the nantucket project

the nantucket project

By the nantucket projectSociety & CulturePhilosophy
Download on the App Store

the nantucket project episodes

  • rp daily: a check on vaccine

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    a check on vaccine. today, tom and rp discuss the current state of covid-19; as states begin to reopen at different rates, discrepancies in the severity of the pandemic are more and more evident. they cover sweden's failed "herd immunity" experiment, the speed of the vaccine's development, and how likely it is for americans to want a vaccine in the first place. the fourth of july has passed, and after celebrations occurred across america, tom and rp ask how seriously many americans are taking the pandemic.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    rp daily a check on vaccine.mp3

    [00:00:17] How are you doing? Good to see you. Welcome back.

    [00:00:20] Good. I'm Sago's fourth. I say excited. Get back in the car.

    [00:00:25] Did you what do you do for the fourth?

    [00:00:28] We we were in Courtland, Idaho, and we sat on a balcony and watched illegal fireworks all around the lake, which is a different other than one place we know where everyone watches the town fireworks, everyone in town decide to have their own fireworks. So it's kind of fun, but it didn't end till about 1:00 the morning.

    [00:00:49] Wow, how about you?

    [00:00:53] I was home and I was asleep pretty early. My children went out and.

    [00:01:02] You know, normally. Well, it was interesting because I can see across the board the Long Island Sound here and you can see a lot of fireworks from towns up and down. And I wasn't sure what would happen this year. I was at my workout yesterday and the guy had come in. He's a very friendly guy, wanted to join the class. And he said I said, well, where do you live? And he said, I live in Bayside, Queens. So we'll have. Why'd you come here? He goes, because we can't work out in New York, in the gyms. So I wasn't sure because you know, where we live, you know, we live right near the border, not far from New Jersey, right next to New York. We're in Connecticut. Connecticut gyms are open. I still do it outside. He came up for that. It turns out Long Island, I guess you could have all the fireworks displays and everything.

    [00:01:50] And so I ended up just watching that. But I mentioned some of that stuff because. I don't know exactly how this works. OK? And I'm going to I'm going to give you a little bit of a.

    [00:02:04] Preamble here, which is that I've been like reading far afield on this topic the last few days, which is to say I've been reading ActiveX things and I've listened a little bit to Bobby Kennedy and others.

    [00:02:19] I've also read some interesting things about vaccines. I want to talk to you about that quickly.

    [00:02:28] And by the way, the reason I do this for me is that I know I don't know. Right. So what do I do? I tend to follow the crowd, which is what we all do to a certain extent, whether we know it or not. There's no way I know enough about vaccines to understand it for myself more often than not. I take what I hear from you, Arpey. And by and large, for example, I hear that Sweden has been a failure. But there's others who would say the opposite, that Sweden has actually been a success, which in today's world, I know this stuff gets really complicated because we hear it from all sides. This is all in the context of what I was describing is why I can and can't see fireworks, because the rules are different from state to state. We live right on a border. So it's interesting that different states are different places.

    [00:03:11] But our state Arpey both and I live in Connecticut. And yesterday or maybe it was today. Yeah. I mean, yesterday we had zero deaths in the state of Connecticut. Yeah. And we were a hotspot. New cases, which is really low.

    [00:03:30] Now, here's a trick up to this, which is my observation of the general behaviors of the people who live around where we live is that it's relatively it's mixed. Let's put it that way. That way. And very often I see what I would observe as seemingly irresponsible behavior feasibly covered.

    [00:03:51] And we are actually in good shape as that because we got our number way down. What is it? What is it that I'm seeing that that creates all that? And we we don't have to get into the conversation about some of the anti VAX stuff that I read if you don't want to. But I would like to talk about some new news on vaccinations, which I sent you an e-mail last night, and I can share some of that when we want to talk about.

    [00:04:14] Can I respond to some stuff you just said? Yeah. So first on Sweden, if you want to find someone and completely reveal them for just being wrong, for whatever reason, they're wrong and find someone who thinks the Sweden experiment worked because it was a total failure and it cost thousands of lives that needed to be called needn't be dead. That's inarguable. You could argue that they're faster towards herd immunity, but that's wrong. So even Sweden acknowledges they made a mistake. It's too bad they gambled with lives. They at least did it thoughtfully. They at least understood that. Here's what the virus is. It's real. It's not a hoax. We have to address it. They just addressed it incorrectly. For those of you who haven't followed, we've we've had a couple of shows on Sweden. They decided, look, we trust the people enough just to socially distance and we're going to. And we don't want to hurt our economy. So we're going to keep everything open economically and help people help people wash your hands and social distance and and we'll try to protect the elderly. They didn't protect the elderly. They have had massive deaths among their elderly population and their economy has dropped just as much as their neighboring equivalent economies like Denmark. Even though businesses were open. How can that be? Here's the big lesson. The virus is what destroys your economy. People being sick, people being afraid, people being in hospitals, people not going on and shopping. That's what destroys your economy, not just the shutdowns. The shutdowns help stop the virus in Sweden. Prove that to us clearly. Here's a little factoid. In Sweden, the elderly population, not the ones in elder care facilities with people over 55. Even though they were entirely allowed to go out and shop like everyone else in Sweden was, their consumption went down faster than anyone else's. Why? Because they were afraid of the virus. They reasonably decided not to go out and shop. The economy in Sweden has dropped just as much as anyone else's. And they've taken 10 times a death per capita of their neighboring states, a total failure. Quickly on reading other issues and making up our own minds. You nailed it, Tom, right. Like we've talked a lot about this, it's something that one of the greatest lessons I ever learned was we don't learn lessons. We don't make up our own minds. You we we follow the leader. It's it's 80 percent of our brain wiring comes from herd animals. We follow the leader. So you have to read your own stuff. You have. But you have to look at it with a critical mind and you have to know that people are great dissemblers and there's a lot of great false information out there. And and so anti vax all of a sudden it gets extremely complicated, like deeply, deeply complicated. Like maybe you need a masters to understand some of the science or have done this for decades to really or many years to really understand a lot of what you're reading. If you don't have that, you can easily be fooled or you can easily get it wrong. So eventually, for very complex topics, there's a simple rule of thumb that I think we have to follow, which is find a group of trusted experts who are degreed, credentialed are the ones that we pay to trust. We paid a war and we paid I listened to and listened to them. So there's things in your life where you have to just give some of the knowledge over to others. Not everything. Not much. And you should do as much reading as you can. And as soon as you get there, you know, take back take back the reins of the leadership of yourself. But don't be afraid to trust, you know, every person at CDC, Public Health Service and across the world when it comes to vaccines versus a very small number of splinter activists who whose who rely on papers that were all discredited.

    [00:07:54] But it's a bit of a complexity. So I'm saying on one hand, well, for very complex things, you've got to lead yourself. But you've also got to understand there's certain groups of experts that are just worth trusting until you get up to that level of expertize to make your own decision. And then finally, Connecticut, Ned Lamont, the governor, period, he nailed it. He's a friend of mine. So I I'm biased. But he did a great job and he inter instituted mask wearing early. That's one of the reasons Connecticut got it right. You've got a lot of great testing. He got a lot of great help from Yale. He took decisive leadership actions inside his leadership team. He fired a top official he didn't think was the right person, but other person. Then he took it super seriously. And so we hope from our leaders. And he did it. He did it right. He also believes he had a week to learn from New York and New York, had two weeks to learn from Italy. So he took that time to learn to make the right decisions. I don't think he had a week ahead of New York. He thinks that. I think we got hit right about the same time. We're a commuter commuter county, at least in Fairfield. But he took it seriously. Now, remember, if New York had two weeks before Italy and then we had a week after New York, you know, just a reminder that America had about a month before China, after China. So we all America had a lot of warnings ahead of other states, other countries. Ned was smart enough to figure out how to make that work for us. And let's hope we see a lot of adherence to mass growing and social distancing so that we keep the numbers down.

    [00:09:20] But it's awesome. No one died yesterday in Connecticut from the disease. Yeah.

    [00:09:25] So Arpey, I know we both have limited time today. I want to talk a little bit about vaccines.

    [00:09:33] I sent you this e-mail last night, I don't know if you got a chance to see it, but essentially there's an outline here.

    [00:09:42] And this comes from Morgan Stanley research. And they talk about Maidana, Pfizer, AstraZeneca.

    [00:09:51] They'll all start phase three trials before the end of the summer. And it says here that which is very interesting, preelection data is possible. But the base case is that by mid-November there will be available data and then it says early your data increases our economists convictions that this will be a V shaped recovery, which is interesting.

    [00:10:18] And then finally, it says we see limited election impact.

    [00:10:25] I find that hard to believe. I find it hard to believe that if information is on the horizon, good information is on the horizon as you lead into the election around a vaccine that it would stay out of the picture.

    [00:10:37] It doesn't. That doesn't make sense to me. Anyway, now I'm reading this as if it's news and it may not be news at all. But just curious how you react to it.

    [00:10:50] So it's early. Let's focus on the vaccine in the election. Let's start with. Again, there's 126 groups trying to find vaccines, we're getting down to about seven and eight that are making real success, having little success. First little footnote, we should talk about more at one point, we don't want to rush into production of vaccine, that's not as effective as possible. This is a big point. Sixty six percent. Sixty one third of Americans say they won't use a Corona vaccine. One third, according to a CNN poll. We don't get to herd immunity until 70 percent of the population is seropositive. Point three zero positivity doesn't confer immunity, meaning having the vacs, having been exposed to the disease doesn't make you immune. Probably for more than a year and a half. We don't know the science on that yet, but that's possible. Say it again. If you've been exposed and you've recovered, it's more complicated than this, but it's quite possible that your conferred immunity, it's called conferred immunity from being sick and now being recovered will not last two years, maybe, what, last year and a half. It's also possible that the degree to which you were sick has some impact on the degree to how long you'll be immune because you will create more antibodies. There's a lot more science involved there. Yes, there's a TSA regulated response possible as well. So quickly, the math, if a third of the country won't take the take the medicine, take a vaccine, if we get one, if the vaccines are what's called a hundred percent effective, which it won't be, but let's say it is. You're at 66 percent and then you have how many people already seropositive? Maybe it's five across the country, maybe 10. We maybe get to that 70 percent number where we have herd immunity, which means it's basically safe to go outside. If we have one percent vaccine, an effective vaccine, if we have anything below 90 percent effective vaccine, you see how the math works. All right. So what we have that up is. That potentially will have the vaccine, how effective the vaccine is, the percentage of people who also are seropositive, who have been exposed and now have conferred immunity. Does that equal 70 percent right now? Probably not. It's a big issue unless we have a almost perfectly effective vaccine. So talk about that later. Elections and vaccine, I think we can look at the way the president handled hydroxyl chloroquine, and it's to understand how he's going to think about the vaccines in the election. He got way ahead of the science touting in medicine thinking and by the way, touting it well beyond even what every scientist said. Even the optimistic scientists said hydroxy chloroquine can help in certain stage of the disease. He came out and said, we found a basically cure all. Not only was he wrong, optimistic scientists were wrong. Hydroxyl chloroquine basically does not help. But we saw for one of the first times ever, maybe the first time ever, a president standing at the press room in the White House, the West Wing screaming and yelling about medicine. And he was wrong. And people may have died from that. Unfortunately, believing it was right. It certainly created a huge problem around the world in the production of Hydroxyl Corkman people needed for other things that groups couldn't get it. How will he act with a vaccine right now in all polling? He's losing a vaccine would be transformative. The reason that Morgan Stanley, where we are reading leasers a V shaped recovery is because we'll have a vaccine until we have a vaccine. We're going to continue to have the problems that we've had. As I said in the beginning, the virus is what shuts down the economy, not the shutdowns. So Tilling of vaccine, the virus will keep crushing us and slowing us down. Look, I think I would bet you anything the president will be touting vaccine successes very early as soon as he has anything to tout them on. And I would just remind you that two bodies right now that have data on vaccine production are, one, the for profit companies that are making them. Who obviously are eager. By all sorts of reasons, good and not many bad two to ensure there is is the best thing they wanted. When they know it's the best, their stocks will go up. Their CEOs will get richer if they're right. So they are interested in getting the best news out there. They can as fast as they can and maybe not as carefully as they should. And a president who very, very badly wants a vaccine. So those two bodies, the government, the rest the government is not commenting on vaccines are both highly biased towards a positive outcome. And the president, you know, we've talked a lot at Airto about an October surprise. Meaning he comes out and says, Mugabi the vaccine and people believe it if we don't. So let's let's hope we do my gotta to be the best thing in the world if the vaccine tomorrow or October. I can't say if we will or we won't. I hope we do. But I can say with high certainty, the president will hype whatever we have. And we have to just ensure that whatever we put into production based on the math I just mentioned, is a highly effective vaccine because once we put one into production, you can't go put another into production. So the machinery available to mass produce billions of doses of vaccine or in America's instance, 300 million. Can't be used twice. You can't parallel process. You pick one vaccine and get behind one winner, you make that one. If it's not effective enough, if the president says, I don't care if it's only 70 percent effective, let's get it out there because I think I'll win. Then we'll be making a dire error by allocating those precious production resources to something that we probably should have waited longer for something else. And that's a, by the way, a super hard call to make. We'll have an impact on the election. I suspect that Morgan Stanley is looking at the Electoral College numbers, but look, it looks really bad for Trump right now. There's a lot of water to go under, a lot of bridges between now and the election. He's going to try every trick he can to win, as every candidate would not. So long as he does it legally and ethically, then that's his right. So I wouldn't count him out yet, but a vaccine would certainly help.

    [00:16:59] What's your view on leaving the WHL?

    [00:17:02] Just foolish, foolish, foolish on the fragment, foolish.

    [00:17:05] Now it's just politicking like it's a critical organization. It doesn't really work well without us in it. They made some mistakes. They actually weren't as profound as our own mistakes at our own CDC level or certainly in our own executive level or the level of the mistake. We made a lot of governors offices.

    [00:17:23] It's done. You know it. And.

    [00:17:26] It'll just hurt us. It's not like it costs us real money. It's an organization that is, by the way, look, we're the leader of these organizations, all these multilateral organizations. We pay a quarter the bills, basically, and we get what we want. So if that organization doesn't work, it's probably largely our fault for neglecting it, not getting in there, not beating it up. There's a lot of work America's done. A lot of diplomats mean a lot of time working with multilateral organizations, getting them to get rid of waste, fraud and abuse, and getting them to respond as best we can to what America wants. Maybe not what Russia China wants Iran. There's a lot of fighting among those other countries for how these organizations will behave. And if certain, if not a member, you have no influence. But if you don't show up, if you don't put good diplomats there, if you don't take it all seriously, you don't have influence either. But it's it's like quitting your own private. No club. Right. We are the boss of these things largely. And we need to be in there in reforming them. And the W8 show is a necessary, important organization for global health. It's saved millions, millions lives. And we have to be responsible to Americans and the rest of the world to ensure that organizations properties on properly managed and doing what it's supposed to do if it isn't. We got to get in there and fix it, not quit it.

    [00:18:43] So, Arpey, we're going on the road. Yeah. We're so excited for you. Yeah. So here's the most recent poster. Let's go. I love it.

    [00:18:52] It's so I leave a week from Friday. I mean, this is coming soon now. The first event is in Minneapolis, you see there on the 22nd of July. The last one is the night of August 2nd down in New Orleans. You know, as we've been building this, you know, part of the recruiting group that we recruit the people to come and basically we're having conversations in all these towns. And really the story's already begun because you you start getting feedback right away on many things. You know, by and large, by the way, the conversations are great. You know, we're talking to people who are college professors or, you know, hardware store owners to head of the NAACP from Dubuque, Iowa. I mean, like all these interesting and different people. And as I say, the story begins now because the questions they ask, the concerns they bring, their willingness to participate is very high, by the way. So we'll we'll do these conversations in every place. Normally, we put on a show. In this case, it's not a show. It is literally a conversation. But as you might guess, what often comes up is covered. I've been doing I do a regular set of meetings, actually daily. I do a meetings with a group of about 25 people that we do them outdoors. I have another part of a gym where I workout outdoors. I have a lot of confidence in our ability to stay safe as a team, and I have a lot of ability. Excuse me, I have a lot of confidence in our ability to create a safe environment when people come on this trip. To me, the most risky part of this trip for my team. Most of us are driving out and back. So we go from here, northern tip of Mississippi, down to the south tip of the Mississippi and back. I think the airplanes, a couple of people would rather fly and we if we made it their option.

    [00:20:46] Does that make sense? Yeah, that makes sense to me. You know, we're if you look at this backdrop, I'm in Montana right now. You may recall we put three boys in a suburban Kelli and I and drove Kennicott to Idaho, stopped and saw friends safely on the way. Now we're going to fly back and have someone drive the truck back. The Suburban. We decided that we didn't think that will be safe, partly because we have a six year old hard to contain him, partly because we couldn't get blocks of seats.

    [00:21:16] And partly because just the anxiety of not knowing how exposed we were would be with us for 14 days. And we are going to go see other people and what we do in that very time. So I can have higher confidence of my exposure not being on an airplane. Now, the airlines will tell you that they have well filtered air, this and that. But you're in a closed, confined place space next to much other people. So it's actually a higher risk endeavor than what we're doing. Your car rides will be high risk so long as those cars don't have contaminate. People in your meetings outside will not be high risk. We'll still be of risk. So, no, I think I wouldn't do an airplane. It's certainly easier. So the 36 hour car ride I've signed up for, but the first leg in yesterday, my back is all my arms and all kinked up. It would've been easier to sit in an airplane. But I think the stress, let alone the potential of contracting the disease. I don't want to do it. And by the way, we can have a great time.

    [00:22:15] So there's a pond back here and I think boys out there fishing on it.

    [00:22:20] OK. You tell you the. I've been using an analogy and I've got to go in a minute. It's a little dirty, but.

    [00:22:31] Flatulence. Gas. Having gas. That's a good point. You have gas?

    [00:22:39] Well, I feel it if you have gas at an outdoor gathering. Maybe one person will catch wind of it. Maybe too. Depends on how close you are to each other. If you're in a car, the coal car, if the windows aren't down, they're going to they're going to fill you in. I got three little boys. I know it. Same with a conference room. And I actually, the more I thought about it like this is as good an analogy is as I've heard it.

    [00:23:01] Think about it because I don't want I don't want to start selling it as like if you're trying to be safe with it, could even add your to to or analogy to there for the people are really are the ones and the super spreaders got hooks in America that stick with you.

    [00:23:12] Right. So if it's that if if that chorus had been outside.

    [00:23:18] No, all the people he asked. I think very likely that Woolworths would have had much less far better results, right?

    [00:23:24] Well, and then and then you throw in the mask factor now, mask. I don't know how a mask does against flatulence, but if you think about being outside with a mask and just imagining just your own sort of unscientific understanding of the way air moves and molecules move, it's a relatively safe bet to say think of it like a passing gas.

    [00:23:42] Yep. I don't think that's such a bet that, you know what differences.

    [00:23:45] It's a gas nano molecule, but hypocenter. Right? Yeah, that's that's a good one.

    [00:23:49] So every time we smell a little boy fart in the car with a computer. All right. I got to go. I'm sorry. I've got another is. I love it. We'll be in touch again this week. Great to catch up.

    25 min
  • rp daily: independence day

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    independence day. this independence day is like no other, as is the state of the nation: covid-19 numbers are spiking, widespread protests against racism continue, and a lack of leadership at the helm of the government is more evident than ever. all of this begs to ask: how do we celebrate this independence day—together, socially distant, or at all? what are the implications of celebrating a country in this current state? tom and rp unpack patriotism and its ever-changing definition on a remarkable july 4th weekend.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    transcript

    [00:00:16] Hi, everybody. My name is Tom Scott. Welcome, Fourth of July weekend. It's Fourth of July time. I can't believe it's that time again, mostly because I sort of for some reason, I had this psychological sense of it will end, the summer will start, we'll do summer and then we'll have the Fourth of July.

    [00:00:38] It's like here I am in the garage.

    [00:00:40] Here comes the Fourth of July and Robin Till stay home.

    [00:00:45] Yeah.

    [00:00:47] I mean, it's you know, I as usual, I don't know exactly how to consume or or consider the News of the World.

    [00:00:58] And let me just add that there was a moment earlier this week, and I think I'm still there, but I was very cognizant of how how much I was there earlier in the week, which is.

    [00:01:16] This world is completely chaotic. I don't know where anything in this world stands. And just as an example, like what's the Republican Party? Who's on the right? What does the left stand for? What's next with George Floyd? What's next with Kofod? What's going to happen to the economy? Where are the kids going to school. I could go on and on and on. You know, there's just so many things going on. And it does feel to me like we're now all speaking a form of psychobabble. Now, I just want to add that in part because of the show, because people communicate with me about the show through social media. I'm more in Facebook in particular than I used to be. And Facebook is a mess. I mean, it is just a mess. The back and forth and the things people say and the things that they post, it's just like, why how can that be enjoyable to somebody? Now I understand why it's a dopamine rush. Like, I understand the the car wreck aspect to it. I'm not seeing the the joy or the information side of what it is. So anyway, I just said a lot.

    [00:02:23] But but I really in my whole life I've never felt so strongly. And it may just be an emotion of of sorts, but I think there's actually a lot of logic in it where I feel like, what is this country like? What is this moment?

    [00:02:37] We are, yeah. I mean, we're leaderless. We're rudderless. We don't know which way the oceans are moving. You asked a lot of great questions. We don't have a lot of the things that often give us solace. We don't have sport unless you want to watch MDMA all day or South Korean baseball. And into your first point, we thought that perhaps this would be some degree return to normalcy and it's not. And then you'd have like these memories we have. Right. Fourth of July with your friends huddled together, drinking beer, trying to find the cold beer in the cooler. That's full of melted ice watching fireworks go off. And, you know, for some of some people, maybe they'll get to do that, but it's going to be a very different circumstance. You know, I was what I think I mentioned as far as walking through a Home Depot the other day and most people had masks on and it just sort of struck me like, holy shit, I'm walking through a Home Depot and I want as masks on like we are. I mean, obviously we know what we're in. But if you really pull back and look at what's going on here, you know, we are in the middle of a pandemic. Someone wrote recently that it's an omni DEMICK, meaning everyone's having their own personal experience in that different different groups, different minority groups, differently.

    [00:04:01] Socioeconomic groups are experiencing this very differently. Different states are experiencing this very differently. Different countries are experiencing this very differently.

    [00:04:09] And and then we all individually are experiencing differently. Some of us know people who have died. Some was don't. Some people think it's a hoax? Some people know it's not. And that swirl. That chaos, that it's very ripe for disinformation and it creates it creates a deep unease. So, you know, my barometer for this is my my children won't say which one of them, but one of my children and my youngest is six. So you're six, 11 and 14. One of them hid himself away in this rental condo the other day, was crying. He's a very, very with it smart boy. And one thing's been different here that CNN has been on the TV all day because of some folks that were with like to watch that. And we don't watch that generally. So he's seen a little bit of that. He's well aware of what's going on. But he was crying and it took a long, long time to get him to understand and to explain to me why. And he said, I'm afraid that all my friends will die and I'll never see them again.

    [00:05:20] And I think that we as adults know that we. We rashly know that's not the case.

    [00:05:27] But it's not you know, it's scary for him.

    [00:05:33] And I think a lot of us have fears that are in that direction. Hey, look what's really going on here. And we know everyone's not going to die. But it also makes us very, very ripe for other scary news. So you saw, oh, my gosh, there's a new H1N1 virus coming from China. Like, wow, like we're on razor's edge. I'll leave it at that. Anyway, he was fine, by the way. And then he explained he was also very sad. He didn't have a school work packet. So we're going to find a printer or print out his work package. So it was like a sad news and an inspirational thing. He was upset about it.

    [00:06:09] I've been through the work packet panic before. I know it. That is, you know, and as I look at this today, before we came on, I just took another look at sort of some of the headlines. You know, what's going on in Hong Kong is really intense.

    [00:06:24] I'm sure is the you know, there's a headline here. The hundreds who served under George W. Bush will endorse Biden. You know, they're going to do it in sort of a collective format. And it goes on and on. I mean, obviously, the covered numbers. Let me ask you. Koven question. I know the president took a lot of grief for what the numbers are going up because they're doing more testing.

    [00:06:50] I think I mentioned this to you the other day, and it is sort of a silly point on one hand. But on the other hand, isn't that true? Aren't we doing a lot more testing now? Yeah, well, first.

    [00:07:01] He said it twice. So the first time he said it, I said he can't be that stupid. He said, you know, he said we should get the exact quote, but it was. The more testing we do, the more cases we find. So I told them to slow down the kept testing and then his spokesman came out, said he was joking, which is their trope. You know, he was joking about injecting disinfectant. Well, we'll watch the video. He wasn't joking at all. He was joking about more testing. Stop the testing because that equals more cases. He wasn't joking at all. He then said it again the next day. So when it when coming out of his mouth, we have two chances of looking at it. It appears this man thinks about testing the way you think about testing pregnancy. If you don't test a woman who's pregnant, she's not pregnant. If you don't write down the number of school shootings, you don't have school shootings or something like something. Apsley just makes no sense. Any of us like that. Now, is it true that you find more cases, thereby you have the ability to give more treatment and save more lives and reduce the virus more if you test more? Yeah. Is it true that by testing we're going to find more cases? Yes, it is. You test the air, you find none. Just everyone. You find them all. Now, the question that I think you're asked, whether you are asking is, for example, Florida. Florida appears to be in really dire straits, like the disease is going straight up in Florida. Is that because of more testing? Yes. Is it because of more D disease? Also disease growth? Also, yes. So the disease is actually organically growing at an alarming rate in Florida and a bunch of other states, including where I am today in Idaho. Is that just because we're finding more cases from testing? Absolutely not. It is really, truly growing.

    [00:09:05] You know, the quote is, if we stop testing right now, we'd have a few cases. Ethicist thinks is a grammatical challenge within that sentence. There's a lot there's a lot there. I'm not sure exactly what he meant, but you can sort of interpret it in a variety of ways.

    [00:09:27] And so.

    [00:09:30] In Idaho, for example, just and I know that there's there's not a ton of science here, but what you observe is how different is is it than what you would have observed back here?

    [00:09:40] Very different. But I but I it's not one where were you? Anyone would walk around and go, oh, my God, look at these idiots. It's not that by any measure, it's, you know, shared consequence. They in Idaho, even now, there's a great irony for us being here. We are in this state with, I think, the fastest growing caseload per capita. And we left the state with the fastest reducing caseload per capita. So Connecticut has done an extraordinarily good job. Governor Lamont will get great kudos for what he's done. He's a friend of mine. So obviously keep that in mind. But the numbers don't lie. Idaho has the fastest growing count, but very different and very different numbers. So Connecticut, you know, you have tens and tens of thousands of cases. Idaho, I think we're still below 10000 cases. So people don't know people who've died. It's not really hitting folks, et cetera, et cetera, yet. And I hope it doesn't, but statistically it will. So I went into a bike shop to the day I had my mask on. You know, we I was socially distance. They had the right signs in the door. They limit the number of people in the store. But no one had a mask on. And these are the people who work. There are bikers, right? They're super fit. And we talked about the disease. And one guy was concerned about long, long, long term lung damage. Other than that, there wasn't a lot of concern. So they just they don't they haven't seen it yet. So, no, there's not as much mass wearing at all. We walked down the street the other day yesterday to get some ice cream with the kids. We order masks on and. Instead, here's here's what wasn't said. Instead of people looking at us like we were we were the alien other because we had masks on and they didn't. A lot of people actually who had mass in their pockets or mask their hands, put their masks on when they saw it coming. So I think, you know, from that little experiment.

    [00:11:39] The word. The words, you know, it's pretty it's pretty clearly understood now that wearing a mask is at least a social good, if not a biological necessity. A medical.

    [00:11:51] Is the if you are going to outline and I don't know that you have any give any different views on, just be a behavioral. Patterns. I mean, I give you a here, here. Here was a line I heard a lot this week.

    [00:12:11] You need, like, a lot of heavy incoming virus to get it.

    [00:12:19] Yeah, we talked about that before. I mean, we hope that's right. We don't know the answer to any. We don't know the answer to that question for sure.

    [00:12:29] But there's a lot a lot of anecdotal evidence that says me walking down that street and calling Idaho an infected person walks by me. I walk by them.

    [00:12:42] We exchange, you know, just recip respirator at air. He's infected. I'm not. Do I get infected? So there's first. First of all, the question of where is that person in his viral load? Right. So how much virus is in him? How much is he explicating? Then the question is, how's my immune system? It's strongly believed that your immune system can can create an initial assault against initial insult. So if a little bit of the virus gets in my nose, there is a belief that my initial immune system can battle off a small insult.

    [00:13:26] A small call it a dose of the virus from that exchange and that I walk away completely unscathed.

    [00:13:36] And in that case, if you tested, you would have you wouldn't show up now and you do not thank you.

    [00:13:40] And you do not come up later. Seropositive. You didn't go through enough of an immune generation to be able to be to create the antibodies for future defense against a disease. So in that instance, what we understand now is most likely not a problem. Now, what if alternatively he sneezes right at me and it may get a ton of spittle on me. And he is at peak viral load and he appears to be a super spreader. So some people and it's not clear if it's their biology, if it's literally their mouth and throat the way they speak. Some people spread 10 times more than other people. My guess is it's like close talkers who actually just really the physics of their mouth. Just a lot of spittle coming out loud. Close talkers, lot of expiration. So let's imagine. Boom. I just get hit with this huge amount of big, huge, disgusting sneeze right on my face. Now you're starting to like, wow, OK. Maybe you could get infected that way. Now, when you science is an arguable confined space. Longer term exposure, lots of exploration. You're gonna get sick and the case study that really made this clear to me was about a choir in a church where basically everybody there got got sick because of one person. So, again, keep you know, we again, we learn through models. We learn through stories, you know, learn through stats. So just as you think about these things, think about two dynamics.

    [00:15:18] Think about the meat processing plant. Right. Close proximity, many hours, cold, damp, no UV light and people right next to each other. It rips through the meat processing plant, spreads disease. Think of a prison high density. It rips through prisons. Think about low income, high density housing families. You know, three people per bedroom. It rips through those areas. OK. So that's where it spreads. And then if this choir you're inside a room, you're singing, you're you're spending a lot of respiration back and forth, like that's high spread.

    [00:15:54] It turns out the protests, thank God, have not been cause of large spread. Why you're outside. There's usually light, there's wind motion. You know, the it's not sitting in one area getting denser and denser.

    [00:16:07] Now, also do note in protests, people are yelling, talking very loudly. There is a lot of exploration. So and by the way, there was a pretty good amount of Maheswaran in the protest so far as you can tell, by looking at videos. So. So, yeah, we do believe now the problem with all this, Tom, is, look, we went through this with my family yesterday walking down the street. I know one of the kids says we'll wait. We're outside. We don't wear masks. Nonono. So maybe everything I just said is true. We don't know for sure, but everything I told you is is probably correct. So far as I understand now, we are very, very bad at risk analysis.

    [00:16:47] There is an article near times that had exactly that headline today, which kind of made me smile because we said this in our first meeting. Right.

    [00:16:54] Humans are about it. Here's a better word, better at risk analysis, whatever it is, because we forget consequence, right?

    [00:17:03] So risk equals consequence, times likelihood. So now just imagine I'm like, hey, I kids, don't worry. You take your mask off or walking on a big open sidewalk. There's not a lot of people around. And that guy comes down and he sneezes right in my face and I get sick. The consequence is so dramatic in that instance. Well, the likelihood might be small. So what's the cost to me? Keeping a mask on as I walk down the street and with a chance of walking to somebody? The cost is super low. Throw a breath mint and by the way, so you don't get mass breath. I know that's something I pride myself on, not having bad breath like it's, you know, all of us like it. I freak out if someone tells me I have bad breath happens like once a decade. Oh my God. I feel so bad about I want to call everybody up and apologize. So, you know, mass breath is a problem. So throw a breath mint in or double scrub your teeth before you go. Don't drink it. As I learned yesterday, don't drink a cup of coffee and throw a mask on. You'll be tasting a cup of coffee for now.

    [00:17:57] You know, so many you some bad science.

    [00:18:03] The.

    [00:18:06] Connecticut doing great. Connecticut is doing just civilly speaking.

    [00:18:10] Connecticut is doing great. So that would so. So, one, if you know A plus B, transitive property thing I would do here is I would say, OK, so then therefore, if I observe the behavior of people in Connecticut, there's behavior of people in Connecticut seems to be functional. It seems to work. And that and what I see in Connecticut is just for example, I have not been in Starbucks for more than 15 seconds. And I go everyday now. I order ahead when I'm in Starbucks. I've not once seen anyone without a mask. Not one time. Everyone has on a mask every time I go in and out. They're not very close to me. I get my coffee now. I spray my coffee with alcohol because I'm sort of a freak about it. OK. So that's that. And that's the time each day where I'm the biggest interactive with people. Now I do the similar same thing in the supermarket. I go to the supermarket, they've got the hand sanitizer at the door. I put on the mask. I sanitize my hands, I shop in peace, I stay away from people. And then I leave and I get back outside and I wash my hands again and I go on my way. The one other thing I want to point out is that in my town and in your town, they've closed what is effectively the main street for parts of the main street for dining and dining protocol. As you walk in and out of the outdoor dining with a mask, when you're seated, you do not wear a mask. Your servers wear masks. And that's kind of life. I mean, you know, let me throw one more thing in there. The gym, the gym. I don't get. OK, so I go to the gym almost every day now. And I where I work, have worked out, worked out outside. One hundred percent of the day is me and Joe. Another guy I know are the only people who work out outside that I don't get.

    [00:20:00] I look at that. I don't get that at all. And I'm going to text. The governor today and remind him of that. I'm sure he knows that, but I don't get that at all.

    [00:20:12] Yeah. I mean, they're in there every day, and when I. So I have to go in to get my equipment, come out, do my workout and then bring it back in in the end. And when I go back in and each time I wear a mask and I do the spray and when I'm in there I'm kind of like, whoa, I'm in the death zone here.

    [00:20:28] I think these guys are all sweat. So here's here's part of this year. Here's like, here's why.

    [00:20:35] Pick a state that isn't. Pick a city basically that isn't, you know, the New York metro area.

    [00:20:41] Seattle, New Orleans, pick a state or city that hasn't had a crisis yet. So here we are calling out. Right. And there's two dramatically different things here versus what's going on in, for example, New York metro area. So one is people just aren't doing what you're doing. Right. They're not doing the hand sanitizer program. They're not doing them scoring program. They're not doing the social distancing program. Right. So those things are huge. It's not happening here because, again, they they just don't get it right because they haven't learned it. Now, just footnote. They were doing things like that in South Korea for years before Saar's Kobe to Cauvin, 19, showed up because of their memory of Meurs just as disremember. So they were used to those behaviors in South Korea as an example. And in Japan and in in a number of other countries that have done really well, they were used to those behaviors before Korona showed up. So guess what? When Crenna showed up, they had a natural defense. They already were doing fine. You know, they already were doing those behaviors. And then when they were told to double down on those behaviors, it was very easy to do. There's other reasons, and that's why many of those countries, all those countries are doing beautifully. And we look like a frickin dumpster fire and they look like a gar, a garden party. Right. So. So that's part one.

    [00:22:07] And can I assume that they're behaving in the ways I just said? Is that generally.

    [00:22:11] Well, yeah. Yeah. How do they go out to lunch to. They're not like all. No. They're not locked in their room at all. Go, go.

    [00:22:18] South Korea. Japan, you know, Japan is a little different. They they've been they've been kind of open for business whole time, but they've been doing really good mask wearing and a bunch of their, you know, the sanitation steps you took.

    [00:22:28] And they're fine. They're better in a much, much, much, much better. Like orders of magnitude logarithmically better than they are embarrassing. So that's part one, right? You have those just sanitary behaviors and you can think of a thousand analogies. Right. So, you know. I don't know. I could find only examples, I can think of her fellow fairly disgusting. But we know that when we use sanitary behaviors, we don't get sick. OK, fine. That's part one. Here's part two. It's the amount of disease that's just endemic, right? The amount of disease that's floating around. And I'm trying to find the right analogy. So here's what I've come up with. So a vending machine at, you know, a vending machine. So I'm picturing because we watch friends all the time. The vending machines and friends. I sorry. I mean, the office. So the vending machine, it's got 50 pieces of candy or chips or bags you can get. So imagine a vending machine that every interaction you have turns one of the dials and out drops whatever's in that machine. So in New York, at the peak of the crisis, the vending machine, of course, was in our example is full. And like, you know, half of all, to be accurate, probably 20 percent of the things the vending machine where a virus, 80 percent were an apple. So you pressed, boom, what do I get? Boom, one fifth of the time out dropped the virus. So now now you've got a viral insults and you've got, you know, are you ready for this or not? So boom, outcomes of virus. Did you wash your hands? Did you wear a mask? Were you social distance? Were you able to grazed by that one? No problem. Hey, victory. Now, here now. So now in Connecticut, Tom, ironically, that vending machine is like five percent virus. Ninety five percent not meaning a vast majority of people who are tested in Connecticut. Less than five percent have the virus. So every interaction you have with a person, you know, statistically, 95 percent chance you're not actually confronting the virus. New York, during the peak, there was a 20 percent chance, you know, four times more, 40 percent more likely you work in fighting the virus. So you're at bat. You know, you you had you had you know, when you press the vending machine, you were getting a virus opportunity, the chance to get infected, much, much more likely historically. New York, you know, two months ago now in Idaho, less than Connecticut.

    [00:24:48] Now, thankfully, the number is nine. So on a gross volume aren't very high in a per capita volume are very high. But on a growth volume, on a growth basis, they're quite high.

    [00:24:57] So, again, you better as the disease. And so what ends up happening and this is I hope I'm not losing you, but not I'm not losing the audience here.

    [00:25:06] But what ends up happening on a large scale basis is you get to where a leader from the CDC two days ago said we are now in America, which is basically there's so much disease here now that a lot of the institutional public health tools will no longer work.

    [00:25:26] What am I talking about? Mass wearing? Absolutely handwashing. Absolutely. Social distancing. Absolutely must. You must do. You must do. And they are really your only line of defense if you don't lock yourself at home. But testing and tracing, particularly contact tracing, probably will not work in America anymore. Why? There's just too much disease running around. There are too many outbreaks in too many places. So the end that's on one side and then on the other side. Call it the demand side. On the supply side, the ability to supply that need. We do not have sufficient contact tracing skills in almost any state in this country. Maybe Massachusetts does. Maybe so. Very few states have the ability to contact trace. The disease is so rampant now that many states are just asking to even try.

    [00:26:16] So so what we've talked about a lot is it's a whole lot easier to deal with these things early on in the progression.

    [00:26:25] You have to nip it in the bud. We did not nip it in the bud. We now have a massive forest growing of this disease. The vending machine is very full and we don't have the ability to do some of the public health tools we need to do it. So as we've said over and over, it gets down to you. It's you not going in the gym. It's my kids wearing the mask on the street. And it's the person serving the food, wearing a mask, et cetera. So it's totally and completely up to individuals right now. So just to be explicit, what the leaders of the U.S. Public Health Service CDC said last week, that the disease is too rampant for us to do effective contact tracing anymore. Right. It's really, really up to us now.

    [00:27:13] Can we talk about. I want to get your feedback. I read the story about the bounty rush in Afghanistan, bounties on U.S. soldiers. It's one of these stories where depending on.

    [00:27:26] The source, the details, it could be a big story, could be a medium story. Could be a small story. What do you know about it?

    [00:27:35] I guess a couple of things I might know that others don't know immediately is so quickly. The story is that the Russian government offered members of the Taliban or other people in Afghanistan bounties cash for killing American soldiers. Wow. That's pretty shitty, right? Meaning just to be explicit, like, hey, Afghanistan, private X or Taliban member X, if you go blow up a Humvee, you go shoot a sniper round into an American Marine or whatever it is, we'll give you 10000 bucks, whatever the number is. Which, of course, is the king's ransom in these countries. So it's an assassination, right? Paid assassination. Russia's not at war with us. It's a war crime. No, it's just a fucking evil thing. Right. So let's start with that.

    [00:28:25] Now, here's what I know, that maybe most people don't live with this kind of reality. That's not shocking. Covert, it's horrible, it's illegal, it's wrong. America does not do that. Don't let anyone tell you, oh, we do that, too. They just got caught. Bullshit. We do not.

    [00:28:45] At all.

    [00:28:48] But in the dark world of covert activity, this isn't unheard of. Why does Russia want to do this? Is it because they want Afghanistan to win the war and kill American soldiers, like in a one to one battle? No, it's because they want to keep us on our toes. They want to keep us chasing our tail. They want to keep us in a panic mode. Why? Same reason they want to fuck with our elections. Same reason that they they just the more confused and desperate and panicked we are, the better it is for them, just zero battle as just a zero balance of power equation by them.

    [00:29:28] So that's why they want to do it.

    [00:29:32] Now, the quick show, that's like that's sort of, you know, paragraph three in the stories, paragraph one and two in the news stories in America are what did Trump know and when did he know it and what he'd do about it? So the liberal media would like us to believe that Trump. Here's here's what like the liberal media would love for us to believe right now. And they're teasing this. And I don't know if it's true or not. Trump fully knew this. The intelligence community came to him, gave him complete awareness that this was happening on date X. And then, you know, in the time after that, he continued to pander to Putin and be friendly to Russia. He never raised it. He never pressed them. And look, this soldier, this airman, this Marine was killed, assassinated. And that bounty program buyer, Russian paid Afghanistani soldier during that program. And Trump did shit about it. So that's like that's the worst case scenario. We don't know if that's true at all. I think we I think we understand now that American military members were killed by Russian paid assassins in this instance. That's really bad. What is not known yet, and it will clearly be known unless they destroy their records, is if President Trump is briefed on this or not. The director of national intelligence, who's nominally the absolute head of the intelligence community, above the CIA, above the NSA, above the CIA, above all that.

    [00:31:02] It's an on again, I say nominal because the system's not really been rationalized yet. That person came out with a press release yesterday, I think, or two days ago, and said the president was not told of this.

    [00:31:16] That person, the director of national intelligence right now is a partizan selected, highly partizan person. He is not a proven long term intelligence professional.

    [00:31:26] And by the way, that's why his appointment was very controversial. Normally in these jobs, you don't really want a partizan as much as you want an expert professional. And this guy is neither. He's a partizan. So that's you know, that's the story. My. So what has to happen? It's pretty obvious we have to figure out. I launched it in the reality versus political reality.

    [00:31:54] It's gonna be muddy anyway about what Trump did. No, it didn't know. No, I think we are pretty clearly understand at this point the man apparently he talks eighty five percent of the time during his intelligence briefings. Right. We know he makes bad decisions. I happen to think he's. Now we know he makes bad decisions. And when he does rarely take his intelligence briefings, he doesn't listen, he talks and tries to prove the intelligence briefer, how smart he is on these topics versus having the best expertize in America presented to him so he can make informed decisions. He likes to spend this time apparently showing off to the briefers about what he knows. So he doesn't listen much anyway. So was it in what's called the PDB, PDB, the president's daily brief, which is a very, very special document that's put together the entire intelligence apparatus every day, focuses on what do we tell the president today? It's an amazing focus of intellectual effort.

    [00:32:50] And that document, the PDB, is guarded like the king's treasure. I mean, it's, you know, the tiniest number people get to see it. It's got unbelievable secrets in it. It's presented to the president. They worked really hard on how to present and who presents what. You know, there's a big dance around this.

    [00:33:06] It's a ballet and.

    [00:33:09] And was it in there or not? We don't know.

    [00:33:12] But if it was at all ever briefed to him, a competent leader who holds this holy mantle of power in America. And here's why it's holy. Here's why it's holy to be present United States. This example. Exactly. You are the ultimate safeguard in this instance for American lives. So if it had been raised with him one way or the other and they said, hey, we're not so sure our confidence in this intelligence is this sourcing is not so great. This is kind of how you determine if you listen to intelligence or not a competent leader. And I don't know if he did or didn't, should say put on stop what you're telling me that Russia has a bounty program, possibly even 10 percent likely on our troops. Get to the bottom of that right now. I need an answer to that. That's a humongous deal. Deal with it. And we don't know that he did that or not. But my guess is that's not the way he operates. And apparently that's not how he uses his intelligence briefings to God interact and said he uses it to show off. So, I mean, come on, what point are we going to recognize this guy is just a total buffoon and it just sort of expect the worst. And that's about where it appears he's going to meet you on these issues. Sorry.

    [00:34:23] I mean, I know that's a little more political than we've been, but this is an issue that really bothers me. And having worked in intelligence for a long, long time, this is appalling.

    [00:34:36] And my expectation is that nothing will come of it because it's just too muddy and it'll stay muddy and that's what it'll be. I think that's right.

    [00:34:46] But it also points to. So let's imagine that the honest answer is no. No one ever briefed the president. So now, look, to be fair, if it was a really bad source, you know, walk in. Right. Some guy walks into the U.S. embassy in Afghanistan and says, you know, whatever it is, I have this information, pay me for it. And his story doesn't hold together. This happens every day.

    [00:35:06] People show up to the U.S. government, say, I have a secret. I want to tell you. You take care of me, happens constantly. And so a big part of the frontline of U.S. intelligence and U.S. diplomacy is fending off this disinformation, these these liars. So it's the magic comes and it's super weak and it's not well sourced.

    [00:35:23] It's not reliable. There's no there's no backup evidence. You could absolutely. It would be OK if that wasn't proven or sorry.

    [00:35:29] Brought up to the president what we learned. So the story that came out a couple days ago, the initial reporting said America got turned on to this possibility because we found caches of cache caches of U.S. dollars in some F in some Taliban strongholds that we overran. Right. So so we busted down the door and some Taliban room and found, you know, ten thousand U.S. dollars, which is a humungous amount of money for them to have whatever the number is. Five thousand, ten thousand twenty thousand. I don't know as we'd shut as we chase down where this cash come from. We came up with this reality that the Russians were paying bounties. Right. So that was the initial story that didn't really ring true to me. By the way, that wouldn't be that alone. You'd have a pretty hard time creating very, very credible intelligence around that to bring to the president, because you'd only have human sources. You'd have a couple young Taliban foot soldiers. They'd tell you, oh, yeah, the Russians gave it to us. Who's the Russian? I don't know. This and that. You know, saturate the news yesterday, which seemed more like the way America would have high confidence in intelligence was about movement of cash out of bank accounts we know are controlled by Russians. So now you're getting into like what's called maybe more signals intelligence versus human intelligence, much more reliable generally. You can really audit the information.

    [00:36:48] You don't have to see if, you know, Taliban foot soldier acts as lying to you or not. You know, you're actually looking at the transfer numbers. And so that's that's what the intel was.

    [00:36:59] And so if that's the case and someone didn't brief the president, that's a failure of leadership underneath the president. And that ultimately actually gets to a failure of his leadership for not having the right people in the right positions.

    [00:37:11] And we saw that in the Navy with the Captain crosier's situation with the USS Theodore Roosevelt. Right. So Crosier probably made a good decision. He then got relieved by the acting secretary of Navy who proved who proved to be a very incompetent leader. And he was like the third secretary of Navy in that position, the Trump administration, because they were just a series of poor picks by the president over and over and over.

    [00:37:37] I know. I'm rambling.

    [00:37:38] Last point I would ask you to look at the Trump the Trump cabinet positions, the people in national security positions picked by Trump, including chief of staff positions. You'd find every single one of them who has left has done so criticizing the president.

    [00:37:53] So suffice it to say, he doesn't pick great people or which was what he'd want us to believe, or they they are of some value and they come out, they criticize him later. But the leadership dynamic is clearly not working. And here's an example of where that may have failed to bring proper intelligence to the commander in chief of time we needed.

    [00:38:11] There's a fair amount of talk about how he's going to bag it.

    [00:38:16] No, I don't believe it. You don't believe it? No, I think.

    [00:38:22] I think his fear of what comes without presidential immunity is so strong. I think the Dunning Kruger effect on him is so real, meaning he thinks he's much smarter than everybody else. Meaning he thinks he can pull a trick on us that, you know, will make him win. I think his narcissism is so overwhelming and I think the breadth of tools he has available to him is so vast. And he knows that that he's not going to give up without grabbing all sorts of clubs out of his golf bag, all sorts of weapons from his arsenal and flinging them at the situation to see what happens. I strongly believe this man does not want to get out of the Oval Office for a variety reasons. One being he fears prosecution from the Southern District of New York, perhaps for crimes related to sexual activity or other things. And while he has the cloak of immunity, presidential immunity, which he has, you know, he's protected from that. So I think that is a strong motivator for him not to lose, not to walk away. That might be a little shocking for people to hear me say that. But I don't say that.

    [00:39:33] I say that based on talking to people who are aware of potential prosecutorial activity against him. So, no, I think nothing he can do in advance of that.

    [00:39:46] Right. I. The president apparently cannot pardon himself. I think is what we learned during the Nixon administration. I could be wrong. And but what he tried to do was fire the prosecutor from New York. He tried to put a loyalist in that job. He went golfing with Adam Clayton Powell. I think that's his name. Head of the FCC. Right. And they had a conversation. And at the end of the conversation, he announced rapidly he was going to fire the lead prosecutor in the southern district of New York. So the FDNY Southern District in New York is also nicknamed the sovereign district nickname of New York, because they pursue things a politically historically most you know, a lot of prosecutors offices do. Cuz you put a loyalist in there, I suspect the plan was get in there, figure out what kind of trash they have against me and crush it while I still am in power. And thereby I can reduce the chance of having trouble when I no longer presidential immunity. That's my theory. Not just mine. And of course, that got foiled and he wasn't allowed to do that. There's a real conundrum about Attorney General Barr, who does not have the authority to fire that prosecutor, firing that prosecutor and claiming that the person who does have the authority to do it, the president ordered him to do it than the president claiming, no, I had nothing to do with this. So it's really a bit of a goat rope on that one. So that's one thing he could do. But look. But, Tom, what I'm referring to isn't about what he does about that persay. It's about what he does to try to ensure he doesn't have to leave office. And so, you know, that gets to, you know, probably some very untoward activities that we're going to see in the next couple of months. And in fact, I've historically I've said the last few months that look for August, September, October and and into November, obviously to be a really, really rancid time in America and a really horrible time for how we treat each other. And massively that's sadly divisive, mostly partizan.

    [00:41:50] I was just reminded that because there will be so much mail in balloting that that timeframe might move up, that if you wanted to embarrass the president, for example, an October surprise they used to call it, maybe you should make it a September surprise if the president wanted to do something on his end instead of making it in October, maybe June, September, so that that whole world might accelerate a little bit, too. We might. So it might be more like July, August, September versus moving that I had one or two work months where we're gonna see a huge amount of ugliness.

    [00:42:24] Not that's what I think is going to happen. And so, I mean, you know, voter suppression by Republican governors I think will be a big deal.

    [00:42:35] And I think the president's instinct, of course, is to divide. You know, that's where he that's where he's best. That's his best animal instinct. I think that's working against him now. So we'll see. So Hong Kong.

    [00:42:55] The. I think I'm pretty correct in saying that if you if you're if you if you live in Hong Kong, you were raised in Hong Kong, you essentially live in a place that is not so unlike living in the United States. The freedoms that we have in the United States, the financial systems we have in the United States, it's very much like growing up and living within the United States. And basically what China has done is China has made a move to make Hong Kong effectively exactly like China, which is to say. You know, if you if you make trouble, I'm going to bring in to China and put you in a jail in regular China. That's how that's gonna go down. A Mai Mai characterizing that correctly. And B, if I am right, imagine.

    [00:43:43] As an American, how you would react to that? To me, it seems impossible that the culture of Hong Kong will ever accept the culture of China without, frankly, a lot of bloodshed.

    [00:43:54] May sound dramatic, but I just don't see it happening.

    [00:43:58] Mm hmm. Yeah. So just quickly to sit at it, previously a misnamed the head of the SCC who Trump tried to put in as the lead prosecutor NSD and why the name was Jay Clayton.

    [00:44:10] So we try to put and not not Adam Clayton Powell in Hong Kong. Hong Kong's a real sad story, Tom. You're exactly right.

    [00:44:21] Yeah, so Hong Kong is very much like New York, you know, a year ago. Free speech. You know, pretty clear, pretty fair system of jurisprudence. And now through this accelerated in various assertive national security law promulgated by Beijing, they are now going to live under, as you well put it, you know, sort of like the same mandates, same laws as you'd have in Beijing, which means living under a totalitarian, totalitarian demagogery.

    [00:44:55] Communist. And, yeah, so it's really shitty. And there's there's not much that's going to happen. So there's not much you can do about it. You have an optimistic view.

    [00:45:05] It sounds like, which is that the people of Hong Kong, the culture of Hong Kong, couldn't, you know, will will not in any near term be morphed into looking like the culture of Beijing or Shanghai. Now, to be clear, you walk around the streets of Shanghai, you don't feel like you're in a totalitarian state. You feel like you're in a thriving capitalist area. And half of half, that's half. It's half correct. But you also are in a place where if you get on your phone and try to access the wrong thing in the Internet, A, you can't because it's all locked down. There is no freedom of information. And B, if you write the wrong thing, you can go to jail for life. Or if you do the wrong thing, you can be executed by the state and they bill your family for the bullet. Right. I mean, it is a it's a harsh reality. It just doesn't appear to be until you scratch at it in Hong Kong's head in that direction. I'm not as optimistic as you that the culture and people of Hong Kong and Hong Kong's will be able to resist that for long. I hope that China is somewhat thoughtful and careful about how they implement the national sovereignty law in Hong Kong, how they implement this reintegration, that you're smart enough, at least pragmatically smart enough, not to just drop the hammer and crush everybody. But at the same time, they clearly are going to have to show that they're in charge now. So there will probably be protests today, tomorrow. Coming up. In Hong Kong, they will have to be large or people won't do it. They're going to want to find safety in numbers in Hong Kong and in those protests, I think the Chinese government will probably have to insist on the arrest of a few people. And the, you know, what we would probably call know really cruel treatment to them to show the people of Hong Kong, hey, you know, so new sheriff in town, new set of rules. We'll see. And why do I say pragmatic? Because they still have to live in the international court of public opinion to some extent. Beijing does. They still want to entice Taiwan into their borders eventually, although that they must know that's not going to happen peacefully.

    [00:47:14] And so ideally, they don't come out and act like complete rogues and crush everybody. We'll see. But it's going to be fascinating and somewhat horrible to watch. Thank you. It's very sad. Yeah. Jerry Cohen from NYU, who is one of the best experts on China and Hong Kong, wrote yesterday in a piece that didn't get enough coverage that, you know, he's he's been doing this for 60 years. He's there's really no one smarter on this from the American side. And he said. You know, the spirit of Hong Kong will survive. Don't worry. When she's out of office, this will be changed. And I think that's another example of overoptimism. She's not leaving office anytime soon unless it's feetfirst and. This is a new, assertive China. So that's really a punch line. China, historically, the sum of Mao's Tennant's kind of lie laid in wait, laid quietly and and amassed its power and its arms and its economic strength, which it's done and now encourage this. And it always kind of sat back and didn't act very assertively. And that's change we see. We now clearly see a more assertive China. So the Sleeping Dragon has a woak to use. Some of the language of the conversation in Hong Kong is one of the places where the Talon's or the flames have landed most hard. And we'll see, you know, how long that persists. So I would probably disagree with you that Hong Kong will come out of this with the same spirit it had a year ago.

    [00:48:52] Yeah, yeah, and I guess for me, I mean, for whatever reason, between what's been going on in the United States, I watched I'm not done yet, but I'm watching the movie Reds again. I'm watching Babylon Berlin.

    [00:49:04] Which which rights are you watching? Watching the Warren Beatty o k rom movie I was thinking of what's that movie where the kids run up in the hills and they say Wolverines over Hanieh Red Dawn Red, Dark Red, Dawn, Lovebug.

    [00:49:19] But Redds is incredible. And then there's Babylon, Berlin. It's just so good. It's so well done. Three seasons. It's on Netflix, it's subtitles.

    [00:49:28] But man, it really describes like the drama behind a revolutionary moment in in Germany. And then you know what's going on in our own country, and it's very hard for me to imagine people like us living under a resent a regime like you see in China.

    [00:49:51] But, you know, time will tell and these things are different. Let me mention one more thing and then we'll go. But, you know, Mississippi. Mississippi. The change in the Mississippi flag. It's been an incredible few weeks for this kind of stuff.

    [00:50:05] You know, NASCAR statues and now Mississippi, you know, the Mississippi state flag with the Confederate emblem. Pretty amazing. Pretty amazing. What's what's happening right here. And, you know, I have to say and it did that for me. It's.

    [00:50:30] It's overdue, but I'm not from the South and I you know, I my perspective is is different from many peoples. It seems like the right thing to do. But let me just say why I'm so amazed by it is this is not the first run at this stuff that's been going on as long as I've been alive. But this just in the last few weeks that this change has come fast and it's powerful.

    [00:50:55] I yeah, Aymen. I mean, I am I have just zero zero tolerance for a Confederate flag.

    [00:51:02] Right. It's a flag of treason. It's a flag of failure. It's a flag of slavery. It's a flag of genocide.

    [00:51:08] I mean, it's fucking appalling that someone would wave that thing. Sorry, I keep cursing, but I just find that I mean, what what an emblem of idiocy and horror.

    [00:51:18] And the thing that makes even worse, as we know, is these Confederate statues and the application, the Confederate flag to the Mississippi flag and other flags was done well after the Confederate after the Civil War. It was done as a move to remind African-Americans that the KKK lingers, that they are subject still to massive oppression just to try to put fear in their hearts. You know, just a just evil, right. Like many of the statues that were put up were of of intentionally of the most racist and evil Confederate leaders, not of the even of the people who were excellent at building the Confederacy on the battlefield. It was people who were hurt the most atrocious to slaves. And that was done by the KKK. Many of those statutes were put up for those reasons in the in the early and in mid nineteen hundreds. Well, after the war.

    [00:52:05] So it's just appalling. Thank God they're coming down. Thank God this came off the flag. And shame on anybody who who pushed against it in the decades passed. But yeah. Yeah, it's great. It's great. It's really it's it's terrific that we're finally getting there. And it it there's some lesson in here about how hard it is to get things done in this democracy.

    [00:52:30] You know that it's taken some of these statues have been taken down, quote unquote, illegally. Well, not quote unquote. They've been taken down illegally. But I think by most people's measure, properly, correctly, like this should have happened so long ago. And, you know, this is what federalism is interesting.

    [00:52:49] I mean, it's. Well, you know Bryan Stevenson. When he talked about themes in his book, I've read his book, which I commend what it's called Just Mercy. And he describes that, you know, he would bring these cases in late 90s and they were mostly black men, mostly on death row. All certainly in his view and mostly proven. So to be wrongly accused or wrongly convicted, I should say, of horrible crimes, often with the death sentence as a penalty.

    [00:53:23] And the thing that he talks about is that let's say he would lose a lot of these cases in the 90s and he'd retry them in the 2010s, let's say. Well, the thing he would say is like the legal strategy was exactly the same. It's just the narrative of the of the world changes the same. Legal facts meet a different fate as the narrative of the world changes. And so the narrative of the world is changing. You know, one of the most impressive things in the last few weeks to me was NASCAR. Like, they jumped on that and said, no, no rebel flags at NASCAR ever again. They got behind Bubba Wallace and like all marched in unison with him and it was like, wow, bang. Like, we're gonna we're going to confront this head on. And they did. It was really impressive.

    [00:54:07] We were talking the other day about some friends of mine and I apparently George Floyds, four year old daughter.

    [00:54:15] Said My daddy changed the world. Not obviously entirely understand what's going on in the world and sadly not having a daddy anymore, but saying my daddy changed the world. And.

    [00:54:33] You know, there are potentially very I mean, there what we're talking about are silver linings on the Slow Motion murder of a defenseless man by our police force.

    [00:54:47] The silver linings might be quite strong here. And we might be finally waking up to, as you put, as you put it, like the necessary cultural shift on some historical horrors that we got to just change. So maybe an end. Imagine if the George Floyd protests. And all this social observation that's happened since his murder mobilizes more voters of any sort in this next election.

    [00:55:24] That will have changed the world when more people vote, Democrats win, if more African-Americans vote, historically, Democrats win if more young people vote. Historically, Democrats win. And historically, young people and African-Americans and other minorities don't vote at the same rate as older white people. Same proportion. So there's I mean, I think everyone knows this now, but there's this voter mobilization is the number one key for Democrats to win if George Floyds murder mobilizes more voters. That could be the way that Donald Trump loses. And Joe Biden becomes president. And that, as George Floyds, four year old daughter put could have changed the world. And it's not just America. Right. The president had state sits on a mantle with influence across the entire world, obviously.

    [00:56:23] So Arpey, she's six years old. Her name's Janet Gianna Floyd and I have it. Let's just look at it real quick on two slots, Sheriff, to go right back work. She would never say the word daddy's changing the word very cute kid.

    [00:56:46] And powerful and sad.

    [00:56:53] I remember when when my friend John O'Neill died on 9/11, which is a whole nother story, obviously. I called up a dear mutual friend of ours and I had the sad news to report to them that they had found John's body. We were pretty sure he was dead. They found his body very soon after the tower had collapsed. And I called up and John had died, a hero truck running in and out of the tower, saving people. Well aware that that second tower was going to fall. In his suit with his, you know, Bruno Magli shoes on, meaning not prepared for this. And he was pulling people out of the lobby. So I said to our mutual friend, at least John died a hero. Here comes another curse. And he said, fuck that. Go tell that to his son. Who's going to now not have a daddy? So. While it's true that George Floyds murder appears to be making a massive and positive impact on the world right now, that little girl is gonna grow up without a daddy.

    [00:57:55] So Fourth of July, I hope everyone has a safe one.

    [00:58:00] All right, great. Happy. I guess I'd be Fourth of July everybody then. Stay safe.

    59 min
  • rp daily: in mask we trust

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    in mask we trust. following up to friday's episode with police chief william bratton, tom and rp discuss leadership in police departments. going further into the episode, they turn to the topic of covid-19 and it's resurgence in states that were not initially impacted: how can it be handled in rural areas? at what rate is the pandemic still spreading? rp points out the full capacity of icu's in texas and arizona, the politicization of face masks, and the varying degrees of leadership across different levels of the american government.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    Copyright TNP 2020

    we sometimes receive a small commission for purchases made when visiting some links provided in our show notes and we wanted you to know.

    52 min
  • rp daily: re-imagine the police

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    re-imagine the police. tom and rp sit down to discuss the state of policing in america with police chief william bratton. amid mounting encouragement to reform policing in america, bratton discusses systemic changes from both outside and inside the police. bratton served as the New York City police commissioner for two terms (1994–1996 and 2014–2016) after previously serving as the Boston police commissioner. he also took on the role of chief of police in L.A. and continues to influence American law enforcement today. he is the author of the book Turnaround.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    rp daily re-imagine the police.mp3

    [00:00:18] Good morning, everybody, my name is Tom Scott. Chairman of the Nantucket Project, join, as I always am, by R.P. Eddy. Also today by Chief William Bratton, who Arpey, who has a long history with and is going to give us an introduction to the chief. So, Arpey, take it away.

    [00:00:35] Chief, I'm so glad you're here. Thanks for being here.

    [00:00:37] In as an unfamiliar and I don't think many people are, you're considered perhaps one of the greatest leaders of policing in last century. I'm not the only person to have said that far, far from it. You're the only person to have been the chief of police of both L.A. and New York, America's largest cities. In fact, you were the police, the police leader in New York twice. You are largely credited for the massive decline in crime in New York from about 26, 27 years ago, when it was perhaps the least livable, least safe city in America to now when it's one of the safest in America. Most folks say you are a humungous, if not the sole reason for that to happen. You also, as I mentioned, the police commissioner of Los Angeles, end of Boston, you've helped London and the UK with their policing system. You've been recognized by the queen as a OBD for your service there. And you're generally recognized as one of the foremost leaders on on advances in policing, such as cop stop broken Windows series, variety of other things. You and I have been friends for well over a decade. It's been a pleasure to work with you. You and I spent most of our time working on counterterrorism, another area where you've been an extraordinary leader. And perhaps as we talked today, counter-terrorism might be one of the reasons the police are in a bit of the pickle they're in today about the militarization of police. It's something we hear a lot about, etc.. So it's it's a privilege to have you here. I really appreciate you taking the time. And I look forward to learning from you in a moment when being a police officer in America is probably as hard as ever been. And being a black man in America is probably as hard as it's ever been as well. So this is a tumultuous time. And leaders like you who have deep knowledge, deep wisdom and deep empathy are going to be critical to us to to chart a path ahead. Well, I know there's a lot of good actors and way more than there are bad actors. So thanks for spending some time with us.

    [00:02:22] It's great to be with you. If I may expand a little on the introduction as relates to you and I. When I go back a little, almost a quarter of a century, not 10 years.

    [00:02:31] That is how much time flies experience together expanded greatly post 9/11 days that those that know, you know, you have a particular interest and expertize in the area. Terrorism, your relationship with many of the top leaders in the world in that regard. Coming up, Richard Clarke, who certainly was a major player in the events of 9/11, was introduced to to you. Our relationship is that close that, you know, I offered you a position with me when I went to the LAPD with John Miller, who was heading up counterterrorism, to come out and work with us to create for that department its counterterrorism expansion after 9/11. And we've kept in touch on a myriad of issues since that time and a privilege to be here to also attend that great conference you put together here in New York with many of the leaders in the world discussing many of the world's issues. I can hardly wait for the 20/20 version of that for all that's going on. It's going to have room for all the issues that need to be discussed. So just a little background for you, your audience in terms of I am a sensitive patient.

    [00:03:44] Thank you, Chief.

    [00:03:49] Chief, what I thought I do is just give you a little bit more of an intro to the show and then also just to give an audience a sense of the point of view as we come at this today. I think it goes without saying where three white men here, our perspectives are what they are and limited to certain extent, which makes sense to me. My great grandfather, Charlie Scott, was the chief of police of Porchester, New York, many years ago.

    [00:04:13] My father, both father and brother Marines. I would describe myself politically as a version of a libertarian, which is to say generally maybe a little bit more conservative than most. But I also have a specific view of the time that we're in, and it relates in many ways to that the tenor of the show. And generally we've avoided politics because our feeling was that particularly in a time of Kova getting out really reliable information, which was very meaningful and towards the tail end or whatever, or, you know, a number of months into the covered story, the George flawed story kind of blew up. And the tenor of the show has changed a little bit. And I thought that I would give us just a quick video introduction, which sort of outlines partly my point of view, because you'll see it a lot from my point of view. But I think also will outline generally the point of view of the show itself and in a way that I think might be helpful both to you and to people watching. So I'm going to do that now.

    [00:05:23] Friday, I participated in a in a demonstration in the city. I went to New York and who was a Black Lives Matter gathering. And it was pretty powerful, I have to say, was one of the more powerful experiences in my life. I got very emotional, you know, and I got emotional in an unexpected moments from unexpected things. It was people's passion. Like I was really inspired by their passion was very clear to me that there was big groups of people who were sort of at their wit's end. But they also just had such I felt hope. That's what I felt. I felt a degree of hope and like a strident desire to be heard. And I thought I was beautiful. What followed was the mayor of Washington and the city council.

    [00:06:18] Yeah.

    [00:06:19] Change the name of the it became Black Lives Matter Plaza. They wrote Black Lives Matter in the road.

    [00:06:25] In between the street and the White House is Lafayette Square. And this image from the sky showed the White House currently occupied by Donald Trump and Black Lives Matter. And for me, I posted that on Instagram. I've never done a political post. I don't know if you call that a political post. I guess you'd probably call it political post. I know exactly where I stand on that image. I know exactly that. I stand with the hopes of what Black Lives Lives Matter currently represents versus the way the White House is acting and speaking. I just I know exactly where I stand and that, you know, anyone who starts starts to bring up different technicalities of either side of that equation. I know exactly where I stand on that equation, which brought me to do it. And you're right. We are talking a lot about Donald Trump. It's interesting because you if you've been listening, you hear us say what we say about politics.

    [00:07:24] But what we and we talk about it from a point of view of humanity like we want to be. We wanted to be informative to humanity about covered. And I stand there still. But I think humanity has been played out so clearly in my head that it's hard to keep my mouth shut. And in some ways, it does relate to my children, but it also just relates to this notion of my brothers and my sisters, symbolically speaking, at myse fellow citizens like I want to. I want to be part of a healthy, happy, loving culture. And therefore, whether you think we should be back to business or not around COVA, just wear a mask. It's OK. Like no one's it's OK. You're going to be better off with the mask and you can probably be in business and you can treat people with respect and you can treat people with love and lift them up and do. Those are the things we do not have to be an opposition to ourselves all the time. And if the president is going to so loudly proclaim his desire for divisiveness, I'm going to declare the other. So, you know, you get a sense I mean, again, that was a lot of that was personal to me.

    [00:08:26] But I think it also reflects the journey that the show has been on. And I'm comfortable today talking about specifics, of course. Oh, maybe it's not, of course. But I am. And I know that this the spirit of the conversation will be healthy. But I also just wanted to, again, set up short sort of how we were viewing this and why I think, you know, having these kinds of conversations at this time is is, you know, important, but also tricky. And I'm sure this isn't the first you've heard of this. So anyway, Arpey, that that's sort of my setup for today. And I'm going to toss it to you and and let let's let's get into it. And again, Chief, thank you so much for being here. We really appreciate it.

    [00:09:07] Chief Bratton, again, it's so great to be with you. Thanks. This is one of you. Is there been a more difficult time to be a police officer right now? Is there ever been a moment that's been as complex as this right now what we're seeing?

    [00:09:20] I don't think there's ever been a more difficult time, but certainly from my experiences over 50 years and.

    [00:09:29] The idea of the show being on a journey, in fact, policing has been on a journey since. What I would describe as its beginning in 1829, Sir Robert Peel. Metropolitan Police has nine principles which have been basically my Bible. And that first principle was that the basic mission for which the police exist is to prevent crime and disorder. And another principles is the idea that the people are the police and the police are the people. And I would describe where we are on that journey now as in question point, as a extraordinary point in time, a time of revolution.

    [00:10:15] The 50 years I've been associated with policing has been an evolutionary period interrupted by four or five revolutions. Let me take a moment just to take you back and bring you forward. 1970, I commit to policing in Boston. Just back in Vietnam War was a time of great change in our country. Similar demonstrations we're experiencing now against the war in support of civil rights time with great hope and optimism, so much of which faded over the next 20 years as the issues of race seemingly got better. But as we're clearly seen recently, there was always just beneath the surface, this volcano ready to erupt. Policing also went through phenomenal changes in this time mostly for the better. We entered in the 70s and 80s, what we call the professional era, which were going to try and professionalize, try and prove ourselves. And we ended up in what we describe also as the response, Florian's era emphasis on responding to crime after the fact. 9/11 reactive investigations wasn't we please could prevent crime, that society was going to be responsible for that. But society failed miserably in the 70s and 80s. So by 1990, after 10 years of steady crime increase, 1990 was crime in the history of our country. Certainly New York City is reflected on that. Police, leaders, academics, reformers, community activists got together in Harvard Kennedy School and at the executive sessions and came up with a new philosophy of policing called Community Policing, the idea of partnership, community working together, focusing on mutually agreed problems with a return to emphasis on prevention. And it's been my model of policing actually since the 70s as a young guy in Boston. The focus of Sir Robert Peel on not only the prevention of crime, but also just sort of the so-called broken windows quality of life, emphasized something we must focus on in the 70s and 80s. And in responding only to crime, we didn't focus on preventing it in the 90s in the community police era. We created a new successful revolutionary step, timely, accurate focus on crime, the extent that we could predict where was going to occur. Focus on also quality of life to prevent things from getting larger. By focusing on them when they were small for that area, we also began what has been one of the main targets of a lot of the demonstrations. Mass incarceration. We had to try to correct the chaos of the 70s and 80s. Well intended efforts to control behavior. A lot of people went to jail, started to join treatment to alternative types of correction of behavior. And we ended up with some of the terrible grievances we're dealing with today. We also one of the tools we use was overused over the next 20 or 30 years by American police in New York and elsewhere. That's the stop, question and frisk tool. Absolutely essential policing. But it was overused in any event. The 90s saw 40 to 50 percent decline in violent crime in the country. And as we moved into the 21st century, we were then in the midst of another revolution, 9/11, which by policing into the counterterrorism world, but policing coming into the counterterrorism world became much more intrusive into the private lives of many citizens, Muslim citizens. Once again, our black citizens in new ways that were being challenged. So police will once again find themselves in conflict. And then we ended another revolution in 2006 to 2008, social media revolution. The smartphone was invented. And without all the technology that's flow creating the social media effort, kindle Twitter so much that shapes our world today. And please, trying to get their minds around that and to use it. And then now the era that we're in, which effectively is the precision focus of policing, using intelligence so that we can concentrate on the criminal that we identify rather than the broad. Minority community that we live, in many respects abusing over you, stop, question, frisk, even understanding the unrecognized aspect of that world, that the majority of crime in our country, unfortunately, in cities, occurs in the inner city on minority neighborhoods. Vast majority of victims are minority and unfortunately, the vast majority of perpetrators minority. So police as to became more precise when it's dealing with terrorism, dealing with traditional time is short up with finding themselves in increasing conflict. But along the way, we lost an important component of what some of it feel identified. And that was legitimacy. We lost the support of those. We are trying to protect those we are trying to prevent crime for. And the crux of the issue now in this era of racial redress is that what people are demanding is police legitimacy, transparency, accountability, much more responsiveness. So you correct a long winded answer. This is our time, like any other time.

    [00:15:36] No surprise. But that was encyclopedic, probably because you were part of that initial conversation. All those conversations, including the one at Harvard where you decided to direct policing back towards community policing. So if I hear you correctly, you had there is this initiative in 70s and 80s, probably more in the 80s of let's get back to serving our communities back to the Peel Principle. But at the same time, you have mass incarceration going on. You have overuse of stop and frisk going on. You have counter-terrorism being given to policing, something you and I worked a lot on in a role that I think policing is critical. Police have a critical role in and in the entire time. Police are losing legitimacy because of those some of those behaviors being overused. And in many communities, police are looked more as occupiers, looked at more as occupiers and worriers, and less as a group working with the community and more as a group working upon the community. And so that entire thing, again, as you say, the police began to lose legitimacy in many communities. And that actually leads not only to huge problems, often for minority populations, but an inability to police as well as a police officer or police department. Should the communities not working with you? You're not getting the intelligence. You're not getting the insights. You're seeing, again, as an occupier. And it becomes a really nasty dynamic.

    [00:16:57] Is that is that about my summarizing effectively what I think I heard you say that the frustration of American police leaders at this time and I've been very fortunate over these last 50 years, particularly over the last 30. I've worked with some extraordinary reformers. I myself describe myself as a. I think they would describe themselves as progressive, Democrat or Republican. We serve whatever the office holders party might be, but progressive in the sense that we recognize were always evolving and always seeking to get better. So in many respects, we've been leading the modernization of policing. We've been leading the of community policing. We've been leading the embrace of transparency. A frustration we feel at the moment. And I'll speak for myself. I think I speak for my colleagues who I stay in close touch with, many of the major chiefs of major cities that are in the midst of all of this travel. I would describe this as an Etch a Sketch moment for us in that 20, 30 years of significant reform of our profession that has resulted in a traumatic turnaround of crime, effectively addressing terrorism, trying to address all the changes that technology has brought about, dealing with the very contentious debates around artificial intelligence, facial recognition, use of cameras, the whole idea of social media privacy that we're in the middle of all of that. And I think we have really come a long way. Minority representation in apartments and women of minority communities, all communities, gay communities, for example. And our frustration is at the moment, the demonstrations that we referred to that are still going on, most of them now very largely peaceful, thank God, because they'll get done with that violence. But that is not a recognition of how far we've come. In some respects, it's as if all the progress of the last particularly 20, 30 years, going back to 1990, the creation of very policing. It's as if none of that ever happened to date. Police departments that are now being attacked, New York City, L.A., Boston, maybe to a lesser extent, L.A. and New York. Once we started this more significant reformation of any organization in America, the consent decree in Los Angeles that I get it up to seven years largest in the country, New York, with all the oversight that everybody is demanding, it already is. So we are not a perfect institution like Madison trying to divide us. It's not a perfect institution because it's still wrestling with how to deal with it both to try to advance it, as well as to try to heal it. We're still wrestling with what is the best way to prevent it as well as to heal it. And we give it no credit at all for the many positive changes. So as we seek to now come to common ground and collaborate, you're going to hear police chiefs advocating that, look, we don't have to reinvent the wheel. A lot of the things we've been doing already work. It's a matter of institutionalizing them in many departments, changing that culture. So much of what's being looked at is cultural change.

    [00:20:09] So there are there are clearly there many dramatic advances in policing.

    [00:20:17] And I think you've described them really clearly in a way that makes a lot of sense. At the same time, there are these absolutely inhuman brutalities that we now all share the slow motion murder of George Floyd. We all have to see we all, unfortunately, should stand with and witness to. And it appears to be a drumbeat. It happens over and over and over. Now, I know there's lots of ways of looking at that. Well, so sure. While there's black men being murdered by police with some regularity among one million law enforcement officers in America. Right. So I understand that statistically we're understanding what we're looking at. And I also understand that there's violence against police officers. But the focus right now is on that violence against black people and particularly black men. And and as much as there has been all this progress with policing, there are still departments and there are still parts of certain departments, I suspect you agree, that need a dramatic shift. And again, I'm thinking of the police chief of Camden, a protege of yours. I think his name is Scott Thompson. And you were saying earlier and I'll I'll just I'll just make sure one understands the time I've spent with dozens of police chiefs. They all really of major police departments are your proteges. Right. So to listen to you right now is a huge privilege. You have an insight into what's going on there. Scott Thompson had a previous head of the Camden Police Department completely defunded, stopped his entire police department, rebuilt it. And in so doing, really does not try to design this police department type the mentality. Again, back to your Peel principle of S.O.P, citizens on patrol by the citizens with the citizens versus occupiers and warriors. It appears that it worked. I don't know that you need to do that in L.A. or New York or Boston. Departments you ran in perhaps this because you ran them or the consent decree or other things. But are the departments around the city or part of Suzanne, around the world or parts of departments where we need to do something this dramatic? We have to say, look, just stop, restart, regear. We understand, get back to we need community policing and demilitarize, et cetera, and understand that you are servant leaders. You are here to serve and protect. Is that necessary in some places or not?

    [00:22:32] It's definitely necessary. And the good news is we are at that inflection point where there is an opportunity to reimagine.

    [00:22:40] Yes, Sir Robert Peel did an 18 twenty with his imagination at the beginning of policing. What police should be doing and if you look, is nine principles. Basically, there is every bit as applicable today as they were back then. But we imagining police is the idea of so much has been put upon the police as governments and budget crises in response to move waves of epidemics, whether it's the mentally ill, whether it's the drug addiction issues of crack in the 80s. Opioids are the most recent time that the homeless issue, which has been forced upon the police in a big way that always reminded that commercial many years ago of give it to Mikey.

    [00:23:20] Mikey will lead it. We'll give it to the police. Won't do it. And look at what's been lately dumped on the police. Why? Because we're there 24 hours a day like the fire. And with with the exception of hospitals where the only three entities that are there 24 hours a day. And when we imagine the police, a lot of work we're looking at is taking some of those responsibilities away from us and giving them over to people who are more skilled, more trained, added or sharing those responsibilities.

    [00:23:52] The AWC has been investing with this with the homeless issue, spending billions of dollars on it with very mixed success. But we need to imagine what is the role of the police? The concept of defunding the police effectively. If you look at it, it's four elements. It's we form the police. We imagine he's talking about defunding, taking actual money away and maybe putting it into other services. Dismantling the police are not going to happen. That's a paradigm shift that most people are not going to accept. And the abolition of the police will have to be pretty far left so far to the left that you're actually not even in the frame frame any longer. Nobody's going to basically abolish the police. So we are focusing on reform. We imagination. But ironically, talking about doing that with less money. So how are we going to train the officers, retrain them? How are we going to attract new officers at a time when policing is being so vigorously attacked for its failings and not celebrated for any of its successes? How do you expect that we're going to get minority young men and women in to police departments? We've been actually doing pretty well. New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago. Almost every flexion of the population concentrations. So they are all minority majority police departments now, but are going to continue to attract young people into this profession. When has been so vilified? That's why I talk about the Etch A Sketch moment. Instead of taking a look at this has failed. But this has worked. We talked about Scott Thompson. Everything Scott did in Camden was a reflection of things that were being done in Boston, Los Angeles, New York being done on larger scale. He had the benefit, the phenomenal benefit of being able to effectively get rid of his city police department. But the services were taken over immediately by the county. So he was able to effectively take the best bit of the worst and had phenomenal success, 50 percent reduction in crime and an extraordinarily distressed community.

    [00:25:59] So where we are is not where we want to be. It's a long way from where we want to be. But in that evolution I keep talking about that is an opportunity to in the course of this revolution, let's get it right. In all the previous revolutions, we've got some things right. But we also got a lot more. I worry in the frenzy of the moment that we don't have the time to really work on it, digest it and come out of it with benefits for all.

    [00:26:33] I think it's important that, wow, there's a tremendous amount to be proud of about how policing has evolved.

    [00:26:41] And I think you mentioned a lot of the new burdens police have had. That this is also a moment when we have to recognize and you're clearly doing this, that policing in some places by some police or maybe general aspects of culture across police have got to change. And I think a lot of what I hear you talking about, a lot of your protege is talk about about the the occupier mentality, the warrior mentality, kind of it's a bit of a, you know, the samurai versus Ronin, you know, the armed the armed person who's enforcing the law upon people versus with people. As much as we can get away from that, as much as we can acknowledge that the better part of what. When you mentioned what defined police means and you know, it means a lot of things, a lot of people to Rashomon. One thing, it means that any good. Be very careful about is it means to further write law and order voters. And that's a category of voters. They're called law and order voters. It's a dog whistle that Donald Trump is using to motivate them to vote for him. Because of the point you make, Chief Bratton, that, you know, there's this immature idea that we'll just get rid of policing. Obviously, we can't do that. We have to be able to protect the sheep from the wolves with sheep dogs. The sheep dogs need to be there. But it's become a dog whistle. I guess I'm really extending the dog, the dog analogy, or it's become a dog whistle to far right voters because of its it's fear and basing to them, looking at videos of our president sending videos of African-Americans hurting white people, you know, is really blowing the dog whistle hard. But I think this is a moment where people like you. I'm so glad you're standing up and others saying like, let's reconsider how citizens can work with citizens to reduce crime and let's reconsider what it is we ask of police. I think it's worth noting that you go back to this moment where community policing was created a re-created in the 80s and 90s and again, largely by you and in and of itself, that probably would have been a pure and good mission and it probably would've been largely successful. But too much then was asked of the police and put on them. And perhaps we have to figure out how to break it down. I think of New York, where you dial nine one one nominally for an emergency or a violent crime. You dial three one one for a lifestyle problem, a noise violation, a parking issue or whatever. And I think of the UK where you've spent a lot of time and a lot of the police response and police presence is unarmed. More of that three one one de escalating community policing. Get to know your town kind of policing that you've advocated for so long. When you need the nine one one emergency response, you need the armed response. It shows up. Is there a role to take the guns away from a number of police officers or law enforcement officers or community polices or community assistance in this country? Can we get towards that British model or are we too much of a gun culture and unable to do that?

    [00:29:42] And we have several comments in Britain. There is great dissatisfaction with police services, has been for generations now, despite Postum being unarmed, free choice unions over there have consistently voiced opposition to being armed, that focusing on de-escalation would properly what living in a very different society than us in a country like ours with more guns and people with the love of firearms. The history of firearms. England is a very different society, so you really cannot compare the two experiences. But even in England, Mendis racial tension around policing talked about this idea of policing in America. There's no belief in America today to disarm the police. I'm sorry. The society we live in. You can't ask officers to go to the dangers they face. It's terrorism. Traditional crime can't do it. Can we seek to involve many other types of agencies working in partnership with them? Oftentimes. Maybe separate from them. This is the funding effort that we're talking about. Possibly that some of the things that been proposed, New York has tried it with limited success. One of the reasons things keep getting dumped on the police is that the use of police powers oftentimes ends up becoming necessary. Isn't New York City every four minutes. Give us a call. An emotionally disturbed person in the city. That call usually fits a nine on one. They now have teams of officers and specially trained medical people that can respond to some of those calls. But so often those calls, you don't know what's happening to you. Get them. And that's the difficulty. Three. One, one. Judy, what you just described, those type of calls. It was nobody in New York to respond to those three one one calls except the police.

    [00:31:40] We won one when it was set up by may have Bloomberg. It was not something that was going to take police out of the response picture effectively, just basically remove the emergency out of it. Nine one one was priority one, life threatening calls for people and one was far less life threatening. So, for example, at we're now into what we describe in policing as the barbecue season in the inner city, the barbecue on the corner. People don't have backyards, so they barbecue on the front sidewalk on a block party. Unfortunately, many of those block parties get out of control. What is the first call that is sent to three one one? Because it's a nuisance complaint, but who ends up having to come as the police? So as part of this reimagining of police, it is going to be a discussion around who has to go.

    [00:32:29] Do we need to send in our police officer or can we send a neighborhood representative from the community who knows everybody at that party? Those are options we can look at. What's the same as we police now for twenty five years using gang intervention players who are oftentimes former gang members who can relate to gangs better than we can in L.A.? While I was there as chief. We created a gang intervention academy where we literally sent all these young men to school, gave them diplomas, oftentimes was the first one they received in their life. So we're trying a lot of different things. The problem at this juncture, IP, what I'm worrying about is unlike previous times, because of that situation, we find ourselves the rotavirus, the economy, the credible political divide we have when nothing is getting done in Washington. I don't think the money is going to be there to do all these things. When you're talking about an 11 billion dollar deficit in New York City, laying off thirty three thousand employees, including three thousand police officers. Where is the money going to come from to fund just quality of life, enforcement, petalled enforcement in Manhattan? You live in Manhattan. You may with the pedalo situation, illegal peddlers. They want to take have they taken over take away from police. Police want to get rid of it. But when they sat down to discuss taking it over and they saw all the bureaucracy that was involved, Readiest stole all these goods. You get. How do you inventory them? How do you keep track of them? How do you keep them safe? Could it they backed away very quickly because the cost of the new bureaucracy was something the city was unwilling to take on. So a lot of great ideas at this particular point in time. But what I worry about is the soft underbelly of so much of what's going on is the funding that's going to be necessary for it. And with the political divide we have in Washington right now, for that matter, and cities that are a money that we assist funding going to come from.

    [00:34:32] It is a horrible time in America right now, unfortunately, the U.S. economy has shrunk, is shrinking. States like New York and others are going to build massive deficits. As you mentioned, the money to try creative things isn't going to be there yet. We are demanding of our governments to do things they haven't done before, some of which are going to cost a lot of dough. It's a horrible reality. I was looking at the protests in Philadelphia and how the police cornered a bunch of protesters and tear gassed them as they were stuck between fences and a highway. New York Times that a piece on that today sparked. You've seen it. And I was struck with the fact that you had a relatively small number of Soire police there. And I didn't see any white shirt leadership. And I was wondering, where are the city council members? So when you think of the second force, I know. I know you've really obviously worked extraordinarily closely with your civilian leadership in your policing history. But I wonder if it's time for us to ask our council members and our mayors and others to get down on the street with the police during these protests and take a look at what's going on. And ultimately, their response was ultimately there. It's their force, at least from a chain of command status. And I know I never see that.

    [00:35:45] So this is one quick thought out along that line that quite obviously some of the tactics that police have used to deal with the disturbances, those that drifted into violence, looting, disorderly behavior, and on occasion, unfortunately, when that behavior was not disorderly, it was over use of police equipment, which he Agassiz said, well, that was pepper spray. I'd point out that in New York City, city of St. Louis today with one I'm very intimate with the New York City Police Department should not use tear gas since the 1960s, doesn't use rubber bullets, with the exception that CSU usually and hostage type violent situations where they effectively use the cops with taunts and occasionally shields. So enchanted by the shields in 2014. Is it inevitable that when we're in the midst of those disturbances after the various police officers, Ramos and Liu? So going forward, there's going to be a significant re evaluation of what is appropriate police response, what is appropriate? Police quickly. I'd like to raise an issue that you've touched on twice in the commentary about police. So much of our activity is directed by politicians who disgrace the nation where we're so many politicians during the recent disturbances. Many where their voice was lost in the Tomball to voices. These demonstrations in many respects were leaderless and some of them upset about is celebrate the fact that they don't have organized structure, which makes it very difficult for police to deal with demonstrations when you don't know who to talk with, who actually speaks with the voice of the Martin Luther King in the civil rights demonstrations of so many events that I dealt with back in 2014. But the idea is that politicians oftentimes to their policies, laws, actually control and direct police activity. So whether it's fare evasion, whether it's in Ferguson, Missouri, the state of Missouri, many other cities and counties in Missouri rely on revenue from police enforcement activities as a principal source of revenue. So when they after effect in Ferguson, when they analyzed it, the bulk of that city's revenue came from the city, pushing the cops to get more tickets.

    [00:37:59] What are the cops do? They responded to political question and leadership and got more chickens in a community that has a huge number of minorities. They ended up getting caught the middle of it. So there's a lot of blame to go around here.

    [00:38:12] And as we go forward, the idea of assessing who to blame, but that assess after we get out the blaming, let's get on with getting it fixed.

    [00:38:22] So, you know, I think one of the things that that's important to point out is that, you know, racism in America is a cultural problem. And in many ways, it's way upstream of policing and it's way downstream of policing. And, you know, police sits in this critical middle place and you think about, you know, just mass incarceration, for example, and, you know, the sentencing structures across the country. Again, that's that's these these are voters. These are these are politicians who are making these decisions. And I just want to point out that side of this equation minut currently at the moment, the police are like right in the middle of this this this question of racism in America. And so that's kind of one side of the equation that makes life difficult for police. And I want to point out that when I was at those demonstrations in New York City, there was a lot of police were there. They were a multiracial, you know, many races represented in the force. And, you know, a lot of abuse towards them. And I was fully impressed with, you know, their their their demeanor, their commitment. I mean, they're playing such a critical role. And it was just such an interesting cultural moment to sit in that place and. Feel that. And I was, you know. And listen, I was there's no science in this. But what I observed, I was very impressed with. So that's kind of one side of it, is that the police get caught in in this in this cultural place. The other side of it is and, you know, we did it. We did a film a couple of years ago, Chief, on on the life of police. And, you know, the first time you've you pick up a SIDS baby or the violence you you witness or the stresses that come with the job and then the abuses that come with the job. And that's a whole nother side that most people just don't have the time to think about or to consider. And so it was like the psychological makeup of the police force itself. You know, and I remember my brother when he fought in the Gulf War, he came back and he would tell me these stories. He doesn't tell many stories about those days. But, you know, the one thing he does say is that when you're in these certain critical situations that most humans have never experienced, it's going to break some people down mentally in ways that aren't that easy to understand as outsiders. And I think so both sides of that equation and sort of for the police to be left in the middle of that. And I want to be clear that police could do better jobs. That would be my observation. But the pressures are real and generally unknown. And I'd be curious on the on sort of the second part of that equation, which is the life of a policeman on a day to day basis and the challenges that go along with that.

    [00:40:49] Well, the point you're raising, the idea of looking to a prison that has many images, depending on which part of the prison you're looking at and the vast majority of police is do the right thing.

    [00:41:05] Almost all the time make mistakes. Some of them, unfortunately, intentionally cross the line across the brutal, vivacious on average in the police department s led. I would indicate, based on the complaint structure of those departments. The three to four percent of those officers shouldn't have been on the department. We worked very hard to try and get them off. The department were limited by labor rules, by laws, etc. But we're very understanding how they can corrupt the image of that. Vast majority work very hard. I'd like to comment about the demonstrations that you attended and the idea of the videos that are played over and over again, either by the news media with cable TV or the networks or on social media that in those demonstrations were 10, 20, 30, 40 thousand people in New York City, for example.

    [00:42:01] We have seen the same, I'd say ten or twelve incidents played over and over again. This where almost everybody in New York is carrying a camera.

    [00:42:11] The video came spiteful and meet the regular media was out there in force. And when you consider the thousands of officers that were engaged on a daily basis and what they were dealing with, some of the tensions you talked about, whether you saw some of what was directed at the police and by allies, the response of being stalking, you know, sucking it up and do some of them great from time to time.

    [00:42:37] We saw some of that. So those egregious actions which are being dealt with. But I would point out that why do we play the same Channel 12 images over and over again? As there were 10 or 12 images. You think if any of those demonstrators, yourself included, captured with the iPhone, an officer, engage in what would seemingly be an egregious action, they wouldn't push that out. So some of the good news is that we effectively have in this country now a couple hundred million monitors carrying a smartphone. First time a police engagement, whether it's lawful but awful, they start videotaping. And what do we see on television? We've had some horrific incident certainly the last couple of weeks as it's just the scale of demonstrations. But the good news is as we go forward, we can actually put things into a proper perspective. There's a lot that goes on a police car and it shouldn't. And we have better ways of dealing with it. And that's a lot that goes on. The behavior of the public and these demonstrations that shouldn't happen is a way of addressing that also. So coming out of this, that is that is the times I'm optimistic based on previous experiences that we use, if not of these times, the better for the.

    [00:43:51] The cauldron that we find ourselves in this time, however, the idea is that the issue, systemic racism with us for 400 years permeates every form of our society. We're not all racist, but we operate in a very systemic racial society.

    [00:44:07] And it's just denigrations world, for that matter. But just against blacks. But it's it's the nature of the world. It's an opportunity to do better, to make it a better place everywhere for everyone, at least in this country. Let's not blow that opportunity. That so in the midst of some of the chaos, in the midst of some of the anger, frustration. Let's find a place where we can all get together some common ground that we can collaborate with each other and everybody come out of it with something. Is everybody going to get everything they want? Abe Lincoln was so smart when he talked about you can please some of the people some of the time. Please mall. Let's start to please as many as we can this time and come out of this experience to better for.

    [00:44:53] Thanks. The whole conversation was fantastic. I think part of what we have to understand here is we're we're basically talking about basketball with Michael Jordan. So you have been, you know, if not the best, certainly recognizes as one of the very best police commissioners and chiefs of last century. And if we had every police department run by someone like you, we probably wouldn't be in this problem. But we don't. The cities that we mentioned today and talk about where things are going relatively well are largely departments that have been run by you or your proteges or other very enlightened police officers. But we still have a number of police officers who feel like occupiers and feel like it's there. There's some warrior mentality. And perhaps in the culture change that we need to get to here, we can reimagine that as well.

    [00:45:38] And it has been a change. The warriors that we saw each recruit in the 80s were necessary because the 80s were horrific. The gun violence. Twenty two out of forty three murders. Six thousand people shot with streets New York in 1990. You had to make the streets safer for keeps them plowed into the streets. You also had to make it safe.

    [00:45:57] The she could recruit a different type of cop who effectively would be going into a different environment. And I think we've been succeeding at that. It's not been as recognized as I'd like it to be. But even going to Michael Jordan Coleman, thank you for the compliment. Call me that.

    [00:46:13] I get attacked as much as I get praised, and particularly in this age, going after quality of life, spoken with windows, now going after concert at all, things I'm very proud of and will continue to fight up. But even using Michael Jordan, that dramatical couple of weeks ago about Michael that were the most significant basketball players in history, talking about him in the sport that the other side of him. So even the legendary hero ends up getting beat up about some of his issues. It is moot for all of us to get up there, and we do. But we need to get beyond that and take a look at what's worked out to make it work better in the future.

    [00:46:52] And I thank you for this opportunity to talk about it is it's not just a soundbite conversation. It's it's a deeper discussion on the map and has to be a deeper discussion.

    [00:47:00] And I also think it's really important that we all hear you recognizing the systemic racism in our society, the major fixes that have to happen at the time from your imagination and the outer world.

    [00:47:11] That the old Beatles song Imagination did that song back in the 60s. It's it's it's a wonderful theme for 2020. It really is that term. So that's said that should be the the anthem with 20 20.

    [00:47:27] Chief, I admire your candor, your commitment. I lived in the last 30 years, led to Boston, I lived in New York, I lived in Los Angeles. So thank you also for your service.

    [00:47:37] And I appreciate your time tonight serving continue to enjoy serving. And I look forward to seeing the finished product to you when you guys get done with it.

    Copyright TNP 2020

    * we sometimes receive a small commission for purchases made when visiting some links provided in our show notes and we wanted you to know.

    48 min
  • rp daily: president chaos

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    president chaos. tom speaks about an upcoming trip down the mississippi. stopping in nine locations on the river, the trip's mission is to gather people where they are and encourage conversation on the topic of racism in america today. tom and rp also discuss the leadership vacuum left by a polarizing president, the politicization of the pandemic, and how we can move forward without a clear leader.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    transcript

    [00:00:16] It's Wednesday. My name's Tom Scott. I'm with our . R p. I heard a lot of feedback from yesterday's show, Covid is back. I want to go I want to go back on something we discussed yesterday and I want to dig in again on Markovits stuff.

    [00:00:34] There's so much going on in the world right now that it's hard to, like, sort it all out. Right. And if you go back to.

    [00:00:42] The Trump rally. Because I did like I did a double take and I thought.

    [00:00:50] Was he really in a an arena?

    [00:00:53] With boatloads of people without masks on. I just thought, like what? Like did I. Is that really what happened?

    [00:00:59] Because there was so much going on, like my own sort of priority list as I would as a as I was observing the gathering.

    [00:01:08] Koven wasn't that high on my list. It was more politics and other things. And then the story predominantly was about how his crowd didn't turn out right. That was sort of what grabbed all the headlines. And then I thought, well, I'm going to go back and look at some of the pictures and just see, is it really true that none of these people had en mass? It's really true. And I thought.

    [00:01:31] It's just wildly irresponsible. I'm not trying to pick on the guy all the time, but a man, I just think you really packed a stadium with people with no masks on.

    [00:01:42] Average age of a Trump voter is 60. Average. He means half is above 60. Half are above 60. If you're over 65, this disease becomes like extremely lethal. So it's even more foolhardy than it looks at first glance. It's crazy. It's crazy. This whole mask thing, we've just got to get over it. Leaders have got to lead. He's killing people. He's killing his supporters. People will die. Someone from that rally is going to contract the virus from that rally. And he's going to die from a virus they contracted at that rally because was indoors in an air conditioned space in an area with a high prevalence of endemic disease. And they weren't wearing masks. That's an 80 percent, 90 percent likelihood. It's a horror. It's sad. I don't want it to happen, but it's going to happen. And I'm looking at. Kiki, give a. Does he.

    [00:02:39] I mean. You know, that probably didn't cross his mind.

    [00:02:46] I mean, just symbolically, you know, just as a way of saying, hey, guys, let's be safe. I'm looking at it right now and I see the crowd behind him. Not one person.

    [00:02:53] I did the exact same thing. I could. I actually went back and looks like. Is it. Does it true that red mass. And they don't look at it. So what are they? You know, they're not evil people. What are they thinking. That were different than what we're thinking. They're thinking again, shared consequence. What disease are you talking about? I don't know anyone who died. No famous person has died. You know, Arizona, Arizona's actually headed to real trouble there. They're getting the maximum ICU capacity very quickly. You talked about the Tucson rally. So there was.

    [00:03:31] No, no, sorry. I'm sorry. Tulsa. OK. Two different rallies. Tougher.

    [00:03:36] So Oklahoma even makes my point of them are clearly like there is not a lot of disease in Oklahoma. So people live in Oklahoma have seen something around 80 or 100 days of economic slowdown, a country one hundred and eight days, an economic slowdown and three days or something. And they don't understand why. And, you know, back in ancient Arab ancient man, when there was thunder and lightning in the sky. People understand why they ascribe meaning to it. It's the gods store. And and so they see a dynamic happening and they're ascribing meaning to it. So that leads to conspiracy theories. Oh, it's the Democrats trying to hurt Trump's chance of winning. OK. It's an it's an attempt to literally muzzle us as being the folks the mainstream media doesn't like. OK. Any number of things. But they don't see it. They don't believe it. There's a history of that rebellion in America. There's a history of self-reliance in America was a part of what made us great. That's part of what made us expand as a nation, which obviously has its its ills as well. But it's it's sort of taking a wrong turn right. It's like something that's evolutionarily good about Americans is now headed in the wrong direction. It's like your appendix, which, you know, evolutionarily is less critical. And it used to be at some point was relevant. Isn't anymore now just causes problems. So in this instance, the self-reliant rebellion is making people say Masser a bad thing. Donald Trump apps that sound like he intimates it's a bad thing. It's not like he hints at a bad thing. It's not like just by not wearing one. He's signaling it's a bad thing. He literally says it's oppressive, it's liberal. It's a wussy thing to do. So people. And then he calls a rally inside an air conditioned space with people not wearing masks. So Arizona hired endemic disease. Average Trump voters, 60 years old. Average rally participant, probably 65 years old. Don't I don't know that number for sure. And people in Arizona, at least there's a lot of endemic disease, are going to get the disease from the rally. So if you think that's silly, go look at the Wisconsin voting. Your call, the Wisconsin election. A month and a half ago, people contracted the disease from that poorly handled voting. Remember what I'm referring to? And and I don't know if anyone has died, but but over 50 people, he it's 30 to 50 people a few months ago or, you know, a few weeks ago, clearly got the disease from that rally. So, you know, people who get the disease in the rally. Let me make one more point. There's nothing in our brains that understands logarithmic growth. Nothing in our lives that grow logarithmically except things that are invisible, like viruses. And so we kind of know that we rationally understand that these things grow, quote unquote, logarithmically exponentially. What does that mean? Course, he means us two to four to 16, 32 to 64, you know. You know what it means? Means one person when the disease spreads to three people is basically what happens with this disease. One person gives to three and that gives to nine. Right. So it's a factor of three. Growths are not a three. So that in and of itself is trouble. The other problem is the base number you start from obviously dramatically matters. So if you start from one hundred infections before you get your act together versus one versus a thousand, it's an extremely different outcome. Part of what happened in America, and there's a longer story about the heavy viral load they got to New York relatively quickly, the heavy viral load, they got to Seattle relatively quickly, although it wasn't quick at all.

    [00:07:17] Took months. It took over a month of warning before it really got here.

    [00:07:21] Caused a crisis quickly. Crisis thinking is this stupid zone, right? When you're thinking in crisis about a novel challenge like a disease. You know, you're a policymaker. You, Donald Trump, your real estate guy, you're a reality TV show. All of a sudden you have to think about a disease. I don't know if you ever took a biology class in college. I don't know what his background is. Understand this or advanced mathematics. I'm not criticizing my new measure. Most policymakers don't understand these things. And there's you add to it. So complexity mismatch is much more complex than it used to. It's a crisis. It's politically charged. People are literally dying. And you have to all do it real time. And private TV camera. It becomes much, much harder. Why do I mention on this? Because the 23 states in America that are now having growth of the virus are bringing this problem on themselves. And I don't just mean that disease growing logarithmically or exponentially, I mean creating a sense of crisis in which decision making is harder. Final point is when you're in this disease crisis mode, obviously. But the point I'm making is it's too hard to shut down easily. You can't test and trace the one or the 10 or the 50 cases. All of a sudden it's a thousand cases and you're well beyond your body test trace. You have to shut down. So you what you end up doing is making your solution set to one extremely expensive, unattractive solution. Shutdown. If you deal with that earlier, you have less expensive, less contentious solutions. Right. Test and trace. Isolate, mask wearing handwashing, social distancing. Those things can work better, much better when you have a lower amount of disease running around a lower amount of vectors. Final point on final point, just to make it clear, just think of it as an invading army. If you have, you know, five Russian soldiers with AK 47 landing in your town, the police department can probably get their hands on that thing inside your town. If that becomes 25 becomes an issue, may the National Guard shows up, becomes two in and fifty, then all of a sudden you probably are in real trouble. Right. And you have to go to different and more extreme solutions to deal with it. That's what's happening here. So these states that didn't take it seriously in the first place because they didn't share a consequence. So it wasn't ridiculous for them not to. Now are going to have to take it seriously in a much more difficult situation. So they're learning to ski on a triple back diamond, whereas they could have handled it and the Bunny Hill, if they got on top of it faster. The president is making that worse by telling people they shouldn't wear masks by literally mocking mask wearing. And then on top of that, he's making it worse by having rallies in places indoors with older people who are going to catch a disease, are going to spread the disease and some are going to die. So, you know, welcome to leadership in America today. So what do you do about it?

    [00:10:12] Don't expect leadership in the White House expected from yourself, from your company, from your family, from the mayor, from your governor, just not there. You better find it yourself.

    [00:10:25] It was interesting. You know, basically, the EU is saying, no, this is this is a big deal.

    [00:10:33] Such a huge deal. Yeah, yeah.

    [00:10:36] I mean, they're saying Americans cannot. I think you're opening on July 1st and they're saying, no, America can't come here.

    [00:10:43] Saying like that. So not only. Holy shit. You know, business people can't go fly over and look at their factories. Parents can go over and see their kids. Kids can't come over. I mean, you know, the separation of humans from commerce and life and love. That's a real thing. The economic impact is not just bonkers on that inability to literally get to our businesses. Yeah. The economic impact on the travel industry, the whole hotel industry and everything else is insane.

    [00:11:11] Right.

    [00:11:13] But the shame to America, where the EU, a nation, Europe, that the continent we've rescued twice in the past century, saying you can't come here anymore. And by the way, they're not wrong.

    [00:11:32] The in that to me.

    [00:11:35] I mean, holy Moses. What more do you need to see about America completely abandoning its role as a global leader? Which is what I talk about a lot. But now, even as a responsible global citizen, like you're not invited to come to my meeting because you're so irresponsible in my meeting, you know, you show up and you spill coffee on everybody and you take your clothes off. Mm. You can't even come here anymore, let alone leave the meeting.

    [00:12:01] It's, it's, it's awesome. Yeah. It's.

    [00:12:08] Well, I think the other thing that's happening. So we have this trip coming up and we're going to go. Over 14 nights, we're going to have at least eleven conversations and it's a conversation on race. We're gonna do it down the Mississippi again. Now, you know, you may love what we're doing, you may like less what we're doing depending on who you might be. The goal is. To build useful conversation.

    [00:12:41] And unite.

    [00:12:42] That's what it's for. And hopefully the conversations are courageous and that they are, you know, useful and sharable and all these other things. That's what we hope for. Now, I'm mentioning it because.

    [00:12:56] We're doing this in a moment where.

    [00:13:00] Our president is literally trying to divide us. I'm being literal here, right? It's a literal decision to, you know, put masks in people's face faces as a dividing point or to do some of the political things. And, you know, divisiveness is part of politics to a certain extent. But at this moment, one of the things that's happening in a moment where America needs, you know, like some kind of unified progress, is that the division? Makes it all the harder. You know, I want to add there's an irony to what I just said, because I also think it's going to bring people to the table. I think there's an exam aspiration on a lot of people's parts where they're going to want to participate even more because of what's going on. And it relates back to your point, because I get frustrated. I get afraid. There's a lot of I mean, we have to be healthy on our trip. We have to be smart on our trip. I want to be productive on our trip. And, you know, look, we're gonna make a small dent. And I get that.

    [00:13:56] But it does make me want to do it more. The oppositional nature of what seems to be happening in the world does give me a little bit of energy to even do a better job, if that makes sense. But that's how I feel. It's like I'm a man. I'm in a I'm in a bit of a battle. With my own senior level of government, you're doing.

    [00:14:15] No. OK. Sure. But you're you're doing your practice what you preach.

    [00:14:20] Right.

    [00:14:24] And I think the other thing for people, you know, you're not you're not making money off. I mean, like, you're going out there now. You're trying to combine Tom.

    [00:14:37] I have two stickers in the back of our suburban. And I was looking at them yesterday. I got my car washed after twenty two days of driving across the country with three little boys. You can imagine what that thing smelled like. So I got a wash and I was scrubbing it. And then I was fighting on the to bumper stickers, the back of my car, both of which have been on there for over a year. Top one is neighborhood, the Nantucket Project Neighborhood Project. I love that where you're going out and you're bringing people together and having them drop their electronic devices and drop their ego devices and drop all the things that separate us and try to encourage conversations in what has sadly become this magical revelation that talking face to face is a beautiful thing and that humans, Americans have more in common than separates us. And that's sticker number one. You want to guess what sticker number two is? Actually, I will make it stick. Number two is the black purple black bar of I support the police. Again, I've had this up there for a few years because I have worked with police departments for a number of years. I train with police departments once a year and generally was kind of a law and order police supporter. You know, obviously within constraints and trying to modify and improve police departments in a counterterrorism basis has been one of my things for a long time. And just to be clear, helping police departments fight terrorists has been what I've been working on for since, you know, one degree, the other since 95. And so I have that on there and also have it on there is when a policeman pulls me over, hopefully they feel some degree of alliance. And I'm looking at these two things, both of which have to be purple and black. The colors I have and I'm thinking, you know, are these contradictory, what's going on here? And it's it's a it's a bit of the conversation you're having. Right. So one of those has become a divisive symbol. One of those policing has become a divisive force. And there's so much more to talk about that because I talked with our Chief Bratton and one of those is your effort to heal that division. And you've been doing that, of course, PREE for years and years and doing that. So you're this is the time when we must do that. And again, it's very easy to get in social media and Black Lives Matter post whatever it is like, get out and do it right. Go talk to people. So this trip across country for us has been such a revelation. And I've mentioned a couple of stories in the way of people. You know, everything everything you shared on your trip previously, which I only saw it sort of distance is now kind of the lessons of it have come home to us, too. So I can't commend you for what you're doing. It's not what you're doing isn't in contrast to the president. What you're doing is in furtherance of America, in furtherance of humanity, in increasing circles of empathy.

    [00:17:34] One last point. Here's why I can look at polling data.

    [00:17:43] I can talk to experts. We do that professionally. We build our own models about will the president win or lose? It's one of 15, I think, at this point. Fifteen Global Dynamics at my firm tracks every day.

    [00:17:57] And you can imagine the election of the U.S. president in every instance matters. In this instance, it matters dramatically. We obviously track Corona. We track North Korea. We track Saudi Iranian tensions. We track Venezuela. We track all these things. And we track the election. The U.S. president using the same extraordinarily powerful frameworks, expensive tools, lots of experts, constant modeling on all these things to help keep our clients, government and business ahead of the curve ahead of the headlines. That's what we do professionally. One of the things we you and I can go look at our models right now, and I can tell you that the world's best experts and world's best models say Donald Trump today, when we four months out, has an eighty five percent chance of losing the election.

    [00:18:44] Now, please understand, four months is a eternity, particularly today's dynamic. And so I really wouldn't bet a penny on that yet. But here's why. I actually think Donald Trump will lose. It's not because of all that expensive modeling and the experts and the tools we're building. And what I read, it's because of sort of what you're saying, Tom. Donald Trump is a chaos president, right? He is a. Test president polling data shows interviews show a large number of the swing voters who got him into office using the quirks of the Electoral College didn't vote for him because they agree with his policies or agree with him as a man. It was because, in the words of one of the great leaders, the RNC vote for Donald Trump was the biggest middle finger they could give to their country at that moment. The biggest protest they could give at that moment, because at that point, they felt left behind and ignored and not wrongly, by the way, says when Hillary Clinton called them deplorable as et cetera, et cetera, they felt no one cared about them. The system is rigged against them. Pretty cogent argument, in my opinion, by the way. So how does he lead?

    [00:20:00] He leads by dividing us exactly as you said.

    [00:20:03] He profits from division. He profits from you shouldn't wear a mask.

    [00:20:07] He profits from, you know, I mean, the litany of things that the dog whistle, race baiting that he's doing, etc.. Right. The law and order kind of pounding the drums, showing videos last two days of black people attacking white people, which is what he's spent his time on Twitter doing. President of our country has done that. So that had worked for him because those voters bought into that. In this election, in this era in America today, we are fatigued. This is why I think he's going to lose. We've had enough. We don't want division. We don't want chaos. We don't want crisis.

    [00:20:47] Most Americans now want a healing. They want to get back to the sense of what's beautiful in this country. And that's just not what he embodies, is not what he conveyed, is not what he's teaching us, not how he's leading us. So it's for those reasons and actually it's not the polling. It's not the experts. It's I. And that's the trip that's allowing me to see this, I believe are coming to a moment where America's just had enough of the division and the chaos of the disease, of the black lives, of the murder of George Floyd and the inherent division that came from that. I and him constantly throwing gasoline on the fires. So that was very long. I apologize, but I think about that for a few days. And so, again, thank you for what you're doing. Congratulations. What you're doing. It's we all ought to be doing. And I think because Americans are receptive to the neighborhood project to what you do, because that works. Here is why I think that we as a country probably have had enough. Those swing voters in those critical states probably had enough chaos. The Democratic bloc voters probably know they need to get out and vote. So I think that's why I'm pretty confident to be the last term for Donald Trump.

    [00:22:02] It's interesting, I mean. Yeah, I'm sure you saw some of those numbers.

    [00:22:06] Fifty to thirty six in one of the polls, I saw 50 to Biden, 36 to Trump. That's a national number. There's a whole variety of places where the numbers have moved in favor of Biden. And Biden is at numbers at currently that Hillary Clinton never reach. She never reached 50 percent.

    [00:22:22] The gap was never so wide. As our piece said, there's plenty of time left. You know, the thing I think a lot about is. You know, there's some kind of a galvanizing effect happening on the left, which is to say within the Democratic Party, largely in opposition to Trump. But then I also just wondered, like, what is the state of the Republican Party like? I do I, I don't even understand what it is. You know, I can imagine, like the Ben Sasse.

    [00:22:51] Sort of.

    [00:22:53] I'm going to describe as sort of a older school. George Bush like, H.W. Bush like. Republicans set of values that right or wrong, I would argue I would prefer that these kinds of people would speak out more. I think they're doing they're making what they view as pragmatic choices by by remaining quiet. But I wonder what's left of a party for them when all is said and done. And what does that party even look like or stand for? It's just very, very difficult to know. And I feel like there. I mean, I read I read a tweet today from Bill Kristol, which, by the way, don't to Twitter, but somebody sent it to me.

    [00:23:32] And it sounded like something.

    [00:23:37] You know.

    [00:23:40] Mika Brzezinski would have posted it at a time in the past, which is to say it read like a left wing rejection of Donald Trump. Like it was incredible. Bill Kristol, for those of you don't know, is a conservative writer, thinker, pundit type, a guy who, you know, historically wouldn't have said anything like that. It was just so interesting to see it. And I just kind of thought, like, what is the state of the Republican Party like? Where does this all land? I mean, like so many other things in life right now. I mean, you're talking about a four point nine SPEs. The global economy will shrink four point nine percent. You know, four point nine percent. Sorry to shrink, to shrink four point nine percent is radical. I mean, it's a radical. World, I mean, to grow zero is radical, right? Like, no growth is radical. The number of radical things that are going on right now, it's it's it's overwhelming. And to the point, you just made a point about Trump's recent tweets that I don't know anything about. I don't know a thing about them. And I'm judging from afar. But would you describe sense? It sounds terrible. Terrible.

    [00:24:45] No, it's it's what you know, you and I have kids around the same age. If our children tweeted what he tweeted, they'd probably get asked to. Did they get punished by their school? Yeah. Yeah. You know, tweeting, like, literally. Right. Like, we'd have a school conference, you know, a little junior year. Who's been tweeting videos of black people attacking white people. Some of it's your source to. Right. Neo-Nazi sources. What's going on with Junior? Like what's going on at home? Do you know Arpey? Like, what's he seen it like? We're really worried about his mental health. You know, all a lot of his classmates are really upset. Is his is his African-American classmates are just in tears. You know, that's like that's what our president's doing in the state of the GOP. You know, you can have it seems like every time a new president takes over, he redefines his party. Right. And oh, my gosh. His party, the party right now of President Clinton isn't the same party as of Carter. And the president of Bush 43 isn't the same as his dad, 41, and of Trump isn't the same 43 or 41. Well. So there's constantly that conversation. It's real. President sort of has. That's what happens. Like, he wins. He's the boss, you know, defines in his image to some extent during his term. This is dramatically, dramatically different because there's there's maybe only two or three of dozens of Republican planks that this president actually supports. So if you were to go back, you know, if you're going a time machine and go back to any Republican before Donald Trump emerged as a candidate, let's say, and said here's how he's actually going to govern, he's going to be isolationists. Some are part Republicans. But I yeah, it's kind of our plank, tiny, small plank. He's going to be deregulatory. Definitely a Republican plank. He's going to try to get conservative justices definitely concerned. Definitely a Republican plank. And he's going to try to reduce taxes. That's Republican plank. And he's going to try to repressor China on trade. You know, probably some Republicans held it. Those things only are where he is coordinated with any historical Republican will be mainstream Republican planks. And I mean it. I like go back and look at the planks in the Republican National Committee Committee that they put together before every presidential election, whatever you want to define as the Republican shared thesis. Right. Every single thing else that he's done is not Republican plank. And I can't list them all at a.. Expertizes a.. NATO supporting Russia. Holy shit. Completely anti Republican supporting China, human rights violations, completely anti Republican, et cetera. So, no, he he doesn't look like anything historically.

    [00:27:49] So what do you and I to two morals.

    [00:27:54] Well, so that that's a big point. So the big difference, you know, we talked with The New Yorker article about Greenwich. There was a New York article maybe what's it, two months ago about how Greenidge things like Greenwich sold its soul and changed Republican Party or something like that in Connecticut, very wealthy suburb of New York that you know well. And in that article, which I I didn't love the article, it was kind of gossipy and, you know, didn't appear to me to be New York quality. If I can say so. But one thesis, the article is definitely stuck with me, which is that what used to be a party that was proud of the prevalence of morality. To some extent, Judeo-Christian Abrahamic theology in its precepts is now replaced.

    [00:28:46] Those precepts of the golden rule. All that. All all of that.

    [00:28:51] So Bush 41 Reagan type, I actually care about other people. I actually am other focused. I care about service. I care about my nation. I care about my nation's role in the world. I care about how my nation takes care of the least among us. Much like Jesus would preach, much like the Abrahamic religions would preach. That's been replaced, says a New Yorker article. And I kind of buy it with an emphasis on greed, gathering and deregulation because you can't have both. You can't simultaneously say I care about the least among us. I want to live a crowd. I'm Christian, so I'll keep referring to Christianity. I can't live a Christ centered life. I can't live by the golden rule I'll do and others wish they were doing to me and also want deregulation so I can complete can pollute the the air that we share. And and pat. The courts with conservatives so that I can talk through the deregulation and lower taxes, dramatically lower taxes, so I can hoard my wealth. Now, Republicans have always want lower taxes, but those two things are not in concert there. Baer in contrast and I think that article got that point right. And it's this president absolutely exemplifies the latter. Right. You know, he's you know, like we're talking too much about him. But he he's not other focused. He you know, he stormed across Lafayette Square, gassed protesters who PPIF peacefully protesting, some of whom were beaten by the federal police to get to the steps of a church where nuns, members of the church, were caring for injured people, have them cleared out physically with tear gas. So he could hold a Bible in front of a church to try to show us he loves Jesus. Like the irony of that is.

    [00:30:48] He's saying to me that, you know, hold the Bible upside down and backwards. To me, that's kind of what Trump Republicanism looks like so far as you think about other people.

    [00:31:05] Well, for me. I said this about a week or so ago. But. What followed was. The mayor of Washington and the city council changed the name of the it became Black Lives Matter Plaza. They wrote Black Lives Matter in the road, in between the street and the White House is Lafayette Square. And this image from the sky showed the White House currently occupied by Donald Trump and Black Lives Matter. And for me, I posted that on Instagram. I've never done a political post. I don't know if you call that a political post. I guess you'd probably call it a political post. I know exactly where I stand on that image. I know exactly that I stand with. The hopes of what Black Lives Lives Matter currently represents versus the way the White House is acting and speaking, I just I know exactly where I stand and that, you know, anyone who starts starts to bring up different technicalities of either side of that equation. I know exactly where I stand on that equation, which brought me to do it. And you're right. We are talking a lot about Donald Trump. It's interesting because.

    [00:32:18] You if you've been listening, you hear us say what we say about politics, but we and we talk about it from a point of view of humanity like we want to be. We wanted to be informative to humanity about Kofod. And I stand there still. But I think humanity has been played out so clearly in my head that it's hard to keep my mouth shut. And in some ways, it does relate to my children, but it also just relates to this notion of my brothers and my sisters, symbolically speaking, at myse fellow citizens like I want to. I want to be part of a healthy, happy, loving culture. And therefore, whether you think we should be back to business or not around Kova, just wear a mask. It's OK. No. One, it's OK. You're going to be better off with a mask and you can probably be in business and you can treat people with respect and you can treat people with love and lift them up and do. Those are the things we do not have to be in opposition to ourselves all the time. And if the president is going to so loudly proclaim his desire for divisiveness, I'm going to declare the other.

    [00:33:21] Hallelujah. So God God bless you, Tom. Just while we're cooking in the Republican thing very quickly, if people are interested in what I would call the best of the Republican Party, what it's thinking now, look up the Lincoln Project, Abraham Lincoln, the Lincoln Project.

    [00:33:42] It's led, I think, led by Steve Schmidt, who was McCain's top adviser. And ironically, what what is what is his next George Kahnweiler and George Conway. What a story that is. That's gonna be a movie, right? George Conaway's wife, of course, is one of the president's top advisers. George Conway, of course, is one of the president's top critics. It's amazing. And the Lincoln Project has some awesome stuff up there. Thank you.

    [00:34:12] And they also have they're putting ads out very, very quickly and very poignantly about what they see as their Republicanism ought to be where the president is. It's it's a pretty cool, pretty cool movement.

    [00:34:26] Pretty selfless, right? These guys aren't going to win. Biden wins. They're not getting jobs. The Biden White House, you know, very few of them around. They're they're doing. That's a patriotic move, right.

    [00:34:38] Okapi, we're we're we're out of time. The New York City Marathon has been canceled. The MLT, the Major League Baseball season, is going to open on July 20, 30, June, July 24th. There hasn't been arrests yet or charges in the Briona Taylor. Shooting. There's a lot of different things going on right now.

    [00:35:00] You know, Foushee expects to see this surge of infections. You know, the irony of the fact that I think Foushee generally seems like a guy who cares about the right things, but his boss is less tied in. I just want to throw out some headlines before we go. And if you want to make a final comment, go for it.

    [00:35:17] But thanks for the time. I think I'm really excited for tomorrow.

    [00:35:21] Ramming Police Commissioner, Police Chief Bratton, old friend of mine, old colleague of mine, police chief of New York, Los Angeles, Boston.

    [00:35:34] Help redesign London policing. Great human, great thinker. Great public servant. We're going to get some time with him tomorrow, Tom. I hope people get to tune into that. I want to hear about defend the police. I want to understand how, you know, in some ways, just to be clear, policing is also one of the best ways that minorities achieve Middle-Class status in America. Right. If you look at who gets to join, who joins the police force in many cities, who gets that income that kicked that can become a middle class income, it sure doesn't start as one. A lot of them are minorities. So there are some aspects of policing we have to think about, and there's certainly things that have to be fixed. And so this is a man who, you know, I've always been surprised. He is not a gung ho stand by the cop guy by any measure. He's stand by the lawful public servant citizen on patrol police officer, of course. But he's also the first one to criticize the police and they step over the line. It's gonna be fascinating to spend time with him tomorrow. So I'm psyched for that. And I liked our conversation today. I think we covered a lot of kind of important ground. And I'm proud to get to work with someone like you. And I'm really excited for the trip you're going on in the conversations you're going to bring together. Well, jealous, I'm not going. I can't do it, but it's gonna be awesome. So thanks for doing that.

    [00:37:02] I appreciate it. I appreciate. I appreciate your time and. I know when we started this, we didn't see this coming. And it's been a journey. So thanks for all your commitment.

    Copyright TNP 2020

    we sometimes receive a small commission for purchases made when visiting some links provided in our show notes and we wanted you to know.

    38 min
  • rp daily: covid is back

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    covid is back. with covid-19 case numbers suddenly surging to coincide with the reopening of the nation and hesitant returns to normalcy, it's clear that america hasn't flattened the curve. as a second wave of infections looms in the very near horizon, rp and tom discuss the spike in cases, how we can prevent further spikes, and where to go now.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    transcript

    [00:00:16] Tuesday, my name's Tom Scott, I'm here with our P.E.T. Arpey. Typically, what we do is we make these shows and then after we finish the shows, we title these shows and build a little artwork around it. I'm going to take a guess that we're gonna call this show. Koven is back because it seems to be the case that Koven is back. There's a variety of statistics I have here, news that I have here. We were talking, you know, I'm going to start here, actually, Sweden.

    [00:00:49] If you look at Sweden.

    [00:00:51] Look at the Scandinavian countries, Denmark, Finland, Norway. They all had strict lockdown. Sweden did not. Sweden now has roughly twice as many infections and five times as many deaths as the other three nations combined.

    [00:01:09] So Sweden, as a as an experiment, based on the metrics I used, did not go very well.

    [00:01:19] We can talk about many others here, IPN, I would like to, but let's just start there. Your reaction to what I said about the title in your reaction to what's happening in Sweden?

    [00:01:29] I think you and I are paying really close attention. I think we've been paying close attention for a few months. So I think to us, it's pretty obvious that we're we're entering a dangerous zone again. We may have had a couple of weeks of reprieve after the lockdowns. I'm not sure the body politic gets that yet. So if we say the krona is back, you know, we'll be right. We're going to definitely feel that in a week, two weeks, three weeks in a month. So, yeah, Corona's back Sweden, as we talked about Sweden before, we spend some real time talking about that country, a country Holden, actually very high esteem before this happened. Public health service, public health infrastructure, pretty extraordinary country. Thank you. But they completely blew it on Korona in district context. They thought, hey, you know, it really seems like Till older people will lock down the older people. Well, that the younger people just get to life. We don't want our economy to suffer and let the economy suffer when you lock down. And it didn't work partly because they didn't lock down the older people enough. Huge flashing Asterix here. Neither is America. Very few countries have figured this out. If you can protect your vulnerable populations, you will save lives. You will save 90 percent of lives. No one has done it well except Serbia. Crazy, right? The one country you never think of somehow figured out how to protect the elderly populations. So what is it? If you had to guess Sweden versus Serbia. Who's going to do it right? Well, turns out it was Serbia, not Sweden, who he had to get Serbia versus the U.S.. Who would do it right? Serbia, not the United States. A lot of countries have done better than both Sweden and United States. So, yeah, it's back. So here domestically, just as we've talked about, Thomas isn't news. If you're if you know, based on conversations you and I've been having, it's it's ripping back. And of course it is. So we have to just get to this framework.

    [00:03:19] We have to either accept, you know, this is a cagy virus that gives no quarter.

    [00:03:27] That has no emotions. Doesn't care how prepared you were. Doesn't care how well you worked previously. Doesn't care that you wore a mask yesterday. It just cares about that singular moment when an individual exposes themselves for infection. Right. You know, we have to accept that we're not going to outthink this thing, you know, being crafty. We're just going to have to put real effort into it. And the second thing we're going to have to either accept as a nation or not, in fact, enforcing our is going to have to accept it is we're going to have hundreds and hundreds of thousands of Americans dead from this disease. Germany isn't suffering that fate. Australia is not suffering that fate. Canada probably won't suffer that fate on a per capita basis. They're not doing great but to do better than us. Many, many nations, a lot like us, have done a whole lot better than us.

    [00:04:14] So the second point is we have to accept that we're going to have hundreds of thousands Americans dead sooner rather than later. And that's just where we are now.

    [00:04:23] We can accelerate that number by continuing the socialization in the non safe behaviors that are rampant all across the country. Or we can say, look, we're willing to make sacrifices and lock back down to save the lives of older people, which is effectively the question. And right now we're making a decision. No, we're not willing to make that. We're not not not going to make that sacrifice.

    [00:04:46] Yeah, I mean, it's.

    [00:04:50] It's sort of staggering. I mean, I don't know. I mean, we're one hundred twenty thousand deaths as of today.

    [00:04:57] Two point three million cases in America. I'm gonna assume that the.

    [00:05:04] That number of two point three million is derived by increased testing, which which is to say that numbers probably still, though much larger. You know, and here I'll just go here, I think about it, and I look, I don't know. I think generally my behavior is safe. Generally, my behavior is safe. And I think the behavior of my family and the people I work with is quite safe. You know, I was in our office today by myself. I hadn't been there in weeks. You know, it's it's sitting there as an empty building because we're doing our work from a distance. And then I think about.

    [00:05:47] Tulsa.

    [00:05:49] And you know that the story this week was, oh, Trump's numbers and his Tulsa gathering were smaller than he suspected or it had anticipated, and less talk of how well he gathering all these people inside in the first place. You know, we've shut down all the sports teams and, you know, our events shut down. And I stand by that. I think it's the right decision. And in the meantime, the president of our country was going to gather as many people as he possibly could endorse.

    [00:06:22] It seems crazy to me.

    [00:06:24] I think I think you and I and I think probably everybody, almost everybody listening to this grew up not just with memory after memory of presidents who were competent and others centered in nation nation focused. But it was something that we became a leitmotif and an archetype of who we are and how we think about this nation. Right. And what we have now is a president who is so dramatically different than everything we grew up with, everything we ever considered, anything we ever taught, even if you hated the politics of the president. We never, ever had a president who was this profoundly incompetent, this profoundly narcissistic, this profoundly bad at his job.

    [00:07:09] And I think it's very hard for us just to accept that. Right. It's like waking up one day and all of a sudden thinking you're realizing your parent is a horrible parent. Right. After decades of having a different belief. So the leadership by the president is so horrendous that there's no word that really gets to it. Why am I so particularly animated about it today versus other days? Probably because the comment he made at that rally. So you're right. Like the whole concept of building a rally, bringing people together during a pandemic is is selfish and dangerous and stupid. And that's wrong example. OK, we get it. But then to standing there in the rally and say every time we test, we find more cases. So I told them to stop testing.

    [00:08:00] In the president's states, little said that.

    [00:08:02] So we can go on and on with the opprobrium and the anger about who he is or we can get back to accepting as hard as it is to accept that that's who our leader is and get back to. We have to lead ourselves. And that gets to your question of being safe. And we should talk more about that, because, you know, I'm I don't know, I probably been in 10 states in the last two weeks moving progressively west. Now we're in Idaho, I hope, tomorrow to give you a better view of these gorgeous lakes, these gorgeous mountains. But as we move further west, there's less and less disease burden per state till we get to Idaho, Idaho starting to pick back up. But across North Dakota, South Dakota, Wisconsin, Iowa, etc., the disease burden was quite low. Wyoming, Montana. It's starting to pick up here and it's picking up everywhere now. And it's fascinating to look at the behaviors. And it's fascinating to think about shared consequence. People still do not get it. Every conversation I have, I've only had one conversation on the trip where people denied the disease. Now, I was in my home state of Wisconsin. It was surprising. We talked about that already. But now it's more like, hey, it really doesn't matter to us. And it will.

    [00:09:14] Yeah, well, it's some I mean, Nogami just rattle through true statistics. I mean, what I'm showing in Arizona. Is that one hundred percent of their ICU spaces being used now? Now, there's other space. I mean, you know, that that happened here in New York. We're not talking about total hospital space, but we're talking about ICU space. And that, you know, in Alabama, 28 percent in Georgia, 28 percent in South Carolina, 31 percent. You know, and these numbers are rising. I think it's. I want to talk a little bit about this question of indoor outdoor. You said this last week when your your your feeling is that Arizona's. Weather is offset by the fact that people are inside in Arizona, inside with the air conditioning. Right.

    [00:10:08] And how big is the indoor outdoor aspen?

    [00:10:11] Usually big. Usually big. You look just it's a brand new disease, like unbelievably new in the context of how long we've lived with the disease diseases. Right. But we do believe that it is much more transmissible inside. I mean, the critical factors are is the spittle directed at you? Do you? Is it getting into your nose, your mouth or your eyes? And are you getting a sustained insult from the spittle of an infected person? So if you end inside that, what's the healthy? What's the context of that spittle surviving? So if they're low humidity, is their high temperature, how you ve if so, the spittle, the disease will die faster or the inverse. The disease will live longer. So effectively, just think about it. And this is this is all you have to know. Where does it spread the most rapidly in America? Meat, meat processing plants. I suspect almost no one on here has been in a meat processing plant. I don't think I have, but I've seen pictures. Right. So it's freezing. The workers are right near each other. There's no light. It's inside. It's perfect for the disease. So if that's perfect, then just figure out, you know, the spectrum of of when you start approximating safer. So if you are outside on an Arizona desert, playing golf, walking alongside someone or going for a walk, that's probably fantastically safe. Well, not wrong. That is probably as safe as you can be for a. Environment. Right. Alternatively, if you're in Arizona, an air conditioned room and you're seeing together, we're talking together. That's dangerous. So it's it. That's what we think we know now. Every single thing you hear about this disease. You are going to change our minds on you should take with a grain of salt. There's a lot more we have to learn. You know, the big news in the last couple of weeks on the biology, the disease, was that it appears children are half as likely to be infected. That's positive news. It's big and it's new. And then we're going to continue to find positive molecules to help us deal with the disease. Right. So dextromethorphan or dexamethasone was just discovered to be a positive therapeutic for the disease. So we're going to keep learning things about this as we go on. But right now, that's the concept of whether E.V., wind, heat, moisture, etc..

    [00:12:36] On Friday, I participated in a in a demonstration in the city. I went to New York and. It was a Black Lives Matter gathering, and it was pre powerful, I have to say, was one of the more powerful experiences in my life. I got very emotional, you know, and I got emotional in an unexpected moments from unexpected things. It was people's passion, like I was really. Inspired by their passion and their. Was very clear to me that there was a big groups of people who were sort of at their wit's end. But they also just had such I felt hope. That's what I felt. I felt a degree of hope and like a strident desire to be heard. That I would observe.

    [00:13:39] I don't know. They've been carrying with him for a very long time. OK, now I'm speculating there. I don't know. And what am I reacting to? I'm reacting to the nuance of being with people live and seeing the way they they're behaving and the way that they're expressing their energy. That's it. And I thought it was beautiful. I thought it was beautiful. I thought it was. I'm so glad I went. I'm so glad I spent the time. And what happens in New York is these marches start in these different parts of the city and then they combine and it's like it's like rivers feeding together. And there's moments when you see streams come into getting a little nervous because you feel like, you know, it's where we get packed in on the street. I bring it up. You know what? I just want to make the observation I thought it was beautiful. I think it's.

    [00:14:24] I think, you know, the behavior of the president in the last few weeks has been abhorrent.

    [00:14:30] And it's part of the reason I think there's such strength in this group of people who are marching under the banner of Black Lives Matter. I thought it was really great.

    [00:14:41] But then I have to say, I talked about covered a lot. You know, I wore my mask the whole time. It's hot. It's not fun wearing a mask in the heat, in the heat like that.

    [00:14:52] But, man, were we close to each other. You really figure out if he had to brush your teeth after it on you? We have a mask on for sure. God, it's true.

    [00:15:00] By the way, I could do a better job, but I was nervous.

    [00:15:06] You know, I was nervous for the disease. And do we know yet?

    [00:15:11] Like what? What? How do you react to any of that? I mean, I was really I just want to make a commentary unsorted, like we were talking about the president before. We try to be anti political. But the behavior, the guy just seems to be outrageous to me. And there's two massive stories among others going on. One is about race. And one is about a disease. And they sort of combine in essence in where I was on Friday. And just how do you react to any of that?

    [00:15:36] So protests the president and then the disease quickly on Korona and protesting against initial studies show there is not an increased transmission from people in protest, which is great news because there's a lot of people protesting.

    [00:15:57] So initial non peer reviewed, non empirically, probably, obviously proven studies. Why would that be? Because you're outside winds blowing. You're not talking to one person over and over another. What would be a dangerous aspect to be not in the protest, not wearing a mask and being in a smaller, not a more confined space, but being in a higher density area with the number of people who are are, you know, talking at you. So another thing you remember, so we talked about meatpacking plants. Everything you remember is one of the best studies right now about transmission was about a choir think there in Georgia. And these numbers are directionally accurate. Not exactly right. So I think 45 people went to choir practice. One person was infected, 43 people left infected, indoor choir practice three hours long. They're able to map where everybody sat. So, again, it's choir you're singing. You're you're, you know, exhaling disease out of your lungs over and over and over at the same group of people in a confined space. So anywhere in protest where there's a group of people exhaling on each other over and over, potential chance for transmission, if not a good mask be worn. But otherwise, the studies say right now, not increased transmission from protests. Thank God. The president on an A what's there to say? Probably worth noting, just for the historical record. He tried to fire the. He did fire the Southern District in New York. Prosecutor. He and Attorney General Barr went through kind of an extraordinary bad news cycle. Ham handed handling of fire, trying to fire a U.S. attorney. Why do they want to fire that? Trump appointed Trump donating attorney because he was investigating Trump because that office is going to investigate Trump, because that office has a history of being very independent from from everywhere. Is FDNY Southern District of New York. They nicknamed themselves the Sovereign District of New York, and they hold their independence extraordinarily high. So he tried to fire. He did fire that attorney general choose me, that southern district attorney. There is a whole cycle with the attorney general bargaining in the middle of it. And eventually he's now been replaced by his deputy, who will probably be good for investigation, independent. So bad for Trump. So that's another piece of news. It's just insane. Right.

    [00:18:24] But then finally, on back to the protests, Tom, what was the group like? Like who was there? What did it look like? What was the demographics? What was the age? Was the race?

    [00:18:34] I would say it was. Sixty five percent black. 20 to 50 years old die. 17 to 50 years old. 90 percent mask's. High percentage of mass, for sure.

    [00:18:54] Friendly, you know, and, you know, the it's it's so interesting to be there among all these police and there's police everywhere and the police are the ones that are taking the hit, you know, in a lot of the language.

    [00:19:04] And I don't know, there's something about it that's like. A beautiful statement on democracy, I'm sure. There's a lot of restraint going on in a way that is hopeful, you know, very peaceful. But very brave, you know, very.

    [00:19:29] It felt very real to me. And what do I mean by that? I've been to a number of protests over my lifetime. Not so many, but in college in particular. It felt a little bit like a scene, you know.

    [00:19:41] And in this case, this was not a scene that this is like I remember this one woman.

    [00:19:46] I looked at her and I just judging. But I looked at her passion and she was bombing a guest who was a 30 year old black woman.

    [00:19:52] And I just looked at her and I said, like, she believes every word she's saying, she's angry. But you could feel her hope. You know, you could feel like this is a moment that she's not going to let go and that they're going to accomplish something and we are going to accomplish something that's really important. Anyway, that's that's me reading the crowd and her. But that that would be my reaction.

    [00:20:15] How about the.

    [00:20:17] We're going to have Chief Bratton on, I think, next week, who's been considered the greatest police leader of the 20th century, the previous century's great leader of this century. I'm really excited. Talk to my policing. What was the really. How what was going on with the police?

    [00:20:38] You know, it's interesting. So there was some.

    [00:20:42] It does traffic. Right. So, like cars are trying to do what cars want to do. It's a Friday in New York. I got there at about two thirty on Friday.

    [00:20:51] And so the cops are trying to let people go home.

    [00:20:54] I'm going to guess by 4:00. They want to let the cars move when they can. Moves every now and again. They cut lines in the protest to do so.

    [00:21:01] And the protesters didn't like it. And, you know, in each case.

    [00:21:06] You'd see a guy in charge who in New York, it seems to be like they wear different colored shirts than everybody else, but whatever. And they were like really studying the crowd.

    [00:21:16] My observation is that they were very well trained and the cops were at the, you know, the butt end of a lot of protest and they seemed to handle it really well.

    [00:21:29] I mean, you know, this isn't super scientific, but I was impressed with the way the NYPD handled the situation because they were there to keep peace.

    [00:21:39] They were there on the. Again, the butt end of of what was being said.

    [00:21:43] And they did it sort of seemingly humbly would be my reaction.

    [00:21:50] I have know one thing that we've talked about is it's not necessary to be technically correct right now as perhaps as much as is to be apathetic and to maybe embrace to some instances the very subtle or nuanced realities of the racial situation in America. Some so obviously are not subtle and nuanced. And what I mean is you and I have talked about some critics of the protests who want to come out and talk specifically about the property damage or the riots or why was this statue taken down or that vs. allowing a little room for an awareness that as you were feeling out there, there's millions and millions of people who have deeply seeded, you know, centuries long grievances that they need to air and they need to be fixed. And instead of listening to that and trying to wake up to understand what's going on, you can focus on why was this store looted by this group nonetheless? So I think we've made a lot of room for Lisa, my my let's say my head. I've tried to make a lot of room for not wondering why was this particular crime committed and focusing on that. You know, the law and order side of my head versus the broader. It's time for a social change part of my head. But I have seen these videos of people getting right in the face of police officers, young people, men and women of mixed races and just being unbelievably cruel to them. And it's it hurts me to see that, too, because I've worked a lot with police for a long time. And I've also seen we all have on TV the horrors of police gone wrong. And I hope we can find a balance. But I I'm not going to start talking about the law and order. Why did this happen? Why was this wrong committed, this crime committed amidst this big, broad social change? But I, I, I think a lot of people in America that are more caught, you know. Right. Or Law and order voters, et cetera, are going to get more and more animated and are going to be they're going to be teased and taunted by videos of police being criticized or, you know, yelled at or had things thrown at them right in their face.

    [00:24:08] And so I get it and be back to our Clint.

    [00:24:11] Lots conversations about disinformation, Russia's and Russia's impact on this election, Russia's impact on how we deal with ourselves, neo-Nazi Americans' impact on trying to message to us that kind of video. And I think we've all probably seen it is precisely what they love because it makes people feel the way, you know, the thing that I'm mentioning right now. Like what? You know, maybe they're pushing this too far. What's going on? And it's divisive and I don't know. There's nothing to be nothing we can do about that. But I do want to make sure and noting that a lot of a lot of police officers. I mean, you know, some massive percentage are out there getting paid very poorly, putting themselves in harm's way to help us. Now, there are some that are brutal murders and there's many that aren't. So I hope at some point we get back to that balance. And by the way. Final comment. I'm not saying that this movement to radically restructure police departments is wrong. If you had asked me that a year ago, just flash question, should you define the police or should you do these things with police departments? My gut instinct would've been no. But the more I read about it, the more I think about it, the more I think that there's a huge amount of demilitarization that needs to happen, police departments and and a de-escalation of the aggression that needs to happen police departments. So I hope those things happen, too.

    [00:25:36] And if I have a hope, I mean, I feel like it's some. My own thought experiment and some in my own head. But some of what I've read and conversation I've had is recontact, you know, reconsidering crime and punishment in America entirely. Like, why not? Let's have a really healthy conversation about it. Like, I don't I don't think crime is going to go away. The question is how we react to crime, how we prevent crimes in the first place. How we maintain peace and human rights and all those other things, I think is a valuable conversation no matter how you title it. And then I think the other part of is, is. And for me, the more important part of.

    [00:26:22] Is how do we love our brothers and sisters like I know. I don't know how else to put it, like let's get let's get good at that, because everything that grows out of that has a chance. Everything that starts with policy. I'm not against policy. I'm all for policy.

    [00:26:37] But I feel like if you start in that other place, man, it could be amazing what we might accomplish. And, you know, again, I think it's a beautiful, you know.

    [00:26:49] Human rights, the right to vote, the right to a fair trial. The right to peaceful protest. I mean, it's it's an amazing thing that that we've built and to do it in a multiracial, multiracial, multicultural society is, I think, a great idea. And I think the idea that we could really try to understand each other is so powerful. I want to mention to you know, Dan was trying to watch the Tulsa the Trump gathering because he was just curious. I want to be clear. D.A. never had anything approximating a fan of Donald Trump's. But when he was watching, he was watching people criticize people wearing masks. Now, no matter what you think about whether the economy should have stayed closed or open or whatever it is you think, how the hell did we get to a place where wearing a mask is somehow a negative? Right. And I can say that, you know, I feel very strongly. There's one person who could really help in that regard, and it's our president. Regardless what your politics are, guys wearing a mask is probably a beneficial thing. So let's do that.

    [00:27:55] Yeah, that's a good point. So if we haven't, like, explicitly the safest thing you can do, which the economy can't stand, is just to stay home and separate. We can't do that anymore. No way. The next most effective thing you can do is wear a good mask properly. And it's unbelievably effective to prevent you to infect others and to prevent you from getting infected infected. So remember, proper mask, good mask, properly worn. And so I do encourage every to try to get the best mask they can.

    [00:28:29] And, yes, become the symbol of, you know, I have to say, I'm in Idaho, I'm in a town that actually has a history of far right behavior quarterly in Idaho, a state that has a history of neo-Nazi activity, really strong like percentage activity. And my son and I went out to the stores yesterday to buy stuff and we wore masks and a number of people did not a lot, but I didn't see any side gaze. Like, why are you wearing a mask? Which was cool. But it's certainly become a symbol of, oh, you're one. You know, you're on their side if you're wearing the mask, at least in the Trump rally, I guess.

    [00:29:07] Yeah. It's an unbelievably attractive, interactive and important tool. And it's a generous thing to do, too. Wearing a mask. You're helping other people and you have to sit there and smell your breath for hours while you do it. It's not pleasant, but you're doing it. Help other people, too. And you're right, if the president just wore a mask and said this is a good thing to do, there'd be none of it. But he's not going out.

    [00:29:26] Yeah. And to me, it's like an extension of the divisiveness. It's like, man, we're going to fight over everything, you know, in the fact that we it ends up in that, you know, me being about a mask, it's just there's something about it that's just incredibly disappointing.

    [00:29:45] But we'll see. We'll see. I mean, I do think my this is my general feeling. My feeling of the state of the world right now is that there are a number of people who are acting on hope to make a better world because we think the one that we're coming from wasn't good enough. And, you know, we'll see. We have an election coming. It's probably going to be really divisive, but maybe it'll be hopeful. Maybe it'll be something that is is really good for us, too. And it wouldn't be insane to think that in the midst of some some of these crises, we might find a new kind of hope like that's actually fairly typical that those kinds of things can happen. Doesn't mean it's going to happen. Doesn't mean it's gonna be easy. But it's sort of, you know, what I hope for. And, you know, look, I think when it comes to Cauvin and I know we keep bouncing back and forth on these things, but I think they're so closely related. You know, one of the things that.

    [00:30:43] Comes to mind for me is that.

    [00:30:46] I think fundamentally covered his comp complex and that I've seen behaviors around my own neighborhood.

    [00:30:53] That are, you know, in a my neighborhood is relatively progressive. However you want to put it.

    [00:31:01] And psychologically, when the world changed and the winds change, their behavior changed. When the behavior change, you kind of wonder where this is going to go next. But let me mention another place, India.

    [00:31:11] Dan sort of outlined some stuff to me. What's happening in India? It's happening in India like it's becoming a real problem in India.

    [00:31:20] And so to me, the thing that the place I keep going and it was what you were saying before, I think it's very important that we all accept that the math of the disease, which is to say it's still around, it gets in people's lungs. When it gets kicked out of people's lungs, it can come into your lungs. And if it comes into your lungs and you're in trouble and it seems to be the case that, yes, you're better off outside than inside.

    [00:31:41] But it's growing like crazy in Brazil. And Brazil is essentially, you know, tropical or subtropical, which is to say it's warm year round and that India, too, which is, I think.

    [00:31:55] More tropical. I should. I'm not going to get that exactly right, I've been to India, but and I've been any and the winner and a lot of well, where are you where the disease is spreading right now in India's.

    [00:32:02] It was hot, so.

    [00:32:04] Yeah. So it's happening like it's like this is a real thing and it didn't go away and it's not about to go away.

    [00:32:12] And we're gonna have to have good behaviors for a long period time. But how much you know about India? Cause here it comes. It's coming on in India now.

    [00:32:20] Well, so let me do one thing first. So, United States, October, September, August, September, October, November. That quarter, those for those four months are going to be the most divisive, dangerous and demagogued months in the memory of anyone listening to this show.

    [00:32:38] All the machinations that are going to go on around this election, the brutal realities of this disease and the continued social protests around Black Lives Matter.

    [00:32:49] And George Floyd are going to be extraordinary. Why worse than now? Because the disease will be stronger. Why would disease be stronger? Because children be back at school and they will help spread the disease. And because we'll be entering flu season and states.

    [00:33:03] So just be aware, like these four months are August. And so I'm saying June. July will be. We'll keep watching the disease pop up. Back up. Like I was saying, the beginning. I think you and I and the headlines are showing the disease is coming back. I'm not sure it's in the vault and stronger people yet, but it will clearly be in people's awareness starting in August. I'll get September, October, November. You get to the presidential election. It's going to be an insane time in America.

    [00:33:30] Insane.

    [00:33:31] And in some show, we should start talking about some of the games that are going to be played by both sides around the elections. Or let's say three sides, Democrats, Republicans and foreign interference. And they're going to be dramatic. So that's this one common one to make India. When I went to the State Department years ago, I was very young and I went to work at a bureau in the State Department. And I met a guy who was 10 years older than me. So he was in his mid 30s and he had just joined the Foreign Service, which is a little late. Normally you join in your mid 20s, young, early 20s. Normally, he joined in his early 30s, maybe mid 30s. And I was talking about, wow, you know, what did you do before? And he had been I guess he worked at a hedge fund or had been some sort of stock trader.

    [00:34:23] And to me, that seemed romantic in a way to make a lot of money. You know, the grass is always greener, says, oh, wow, what why? Why, why would you possibly leave that career? And he said, Because I woke up every morning reading the headlines and seeing a catastrophe and wondering how he would make money off of it.

    [00:34:41] And I one day realized, my God, this is horrible. I want to go help the world, not try to profit off of its misery. So I joined the Foreign Service and I'm the conversation actually stuck with me. He was a great diplomat, by the way. I wish I remember his name. And when this disease broke for our clients and for myself, I went around the world, you know, literally, not literally. You know, I studied the whole world and we created some not models about really early on which states were going to be able to resist the virus in which states were going to be hit the hardest. We looked at whether we looked at health infrastructure, we looked at density of population. We looked at, you know, all sorts of things, multiple factors. This was in early March and maybe late February. And at that point, I said India is going to be in so much trouble. And I shorted an ETF on India. I did what this hedge fund guy left to go be of service. I made a bet on the misery of India. And I. I still feel very badly about it. And I lost all the money, by the way, so my option wasn't dated properly. If I had a longer option, I would have probably made money on it because India now is obviously in big trouble. But they resisted it for a long time. So when I think of India, that comes to me first. This idea of like, wow, you actually made a bet you would have made money on more people dying in that country, which is a kind of a perverse thing that's related to this sees India itself. All those reasons that we thought it would have trouble. They're having trouble, right? High density, poor healthcare, low awareness of a low percentage of doctors. One thing that might be working in their favor is it's in their culture to wash their hands a lot. It's in their companies, in their culture. But there are there are a number of societal norms there that do that might make them a little better prepared to prevent microbes from flooding floating around. There also appears to be a vaccination that some Southeast Asian countries have given to a lot of their population that may have provided some buffer. But whatever it was that slowed down, the virus in India is gone. The virus is ripping through the country. And it's very, very sad because they have a very poor every infrastructure in India, poor, including the public health infrastructure. So there was a you know, sorry, I sort of bring a couple of stories into one, but India is in trouble. Brazil's in unbelievable trouble. And Brazil's in trouble because of poor leadership. India is in trouble because structurally, it's just a hard country to get this right. Modi's not a bad leader on the disease. He hasn't been great. But Bulsara, the leader in Brazil, has been criminally bad, very somewhat of our president. And that country's in a massive, massive, massive disaster right now. They are going to overtake the United States in fatalities and in new infections probably sooner rather than later.

    [00:37:42] Do you when you think about where this could go. I mean, we all think in terms of it seems to be the case that we all think of in terms of, you know, about a year from now, we'll all start being immunized from the disease.

    [00:38:06] But I don't know. That may not happen for sure. I mean, there's a lot there's a minute there's a lot of sort of outcomes that can happen. And, you know, the way the global economy is set up today. The implications for health challenges in other countries like Brazil or India, they come home.

    [00:38:25] More than emotionally, they come home in the form of dollars. They come home in the form of politics.

    [00:38:33] How do you look at that? Like, are there are there bad case scenarios that we don't talk about enough?

    [00:38:38] You know, HIV is killed.

    [00:38:44] Deca, millions of people in the world, I think hundreds of millions of people. It's a disease. I spent a lot of time working on and we still don't have an HIV vaccine. HIV AIDS, we don't have a vaccine for that. And there was a lot of effort, not like the effort that's been put into this, but there's a lot of effort.

    [00:39:02] First question is why? Why is there so much ever being put into this disease that's killed? Hundred twenty thousand Americans. It's going to kill 3000 Americans by the end of September, probably. We've lost more people in this country from HIV and in the decades than than that.

    [00:39:18] So why is there so much more effort into this disease than to HIV? Well, that gets a lot to inclusion. It gets a lot to the fact that HIV was considered for a long time a gay disease, that it was an African disease and there wasn't a lot of money in the vaccine. There's probably eventually a lot of money in a in a Saar's Kobe to vaccine. So the bad news is there's still a 25 percent chance I use HIV AIDS as an example of understanding that with a lot of scientific effort, you still can end up with zero. There's still a 25 percent chance we do not get a vaccine in three years, and we should remember that. Now, obviously, we all hope that's wrong. Then there's and then there's a chance that the vaccines developed by an entity that doesn't want to distribute it is called, quote unquote, fairly. Then there's the reality that any country who develops the vaccine minus some regulatory issues they have from donor dollars, which we've talked about before with the SEPI initiative and other initiatives, whoever does develop it, whatever nation does develop it is going to have to give it to its populace first. Meaning, if China gets it is the vaccine first and it's an effective vaccine. And the company there in China that made it didn't have a series of contractual obligations to share it around the world. China will get vaccinated first. How can you be the leader of a country and not take care of your people first? So there is massive vaccine nationalism going on. There's a serious national race to develop the vaccine. America is doing fine. But so that's that's another option. And then a final option is that we come up with a less than perfect vaccine and we rush it out. So if we have a vaccine that works on half the people, that's better than nothing, that's for sure. Particularly if it's safe. But if it works on, again, half the people your President Trump, even if you're President Tom Scott, you're going to be highly motivated to get that vaccine out. Now, in so doing, what you're doing is you're taking up manufacturing capacity, distribution capacity and, you know, people's immunization capacity with a less than perfect vaccine.

    [00:41:24] This president obviously has shown zero. What's the right word? Maturity. There's a better word than that around hyping cures and therapeutics. His behavior with hydroxyl chloroquine being a perfect example.

    [00:41:41] So would we expect him to have any restraints if there's good news about a vaccine made in America? No, he'd have none. And we could rush forward with the left's than vaccine. And meaning if we'd waited a month or two, perhaps, who could have had an 80 percent, 90 percent, 99 percent effective vaccine? So there's a lot of challenges going on here about when will we get it? Will it be the right one? And then to whom does it get distributed in you layer in this nationalism concept on top? So, again, I've said it before. But if China gets the vaccine first, this will be a source of national pride for them, similar to America landing a man on the moon before anybody else. And rightly so. This is a global catastrophe. And they would be someone who provided a solution. And would they extort or extract a cost for that from nations? Of course they would. Amidst all that kind of negativity, there's some kind of beautiful news from the European Union. They have committed to put up I can't read the number. I think they've committed about 50 million doses of the vaccine early for Africa. I think that's a special thing. And when I see things like that, it breaks my heart that America is not trying to figure out how it can help lead other nations and thereby return American to its international preeminence as a leader. Bernard Shaw credentials as a global leader in a time of crisis. Which is what we used to be. But we're not.

    [00:43:04] So if we're gonna project 300000. I'm just going to try this on. Did you say by the end of September, by the way?

    [00:43:13] I think so. You know what? We're 600 dead a day and they're never going to go up. So you can without any dramatic changes, you, unfortunately, are getting to that number.

    [00:43:26] So if we're two hundred thousand, some odd deaths in the latter part of August.

    [00:43:34] Might you not open the schools? No, I don't think so. I mean, I think we have to accept that since member people learn through stories, not statistics.

    [00:43:43] One, death is a tragedy. A million is a statistic. Right? I think that was Stalin who said that. And I think in America, I can just tell you, at least on this car ride scene, thousands and thousands Americans across the country. People want to be out. People want to socialize. People want to get to work. And people even know what we're not asking them. It's doing it. So we've got 120000 dead, 300000 dead.

    [00:44:10] So what it's I think I think we have to accept that this nation has a callousness.

    [00:44:18] I don't throw a word as we call a callousness or a rationality, depending on how you want to look at it, that says we have to get to work. And by the way, American Individualism says a lot of us want to wear masks or just immaturities or not wear masks in public. And what we're doing, the other thing is, remember, it really largely largely kills people over 65 years old. Not entirely, but but dramatically more lethal to people over 65 than 75 than 85 because of about 10 times in each of those age brackets and lethality to get to a four or five percent lethal to someone already five years old, which is a huge number. Right. So and those people die in private. They die hidden behind hipper regulations. They die in old folks homes where the family can't visit anymore. They die without press coverage. And they they're they're old anyway, quote unquote. So folks are probably we are callouses in America where we're kind of willing to accept that three or a thousand probably won't feel a whole lot different than to America than honor. Twenty thousand. That's my guess. It's it's pessimistic. It's sad. But that's my guess about what's gonna happen now.

    [00:45:24] How does that change if we get stories, not statistics. So why did the UK change its point of view dramatically? They were headed for a Sweden solution. They were going to do a hands off, protect the old people, keep the economy alive, let people go to work. Don't lock down answer. That's where they were headed. What happened? Their prime minister, Boris Johnson, got the disease. Got very sick. Went to the ICU. Almost went on a respirator. They woke up. They got Cheesus. They said, okay, I get it.

    [00:45:57] Could something like that happen in America? A celebrity get very sick, a child get very sick. I hope not. I'm certainly not praying for that. That kind of thing.

    [00:46:05] That story could change us, change our decision making process here.

    [00:46:12] Djokovic, the number one tennis player in the world, just tested positive for the disease.

    [00:46:18] He's young and healthy. I pray he'll be fine. Statistically, he will. But that also tells us about sport. Right?

    [00:46:27] So, you know, if we don't have poignant stories, I think America is going to display a callousness where we'll be at 300 and we're not going to bat an eye.

    [00:46:37] Yeah, we're in an interesting time.

    [00:46:40] There's a lot more in a crazy time, and we don't I don't think we know how crazy it is and it's going to get crazier and crazier.

    [00:46:46] And we're missing a center. I mean, whether I think I think I think I've made clear and I I'm not on this side of our current president, I don't think any either of us are on that side.

    [00:47:01] And yet I wish we had. And it's for me, it's it's it's less political than it is human. I think would be really helpful to have someone in office who you might disagree with politically. But you felt like they were trying to hold a center together that was of value or was, you know, a value visa, the Black Lives Matter.

    [00:47:23] It was a value vs v the disease.

    [00:47:26] And I just don't think we have that. And so we're going that this time we're headed into. I talked earlier about the optimism. I still have it. I still have it because I think, you know, these battles are won over time.

    [00:47:39] And that, to me, might my impression is that people are on the good side of the fight, but the fights is going to be messy.

    [00:47:48] That's my impression.

    [00:47:48] I can't prove it. I feel strongly about it because I get around a lot. I say I meet and see lots of different people in lots of different places. By the way, we're going back down the Mississippi again.

    [00:47:57] Yeah. So I'm so excited to watch that.

    [00:48:00] Yeah. And so that'll be very interesting.

    [00:48:02] And it's all about having safe, physically safe and courageous conversations about race. I mean, our conversation is going to be about race. And we're bringing Aleesha Wises, I think, to go with us. Neal Phillips is going to go with us. You know, people whose who are good at this, who understand these things and can do it in a powerful way. But I mention it because, you know, in our little tiny way, it's hopefully a pocket of hope. And I think there are many, many, many others. And that's why I ultimately sign on the place of hope than the other place. But I'm also anxious for sure.

    [00:48:39] Where did you know this? The next few months are going to be horrible. I'm sorry. The disease is going to rip. The partisanships gonna be intense. Other tools, other entities trying to rip us apart are going to be in full gear. There's other things. You know, this is also a moment when those things happen, other bad things happen to becomes an attractant for extremist behavior or terrorist, et cetera. Just having a lot of gasoline laying around. So effectively, what this means just is a bad thing. Could that lead to a great outcome? Could. What does that stupid expression? You can't make an ammo without breaking eggs, which is horrendous and inhuman way of looking at it. I guess it's true. You know, we have a persistent, massive racial disparity in this country that is centuries old and simply hasn't gotten fixed. In some ways it's gotten worse. Are we going to wake up to then try and change it? I hope so. And if it if it hadn't, it wouldn't have happened, unfortunately, if George Floyd hadn't been slow motion murdered in front of us. It's still not happening yet. We'll see. Ripping down statues isn't a long term solution, but this kind of pain is what has to happen. You had a shirt on the today that's had suffered, right? We have to go through or the country's gonna have to go through a lot of pain and reckoning, perhaps to get to where we ought to be. So let's hope that for all the cost we're going to incur and I don't mean the disease so much. I mean the division and the divisiveness, the demagogery. Let's hope that we get a positive outcome from that. But let's not be complacent. I presume we will. So your tautly your trip down to Mississippi, like anything you can do, you want to protest anything we can do. That's what we have to do. All of us. This is a moment when we are we are we are just paying a massive cost and we should try to get something out of it. Neitz was try to get a government by the people, for the people, for all the people to try to get a government where America gets out and leads internationally and shows the world with the city on the hill means let's get a government. Let's get to people where we lead individually. And we are selfless. We wear masks. We don't affect other people. Let's get a world. Let's get a country where we aren't callous about old people dying and that we don't go to parties in the Ozarks or parties in the pool over here or wherever and feel like, well, it's OK if I get the disease or my kids get the disease.

    [00:50:57] And it's probably statistically relatively safe. But you're forgetting that you're going to get. You're going to be then exposed to be bald and are going to die because of your carelessness.

    [00:51:05] Let's see if we can get there. But but let's also gird ourselves. The next four months are going to be extraordinarily difficult unless leaving us in positive out of it.

    [00:51:17] Yeah, well, I think engagement in our society, you know, is.

    [00:51:26] Feels more real to me than it's felt since college. I mean, college, just because that's what college kids do. But, you know, as an adult, it's not even close. And I think that that emotion and that feeling is where the answer will lie, because without it, I don't think we get anywhere. But I think to the extent that people make that sort of civic engagement thing in whatever way you can, it's going to make a difference. It's going to be meaningful. And we're gonna be able to answer questions in a more satisfying way on the other end of this than by sitting back or we're just hoping anyway, that you said something before that struck me.

    [00:52:01] And it was simple and was strong. Twitter is a lie. Right. All this divisive social media in its concept is a lie. Does it mean each individual tweets a lie? But like this, this battlespace has been designed to click bait, make money based on us. Fighting each other is a lie. I think that was really wise of you to comment. Maybe we also know that social media activism is a lie. Right. You know, posting Black Lives Matter on Instagram page or any of these things we do really doesn't forward the ball. I'm a mascot. Maybe. Let me ask. Does it forward the ball? I don't know that it does. I think you have to vote. I think you have to mobilize voters. I think you have to get on the street and protest. I think you have to go call up your police departments and see what rules are you following and hold your mayors accountable, much like Graham Allen, its own vow did. For example, I do want to talk a whole lot more about that. We keep saying we should and we haven't. But that individual leadership is what's going to change us in this instance. Social media activism is a lie, too. It's not going to move us as far as we need to get. And it's probably an opiate, right? It's the lotus eaters. It makes us think like we're doing the right thing. Oh, I posted something on social media. Like I'm good. You're not you're not doing it. This you know, the way you look at what we're doing and say this isn't doing. You a thousand people might watch this. But is this enough? No.

    [00:53:28] No, I yeah, I mean, I think it's some.

    [00:53:31] I did my first political post in my life about two weeks ago.

    [00:53:40] Felt like the right thing. I, I but I generally agree with you. I mean, I think it's. Twitter is a really good battleground. You know, it's a good place to do battle, but you might be in a battle that you're not actually in. And I think that happens a lot. And my own observation, when you see people together live and they have a meaningful conversation, the miracles that happen are beautiful.

    [00:54:03] I mean, I just here's the thing about that. Like, it sounds so simple and I say it all the time and I'm sure people get sick of me saying it. But when I observe it over and over and over again, I do more and more. I believe it's the only way you have to engage with other people, because once you see what the truth is, the truth is hopeful. Right.

    [00:54:23] What?

    [00:54:23] We walked into a bar in Montana, Wyoming, Montana, SILVERGLATE and there was a couple of family sitting at a table and he had the old the grandfather had on the most audacious and bold Trump 20-20 hat I've ever seen and think might as well sparklers on it.

    [00:54:43] And my little boys, my wife and I all kind of, you know, it just the whole table had Trump, Kiran. And I thought, oh, man. Like, I wish I had a visceral response. And there weren't a lot other people in there. And, you know, 20 minutes later, all talking, they're lovely humans there. I didn't get into Trump, but they care. They cared about Black Lives Matter. They cared about the protests.

    [00:55:11] They actually, of course, were. We're good. They appear to be very good people. They just had a very different political point of view than we did.

    [00:55:21] And if we can find that shared heart and empathy and love as a nation, as you've said many times, PBS, a path out and broader conversation to be had another time.

    [00:55:32] But you know one, if you know, if you made a prediction last year about what will be a very hopeful outcome for America, it would be that people learn how to get more in touch with their books, to expand their circles of empathy, right. To love a broader group of people, not just people who look like you and sound like you and talk like you, but a broader and broader group of people. And as those circles under the expand, you know, so will the happiness and the wealth and the health of the economy and a country. Right. It's a fact, but it's very hard to do because when because it's not our designed. But if you were to had a hope a year ago, that would've been your hope. And there's a reason should be your hope now. It's just a moment when there's forces pulling us apart in restricting our circles of empathy as hard as it possibly can be done because lot of people profit from it. The disease profits from it, too. This is a tough time anyway. I feel like I'm over philosophizing.

    [00:56:27] Well, it was good. It was good. I mean, I covered his back.

    [00:56:31] Oh, it is bad. It's where an ask coming on all of us to do the right thing as much as possible.

    [00:56:38] And recognizing that the road ahead is complex. And can we lead ourselves in a way that is hopeful and my. My hope is love. First people first will solve the problems once we sort of commit to each other.

    [00:56:53] That that's my view.

    [00:56:54] But anyway, we'll great to see you, Tom. Thanks, Arpey.

    Copyright TNP 2020

    we sometimes receive a small commission for purchases made when visiting some links provided in our show notes and we wanted you to know.

    58 min
  • rp daily: are you willing to listen to what makes you uncomfortable?

    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

    Subscribe: episode updates

    are you willing to listen to what makes you uncomfortable? join tom and rp's conversation with dr. christine crawford to learn more about covid and her personal insights regarding how the nation is handling it. dr. Crawford received her doctorate in science and epidemiology from Harvard University and also spent time at the CDC.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.

    listen to this episode on apple podcasts

    subscribe to our youtube channel

    follow us on facebook

    follow us on instagram

    transcript

    [00:00:21] I want to welcome Dr Kristine Crawford. Christine, thank you for being with us. I want to say in advance that you asked us to call you Christine, so we're not going to call you Dr. Throughout.

    [00:00:34] But, you know, it's funny.

    [00:00:37] I'm not sure that if you are on the first try in February of 2020, if you ask me what is epidemiology, I might not get it right on the first try. I think I get it right after that, but not on the first try.

    [00:00:50] And. And now I've learned quite a bit. You know, I've largely through our P.A. who, you know, built the first sort of pandemic response plan. I know who was the first Arpey, but certainly, you know, in the 90s in the Clinton administration had built a big and effective plan, including warehouses full of PDP and arbitrary PPE.

    [00:01:13] TPP is the finance thing, is it PPE, PPE, PPE and ventilators and such a.

    [00:01:22] Yeah, so it's been a journey and I was saying to somebody this morning, you know, I'm going to guess we're in ballpark ages. And for me, as a 54 year old, these three months have been the most profound three months of my life. And, you know, it's it's certainly in part impacted by covered by business challenges, by life challenges, by family issues. By George Floyd. There's just so much happening at this moment that it makes it so intense. And, you know, it's not all bad. There's a really powerful mix of hope, fear, challenge, opportunity in the middle, all this. And I'm going to do like a one second thing on your bio, which please fill in any blanks. But, you know, you have an interesting mix of, you know, you're from the South, you from are you from Augusta, Georgia, or just across from Augusta, Georgia? I grew up in Aiken, South Carolina.

    [00:02:27] Yeah, but you're a doctor of science and epidemiology from Harvard and you have a B.S. in Natural Sciences. You graduated from Spelman College. And, you know, so you would think, oh, she must be a doctor or whatever. And you did time at the CDC. But then you also became a you ran a number of franchises for McDonald's, which is, you know, an American institution of in so many ways. And you were also very successful in that realm and over time added a number of franchises in your tenure. And are you still doing that, by the way, now?

    [00:03:02] So I sold some McDonald's was actually the family business. My mom was going to franchisee for about 15 years. So when I came and joined, so it's a story of family business, but also the second generation woman owned family business as well, but also in about two years.

    [00:03:23] And how many did you have at the time? We had seven. OK. And have you seen what's the movie called about Ray Kroc?

    [00:03:30] What's it called? What do you think of that? Tell me what you thought of that.

    [00:03:33] It's interesting. If you read his autobiography, he actually was very transparent about kind of a lot of his darkness, as you know. And so it wasn't quite as dark as maybe he actually was. And I think what's just as an aside, I think as Americans, we don't appreciate that, you know, people can do good things and have other things that they wrestle with in the complexity of all of us. We just want a shiny, pretty happy story. So I think even the founders showed that, you know, Happy Meals may matter have come or developed in the way they grew. It did not grow in the way that people thought it would.

    [00:04:19] Yeah. You know, for me, of any drama I've ever seen scripted, it was the best representation of what a startup is like that I've ever seen.

    [00:04:31] And, you know, they paint those stories between he and the brothers as being like very black and white. And the fact of the matter is, it all makes sense to me. I mean, you know, he had to make some tough decisions and they had to make some tough decisions. And, you know, were they all made, right? Probably not. But I don't think they were all made like just totally as malignant badness as you're saying right now.

    [00:04:55] I mean, people are complicated and processes are complicated. Right. Dehumanize and all of it. And at the end of the day, if he had gone bankrupt, you know, then the brothers would have said, well, we made more than we ever thought. But he didn't. And so then the story looks very different.

    [00:05:13] So, yeah, you know, when I graduated from college, I went to see a guy who I very much respected as a business person. And he and, you know, I was talking about the different choices and I thought about getting an MBA.

    [00:05:24] And he said, work at McDonald's.

    [00:05:28] And I and I was a little like, well, what do you mean? And he's like, go work on McDonald's. Like, you want to really learn about business, go work McDonald's. It's the best place to learn. And I didn't do it, by the way, and take his advice. But it stayed with me and I get it. I mean, it makes sense. Does that advice make sense to you?

    [00:05:44] So I referred to my time at McDonald's as the most expensive MBA ever, because you really do learn about the operations and the nuts and bolts of selling and how complicated it is just to get a cheeseburger right across the counter. And so you learn all of those very operational pieces. But then being a piece of McDonald's in this large corporate community, then you also have insights into supply chain and things that are very strategic in a much larger level than you typically would in a business just as a small business owner in your local community. So it's really, I think, the best of both worlds. So it's getting to see very functional. How do I manage, inspire, take care of my employees in my town. In my home. Right. As well as what does it look like for marketing decisions, menu items. So things that are much higher of you as well. It's it's a it's such great place to learn about this.

    [00:06:47] Yes. You know, when I read the bio there, you know, there's some part of it that, you know, on on on its surface, you think, well, how could this somebody who, you know, has a doctorate in science end up, you know, running McDonald's is and I don't know how you say that word. McDonald's I multiple McDonald's and I get it.

    [00:07:09] But on the other hand, I think. Yeah, well, OK. That, you know, it's just as likely as an artist might run a great McDonald's as a scientist, might run a great McDonald's. That to me is like business. Is that kind of a thing, you know, where you get lots of different kinds of people could successfully run an organization. And the richness of it all is definitely interesting, but I don't think of it as ironic.

    [00:07:31] Does that make sense? No. Think it's interesting because people say, well, how could you? And initially it is. It's all, I think, stewardship and how you choose to serve your community. And so the thing about public health that was attractive to me was it wasn't this kind of let me do this experiment on a flatworm, because there may be some implications eventually. And it was this place where I could see immediately how research and work in science could make an impact. And running a McDonald's is that it is you know, you get kids when they're 60, you have adults, sometimes adults who had some challenges. But that ability to help someone through, you know, seeing and working with them every day and all of the things that they taught and gave me that back and forth in that helping one another is the same. Right? Just that that my my room or my mechanism to doing so changed.

    [00:08:41] Yeah. Yeah.

    [00:08:44] I want to shift into this sort of this macro thing I opened with, which is just like Kovik generally. I'd like to talk a little bit about that before I do. Arpey if there's anything you want to talk about McDonald's. We go back to McDonald's later, too. But I come on in the conversation, RPN, and let's we can talk McDonald's. But I want to sort of talk about the big Cauvin thesis and then I won't talk specifically what's going on. The world covered was Christine.

    [00:09:06] It's nice to meet you. Hope the audio's OK here. I can tell you on a road trip with three boys and I hear the word McDonald's about every 15 minutes. Can we stop out? Where's the next one? Aren't they the best? And last night we had to stop at an Arby's and it was like tears and we couldn't find a McDonald's. But the American institution.

    [00:09:31] Nice of you, too, as well. Yeah.

    [00:09:34] So, Christine, I'm curious just I mean, this has been a phenomenon, right? A three month or more phenomenon in the United States. Can you just react to it on that very high level? Like how has this been for you navigating all this, looking at all this?

    [00:09:51] So I think initially I was very angry for a couple of weeks. I felt as if I'm having been a part of the Centers for Disease Control and I was at the IRS office. So we did outbreak investigations and responded to public health emergencies. And so knowing what we can do and the talent that's there for it, I couldn't understand what was happening. Right. And so I was very frustrated by the response very candidly. And I think I just didn't get it right. I just did not get how we weren't reacting different and how the systems that we had in place weren't being used. And public health. Normally, there's this beautiful dance that occurs between the federal government and state departments of public health. And it's this back and forth. And I just very removed from it, though, but didn't see it. And I was like, OK. So why are the things that should be happened, you know how to do? Why aren't they? And so for years, the Centers for Disease Control in the United States has been seen as the public health response period. And so to hear it silenced, it caused me great pain. And I think some of that frustration still lingers because I feel as if we've gotten to a point where we just accept that we're going to have two hundred thousand Americans who have passed from this. All right. As if it had to be this way. And so that caused me great anger and grief and frustration at certain points. I think one thing that I did not see coming was this whole idea of his business against public health and it being this tension and versus and so having been in both worlds, I understand why they don't quite get one right. So as public healthy ball. And so we make decisions. But there's an understanding that we're always accumulating more debt. Right. And so what we know we're making a recommendation based on what we know today. But that may change tomorrow. It certainly may change a week from now as we gather more information, because the more information we add, the better decision we can make with things change. And so it's not that we didn't know what we were talking about. It's that we've gotten new information and we're making a different decision. And so I understand that that is hard. We're in business. Oftentimes you make decisions and you write it out. We try to add or if you know something happen, you don't overcommunicate it. You fix it. Right. And then you keep moving. But in public health, there's this need to constantly communicate because you need the data that city, the towns information that needs to be accumulated. And so and I think making the environment of the United States of our country safe for people to say, I have hope. Right. So just things like encouraging earlier in the epidemic for people to say, Heddon really people to say, OK, I have it. And if you were around me when I went to church on, you know, the Sunday before it became public. If I want everyone to know because I think I remembered everybody I was in contact with, but I'm not sure. And we didn't even create an environment to help people do that. We got stuck talking about promis laws and restrictions and not just how do we take care of each other. And I just don't know how that.

    [00:13:48] Yeah. You know, the way you were characterizing Ray Kroc, which is that there's nuance and there's there's layers to all these different people and that and that's what we talk about in that case. But that's true of organizations as well. And Arpey, I don't know if you agree with this, but I think the impression that, you know, the modern right has and it's maybe been true in the right for a long period of time and others, too, is that there's a general incompetence to government and that therefore it shouldn't be listened to. And yet I know from people I trust, having not spent a lot of time there, that the qualities of people within places like the CDC is so high and most of us don't know that. And the usefulness of something like the CDC is generally just not understood. It's not even misunderstood. It's just kind of not understood generally. And again, I'm generalizing and I'm generalizing to an extent on the right. But I guess I think I'm generalizing overall, but I don't.

    [00:14:36] So this is so as a business person, right. If you run a company, you listen to what your marketing department touch. You may not understand how jockeys are measured. They usually spend a certain amount on X number of GOP. You do. And so why it is then that you can't trust that scientists and folks who have expertize in coming up with numbers in another way and this other realm might know what they're talking about? Frustrates me because business people always talk about show me the numbers, show me the data. Well, if someone shows you the numbers, even if you don't understand how they came up with them, at some point, you have to trust it. Right. But then exit and try to figure out which piece of it you can't understand. It's not foreign language. And then I said, let me acknowledge this frustration. Well, oftentimes those of us who do that work don't understand how things happen day to day in running businesses and what it takes to get the doors open and what it means to be responsible for those who work with us and their farm. Right. And so we oftentimes don't understand. We need very discrete points of data to make hard decisions around that. But there's got to be a place that we communicate and understand and trust one another. And that that has just made me woefully sad because we could be amazing if business a public works like that. That's. Because that would be the most effective way of communicating in terms of plans around prevention around even when people aren't feeling well. People go to work every day. And so what if we actually work together on this as opposed to just discounting? Yeah.

    [00:16:33] How do you react to that, Arpey? It's it's it's fascinating. Listen, you talk about your former employee, Christine. You know, and you're a great example of the people I worked with at CDC. And there's there's three running three organizations in the U.S. government that I hold in very high esteem that most people usually don't. CDC, Public Health Service and the Coast Guard, it's three organizations. We will get government salaries. They put themselves at risk and they're simply trying to help other people. Now, were we fetishize the Delta Force, the SEALs, you know, the CIA, the FBI. Those are all great organizations, too. But CDC, Public Health Service, U.S. Coast Guard trying to help other people doing it in harm's way and again, getting paid very little for it. And I was heartbroken how poorly CDC did in the beginning and still in this epidemic. And I researched it. I talked to my friends there. And I, I basically, I think, you know, relined. I think, you know, you get what you pay for. We've underfunded government for decades. And so you have an organization that doesn't have the fight that the financing it needs. It made a really serious misstep on testing right off the bat. And then I just I can't imagine it's like working there while you have a president making anti factual anti science proclamations from the Oval Office. No, these are career people who are very used to serving the president. These are an executive branch, obviously. And the president is their ultimate boss. Period. Full stop. So it's got to be very, very hard. But the failures have been very serious. Talking to some friends who work there, there's a spirit of being disheartened. Yet they're still in the fight and this is what they signed up to do. So I think it's amazing. And, you know, you're you're you're a further point about this moment we're in of a.. Expertize ism a. facts, alternative facts, complexity, mismatch. It's this is a really, really hard time to try to bring the nuance, the sacrifice necessary to look at the disease and do it properly. You know, I was just sitting there. I'll leave it at their distress. I'll leave it there for now to reply to your comments on CDC.

    [00:18:44] It's makes me very sad.

    [00:18:48] They literally had errors on their Web site. Right. Like when in the history of that organization, do they put information up on the Web site that they had to retract?

    [00:18:56] Now, that's shocking to me. Same with WHL, of course, too.

    [00:19:02] Do you do you guys think of that? And, Christine, one of the things about this show is that we we try not to delve into politics because we just don't want to be part of that noise. And, you know, sometimes it requires a certain amount of strength. The dam burst a couple of weeks ago largely. Because the guy in charge sort of went too far and just speaking personally, I sort of went off on the guy.

    [00:19:29] So you have a little bit more license now to call the than we did before. And I really we do that for having nothing to do with taking sides, but just to create clarity for people so they can calmly think about what is a really challenging thing that being covered. Do you look at the your frustration? Does it come from the top?

    [00:19:48] No, it does. It does. I think.

    [00:19:56] There are some. So let me manage. So working for the federal government was frustrating for me in lots of ways. So a lot of the things that are talked about being underfunded there being a lack of appreciation for your work in this large institution. But the benefit of this large institution that is, you know, may not get back. It's institutional, not right. So to disregard the work and the sacrifice and the sheer brilliance that lives in those buildings, those people, I just had a problem and I couldn't understand. I mean, you would. We would not discount to the knowledge the ability of our armed forces in any way. So I don't understand why you discount. This is recruiters, the practitioners that had been doing this work for. So they are not. I get you don't agree with it in the way in which to use the information in them to do so. There could be a way to use that. And I think when people mess up, when institutions mess up, they're yours. Right. So the city stays. Failures are all about. And it's not. And it is a government institution. And so as a leader, I think you have. Some responsibility to acknowledge and then fix it again, acknowledging it. Which is why we often talk about how business leaders need to be, you know, in politics. Right, because we have now the problems. We fix it and we strive to make things better. All right. That's what we want our politicians to do. So when you're given that opportunity, then you do. And you leave and you expect that your leader has your back when you mess up. And helps you fix it and grow forward to that, it doesn't undermine all of your previous. And I don't know that that piece of leadership.

    [00:22:17] So can you guys can either one of you guys or maybe both you guys speculate what's going on? What why? Why is there this? Disconnect, is it is it the individual?

    [00:22:30] Well, I think Christine makes a huge point, right? And I haven't heard anyone say it's Christine. The CDC is our organization. The president is our president. We've talked a lot about how we have to take leadership at the individual level, the family level, the business level, regardless of if our government is leading or not. It's incumbent on all of us in the face of disease to do that. That's just a fact. We're not used to that. We're used to maybe it's a nanny state, whatever it is we're used to in some instances, the government taking care of lots of things. And I think we've also become kind of dispossessed of what the government is. So as much as the CDC as our org. I think we're also learning the police departments are artwork's, too, and they should do what the citizens want. We talked about skop citizen on patrol. You know, CDC, our citizens also that are serving us. So if they're failing, it's our fault ultimately. I think that's an awesome point. What's happening there is a long history of presidents second guessing their kind of experts. Right. There's a long history of of Abraham Lincoln taking over some of the war plans during the Civil War because he thought his generals weren't aggressive enough. There's a long history of Winston Churchill being deferential to his leaders, but ultimately pushing him when he had to. This president has both been quoted as saying, I know more about Iraq than the generals do. And then I think I have a really great head for science. I understand this stuff. People say I could have been a doctor. And today he announced the disease is going away in faith in the completely flying in the face of every single piece of evidence. So we're just not used to having such a very, very different person in the White House than we've had through every single presidency. I can think of where the president is just abjectly wrong, abjectly obstinate, constantly randomizing with his tweets and his comments on every topic, particularly on this one. So when I say we're not used to it, was that matter. It means if you're running the CDC or you're running any any part of the US government, you don't have a playbook on what to do when your ultimate boss, who can not only fire you, but worse, is countermanding disregarding everything you're saying. So that's just got to be profoundly hard. And you need to find leaders who can step up and try to fight against that. Every person who's tried to do that in this administration has been fired and embarrassed on the way out. So I don't actually know how you can be a hero for more than a day in this administration because you're gone as soon as you try to be. We've noticed that Foushee has not been at any of the public health briefings lately. A friend of his says that's because he only wants to speak the truth and doesn't want to be there when lies are being said. Who knows? But we also know and Fouchier said so himself. He wants to be part of this conversation. He wants to help lead the Saudis train for his whole life. I think those of us who have any insight into the man think he's highly competent. And so he has to measure politically how he behaves, what he does so that he doesn't get kicked out of the game. You know, he's in there, like many leaders, trying to modify, moderate and lead a president who is completely resistant to it. So this is this is a brand new puzzle and one that effectively we're failing at. And look, this is what our governments designed for. The government is designed in this instance for a very powerful executive. Now, he has extraordinary authority. He's using it, but by omission. He's using it by not doing anything, by handing the leadership down to the states. And then, by the way, today. Today we're announcing governors handed down to the mayors. Right. So I think people are doing this as if they're waving the flag and promoting federalism. You know, the president saying all it's federalist system. I'm going to give it to the states now. No governors saying I'll give it to the mayors. I don't think that's how this is supposed to work. That's to me, that's a. That's throwing away your responsibilities. Sorry, Tom. No problem.

    [00:26:30] Did you ever imagine, Christine, that. Epidemiology would play such a big role in this historic moment. How much does this surprise you or did you think one day this is coming?

    [00:26:43] No, I didn't see this coming. I thought that I would spend the rest of my life. Explain to people what epidemiology is right. So it gets up. So what is that again? And so the fact that I will never, ever have to tell anyone what an epidemiologist does again is so I am shocked and saddened that we had to learn about it in this way. But public health is one of those things where you don't know about it until something goes wrong. Right. And so it has always been my concern that we'll keep defunding and defunding because we don't understand how it works. And then by the time we realize woofs pushed it too far. It's because we are in the middle of a public health emergency. Now, did I think that the public health emergency would be this pandemic? Did I think that the US's response would be what it is that the lives lost in this country would be what it is?

    [00:27:44] Not at all.

    [00:27:45] Yeah, there is a long history of politics, both showing its best face during disease outbreaks and its worst face. There's a number of wars that paused so children could get immunized. But, of course, the history of HIV and political response is, you know, horrendous, horrendous through our country, obviously. Also, throughout other infected nations, I've worked with a number of leaders of states who are in denial about HIV. And I've seen diplomats get in shouting matches with South Africa diplomats, swasey diplomats, Vatican diplomats about how they could deny what's going on with HIV. So politics and disease often are pretty ugly bedfellows. And we're I mean, look, would this be would we see a very different response from Trump if this was the first year of his presidency and he wasn't so laser focused on getting reelected in so short sighted? Maybe maybe then he would say, look, I got a couple of years to work it out, but this election is looming and it's it's clearly panicking him and he doesn't do well, period. He certainly doesn't do well under panic. So politics and disease can be very, very dangerous. And look, let's just remember, oh, three weeks ago, we were talking about how we're going to see a lot of second guessing. So three weeks ago or whatever it was, we came out of our quarantine, depending where you were. We we we saw the economy come back. We had better economic unemployment numbers for non African-Americans two weeks ago. And I saw a lot of Wall Street people say, I can't believe we locked down. This was such a fiasco, such a Schrade, so unnecessary. This is silly. It's just a bad flu. And they were very happy to get back. The market showed that optimism. We'll look at where we are today and we should probably touch on where we are today at some point, Tom. All the news today on the disease is bad. Even where I'm sitting in Wyoming, their caseload is going up. So it's it's going up now in 23 states. It was 21 yesterday, 20 a few days before that. We may not get that second big, huge spike. We should probably ask Christine about this, but I would love to have that conversation, too.

    [00:29:56] Yeah. Well, let's do it.

    [00:29:58] I mean, it's some you know, you taught me this Arpey. And, you know, it's powerful to hear you discuss it, Christine, because I probably fall into the camp of, like, suspicion of too big a government. Right. That's just been who I've been historically and over time, like anything else. The truth is in the nuance and that there's always, you know, there's layers to these things. These things are complicated. And I think more than anything else, I have a stronger appreciation for expertize than I did before. And I'm not going to say that I was like on the loony fringe of this way of thinking. But, you know, it it made me wonder. And as a business person myself, you know, when I when you feel the crust form in a business, it's just a matter of time. Right. So I'm trained that way to be constantly wondering, like, keep it fresh, keep it fresh, keep it fresh. But here we are. And everything I've learned over the last several months, I mean, we keep using the analogy that member the pool in the Ozarks where they showed all those people in the pool and half the country got so pissed at them for being so close to each other while I see that down the street. Now, you know, I'm seeing this kind of behavior everywhere. And so mathematically, I think, okay, the numbers are going to go back up like it did. And unless somehow, like, the sun is shining more brightly than it used to and the movie lights killing it in crazy ways, I don't know how it's not possible that we're gonna have big growth. To what place? I don't know. But how do you react to that? What Arpey said, which is the trends are now moving in the direction. We don't want them to move in.

    [00:31:28] But we're doing all of the things that we know not to do. And so it is and I think some of this is just our very American ability to say that that rule doesn't apply to me. Right. So, you know, it was still a very. We are centered on the individual right. And so it does it will have a get together and it's family members. So we know we're not supposed to have to. But they're my family. I want to see. Right. So that doesn't count. And so we have all of these exceptions to rules in our head that we're applied to this situation. And it is. And then, you know, even my parents or my parents are seven. The seven. And y'all help take care of my one hundred five. Your grandmother. So early on, we were very diligent. And my mother was talking about going to the gym. And I was like, why are you going to do. Wow. And she's like, well, there. Wow. And so it because everyone around you, your trainer is texting you. Well, I've got an appointment open if you want to come back once things open. We feel like we're free and my rights are restored. Let me celebrate by going and having a beer with some of my friends right in this place where there are lots of other people doing the same thing. So we're so we're doing the things that we know we're not supposed to. Because it's hard to still be that person. It is hard to still be that pastor that says, OK, let's face it, we can reopen. But because of my congregation and then being seniors, I think it's best that we stay closed. And it gets harder and harder to do that. So we're going to see numbers roll as we know. Yeah.

    [00:33:25] Well, I think you put that very well it because I think it's I think for a lot of us as Americans, we don't know that we're unique in the world with that sense of individualism. I also think we've been pretty good historically at, oh, here comes the ozone. Well, that's going away. Here comes this next one. Here comes the Russians. Here comes the nukes. Here comes the financial crisis. And, you know, three months later, we're good again, you know, and I think people are doing that now, like, oh, OK, that was a problem. But that was a problem. That was before.

    [00:33:56] Well, the other thing is, I think, though, that with Koban in particular, it's been easy to discount because it has affected more heavily populations that we don't. Right. Yes. I think the elderly. So the fact that is running rampant in nursing homes, in institutions, places where we've put people over there. Yeah. Means that we don't have to deal with it. We don't see it as Pozzuoli and see is OK. You're old. You are probably going to pass anyway and don't see the value that that our seniors bring to our villages and the communities of color, because as a person of color, it felt as if, you know, if there was already some resistance to wearing a mask and to being, you know, quarantined herself confined to your home, that the moment that it was, you know, OK, well, was primarily killed in old people and people of color. I'm good. I need to get a haircut.

    [00:34:57] Yeah.

    [00:34:59] We are a part of what's 100 percent. It's it's killing people that are hidden away. Prisons, old folks, homes, all these things we're not seeing with who they are, where the dying is. We haven't had the famous people dying yet or at all. Hopefully you won't. But the thing, Thomas, just reflecting what you're thinking about American optimism. You know, we've had 75 years since the end of World War Two where American optimism was absolutely the right bet. Every time every time we came ripping out of the 08 crisis faster than anybody else, we won the Cold War. You know, you name it. We have not even of the Iraq war, which is a total fiasco, probably cost us a trillion dollars. And the numbers of people killed overseas, non Americans, is in the hundreds of millions, like the ultimate cost of the American invasion of Iraq, the creation of all the devastation there. There was a lot of American soldiers dead, but we still didn't feel that impact here was felt in other places. Is this the first time? Well, look, let's be honest. 300000 people might die by October one from this disease in America. That's that's not an unreasonable expectation where this disease goes. And that's not really counting in what happens when flu hits and school starts. That's that's a constant trend line of six 700 dead per day till the end of the end of September. Right. Three thousand at that point. Are we going to say Holy Moses like we we are now our city five year win streaks over. Probably not 3000 dead. I think we're going to again, there are largely hidden away. And I think we're just going to just a rough ride through it. So I don't know. I think there's very reasonable people, you know, Larry, largely business people who have large debt based businesses right now who would sit in this conversation and say, look, let's be honest, 3000 people, a lot of them were old anyway. It's OK. We can't take the other negative impact of shutting down our economy. So I'm not sure if we're even realizing what a loss this is. I'm not sure we're realizing how negative this is. 3000 people actually, you know, what's that statistic? One person's a tragedy. A million is a statistic. You know, that's that's where we are right now. The economic toll is going to be extremely hard. Another study today said it will be 16 trillion dollar economic toll versus a 10 trillion dollar economic toll from 08, meaning real real fortunes lost, real businesses destroyed. But are we going to look at this at the end and believes we lost believe this was an American example where America didn't come out on top? I don't know that we will like meaning. Will we get the lesson from this or not? And I'll last sentence. I have already seen a reduction in enthusiasm from a variety of governments that I work with in business as we work with about spending some money to implement a broad risk awareness, broad warning awareness systems. That was really hot. A few weeks ago now they're kind of over it and they want to get back to opening the cafeteria in their building. So I don't know what I don't know if this should be the big wakeup call that we need more money in government. We need to not be anti expertize, et cetera, or if we're just completely blind to this kind of thing. And this is sort of the story of the end of empire, just completely ignoring being completely blind to Kostic realities that you create.

    [00:38:16] Can we also tie that? So, you know, you talked about people of color. And for me, I you know, the relationship between George Floyd and Koven is like this.

    [00:38:28] And how how can I define that scientifically? I don't think I can. But I think other people sort of understand generally when I came back from my trip, so I'd done this trip where I went to the northern tip and the menu of the Mississippi, drove up there, drove all the way down the Mississippi, drove all the way back through the south. And I was interviewing people along the way. And when I came home, I had this overwhelming sense of when I get back home, the minute I open my mouth, people aren't gonna understand what I'm saying, because what I saw was, you know, it was hopeful and beautiful in parts, but it was sad and depressing in many ways. And the sense I had was and I'm going it this is too strong a word, but I think a revolution's coming. That's what I felt. I thought this cannot stand. I had no idea that George Floyd was about to happen. I didn't know the revolution was going to come in the form of race, but it did.

    [00:39:16] And so, you know, part of what we're talking about is sort of operational ideas and outcomes. But I think part of what we're talking about is like the love of each other, you know? And so when you outlined, you know, old folks, homes are surrounded by four walls and an hour marked by age. Race doesn't have those elements. I mean, it has geographic elements and other elements. But how do we deal with that? Like, how to how do we think about what you just said?

    [00:39:46] Well, I mean, I think race is the local movement, right? So it is now over here. And that's the thing that I don't have to do. Yeah. Is that. Those folks are also there because they are late, because they have not taken advantage of all that America needs. And as opposed to thinking that we are as a part of America as anyone and that racism is as part of anything. And so it's been really interesting on black America because for us, George Floyd a. Aubrey, Brianna Taylor. They are among the list of names that are too long for us to remember. And so the sadness, the hurt for me, the inability to watch. I mean, actor Mom Aubrey, a having grown up in the South. They were hunting. Wardens were hunting. Looks like you are in a truck with your rifle. And what they don't like to watch. And again, stop. Right. I'm sorry, what did you say? Again, what I that there was not what this great outpouring of watching for a fellow human being being hunted. And it was still well, why was he Baer right and what was he doing and what was all the conversations that you only have when it is someone who is black and even Brianna Tyler that some how? Because she was a black woman and she should have been expecting the police to storm in her house at any given moment until her. Right. It is. So I am hopeful that real sustained change will come. But I am hesitantly hopeful because a lot of it's you know, you can't you can become lipservice. And I have corporations have been busy posting on social media. Black Lives Matter. We stand with you. And then their employees are blown up, they say, but my black life has not mattered at work. Right. And what does your leadership team look like and why? It so it is everyone is being so defensive in these moments that I wonder if we're still having the difficult conversations that will really spur change. Right. And long term change, not just for today, not just for that one donation, but OK, if you're going to make a donation. Is that commitment over the next 10, 20 years? Right. Not just what your leadership team looks like today or the one person who's black that you call to hurry up and put on your board. Right. What is the plan going forward so that you look up and there might be two or three, you know, five or six years from now. And that's your leadership team. Looks like your customer.

    [00:43:11] Is that so?

    [00:43:13] If I have a hope and people have heard me say this before, but you haven't Till. You know, covered was a prelude to an opportunity. That's my hope. OK. And I know I don't wish ill health on anybody. And there's so much they come gets in the way of what I'm saying, and I appreciate that. But I can speak personally and say, like, this has been such a profound moment in my life and so on, so many levels, which has put me in a position to feel more useful to others. OK, that's just how I feel. I'm just speaking as one individual, and I know I'm not alone because I talk to people about this thing. But my fear. Is that I'm gonna end up like most of us. This is cynical, which is too busy.

    [00:43:58] And not having taken an opportunity to do something, to not let that, because you're right, you corrected me in a certain way and you said it's just like an old folks home, old folks home. It is just like an old folks home. I know you're right. The challenge I have is like. How can I do something tomorrow, today, to not let that opportunity just go away? And I've been thinking a lot about it and having conversations about it, and I know others have as well. And I. You're not I can't expect you to give me, like, the Eureka right now. But I am curious how you would react to what I'm saying. And I do think that I don't I don't think I'm unique in my hope that. Come on, you know, from the time I was do I watch Roots on TV in 1970, whatever, I don't I wish I were part of something that was going further than it has.

    [00:44:57] Well, there've been a couple of suggestions that I have made when people have wanted to have these conversations. So one is what? What is your self reflection shown? Right. And am I willing to hear others viewpoints when it makes me uncomfortable? And so do I want to talk about race. Because I want to say these are my experiences with African-Americans. Am I willing to hear how African-Americans experience me? And that is difficult and that requires sitting and hearing maybe some things that are going to be difficult, right. But if that's how people have been experiencing you, then it already is. All right. Does it become any worse? Because you now know, it gives you an opportunity to grow and to move forward so that when one is just being very self reflective, I think seeking learning in the same way that we do sports, that we do cozied, that we do anything else. And so in particular, because I know in organizations with men, when you're in college football and you want to learn about a team, you look at information from different sources. Right. You don't expect to pick up the phone and call the coach and ask about the difference. Right. You read it from those who are clients. You hear information and seek information from experts or people who aren't fans who are fans of your particular team. But all you know, you want a 360 view. Right. So I think doing that research and work with the easiest thing is picking something that is easy for you to do. There are lots of things that we all have a lack of dominion over. Right. Decisions that we make every day. So it's stopping to say, OK, now that I'm thinking about things differently, now that I'm aware of maybe some blind spots. I've had. What decisions can I make? Different. Right. And. So people talk about what their companies and I'm like, OK. So if you really believe that your company is as equitable as you say it is, then check. Just check. Right. It is pay equity, right? Have somebody go and look and see if it is great. Then there's something else you probably need to look at. But let's just start looking and making sure instead of becoming so like I've been doing the right thing. All of us have room to improve. Right. That that's what business is. That's the other part. Right. So you're never satisfied with twenty five percent market share. You want to grow with a third in the, you know, five years, 10 years. So we set long term goals around that. So with the things that I can control, how do I set long term goals in this area as well? And where do I need to keep a record of them so that I'm held to them? Because you do get beat and you are wanting something else. But in this moment, if people are fundamentally dedicated to making a difference on this, then making some long term commitments and decisions now and again business and especially private companies. People put their cousin's husband on the board, right? All day. Right. You put someone else on the board because they bring a different perspective and have different experiences. Right. And so your cousin's husband in some ways is on there because of the title. But his title does not equal his qualification. Right. So in this instance, it may not. But just to think about things different and that whole conversation about, you know, what it requires for folks of color to be considered qualified. It's thing the suppositions in the fact that I even have to have that conversation is offensive. Right. Because no one else questions whether the cousin's husband is qualified. But I have to be justified in that. If you know someone who very privileged, very fortunate to have a doctorate from Harvard. Right. But that ends up being why people can validate my presence in the room. Yeah, right. Well, Christine here got to be smart. She got a doctorate. If I were a white male, there'd be no need to qualify. It would simply be. This is Christine.

    [00:49:44] So there's there's awareness. So I tell you that I just a minimum rapture by this, I'm just thinking about Christine. You're talking about these sort of waves of awareness. Right. So we've talked earlier about how Korona made us more aware that our government failed us, that it's our CDC, that it's our presidency. We're seeing, you know, efforts to take over our police departments, change them in a way that I think a lot of us kind of are waking up to realizing they should be changed. So that's an awareness thing. George Floyd, awareness. And, you know, this is sort of the point I want to get to is I want to be careful how I say this, because it's so it's such a difficult uncomfort conversation.

    [00:50:26] But would it be fair to say that one of the most powerful things about the slow motion, horrendous murder of George Floyd was it made white people more aware of what African-Americans have been well aware of for a long time? Right. Like we saw that it was in arguably a slow, slow motion murder in a lot of white Americans. Maybe now are more aware of this. And so if you look at the protests there, they're very much multiracial. They're very much multi age. And so, again, you have this awareness. And so, you know, some of these concrete changes, we're talking about police departments taking down statues, more board seats for for broader representation. Those are all positive things. And but I I really like your your comment about how we have to sort of check ourselves and figure out what it is we're doing. I just wonder. I still feel like it. Does it have to. What. So that those are boards. Those are businesses. Those are. But for the vast majority of Americans who don't run businesses don't sit on boards. Is there any you know, this is not put you on the spot. I'm not sure there's an answer. But how does that part of America become more aware of this reality in which we've been this persistent, durable reality this country's been in for 400 years and begin to make changes at a personal level? And I wonder if one of the answers is hard conversations, uncomfortable conversations.

    [00:51:53] I don't know. But that feels like we have some institutional ideas that matter. We feel like I feel like we are business ideas that matter. I feel like we have government is a matter of labor waking up. We think we have an election coming up or perhaps more people get out and vote and realize they have to have their own president in power. But I don't. Is there any set of steps that individuals can take to to take the scales, authorize and be more aware of what's going on in this country?

    [00:52:20] So I think it is, again, always stopping and that self reflection. Right. But it is also the things that you have influence over. So we all make decisions every day. And if it is whose house I let my children go play? If it is speaking up when I'm in the restaurant or in a store and I see something happen, that isn't quite right. We also we all have decisions that we make every day. And so, ladies, how am I going to decide differently based on this new respect? And based on this awareness that I maybe have been just walking off from some things before, when my children say something, when my sibling says something. Right. When I recommend someone. Right. So if I recommend one of my coworkers for promotion. Right. Or I comment on my boss. Am I being equitable in those cockpits? Am I OK? We all make lots of what we think to be small decisions that impact others every day. And so how do we use this knowledge to do that? Do I put on a mask for a Kovik so that I don't impact the community of color the time I make it? So even if I don't believe that, I really should have to. And if it when it's out, it is a hot. It is hard to wear a mask, right? But if I'm willing to demonstrate, if I'm willing to march, can I know that cold it impacts communities of color at a greater rate. Am I willing to put on a mask to protect the. Right. So they did lots of decisions that we can all make. It's just stopping to think about how we do it being more thoughtful and not running from the uncomfortable conversations.

    [00:54:16] You know, I'm going to add one thought to that. And thanks for responding, I mean, it's not your responsibility.

    [00:54:24] Versus Till. Thank you for making that point, Tom, I don't. It's not your job nor your son's body. I'm sorry to put you on the spot, but I, I, I learned a lot. Thank you.

    [00:54:35] Martha Glyphosate would disagree with me right now. I am not so great spokesperson.

    [00:54:43] I'm just glad that you are letting me share my life. And I'm comfortable about when I don't feel like talking about stuff. I'm like, look, I'm tired.

    [00:54:56] Well, so my my strategy at the moment, this is my personal strategy one. You brought it up, which is, you know, and we interview got it last week named Neil Phillips, who talked about that. Like, you got to get comfortable in the uncomfortable period. And if it's not uncomfortable, you're probably wasting your time a little bit. So just go in there and do best. Well, the my takeaway is.

    [00:55:17] Priority. That the priority of.

    [00:55:23] You know, like many of us, I've seen good and bad in my life. I've seen tragedy and I've seen beauty sometimes very close to each other. I do know you're not going to take it with you. You're not. You're not taken with you, man. You're going. You're going out in a box like everybody else. And you're gonna love the people around you or you're not. No, I don't practice that every day. I get greedy. I do. I get impatient. I get selfish. I do lots of things. But I want to live in a culture that achieves something more than. Zeros and ones. And money. Not against it, I'm not against it, but it's like, let's win in another way, like let's have let's prioritize something. And so does that mean, like, you know, I'm not going to get into the debates over some of the miscellaneous. Yeah, that's what it means.

    [00:56:10] Well, I have to say, though, because it's kind of like dating. Right. So it's all good. And butterflies tolerate the fact. Right. But I think the hard part is how do I love when you're showing back to me the ugly parts of myself?

    [00:56:29] Yeah, well, that's a powerful point.

    [00:56:31] You know, I did been wrong. I will continue to be wrong. You know, initially I was like, well, maybe we can get cold under control. Didn't make that. You know, I was hopeful and optimistic and then. No. So I did wrong. I hope that some beautiful, wonderful things grow out of all of this. I don't know what our new normal is going to look like in both addressing racism and cohered, but I am hopeful for both. And that goes back to that American optimism, which you talked about, that we will see.

    [00:57:11] I don't know. But if you have, tell me the ending it is would have been the last three months. OK, I'll go do it right now. So, Christine, thank you for your time and also thank you. Thank you for your generosity on sort of a range of conversation. I love your story.

    Copyright TNP 2020

    we sometimes receive a small commission for purchases made when visiting some links provided in our show notes and we wanted you to know.

    58 min
  • rp daily: read. write. lead.
    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify Subscribe: episode updates read. write. lead. tom and rp spent this Juneteenth in discussion with alyesha wise, who is a spoken word poet, artist, and speaker from camden, new jersey. alyesha currently resides in los angeles where she is the co-founder of Spoken Literature Art Movement—an organization providing poetry education and extensive programming for poets, and is a teaching artist for Street Poets—a non-profit mostly serving juvenile injustice-involved youth. to learn more about alyesha wise: https://www.alyeshawise.com/bio.html to check out alyesha's poetry: https://www.alyeshawise.com/poetry tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo. rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser. listen to this episode on apple podcasts subscribe to our youtube channel follow us on facebook follow us on instagram transcript [00:00:16] So hi, everybody. It's Friday. It is June the 19th. It is. [00:00:23] Quite popular at the moment, and I hope for the future known as Juneteenth, which is in a word or term, I don't think that many Americans would have used. Two weeks ago and now it seems to be on the lips of everybody, which is pretty cool. And I'm going to describe it in a minute. Welcome, Alisha and Arpey. [00:00:48] Hi, guys. And Lisa, I'm going to give you a more formal introduction in a moment, but just by way of background. So Juneteenth. It's also known as Freedom Day or at Emancipation Day. It's from June 19th, 1865, when Texas freed the last slaves who are still being held. Two and a half years after the Emancipation Proclamation. [00:01:07] So this was well after the time that legally they had been freed, but practically they had not. Lincoln was assassinated two months before this date. And so that's what it's meant to both remember. And then I you know, what I've been told by many people is also to celebrate. So it's a day of remembrance and a day of celebration. [00:01:34] One of the things you guys have heard us talk about over the months and an Aleesha, this show was primarily started as a response to Kofod because of our PE's expertize in that specific field. But then more generally in government, in business and in other places, um, and it's evolved over time. But one of the things that Arpey has talked a lot about is that statistics don't tell very good stories, narratives do, and that people the imprints on their souls tend to come from. [00:02:04] The narratives, you know, the narratives and you know my own sense of poetry, which is rare. You know, I don't like spend a lot of my days in poetry. I guess you could say that there's poetry and music and poetry and other things, and I spend more time in those places. But as I've gotten older, I've come to have this profound respect for poetry as like an emotional storytelling efficiency that's very powerful. And I think that you're someone who's particularly powerful in that realm. I want to mention one other thing, which is that Arpey and I are two white men who have our own perspectives. I think we hope to be open and hope to be. Part of solutions. But we also, I think, recognize our limitations and that. [00:02:54] You know, I think you can help us individually to the extent you're open to that and others who are watching, so I just want to recognize that as we kind of dove in here. I'm so Alisha's a poet who I came to know through a friend of mine, Mick Ebeling, actually connected me with you. And then she spoke at the Nantucket Project, performed at the Nantucket Project, and has performed in a variety of ways with a sense.
    1 hr
  • rp daily: we need to talk
    Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify Subscribe: episode updates we need to talk. tom scott, co-founder of the nantucket project in conversation with rp eddy, CEO of Ergo, who is on a cross country road trip stopover at Mt. Rushmore. tom details plans to travel the length of the Mississippi in service of gathering people in this country for conversation. he plans on driving from Itasca to New Orleans, with nine stops in between. furthermore, they take a look at the controversial release of the john bolton book, various national security advisors, the white house, classification, and more. tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration's pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo. rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser. listen to this episode on apple podcasts subscribe to our youtube channel follow us on facebook follow us on instagram transcript [00:00:24] I can I know where you are. But if you look over RPs left shoulder, which is to your right. You look perfect. Wow, look at how that focus is in, you know, RP. I was there. I want to tell a story about it, but I want you to talk about it first. Better than I would have guessed. Like, I really loved it there. Tell me tell me what you. What do you think? [00:00:50] Well, yeah, definitely, you know, I drove I drove right through this area in 1993 with my best buddy on our kind of in college. Let's Travel Across America trip. And we drove right by here and didn't stop. And I think we thought it was probably a, you know, a big tourist attraction. And I think we had read some stuff about Wounded Knee and we decide not to stop and which is kind of crazy to me, drive all in all the way across America, not spend nearly five minutes going up the road and seeing this. It's amazing. It's beautiful. It's stunning. I wish it didn't have the negative history that it has. But I guess a lot of things in America do. [00:01:39] But it's a it's stunning. It's amazing. And it's it's a pretty neat story. And it's gorgeous to look at. [00:01:46] Yeah. Yeah. And I think, you know, it's hard to tell from images, but the size is just stunning. Yeah. [00:01:54] We're we're staying at a hotel that's six miles away. And we have this great profile of George Washington from the hotel. And you can see this from a long way away. That's part of why they they pick this mountain. It's also part of why why this was Holy Mountain to the Native Americans. It's very prominent, as you can tell from the visit you have there. It's the highest mark around. [00:02:15] Yeah. So I was there 17 years ago, and the reason I know it was 17 years ago is because my son was one years old. He was one year old. You know, we had one child at the time and the same thing I was thinking, yeah, you know, whatever, Mount Rushmore. No big deal. We can skip it. And we said, now let's do it. And we came in and I just remember right away thinking, oh, I'm so happy. I came here for a whole variety of reasons. I remember the day we were there. So it's very quiet around there. Does it feel quiet today? [00:02:48] Yeah, it's quiet and it's it's probably pretty low, you know, low number of tourists because of the Corona. It's but it's also just a big, gorgeous area. I mean, you know, so as great as the view is behind me, the view in front of me is looking across the Black Hills of South Dakota. You know, we spent all day, all day yesterday driving across South Dakota. So talk about just humongous flat plains of grain, you know, and the crops were in the end of spring. So the crops are still a foot high at max. And it was stunning. I mean, Kelly and I and the boys, three little boys,
    46 min
  • rp daily: we need to talk
    tom Scott, co-founder of the nantucket project in conversation with rp eddy, CEO of Ergo, who is on a cross country road trip stopover at Mt. Rushmore. tom details plans to travel the length of the Mississippi in service of gathering people in this country for conversation. he plans on driving from Itasca to New Orleans, with nine stops in between. furthermore, they take a look at the controversial release of the john bolton book, various national security advisors, the white house, classification, and more.

    tom scott is chairman & co-founder of the nantucket project. rp eddy was the architect of the Clinton administration’s pandemic response framework and the United Nations response to the global AIDS epidemic & is CEO of global intelligence firm Ergo.

    rp is co-author of the best-selling award-winning book Warnings: Finding Cassandras to Stop Catastrophes with Richard A. Clarke, Former National Security Council counterterrorism adviser.
    46 min

About the nantucket project

From the publisher's feed

transform your life through meaningful conversation