Why did they cancel the all-white play?
When San Jose Playhouse announced in late August its cast for a holiday production of “Into the Woods,” critics on social media saw a big problem: All the actors were white.
An all-white cast might have been less of an issue in a show that offered fewer roles. Or one that’s not about fairy tale characters presumably free from real-world norms about race. Or one not produced in San Jose, where non-Hispanic and non-Latino whites make up just 25.7% of the population, according to the 2020 census.
But all these factors, combined with ongoing, passionate advocacy for racial justice in theater, both locally and across the country, made San Jose Playhouse’s production stand out to detractors.
In attempting to defend itself, San Jose Playhouse, led by married couple Shannon and Scott Evan Guggenheim, made more perceived mistakes, including posting, then deleting, a note that was meant to be private; as well as by recasting one actor with multiple others. That only further inflamed opposition, who asked why the theater was suddenly able to find actors of color now when it couldn’t before. By Sept. 12, San Jose Playhouse canceled the show.
The episode underscores how much casting norms in local theater have evolved. Even a decade ago, if a Bay Area theater had programmed all-white shows, criticism would probably have been much more muted, if it went public at all. It also highlights how outspoken that racial justice advocates have become.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.