In the bustling, not-so-bright town of Infotropolis, Google reigned supreme. It was a place where people worshiped at the altar of the search bar, trusting it to unravel the tangled skein of information with the precision of a seasoned knitter. For years, the townsfolk had perfected the art of discernment, picking through the search results like bargain hunters at a flea market. They knew which sources to trust, which to ignore, and which to laugh at over their morning coffee.

Then, one day, the Oracle of Google announced a shiny new feature: the AI Overview. "No longer will you need to wade through endless pages of search results," the Oracle proclaimed with the confidence of a motivational speaker selling life insurance. "Now, I shall provide you with a single, smooth answer to all your queries."

At first, the townsfolk were elated. “Think of the time we’ll save!” they cheered, imagining all the extra minutes they could spend binge-watching mediocre television. But soon, an uneasy feeling settled in, like realizing too late that the milk in your coffee is a week past its expiration date.

Ellie, a diligent researcher with the curiosity of a cat and the skepticism of a detective, noticed something amiss. She asked the Oracle about the best way to make her grandmother’s famous pizza. Instead of the lively debate among chefs and foodies she expected, she received a neatly packaged response suggesting she add glue to the sauce. "Glue?" she muttered. "This can't be right."

Ellie decided to investigate. She delved into the search results that lay beneath the AI Overview. There, among the links, she found the original source of the bizarre suggestion: a troll post on a long-forgotten forum frequented by people who probably shouldn’t be allowed near a kitchen. Frustrated, she shared her discovery with her friend Sam, a history buff whose idea of a good time involved obscure historical facts and a bottle of wine.

"I asked for information on the history of Mexican cuisine in Santa Fe," Sam said, his voice dripping with sarcasm, "and got a sterile paragraph that reads like it was written by a robot who moonlights as a Wikipedia editor. Where’s the spice? The drama? The controversy?”

Ellie and Sam, armed with righteous indignation and an alarming amount of free time, marched to the Oracle's temple. There, they met Greg, the Oracle’s keeper, a harried technician who looked like he hadn’t seen the sun in months.

"Your AI is making us dumber," Ellie declared, waving her phone like a pitchfork. "We've lost the ability to discern, to learn from the variety of voices and perspectives that once made Google so valuable."

Greg sighed the sigh of a man who had heard this all before. "You're not the first to say this. The AI was supposed to make things easier, but it's become a crutch. People are missing out on the journey of learning."

Sam nodded vigorously. "We need the journey. It’s through comparing, contrasting, and thinking critically that we truly understand."

Inspired by their words, and perhaps a little desperate to stop the complaints, Greg decided to act. He reprogrammed the AI to provide not just a single answer, but a range of sources, encouraging users to explore further. "From now on, the AI will highlight diverse viewpoints and prompt deeper engagement," he announced with the optimism of someone who has yet to realize just how badly things can go wrong.

The townspeople noticed the change immediately. Ellie’s next search for pizza recipes brought back a series of summaries that seemed perfectly reasonable on the surface but were devoid of the contextual clues she had come to rely on. She could no longer tell at a glance which sources were from reputable chefs and which were from hobbyists with dubious culinary skills and a penchant for glue.

Sam’s historical queries now included a mix of academic papers, amateur blogs, and conspiracy theorists, all stripped of the signals that once helped him navigate through them. The absence of recognizable brands and author credibility left him adrift in a sea of seemingly equal sources, unable to discern the valuable from the valueless.

The townspeople of Infotropolis began to realize that without the ability to see the origin of their information, they were more lost than ever. They had traded the messy, vibrant cacophony of the web for a sterile, monotonous hum that flattened every voice into the same dull tone.

The Oracle's attempt to shield them from incorrect information had, paradoxically, left them more vulnerable. Without the practice of sifting through the clutter, the citizens’ discernment skills atrophied. They were no longer able to spot the subtle signals that distinguished trustworthy sources from fraudulent ones. The result was a populace that took everything at face value, unable to engage critically with the information presented to them.

Ellie and Sam, once champions of the quest for knowledge, found themselves in a disorienting world where every answer looked the same and every voice sounded equally convincing. They had lost the very tools that had made them skilled searchers in the first place.

One evening, in a dimly lit pub called The Source, where the town’s more disillusioned thinkers gathered, Ellie and Sam sat nursing their drinks, the weight of their failure hanging heavily over them.

“Remember when we could just look at a URL and know it was trash?” Ellie said, swirling her wine.

“Yeah,” Sam replied, staring into his beer. “Or when a glaring typo in the title was all the warning we needed? Now it’s all this sanitized mush. Everything looks credible and yet, nothing really is.”

Nearby, old Professor Higgins, a retired academic who once thrived on Google’s chaotic but richly informative landscape, overheard their conversation. “The problem,” he interjected, “is that we’ve taken away the very cues that help us make judgments. A poorly designed website or a ridiculous URL—these are all signals. They tell us something about the source. Without them, we’re adrift.”

Ellie nodded. “It’s like we’re back in kindergarten. The Oracle doesn’t trust us to figure things out on our own anymore.”

The pub door creaked open, and Greg shuffled in, looking more harried than ever. He joined their table, glancing nervously around as if expecting a mob with pitchforks at any moment.

“Greg,” Ellie said, “this isn’t working. We need those clues. We need to learn how to discern again.”

Greg sighed, setting down his glass. “You think I don’t know that? The higher-ups wanted simplicity, safety. They thought stripping away the noise would help. But they didn’t realize the noise is what taught us how to listen.”

Sam, ever the history buff, leaned in. “There’s an old saying, ‘The road to hell is paved with good intentions.’ In trying to protect us from bad information, they’ve made us incapable of recognizing it when we see it.”

Greg rubbed his temples. “I’m stuck between a rock and a hard place. The AI is designed to curate, to present, but it lacks the nuance of human judgment. It can’t teach discernment because it doesn’t possess it.”

As the night wore on, the group brainstormed solutions. They talked about reintroducing certain elements—maybe not the chaos of the old web, but enough variety to allow for the development of critical thinking. They discussed ways to teach discernment, to help the townspeople regain the skills they’d lost.

The next morning, with a sense of renewed purpose, Greg went back to the Oracle’s temple. He started by tweaking the AI to bring back some of the old signals—the imperfect, the odd, the clearly amateurish—mixed in with the polished results. He hoped that by seeing the spectrum again, the people of Infotropolis would begin to remember how to tell the difference.

But change came slowly. The townspeople, long accustomed to being spoon-fed neat, tidy answers, struggled to adapt. Many resisted, clinging to the false security of the AI’s smooth but soulless responses. Discernment, once an automatic skill, now felt like a foreign concept.

In The Source, Ellie and Sam continued their crusade, running informal workshops on how to spot a dubious source, how to cross-check information, how to think critically. They faced an uphill battle against a populace that had grown complacent, but bit by bit, they saw glimmers of hope.

One day, a young boy approached Ellie, his eyes wide with curiosity. “I heard you can tell if something on the web is true or not. How do you do it?”

Ellie smiled. “It’s not about knowing what’s true, it’s about knowing how to find out. It’s about questioning, cross-referencing, and thinking for yourself. And it all starts with recognizing the clues.”

The boy nodded, determined. “Teach me.”

Ellie began to explain, feeling a flicker of hope. But just as she was getting into the intricacies of critical thinking, the boy’s eyes glazed over. “Never mind,” he said, pulling out his phone. “I’ll just ask the Oracle.” And with that, he wandered off, leaving Ellie to sip her wine and reflect on the profound truth that you can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it think.

In the end, Infotropolis remained a town caught between the past and the future, its people ever hopeful that one day, someone would invent a search engine smart enough to make them all geniuses without any effort on their part.

Get full access to The Generative Gazette at generativegazette.substack.com/subscribe