We revisit the topic of immigration in order to resolve a long-standing disagreement between us: can restricting immigration be consistent with liberal values? Yuta argues no – restricting immigration is treating people differently based on their country of origin, which contradicts the liberal value that everyone has the same intrinsic moral value. Henry argues yes -in some cases restricting immigration can best serve liberal values.

This is a very long discussion (in addition to many more, over the years and off-mic).