The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Map of maps of interesting fields by Max Görlitz
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Map of maps of interesting fields, published by Max Görlitz on June 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I love seeing cool visualizations (maps) of interesting intellectual fields. I’m also a big fan of making lists!
    Accordingly, I compiled a bunch of maps of fields that I thought were interesting. Please comment if you know of more such maps, and I’ll include them.
    Scott Alexander’s map of Effective Altruism (2020)
    mariekedev’s mindmap of EA organisations (2023)
    Hamish Doodles’ aisafety.world (2023)
    On a side note, I would be very keen for someone to create a similar map of relevant organizations in the biosecurity & pandemic preparedness space. I plan to post a minimum viable product (bullet point list) soon.
    James Lin’s map of biosecurity interventions (2022)
    Scott Alexander’s map of the rationality community (2014)
    Dan Elton’s map of progress studies (2021)
    Ada Nguyen’s map of the Longevity Biotech Landscape (2023)
    Nadia Asparouhova’s map of climate tribes (2022)
    Samuel Arbesman’s Catalog of New Types of Research Organizations (2023)
    This one is more of a long list, but I thought it was very interesting nonetheless!
    Honorable mentions
    These are other mapping efforts that met my "I'm curious about it" but not my "This is super interesting" bar. Some of them also seem outdated.
    xkcd’s map of online communities (2010)
    Julia Galef’s map of the Bay Area memespace (2013)
    Joe Lightfoot’s The Liminal Web: Mapping An Emergent Subculture Of Sensemakers, Meta-Theorists & Systems Poets (2021 & updated in 2023)
    Shoutout to Rival Voices, who created a similar-ish collection of maps (2023), and Nadia Asparouhova, who wrote a more meta-level post about Mapping digital worlds (2023).
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    3 min
  • LW - Model, Care, Execution by Ricki Heicklen
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Model, Care, Execution, published by Ricki Heicklen on June 26, 2023 on LessWrong.
    When Alice harms Bob, it is likely that one of the following three things went wrong:
    Model: Alice’s mental picture of what Bob would want, or of what is going on in the situation (which we’ll call her model), was incorrect and led her to behave in ways that caused Bob harm. If she’d had a better model, she would have acted differently, resulting in a better outcome for Bob.
    Care prioritization: Alice prioritized something else—herself, another person, some abstract value—over Bob. Even if she cares a lot about Bob’s happiness, other factors outweighed her care for him in this situation.
    Execution: Alice knew what Bob would want and cared enough about him, but failed to execute on bringing about the best Bob-outcome. Her execution failure could be the result of physical limitations, impulsivity, depression, structural barriers, or any of a number of other constraints.
    Often, the problem is a combination of two or even all three of these: if I had taken the time to think a little about what you would want (a care problem), I would not have made the mistake I made (a model problem) or would have made a plan that actually worked (an execution problem).
    We have found the framework of Model, Care, and Execution (MCE) to be useful when postmorteming cases of interpersonal harm. What went wrong, and how can we do better next time? More generally, what failure modes are most common for each of us, and what do we need to do to help each other improve in those areas?
    Postmortem: Your Roommate Sleeps Through His Interview
    It’s 1pm and your roommate Choni has fallen asleep on the couch. You see him sleeping and leave him alone. When he wakes up at 4:30pm, he has missed his 2pm job interview and is annoyed. What went wrong? Here are three plausible stories:
    There was a modeling error: You falsely believed that Choni wanted to nap all afternoon—you didn’t know he had an important interview, or thought he had rescheduled it—so you decided to let him sleep, acting reasonably based on your bad model.
    There was a care mismatch: You knew Choni would want to be awakened, but decided against doing so, perhaps because Choni has a tendency to punch people in the face when they wake him up, or because you were helping a friend in crisis and decided that was more urgent, or because you thought there was some chance he actually wouldn’t want to be woken up and you didn’t want it to be your fault if he was tired later.
    There was an execution failure: You knew Choni wanted to wake up, you wanted to help him wake him up, and you nevertheless failed to, perhaps because he slept through your many attempts, or because you came back to wake him for the interview at 1:55pm but had locked yourself out of the apartment by mistake, or because you were too depressed to get out of your bed and knock on his door.
    Depending on which of these went wrong, your plan for the future should be different.
    If it was a model problem, then Choni saying ahead of time “I have an important interview at 2pm today that I can’t miss” would have helped. You could also establish a default decision together—e.g., any time Choni is asleep in the middle of the day, you should wake him—or communicate other relevant information, like “it’s extremely easy for Choni to fall back asleep when awakened undesirably, so it’s better to err on the side of waking him” that will help you get a better idea of what he would want next time.
    If it was due to care prioritization, then Choni has a few options. He might try to change his own behavior so that it’s more rewarding to do what he wants, e.g. by making waking him up more pleasant (and less punchy), or by profusely thanking you afterwards for doing so, or by offering you a cash bounty for every successful ...
    20 min
  • EA - Presentación Introductoria al Altruismo Eficaz by davidfriva
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Presentación Introductoria al Altruismo Eficaz, published by davidfriva on June 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    TL;DR: Spanish-Speaking Introduction to Effective Altruism covering key concepts like EA itself, 80,000 Hours, Longtermism, and the ITN Framework.
    Message to the English-Speaking Community (Mensaje para la comunidad angloparlante):
    Hey everyone!
    I'm David, a 21-year-old Computer Science student at the University of Buenos Aires (Argentina). I recently delivered an introductory talk on Effective Altruism (EA), drawing inspiration from Ajeya Cotra's style and targeting young adults.
    During the talk, I covered various important concepts such as Effective Altruism itself, the idea of 80,000 hours, Longtermism, and the ITN Framework (translated into Spanish), after sharing my personal journey of discovering these concepts and why they hold significance for me.
    As part of my ongoing efforts to address the lack of Spanish content on the EA Forum, I am sharing a link to the talk and the accompanying transcript in the form of an article.
    Spanish, being the second most widely spoken language in the world and extensively used on the internet, deserves greater representation within the EA community. My hope is that this initiative will help bridge the gap and make EA concepts more accessible to Spanish speakers.
    I.
    Hola, soy David, tengo 21 años y estudio Computación en la Universidad de Buenos Aires. Hoy, quiero hablarles sobre un concepto que transformó radicalmente mi vida: el Altruismo Eficaz.
    El Altruismo Eficaz es, básicamente, un proyecto que tiene como objetivo encontrar las mejores formas de ayudar a los demás y ponerlas en práctica.
    Es tanto un campo de investigación que busca identificar los problemas más urgentes del mundo y las mejores soluciones para ellos, como una comunidad práctica que busca utilizar esos hallazgos para hacer el bien.
    Pero. para que entiendan por qué es tan importante para mí, y poder profundizar en esto, necesito antes contarles un poco de mi historia:
    Bueno, era marzo de 2020, cuando habiendo cumplido 18 años, termino la secundaria. El mismo mes me quedo sin hogar justo antes de empezar la universidad, cuando mi padre me echa de la habitación que compartíamos en una vivienda colectiva. Terminé siendo hospedado en la casa de un amigo y comencé a buscar empleo.
    Eran tiempos difíciles, de pandemia, la actividad económica había quedado paralizada.
    Por suerte, mala y buena, me contratan como empleado de limpieza en un Hospital
    En mi tiempo trabajando ahí, pude ser testigo de lo colapsado que se encontraba el sistema sanitario. Veía a personas ansiosas esperando en la guardia, pacientes sufriendo de enfermedades graves, y los trabajadores de la salud que se encargaban de tratarlos, completamente exhaustos. Con la emergencia sanitaria sumándose al caos, era un ambiente bastante estresante, incluso aterrador.En ese ambiente yo trabajaba.
    Y a la vuelta, iba a un comedor comunitario, que maneja una iglesia en el barrio de Constitución, para pedir comida. Es ahí, donde me doy cuenta de que el hambre, frío, y desesperación, que yo sentía, era cotidiano para una parte significativa de nuestra sociedad.
    Durante esta época, hubo noches en las que simplemente lloraba, sintiéndome completamente impotente. No entendía cómo el mundo podía llegar a ser tan injusto, y la gente capaz de ayudar, con recursos de sobra, tan indiferente a la tragedia de otros.
    Eventualmente llego a una posición cómoda, habiendo conseguido empleo como programador podía trabajar desde el confort de un departamento en el barrio más caro de Buenos Aires, alejado de los comedores comunitarios y los hospitales. Viviendo en una burbuja, lentamente, me fuí olvidando de la gente que encontraba en esos lugares, de los pobres y enfermos, los más desfavorecidos.
    Altruismo Efica...
    19 min
  • LW - Why am I Me? by dadadarren
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Why am I Me?, published by dadadarren on June 25, 2023 on LessWrong.
    At 5, I was hospitalized for a month due to pneumonia. Kids of that age have little fear of illnesses, and the discomfort is soon forgotten. What I still remember though is the intense boredom. It is during that dull month I started asking the question everyone has asked themself: "Among all the people in this world, why am I this particular one?". I still recall the ineffable yet intense feeling when thinking about it for the first time.
    Eventually I realized that's a question with no answer. Out of the vast number of things in existence, the fact that I am experiencing the world from the perspective of this particular thing- a human being- has no explanation. Logic and reason are unable to ascribe any underlying cause or rationale. "I am me" is just one fundamental truth that anyone has to take as a given.
    Yet this fundamental truth is different for each person. From each of our distinct perspectives, which physical thing is the "I" is different. Keeping track of such differences is both mentally consuming and often unnecessary. So there is a natural affinity to rid of the first-person and to think "objectively". Instead of basing it on one's own point of view, we organize thoughts and formulate arguments from an imaginary vantage point that is detached and impartial, with an immaterial gaze from nowhere.
    Though I consider such objectivism merely a shortcut for efficiency which has often been mistakenly regarded as an ideal, there is no denying its practical success. We all use it constantly with great results. Even when we do think about something from our own perspective, we can easily transcode it to the objective. All it seems to take is exchanging the perspective-dependent self - the "I"- for the particular person. So "I'm tall" can become "Dadadarren is tall". This is required since there is no "I" in objective reasoning. It is a gaze from nowhere after all.
    We all have performed these transcodings so frequently that they hardly require active thoughts anymore. Every time it subtly reinforces the idea that such transcoding is always possible, so thinking objectively can, some may even say should, supersedes thinking from any single perspective. But in some rare cases, that leads to problems. Anthropic reasoning is such a case.
    Take the Doomsday Argument(DA) as an example. It proposes the uninformed prior of one's own birth rank among all human beings ought to be uniformly distributed from the 1st to the last. So learning our actual birth rank (we are around the 100 billionth) should shift our belief about the future toward earlier extinction. E.g. I am more likely to be the 100 billionth person if there are only 200 Billion humans overall rather than 200 Trillion. So the fact I'm the 100 billionth means the former is more likely.
    The birth rank discussion isn't about if I am born slightly earlier or later. Nobody can be born more than a few months away from their actual birthday. The argument is about scenarios where "I" am altogether a different person. I.E. "If I'm the first human being" does not mean dadadarren is born so prematurely that he predates Adam, but rather "I" am Adam. There is a decoupling between the "I" and the physical person I am. Such decouplings are integral to anthropics. While normal problems discuss different ways of assigning people to rooms, anthropic problems can have only one fixed assignment while contemplating which one of those people is "me".
    By focusing on "my" birth rank the Doomsday Argument uses the perspective-based "I". The argument is often expressed with more inclusive terms such as "us", or "our generation". Unsurprising since explaining the argument to someone requires the recipient to evoke their own perspective too. However, if we reason from our p...
    6 min
  • LW - Another medical miracle by Dentin
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Another medical miracle, published by Dentin on June 25, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Or, "How I became even more disappointed in the medical practice in the USA than I already was".
    I'm getting older - half a century now - and have recently been having health problems. It started with soreness in my right hip about four years ago, gradually getting worse and worse over time. At one point I damaged it by sitting in a funny position for too long; later on, I did what I thought was a very normal set of lunges in the gym that made me almost unable to walk for months afterward.
    Then, about a year ago, I started having issues with my feet. At first, they were a little sore. They got worse and worse, eventually getting to the point where I again couldn't walk comfortably. They just would not heal, no matter how much time off I gave them.
    In the past three years, I've seen half a dozen doctors. Hypotheses ranged from early onset arthritis, to joint damage, to tendon damage, to disc compression in my back. Physical therapy helped a small amount, but the gains tapered off quickly and did not last. I was making no progress, and had simply restricted activity in my life to the point where things were tolerable. None of the doctors had any idea what was going on, and every visit was hundreds of dollars to be told things I already knew. One doctor prescribed exercises for the elderly to build muscle tone, without even bothering to ask about my current exercise regime or current state of fitness. (At the time I could do sets of 40 push-ups and one-legged squats to the floor and back.) To say that I was frustrated is an understatement.
    A bit over six months ago, I began to wonder if perhaps this was a side effect of the low dose statin I had started taking. The problems started prior to my taking the statin, but I found reports of statin side effects that looked vaguely similar to my issues. Perhaps I had fouled my cholesterol metabolism?
    I concocted an experiment to stop taking the statin for a few weeks, and eat a ton of eggs to try to get more cholesterol in my system. I didn't know at the time that dietary cholesterol makes very little contribution to total cholesterol levels, but that turned out to be a good thing: I saw what seemed to be noticeable improvement. The next couple of months I learned about cholesterol metabolism and ran more experiments, eventually narrowing things down to the point that I knew statin use was not responsible. The eggs were the active ingredient.
    But how does that make any sense?
    At some point it occurred to me that eggs also contain protein, that bodybuilders supplement protein in order to build muscle, and that vegetarians could get protein deficiency. With ten minutes of investigation, I discovered that my preferred diet is pretty close close to vegetarian, and had slowly been shifting to become more vegetarian over time. Did I have a protein deficiency?
    Lacking any other options, I used the power of "moar dakka" and tripled the amount of animal protein in my diet. Since then, both of my long-term multi-year health problems have gone away, all in the space of the last three months. I can hike for miles again, I can lift heavy weights, and I heal after taking damage. It's amazing.
    What has not healed is my opinion of medical practice in the USA. How on earth could something like this go undiagnosed for years? How could something as fundamental as protein deficiency not be a standard, ordinary thing we test for? How could half a dozen smart, capable, and highly trained doctors miss something like this repeatedly? How is it that the best modern medicine can do is say "go to physical therapy and hope it gets better"?
    To say that I am disappointed quite undersells my change in opinion. I previously took what doctors said with a grain of salt but largely belie...
    5 min
  • LW - Crystal Healing — or the Origins of Expected Utility Maximizers by Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Crystal Healing — or the Origins of Expected Utility Maximizers, published by Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel on June 25, 2023 on LessWrong.
    (Note: John discusses similar ideas here. We drafted this before he published his post, so some of the concepts might jar if you read it with his framing in mind. )
    Traditionally, focus in Agent Foundations has been around the characterization of ideal agents, often in terms of coherence theorems that state that, under certain conditions capturing rational decision-making, an agent satisfying these conditions must behave as if it maximizes a utility function. In this post, we are not so much interested in characterizing ideal agents — at least not directly. Rather, we are interested in how true agents and not-so true agents may be classified and taxonomized, how agents and pseudo-agents may be hierarchically aggregated and composed out of subagents and how agents with different preferences may be formed and selected for in different training regimes. First and foremost, we are concerned with how unified goal-directed agents form from a not-quite-agentic substratum. In other words, we are interested in Selection Theorems rather than Coherence Theorems.
    (We take the point of view that a significant part of the content of the coherence theorems is not so much in the theorems or rationality conditions themselves but in the money-pump arguments that are used to defend the conditions.)
    This post concerns how expected utility maximizers may form from entities with incomplete preferences.
    Incomplete preferences on the road to maximizing utility
    The classical model of a rational agent assumes it has vNM-preferences. We assume, in particular, that the agent is complete — i.e., that for any options x,y, we have x≥y or y≥x. However, in real-life agents, we often see incompleteness — i.e., a preference for default states, or maybe a path-dependent preference, or maybe a sense that a preference between two options is yet to be defined; we will leave the precise meaning of incompleteness somewhat open for the purposes of this post. The aim of this post is to understand the selection pressures that push agents towards completeness. Here are the main reasons we consider this important:
    Completeness is a prerequisite for applying the money-pump arguments that justify other coherence axioms. It thereby underlies the conception of agents as (rational) goal-directed optimizers.
    Understanding the pressures towards completeness from a plausibly incomplete state of nature can help us understand what kinds of intelligent optimization processes are likely to arise, and in which kinds of conditions / training regimes.
    In particular, since something like completeness seems to be an important facet of consequentialism, understanding the pressures towards completeness helps us understand the pressures towards consequentialism.
    Review of "Why Subagents"
    Let's review John Wentworth's post "Why subagents?" . John observes that inexploitability (= not taking sure losses) is not sufficient to be a vNM expected utility maximizer. An agent with incomplete preferences can be inexploitable without being an expected utility maximizer.
    Although these agents are inexploitable, they can have path-dependent preferences. If John had grown up in Manchester he'd be a United fan. If he had grown up in Liverpool he'd be cracking the skulls of Manchester United fans. We could model this as a dynamical change of preferences ("preference formation"). Alternatively, we can model this as John having incomplete preferences: if he grows up in Manchester he loves United and wouldn't take the offer to switch to Liverpool. If he grows up in Liverpool he loves whatever the team in Liverpool is and doesn't switch to United. In other words, incompleteness is a frame to look at preference for...
    11 min
  • LW - Did Bengio and Tegmark lose a debate about AI x-risk against LeCun and Mitchell? by Karl von Wendt
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Did Bengio and Tegmark lose a debate about AI x-risk against LeCun and Mitchell?, published by Karl von Wendt on June 25, 2023 on LessWrong.
    On June 22nd, there was a “Munk Debate”, facilitated by the Canadian Aurea Foundation, on the question whether “AI research and development poses an existential threat” (you can watch it here, which I highly recommend). On stage were Yoshua Bengio and Max Tegmark as proponents and Yann LeCun and Melanie Mitchell as opponents of the central thesis. This seems like an excellent opportunity to compare their arguments and the effects they had on the audience, in particular because in the Munk Debate format, the audience gets to vote on the issue before and after the debate.
    The vote at the beginning revealed 67% of the audience being pro the existential threat hypothesis and 33% against it. Interestingly, it was also asked if the listeners were prepared to change their minds depending on how the debate went, which 92% answered with “yes”. The moderator later called this extraordinary and a possible record for the format. While this is of course not representative for the general public, it mirrors the high uncertainty that most ordinary people feel about AI and its impacts on our future.
    I am of course heavily biased. I would have counted myself among the 8% of people who were unwilling to change their minds, and indeed I’m still convinced that we need to take existential risks from AI very seriously. While Bengio and Tegmark have strong arguments from years of alignment research on their side, LeCun and Mitchell have often made weak claims in public. So I was convinced that Bengio and Tegmark would easily win the debate.
    However, when I skipped to the end of the video before watching it, there was an unpleasant surprise waiting for me: at the end of the debate, the audience had seemingly switched to a more skeptical view, with now only 61% accepting an existential threat from AI and 39% dismissing it.
    What went wrong? Had Max Tegmark and Yoshua Bengio really lost a debate against two people I hadn’t taken very seriously before? Had the whole debate somehow been biased against them?
    As it turned out, things were not so clear. At the end, the voting system apparently broke down, so the audience wasn’t able to vote on the spot. Instead, they were later asked for their vote by email. It is unknown how many people responded, so the difference can well be a random error. However, it does seem to me that LeCun and Mitchell, although clearly having far weaker arguments, came across quite convincing. A simple count of the hands of the people behind the stage, who can be seen in the video, during a hand vote results almost in a tie. The words of the moderator also seem to indicate that he couldn’t see a clear majority for one side in the audience, so the actual shift may have been even worse.
    In the following, I assume that Bengio and Tegmark were indeed not as convincing as I had hoped. It seems worthwhile to look at this in some more detail to learn from it for future discussions.
    I will not give a detailed description of the debate; I recommend you watch it yourself. However, I will summarize some key points and will give my own opinion on why this may have gone badly from an AI safety perspective, as well as some learnings I extracted for my own outreach work.
    The debate was structured in a good way and very professionally moderated by Munk Debate’s chair Rudyard Griffiths. If anything, he seemed to be supportive of an existential threat from AI; he definitely wasn’t biased against it. At the beginning, each participant gave a 6-minute opening statement, then each one could reply to what the others had said in a brief rebuttal. After that, there was an open discussion for about 40 minutes, until the participants could again summarize the...
    12 min
  • LW - Correctly Calibrated Trust by habryka
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Correctly Calibrated Trust, published by habryka on June 24, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Chana from the CEA Community Health team posted this to the EA Forum, where it sadly seems to have not gotten a lot of traction. I actually think it's a quite important post, so I am signal-boosting it here. On the surface level it talks a lot about EA, but I a lot of it also straightforwardly implies to the AI Alignment or Rationality communities, and as such are also of relevance to a lots of readers on LessWrong.
    Below I shamelessly copied over the whole post content (except the footnotes, since they were hard to copy-paste):
    This post comes from finding out that Asya Bergal was having thoughts about this and was maybe going to write a post, thoughts I was having along similar lines, and a decision to combine energy and use the strategy fortnight as an excuse to get something out the door. A lot of this is written out of notes I took from a call with her, so she get credit for a lot of the concrete examples and the impetus for writing a post shaped like this.
    Interested in whether this resonates with people's experience!
    Short version:
    [Just read the bold to get a really short version]
    There’s a lot of “social sense of trust” in EA, in my experience. There’s a feeling that people, organizations and projects are broadly good and reasonable (often true!) that’s based on a combination of general vibes, EA branding and a few other specific signals of approval, as well as an absence of negative signals. I think that it’s likely common to overweight those signals of approval and the absence of disapproval.
    Especially post-FTX, I’d like us to be well calibrated on what the vague intuition we download from the social web is telling us, and place trust wisely.
    [“Trust” here is a fuzzy and under-defined thing that I’m not going to nail down - I mean here something like a general sense that things are fine and going well]
    Things like getting funding, being highly upvoted on the forum, being on podcasts, being high status and being EA-branded are fuzzy and often poor proxies for trustworthiness and of relevant people’s views on the people, projects and organizations in question[1].
    Negative opinions (anywhere from “that person not so great” to “that organization potentially quite sketch, but I don't have any details”) are not necessarily that likely to find their way to any given person for a bunch of reasons, and we don’t have great solutions to collecting and acting on character evidence that doesn't come along with specific bad actions. It’s easy to overestimate what you would know if there’s a bad thing to know.
    If it’s decision relevant or otherwise important to know how much to trust a person or organization, I think it’s a mistake to rely heavily on the above indicators, or on the “general feeling” in EA. Instead, get data if you can, and ask relevant people their actual thoughts - you might find them surprisingly out of step with what the vibe would indicate.
    I’m pretty unsure what we can or should do as a community about this, but I have a few thoughts at the bottom, and having a post about it as something to point to might help.
    Longer version:
    I think you'll get plenty out of this if you read the headings and read more under each heading if something piques your curiosity
    Part 1: What fuzzy proxies are people using and why would they be systematically overweighted?
    (I don’t know how common these mistakes are, or that they apply to you, the specific reader of the post. I expect them to bite harder if you’re newer or less connected, but I also expect that it’s easy to be somewhat biased in the same directions even if you have a lot of context. I’m hoping this serves as contextualization for the former and a reminder / nudge for the latter.)
    Getting funding from OP and LTFF
    Seems easy to e...
    16 min
  • LW - Will the growing deer prion epidemic spread to humans? Why not? by eukaryote
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Will the growing deer prion epidemic spread to humans? Why not?, published by eukaryote on June 25, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Helpful background reading: What’s the deal with prions?
    A novel lethal infectious neurological disease emerged in American deer a few decades ago. Since then, it’s spread rapidly across the continent. In areas where the disease is found, it can be very common in the deer there.
    Chronic wasting disease isn’t caused by a bacteria, virus, protist, or worm – it’s a prion, which is a little misshapen version of a protein that occurs naturally in the nervous systems of deer.
    Chemically, the prion is made of exactly the same stuff as its regular counterpart – it’s a string of the same amino acids in the same order, just shaped a little differently. Both the prion and its regular version (PrP) are monomers, single units that naturally stack on top of each other or very similar proteins. The prion’s trick is that as other PrP moves to stack atop it, the prion reshapes them – just a little – so that they also become prions. These chains of prions are quite stable, and, over time, they form long, persistent clusters in the tissue of their victims.
    We know of only a few prion diseases in humans. They’re caused by random chance misfolds, a genetic predisposition for PrP to misfold into a prion, accidental cross-contamination via medical supplies, or, rarely, from the consumption of prion-infected meat. Every known animal prions is a misfold of the same specific protein, PrP. PrP is expressed in the nervous system, particularly in the brain – so infections cause neurological symptoms and physical changes to the structure of the brain. Prion diseases are slow to develop (up to decades), incurable, and always fatal.
    There are two known infectious prion diseases in people. One is kuru, which caused an epidemic among tribes who practiced funerary cannibalism in Papua New Guinea. The other is mad cow disease, also known as bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) AKA Variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, which was first seen in humans in 1996 in the UK, and comes from cows.
    Chronic wasting disease (CWD).
    Is, like every other animal prion disease, a misfold of PrP. PrP is quite similar in both humans and deer.
    Is found in multiple deer species which are commonly eaten by humans.
    Can be carried in deer asymptomatically.
    But it doesn’t seem to infect people. Is it ever going to? If a newly-emerged virus were sweeping across the US and killing deer, which could be spread through consuming infected meat, I would think “oh NO.” I’d need to see very good evidence to stop sounding the alarm.
    Now, the fact that it’s been a few decades, and it hasn’t spread to humans yet, is definitely some kind of evidence about safety. But are we humans basically safe from it, or are we living on borrowed time? If you live in an area where CWD has been detected, should you eat the deer?
    Sidenote: Usually, you’ll see “BSE” used for the disease in cows and “VCJ” for the disease in humans. But they’re caused by the same agent and this essay is operating under a zoonotic One Health kind of stance, so I’m just calling the disease BSE here. (As well as the prion that causes it, when I can get away with it.)
    In short
    The current version of CWD is not infectious to people. We checked. BSE showed that prions can spill over, and there’s no reason a new CWD variant will never do the same. The more cases there are, the more likely it is to spill over. That said, BSE did not spill over very effectively. It was always incredibly rare in humans. It’s an awful disease to get, but the chance of getting it is tiny. Prions in general have a harder time spilling over between species than viruses do. CWD might behave somewhat differently but probably will stay hampered by the species barrier.
    Why do I think all of thi...
    22 min
  • EA - Downsides of Small Organizations in EA by Ozzie Gooen
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Downsides of Small Organizations in EA, published by Ozzie Gooen on June 25, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Epistemic Status: This is a subject I've been casually thinking about for a while, but I wrote this document fairly quickly. Take this with a big grain of salt. This is written in a personal capacity.
    A lot of EA, especially in meta and longtermism, is made up of small organizations and independent researchers. This provides some benefits, but I think the downsides are substantial and often unappreciated.
    More clearly:
    EA funding mostly comes from a very few funders, but it goes to a mass of small organizations. My impression is that this is an unusual combination.
    I think that there are a lot of important downsides to having things split up into a bunch of small nonprofits.
    I'm suspicious of many of the reasons for having small organizations that I've come across. There might well still be good reasons I haven't heard or that haven't been suggested.
    I suggest some potential changes we could make to try to get some of the best incremental tradeoffs.
    Downsides
    Low Management Flexibility
    If you want to quickly create a new project in a sizeable organization, you can pull people from existing teams. This requires upper management but is normal for said management. On the other hand, if you instead have a bunch of tiny independent organizations, your options are much more limited. Managers of tiny organizations can be near-impossible to move around because many of them own key funding relationships. Pulling together employees from different organizations is a pain, as no one has the authority to directly do this. The best you can do is slowly encourage people to join said new project.
    Moving people around is crucial for startups and tech firms. The first version Amazon Prime was made in under two months, in large part because Jeff Bezos was able to rapidly deploy the right people to it. At other tech companies, some amounts of regularly rotating team members is considered healthy. Strong software engineers get to work on many projects and people.
    Small nonprofit teams with locked-in mission statements are the opposite of this. This rigidness could be good for donors with little trust, but it comes at a substantial cost of flexibility.
    I’ve seen several projects in EA come up that could use rapid labor. Funding rounds seem particularly labor-intensive. It often seems to me like it should be possible to pull trusted people from existing organizations for a few weeks or months, but doing so is awkward because they’re formally part of separate organizations with specific mission statements and funding agreements.
    A major thing that managers at sizeable organizations do is size up requests for labor changes. The really good requests (with good managers) get quickly moved forward, and the bad ones are shot down. This is hard to do without clear, able, and available authorities.
    Low Employee Flexibility
    Employees that join small organizations with narrow missions can be assured that they will work on those missions. But if they ever want to try working with a different team or project, even just for a few months, the only option is often that they formally quit and formally apply for new roles. This is often a massive pain that could take 2-6+ months. The employee might be nervous about resentment or retaliation from other team members.
    My org, QURI, is doing fairly niche work and has a small team (2 people now!). I’d be excited to have some team members try rotating on and off for a few months here and there. It’s very valuable for us to have people with certain long-term skills “available” for long periods of time, but they don’t need to be active for long portions. I think this project makes sense to keep small, but I also feel awkward about asking others to joi...
    19 min