keith Nester, Catholic author, speaker, YouTuber, and Executive Director of Down to Earth Ministry, for an in-depth Catholic and Protestant conversation about purgatory, salvation, sanctification, and whether a Christian can lose his salvation.
Keith brings a particularly interesting perspective to this discussion because he spent more than 20 years in Protestant ministry before becoming Catholic in 2017. He served in United Methodist, Assemblies of God, and Evangelical Free churches before his conversion to Catholicism.
Keith is the author of The Convert’s Guide to Roman Catholicism: Your First Year in the Church, a book about the challenges, questions, joys, and transitions that come with becoming Catholic. He is also the author of Unpacking the Mysteries of the Rosary: Connecting the Spiritual Fruits to Your Daily Life.
Keith has become a well-known Catholic voice and has appeared on Catholic programs including Pints With Aquinasand The Counsel of Trent.
In our conversation, Keith represents the Catholic perspective while I approach these questions from a Protestant perspective. Rather than simply debating Catholicism vs. Protestantism, we wanted to understand what each side actually believes and find out where genuine common ground exists.
We discuss questions including:
- What do Catholics actually believe about purgatory?
- Is purgatory biblical?
- Do Protestants believe in purification before heaven?
- What is the relationship between justification and sanctification?
- Can a Christian lose his salvation?
- What happens to a Christian who dies before becoming perfectly holy?
- Is purification after death fundamentally different from Protestant ideas of glorification?
- Where do Catholics and Protestants truly disagree about salvation?
- Are Catholics and Protestants sometimes using different language to describe similar realities?
There are significant theological differences between Catholic and Protestant Christianity, and we don't attempt to hide them. But as we worked through these questions, we also discovered more agreement than I expected—especially surrounding the biblical reality that nothing unclean enters the presence of God and that every Christian must ultimately be made perfectly holy.
This conversation isn't about scoring points for Catholicism or Protestantism. It's an attempt to understand each other accurately, challenge our assumptions, and seek the truth about Jesus Christ, salvation, grace, sanctification, purgatory, and eternal life.
Whether you are Catholic, Protestant, Evangelical, Reformed, Methodist, Pentecostal, considering conversion to Catholicism, or simply trying to understand the Catholic teaching on purgatory, I hope this conversation helps you think more carefully about what Christians believe happens between salvation and entering the presence of God.
Guest: Keith Nester
Ministry: Down to Earth Ministry
Books: The Convert’s Guide to Roman Catholicism: Your First Year in the Church and Unpacking the Mysteries of the Rosary: Connecting the Spiritual Fruits to Your Daily Life