The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - The Sinews of Sudan's Latest War by Tim Liptrot
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The Sinews of Sudan's Latest War, published by Tim Liptrot on August 5, 2023 on LessWrong.
    I welcome feedback on this piece! It's the first of a series on the subject and I want to gauge interest in it from the blogging world. I will probably improve it to subsequently move it to the policy community. If people really like it I could transition it to a subscription or tipped model.
    Section One: The Sinews of War
    "There is an opinion in some quarters to send Marcus Antonius to govern Gaul (.) What else is that but supplying an enemy with (...) all the _ sinews of war, money in abundance _ (.) Will you furnish a wicked and desperate citizen with an army of Gauls and Germans, with money, and infantry, and cavalry, and all sorts of resources?" - Cicero
    The war in Sudan has now raged for 4 months. On April 15th, the two armies that had been jointly ruling Sudan turned on one another. The Rapid Support Forces (RSF), a paramilitary army mounted a series of raids on the Sudan Armed Forces (SAF) air bases, headquarters and seats of government. Since then, the two sides have been locked in total war, which has devastated Sudan's capital, led to the return of ethnic massacres in Darfur, and threatens to create yet another failed state in the Horn of Africa.
    Figure 1: Khartoum on Fire in June. Photo is taken from above the meeting of the White and Blue Niles, looking out at downtown Khartoum which contains the presidential palace, several ministries and the SAF headquarters.
    This is the first of a series of reports surveying the sources of funding available to the armed groups of Sudan. Who controls them? How much money can they produce? Is this revenue controlled by senior leadership, or the personal loot of local commanders? Along the way, readers will gain a glimpse into the strange world of armed group finance. Most of the upcoming releases will be pitched for the Sudan-focused policy community, who are already quite interested in Sudan. This post gives a context to the deep dives that should be minimally accessible to a general audience. For an explanation of why the war began, see this other post.
    Those interested in a straight military account or general commentary are already well served. While the 2023 Sudan conflict has not enjoyed the deep OSINT attention lavished on the Ukraine conflict, Sudan is blessed with talented analysts following the military and political developments. SeeDaniel Van's work,Ayin Network and Beam Reports. Sudan Transparency and Policy Tracker is another organization doing excellent public work on the political economy of the war.
    Section Two: Why should we care about money?
    "When you see you are about to lack money, and therefore your Army has to be dissolved in any case(...) one ought always to fight, even at your disadvantage" - Machiavelli, The Art of War
    Prior to the conflict, the RSF and SAF jointly ruled Sudan. The SAF is a true national army, with an airforce and armored divisions equipped for set-piece battles, and its base in Sudan's wealthier center along the Nile. The RSF is a paramilitary organization with its social base in North Darfur, one of Sudan's least developed regions. Prior to the war, the RSF realized that fighting in Sudan's rural periphery would advantage the SAF who have total air dominance. Instead they stationed tens of thousands of fighters in Sudan's capital, the metropolis Khartoum. When fighting began with a series of coordinated RSF attacks, RSF and SAF positions were entwined all across the capital. Over the past few months the RSF has won several early victories in Khartoum and in Darfur, forcing the SAF presence in the capital to several isolated fortresses and their air power.
    Despite major gains for the RSF, neither side has eliminated their opponent's ability to fight. The RSF, once derided as a militia of...
    20 min
  • EA - Hiring Retrospective: ERA Fellowship 2023 by Oscar Delaney
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Hiring Retrospective: ERA Fellowship 2023, published by Oscar Delaney on August 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Summary
    We hired 31 people for our current Summer Research Fellowship, out of 631 applications
    The applications were of impressive quality, so we hired more people than expected
    We think we made several mistakes, and should:
    Communicate more clearly what level of seniority/experience we want in applicants
    Have a slightly shorter initial application, but be upfront that it is a long form
    Assign one person to evaluate all applicants for one particular question, rather than marking all questions on one application together
    Hiring round processes
    The Existential Risk Alliance (ERA) is a non-profit project equipping young researchers with the skills and knowledge needed to tackle existential risks. We achieve this by running a Summer Research Fellowship program where participants do an independent research project, supported by an ERA research manager, and an external subject-matter expert mentor.
    Promotion and Outreach
    We tried quite hard to promote the Fellowship. Personal connections and various EA community sources were the most common referral source for applications:
    Initial application
    Our initial application form consisted of submitting a CV (which we put minimal weight on) and answering various open-ended questions. Some questions on motivation, reasoning ability, and previous experience were the same across all cause areas, and we also asked some cause area-specific subject matter questions. Our application form was open for 22 days, and we received a total of 631 applications from 556 unique applicants (some people applied to multiple cause areas). There was significant variation in the number of applications in each cause area: AI Gov = 167, AI Tech = 127, Climate = 100, Biosecurity = 96, Misc & Meta = 86, Nuclear = 51.
    People tended to apply late in the application period, with more than half of applications arriving within three days of the deadline.
    The majority of applicants were male:
    And the UK and US were by far the most common countries of residence for applicants:
    Interviews
    After assessing the written applications, we invited 80 applicants (13%) for an interview as the second part of the recruitment process. Interviews were conducted by the research manager of the cause area the person was applying to, and lasted around thirty minutes. We used structured interviews, where each cause area had a standard list of questions that all interviewees were asked, to try to maximize comparability between applicants and improve fairness. Interview questions sought to gauge people's cause-area-specific knowledge, and ability to reason clearly responding to unseen questions. Even though only the people who did best on the initial application were invited to interviews, there was some positive correlation between initial application and interview scores. If this correlation was very strong, that would be some reason not to do an interview at all and just select people based on their application.
    This was not the case: the interview changed our ordering of applicants considerably.
    Composition of the final cohort
    We had initially projected to fill approximately 20 fellowship spots, with an expected 3-4 candidates per cause area. We aimed to interview at least three times the number of candidates as the positions we planned to offer, to improve our chances of selecting optimal candidates.
    Because of the large number of excellent applications, we decided to open our fellowship to remote candidates that we couldn't host otherwise. Within cause areas, we selected candidates roughly based on a weighted average of their initial application, and interview (with a 5:3 ratio of weights for application:interview, given the application was far longer than the...
    10 min
  • EA - How can we improve Infohazard Governance in EA Biosecurity? by Nadia Montazeri
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: How can we improve Infohazard Governance in EA Biosecurity?, published by Nadia Montazeri on August 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Or: "Why EA biosecurity epistemics are whack"
    The effective altruism (EA) biosecurity community focuses on reducing the risks associated with global biological catastrophes (GCBRs). This includes preparing for pandemics, improving global surveillance, and developing technologies to mitigate the risks of engineered pathogens. While the work of this community is important, there are significant challenges to developing good epistemics, or practices for acquiring and evaluating knowledge, in this area.
    One major challenge is the issue of infohazards. Infohazards are ideas or information that, if widely disseminated, could cause harm. In the context of biosecurity, this could mean that knowledge of specific pathogens or their capabilities could be used to create bioweapons. As a result, members of the EA biosecurity community are often cautious about sharing information, particularly in online forums where it could be easily disseminated.
    The issue of infohazards is not straightforward. Even senior biosecurity professionals may have different thresholds for what they consider to be an infohazard. This lack of consensus can make it difficult for junior members to learn what is appropriate to share and discuss. Furthermore, it can be challenging for senior members to provide feedback on the appropriateness of specific information without risking further harm if that information is disseminated to a wider audience. At the moment, all EA biosecurity community-building efforts are essentially gate-kept by Open Phil, whose staff are particularly cautious about infohazards, even compared to experts in the field at the Center for Health Security. Open Phil staff time is chronically scarce, making it impossible to copy and critique their heuristics on infohazards, threat models, and big-picture biosecurity strategy from 1:1 conversations.
    Challenges for cause and intervention prioritisation
    These challenges can lead to a lack of good epistemics within the EA biosecurity community, as well as a deference culture where junior members defer to senior members without fully understanding the reasoning behind their decisions. This can result in a failure to adequately assess the risks associated with GCBRs and make well-informed decisions.
    The lack of open discourse on biosecurity risks in the EA community is particularly concerning when compared to the thriving online discourse on AI alignment, another core area of longtermism for the EA movement. While there are legitimate reasons for being cautious about sharing information related to biosecurity, this caution may lead to a lack of knowledge sharing and limited opportunities for junior members of the community to learn from experienced members.
    In the words of a biosecurity researcher who commented on this draft:
    "Because of this lack of this discussion, it seems that some junior biosecurity EAs fixate on the "gospel of EA biosecurity interventions" - the small number of ideas seen as approved, good, and safe to think about. These ideas seem to take up most of the mind space for many junior folks thinking about what to do in biosecurity. I've been asked "So, you're working in biosecurity, are you going to do PPE or UVC?" one too many times. There are many other interesting defence-dominant interventions, and I get the sense that even some experienced folks are reluctant to explore this landscape."
    Another example is the difficulty of comparing biorisk and AI risk without engaging in potentially infohazardous concrete threat models. While both are considered core cause areas of longtermism, it is challenging to determine how to prioritise these risks without evaluating the likelihood of a catast...
    9 min
  • EA - Announcing Squiggle Hub by Ozzie Gooen
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing Squiggle Hub, published by Ozzie Gooen on August 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Overview
    Squiggle Hub is a platform for the creation and sharing of code written in Squiggle. As with Squiggle, Squiggle Hub is free and open-source.
    As a refresher, Squiggle is a simple programming language for probabilistic estimation that runs on Javascript. It begins with the syntax of Guesstimate, but generally adds a lot more functionality. See its launch post here for more information, or the website for the full documentation.
    Squiggle Hub is a lot like a more powerful, but less visual, version of Guesstimate. We hope that it will eventually be much more valuable than Guesstimate is now.
    If you can use Guesstimate, you can basically use Squiggle. If you already use Guesstimate, try using the same syntax in Squiggle. It should mostly work.
    All models on Squiggle Hub are public. We've produced several small ones so far, and a few friends have written some as well. We're looking forward to seeing what others make!
    Looking for Squiggle examples? We've organized some in the docs. The Squiggle EA Forum Tag also has an updating list.
    Key Links
    Squiggle Hub
    Squiggle Discord
    The Squiggle Language Homepage
    Squiggle Newsletter (Part of the QURI Newsletter)
    Functionality
    Squiggle (the language)
    Write functions that accept and return probability distributions. Squiggle generates automatic plots for these.
    You can provide explicit ranges for functions. This helps with the visualization, and ensures they won't be called outside that range. Like, appleStockPrice(t:[2023, 2060]).
    Custom plots for distributions and functions. Scales include linear, log, and symlog (like log, but with support for negative values). Symlog scales accept a parameter constant that you can use for adjusting the scale.
    Make custom tables of any data and functions, with Table.make({data, columns}).
    Automatic conversion of Monte Carlo samples to distribution plots, using KDE. In the cases where the distribution is heavily skewed, Squiggle does this with a log transformation. The result of this is often more accurate than using histograms. Combined with custom scales, Squiggle much better supports highly skewed distributions (i.e. "5 to 5M") than Guesstimate does.
    Squiggle supports most of JSON. You can copy & paste JSON data and begin using it in Squiggle.
    Squiggle runs on Javascript. You can simply take Squiggle code and run it in your website, Observable, Obsidian, and more.[1] If you are making an application that uses probability distributions, you can use the Squiggle components directly.
    Lots of performance enhancements, library additions, and bug fixes, since Squiggle's initial release.
    All the docs and grammar are consolidated here. You can use this to feed into Claude, for some Squiggle generation and assistance.
    Squiggle Editor (The window on the left)
    With "Autorun", the output will update as you type. Turn this off if you want to run it manually.
    Adjust the number of Monte Carlo samples. It defaults to 1000, but you can change this in the settings. Also, there are a bunch of other toggles there to play with.
    A built-in Squiggle code formatter. Useful for lengthy files and for storing data.
    Function and variable autocomplete.
    Squiggle Viewer (The window on the right)
    Click the arrows to open and close visualizations.
    Select any variable in the right view to "zoom in" on it. Very handy when working on particular estimates of a file!
    On hover, there's a "show in editor" button, that finds the source code to the variable in question.
    If your Squiggle file ends with a variable, this will be shown as the "Result." You'll still be able to see all of the other defined variables, but these will be collapsed when you open the model. Useful for selecting a few key findings for display purposes.
    You can...
    10 min
  • EA - ProMED, platform which alerted the world to Covid, might collapse - can EA donors fund it? by freedomandutility
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: ProMED, platform which alerted the world to Covid, might collapse - can EA donors fund it?, published by freedomandutility on August 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    "The early warning disease network that alerted the world to the original SARS outbreak and the start of the Covid-19 pandemic appears to be in peril."
    "In February 2003, it was ProMED that alerted the world to the fact that a new disease that caused pneumonia had started to spread in China's Guangdong province. That disease became known as SARS - severe acute respiratory syndrome. In September 2012, an Egyptian doctor working in Saudi Arabia wrote to ProMED to reveal he had treated a patient who died from pneumonia triggered by a new coronavirus, a camel virus we now know as MERS - Middle East respiratory syndrome. Just before midnight on Dec. 30, 2019, a ProMED "RFI" post - request for information - was the first warning the outside world received of a fast-growing outbreak in Wuhan, China. That was the start of the Covid-19 pandemic."
    ""In its post dated July 14, the ISID revealed it had been having trouble raising the money needed to sustain ProMED. A fundraising drive that aimed for $1 million brought in $20,000. "To put it frankly, ProMED is in dire financial straits," the post said."
    This doesn't seem very expensive to sustain, and losing ProMED would be a step backwards when we're aiming for an effective global early warning system - surely a group of EA donors could save ProMED?
    You can directly donate here -/ but it might make sense to get in touch with ProMED before making large donations.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    2 min
  • EA - How my view on using games for EA has changed by mmKALLL
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: How my view on using games for EA has changed, published by mmKALLL on August 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Last year I wrote a post about the effectiveness of making a video game with the intent of inducing EA ideas naturally through gameplay. The game got released on Steam and received positive impressions, so I wanted to follow up with the results.
    Although I was originally quite optimistic about using games (and other forms of art) for EA, my current thinking has changed. First of all, the original estimates had various flaws:
    1) Combining confidence intervals also increases the uncertainty of the variable. Thus none of the calculations were actually conclusive.
    2) I underestimated the amount of effort/luck needed for marketing, and overestimated the expected number of players.
    3) Although the game received praise for its depth, in 10 follow-up interviews none of the reviewers reported having changed their behavior or thinking as a result of playing it.
    Since only around a thousand players experienced the main part of the game, having spent a whole year on it seems inefficient. Additional effort also seems unlikely to greatly improve the outcome.
    Given this I'm now less confident about whether game development can be reasonably pursued from an EA perspective. The effects don't seem tractable, it's very difficult to know what will be meaningful during development, there's loads of work that's not relevant to the intended message, and any larger influence requires a disproportionately lucky hit in the market.
    As far as I know, it also seems that the people behind/ and/ have experienced similar problems, more or less abandoning their EA+gaming projects. (Although I haven't been able to confirm the exact reasons yet.)
    That being said, I do still think the medium has lots of unexplored potential, it just seems very difficult for game developers to utilize. My guess is that people in lead design, director, and producer roles at large studios seem much more likely to be able to induce relevant insights for (a large number of) players. In comparison, spending lots of time and money for an indie game just to temporarily influence a handful of players doesn't seem like a very effective endeavor.
    Personally, I made the decision to focus more on AI alignment moving forward. It seems more immediate, more important, more tractable, has much higher marginal impact, and could also benefit from shifts in cultural norms. I'd like to recommend looking into it if you're at all interested.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    3 min
  • LW - Private notes on LW? by Raemon
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Private notes on LW?, published by Raemon on August 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Lately I've been noticing what a powerup is to read things in google docs, where I can take whatever notes I want as in-line comments without worrying about looking dumb or confusing. In changes my relationship to confusing passages, where I feel much more affordance to think through what exactly is confusing about it.
    As a general reading-habit, "copy it into google docs" is a pretty good habit. But I (and I think others on LW team although for slightly different reasons) have been thinking about building a feature directly into LW to facilitate it.
    One version of it might explicitly be "private notes" that are optimized as such.
    Another version of it might basically just take the side-comment button we already have and add a "private comments" option that lets you set the comment to "everyone", "only you", "you + author" (for giving the author feedback in a way that's more private than a comment but having more context included than a DM) [edit: also, sharing the comment with arbitrary people is a fairly obvious feature here]
    Curious what people think about this and what options they'd expect themselves to use.
    I'm maybe specifically wondering whether people expect a UI that's oriented around "arbitrary sharing" would feel good enough as a personal note-taking thing.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    2 min
  • EA - Manifund: What we're funding (weeks 2-4) by Austin
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Manifund: What we're funding (weeks 2-4), published by Austin on August 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Overall reflections
    Very happy with the volume and quality of grants we've been making
    $600k+ newly committed across 12 projects
    Regrantors have been initiating grants and coordinating on large projects
    Independent donors have committed $35k+ of their own money!
    We plan to start fundraising soon, based on this pace of distribution
    Happy to be coordinating with funders at LTFF, Lightspeed, Nonlinear and OpenPhil
    We now have a common Slack channel to share knowledge and plans
    Currently floating the idea of setting up a common app between us.
    Happy with our experimentation! Some things we've been trying:
    Equity investments, loans, dominant assurance contracts and retroactive funding
    Grantathon, office hours, feedback on Discord & site comments
    Less happy with our operations (wrt feedback and response times to applicants)
    Taking longer to support to individual grantees, or start new Manifund initiatives
    Please ping us if it's been a week and you haven't heard anything!
    Wise deactivated our account, making international payments more difficult/expensive.
    In cases where multiple regrantors may fund a project, we've observed a bit of "funding chicken"
    Grant of the month
    [$310k] Apollo Research
    This is our largest grant to date! Many of our regrantors were independently excited about Apollo; in the end, we coordinated between Tristan Hume, Evan Hubinger and Marcus Abramovitch to fund this.
    From Tristan:
    I'm very excited about Apollo based on a combination of the track record of it's founding employees and the research agenda they've articulated.
    Marius and Lee have published work that's significantly contributed to Anthropic's work on dictionary learning. I've also met both Marius and Lee and have confidence in them to do a good job with Apollo.
    Additionally, I'm very much a fan of alignment and dangerous capability evals as an area of research and think there's lots of room for more people to work on them.
    In terms of cost-effectiveness I like these research areas because they're ones I think are very tractable to approach from outside a major lab in a helpful way, while not taking large amounts of compute. I also think Apollo existing in London will allow them to hire underutilized talent that would have trouble getting a U.S. visa.
    New grants
    [$112k] Jesse Hoogland: Scoping Developmental Interpretability
    Jesse posted this through our open call:
    We propose a 6-month research project to assess the viability of Developmental Interpretability, a new AI alignment research agenda. "DevInterp" studies how phase transitions give rise to computational structure in neural networks, and offers a possible path to scalable interpretability tools.
    Though we have both empirical and theoretical reasons to believe that phase transitions dominate the training process, the details remain unclear. We plan to clarify the role of phase transitions by studying them in a variety of models combining techniques from Singular Learning Theory and Mechanistic Interpretability. In six months, we expect to have gathered enough evidence to confirm that DevInterp is a viable research program.
    If successful, we expect Developmental Interpretability to become one of the main branches of technical alignment research over the next few years.
    Rachel was excited about this project and considered setting up a dominance assurance contract to encourage regrants, but instead offered 10% matching; Evan took her up on this!
    [$60k] Dam and Pietro: Writeup on Agency and (Dis)Empowerment
    A regrant initiated by Evan:
    6 months support for two people, Damiano and Pietro, to write a paper about (dis)empowerment. Its ultimate aim is to offer formal and operational notions of (dis)empowerment. For example, an inte...
    11 min
  • EA - Seeking founders for new effective giving organisations by Luke Moore
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Seeking founders for new effective giving organisations, published by Luke Moore on August 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Giving What We Can is looking to help founding teams organise to grow effective giving around the world and wants to hear from people excited about helping new effective giving initiatives get off the ground. These are likely to be initiatives in new geographies, like Effektiv Spenden, but we are also open to hearing about ideas for projects seeking to promote effective giving to specific interest groups, like High Impact Athletes. At this point we will prioritise supporting organisations which will fundraise for GWWC's existing recommendations over helping with geographically specific research and making geographically specific recommendations, although we are interested in this as well.
    Send us your expression of interest
    Why?
    Effective giving is an incredibly efficient way for us to convert resources into impact and moreover, there are many positive indirect effects from promoting effective giving; such as advocating for effective altruism and promoting positive values globally. However, there are significant regional gaps in the current effective giving ecosystem. As a result, donors from unrepresented regions or communities may be unable to make (tax-deductible) donations to effective charities and more importantly may not even come to hear about effective giving, as the ideas are not available in their language or cultural/community/social context. We think that this represents a huge missed opportunity - and one that we hope to help rectify.
    What?
    These new effective giving initiative will likely be a fundraising organisation that hosts funds which make grants to other effective charities and high-impact funding opportunities. These new fundraising organisations will need to be able to accept donations (ideally tax-deductible) in their legal jurisdiction and be able to make grants to charitable programs.
    Who?
    We are initially interested in recruiting a working group that would set the strategy, take the initial steps, and hire the executive director (who could be one of the original founding team). The types of roles that could be useful at this stage will be very varied and include e.g. volunteers, board members, an executive director and other team members, particularly those with expertise in the following areas:
    Legal
    Governance
    Website design
    Philanthropic advising
    Marketing and communications
    Accounting and finance
    Community fundraising
    Events
    IT and information security
    Support from Giving What We Can?
    Giving What We Can can provide support to new organisations in the following ways:
    General advice and support
    Sharing best practice and lessons learnt
    An MVP starter-guide for new effective giving organisations
    Access to shared resources and content within the effective giving community
    Introductions to the broader effective giving network (potentially helping form mentorship relationships)
    Assistance in accessing legal advice when needed
    Help in finding funding for the project, and potentially spending some of Giving What We Can's own budget on initial costs
    In some cases, the use of the GWWC brand and donation platform
    The level of support will depend on the specific project, its potential for impact, and the strength of the founding team.
    Giving What We Can has previously provided support in various ways to different effective giving organisations, here are just a few illustrative examples:
    Don Efficace: We provided some funding, governance and legal support, access to our donation platform, and mentorship for the founding team.
    Ayuda Efectiva: We provided a brand partnership and Ayuda Efectiva acts as the community for our members in Spain with their Executive Director being an Ambassador for Giving What We Can.
    Giving Gr...
    4 min
  • EA - Marketing 101 for EA Organizations by Igor Scaldini
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Marketing 101 for EA Organizations, published by Igor Scaldini on August 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    As a newcomer to the EA community, I'm surprised by how rarely EAs talk about marketing and organizational growth. As a marketer myself, maybe it's just a matter of me over-expecting people to give more importance to the matter, but even so, I'm confident that there are good reasons to talk more about it.
    First, according to this survey run by User-Friendly in February 2022, 72% of EA organization leaders said that effective marketing significantly helped their organization to achieve its objectives. I haven't conducted a survey myself, but the dozens of conversations I've had with professionals and founders in the EA movement support this statement.
    Another good reason is that EA organizations need a minimum degree of awareness to raise funds to achieve their goals. Of course, networking is important, but how scalable is it? Since creating awareness is one of the main marketing premises, EA organizations should consider using it more effectively.
    So the question I've been wondering is: why?
    Why don't people in the EA community talk that much about growth loops, retention, and marketing in general? Talking to colleagues in the community, I'm able to see a pattern in the main reasons that EAs are resistant to marketing.
    So my objective with this article is not only to explain what marketing is and provide a roadmap with practical tips that make sense for EA organizations but also to address some of these objections. Hopefully, this will at least get you thinking a bit about the value marketing could bring to your organization.
    Please feel free to share your thoughts and criticisms in the comments section, as I'd like to hear them so that I can improve this post to make it more useful.
    If you are convinced of the importance of marketing and are just looking for a roadmap, I recommend jumping straight to the section "A useful marketing framework for EA organizations."
    You may also be in a situation in which you have been running marketing campaigns for a while but facing some operations issues (misalignment of strategies, missing deadlines, idleness, etc.). In this case, the section "How to be prepared for operational success" may be particularly useful for you.
    Lastly, it's important to note that I will focus on marketing for EA organizations, not the marketing of the effective altruism movement itself. If you're interested in the latter, I recommend this post on making effective altruism enormous, this one on keeping EA welcoming, and this one on movement course corrections.
    Addressing some marketing misconceptions I've seen among EAs
    Misconception #1: Marketing is all about persuasion.
    Some EAs are suspicious of marketing because they think that it's all about persuading people to agree with you, rather than impartially seeking the truth. If used ethically, persuasion can indeed be a vital tool for marketing. However, an effective marketing strategy goes way beyond persuasion - channel optimizations, user journey, targeting, and many other things we do in marketing are important for growth but don't involve persuasion at all.
    Misconception #2: Logical arguments are enough to attract people.
    Some EAs think that there's no need to market EA organizations because the right people will be attracted by logical arguments alone. I deeply wish this were the case, but unfortunately, it's not. There is plenty of research showing that emotions play a huge role in our daily decisions. In my experience, telling a compelling story is one of the greatest and most time-tested ways to encourage people to act - even if those people are part of an audience that highly values logic.
    Misconception #3: Marketing destroys the organization's reputation among EAs.
    If done wrong, ...
    19 min