The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Epoch and FRI Mentorship Program Summer 2023 by merilalama
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Epoch and FRI Mentorship Program Summer 2023, published by merilalama on June 13, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We are thrilled to announce the Epoch and Forecasting Research Institute (FRI) mentorship program for women, non-binary people, and trans people of all genders. This program aims to provide guidance to individuals who want to contribute to the field of AI forecasting.
    The program mentors are Tegan McCaslin (FRI), Molly G Hickman (FRI), Avital Morris (FRI), David Owen (Epoch), Ben Cottier (Epoch) and Pablo Villalobos (Epoch). You can find out more about the mentors in the original post.
    Ajeya Cotra (Open Philanthropy) is a research advisor to the project. The program is coordinated by Jaime Sevilla (Epoch), with the support of Maria de la Lama (Epoch). Kathryn Mecrow-Flynn (Magnify Mentoring) is a program advisor.
    Throughout the program, the mentees will work in pairs under the guidance of a mentor to produce original research on Artificial Intelligence Forecasting. Each mentor will offer to guide a selection of projects within their expertise. Examples of projects on offer might include studying trends on the context size of Large Language Models, estimating the computational resources available to large AI companies, studying the applicability of integrated assessment models to AI and synthesizing predictors of task automation difficulty.
    Applicants must be over the age of 21 and identify as women, non-binary, and/or transgender. We welcome applications from people who are enthusiastic about AI forecasting, regardless of their level of experience. If you are unsure if you would be a good fit for the program, we encourage you to apply anyway!
    The program will run from Monday 3rd of July to Friday 1st of September. We expect a minimum time commitment of 10h/week from participants, including a weekly meeting with your mentor and a second weekly meeting with the rest of program participants. The program will be virtual, free of charge and open to participants around the world. To remove barriers to attendance, we will be offering $1000 stipends to accepted participants who solicit it.
    You can apply now and until the 19th of June through this form. Submit your application today!
    Program meetings are expected to happen within 16:00 to 19:00 UK time / 8:00 to 11:00 West Coast time. Otherwise participants will be free to arrange their time as best suits them.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    3 min
  • LW - <$750k grants for General Purpose AI Assurance/Safety Research by Phosphorous
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: <$750k grants for General Purpose AI Assurance/Safety Research, published by Phosphorous on June 13, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Georgetown University's Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) is accepting applications for AI Safety / AI Assurance research grants.
    They are offering up to $750k per project accepted, expended over 6-24 months.
    1-2 page expression of interest due August 1.
    Applicants should be based at an academic institution or nonprofit research organization.
    More information here.
    From CSET "We’re using 'assurance' here in a broad sense, meaning roughly 'the generation of evidence that an ML system is sufficiently safe for its intended use.'"
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - Tony Blair Institute AI Safety Work by TomWestgarth
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Tony Blair Institute AI Safety Work, published by TomWestgarth on June 13, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    At TBI, we have just written up a big report on AI policy. We cover a whole range of things around improving advice into government, increasing state capacity to deal with emerging AI challenges, and reforming things like public services and our data infrastructure for the AI age.
    But a big area of interest for this forum is our AI safety proposal for the UK. We propose creating AI Sentinel, a national laboratory effort focused on researching and testing safe AI, with the aim of becoming the “brain” for both a UK and an international AI regulator. Sentinel would recognise that effective regulation and control is and will likely remain an ongoing research problem, requiring an unusually close combination of research and regulation.
    Beneath is the copied party of the report that relates to this proposal.
    The UK should create a new national laboratory effort – here given a placeholder name of Sentinel – to test, understand and control safe AI, collaborating with the private sector and complementing its work. The long-term intention would be to grow this initiative into an international collaborative network. This will be catalysed by the UK embarking on a recruitment programme to attract the world’s best scientists to address AI-safety concerns.
    Such an effort should be open to international collaborators who could join the scheme, similar to the EU’s Horizon Europe programme. The UK is uniquely well positioned to do this due to the headquartering of Google DeepMind in London, which has drawn exceptional talent to the city. The EU has previously considered a similar effort but does not appear to have made progress yet; a contributing factor may be that the EU lacks the UK’s depth of AI talent. Sentinel could offer incentives for international collaboration in the form of knowledge and personnel sharing.
    This effort towards safe and interpretable forms of AI should be anchored by an elite public-sector physical laboratory, which has strong collaborative links with private companies. This would fill the space of the Alan Turing Institute in the UK but with a wider remit, markedly increased funding, and improved governance learning from the first New National Purpose report and Sir Paul Nurse’s recent review of the UK’s research, development and innovation landscape.
    This endeavour would have three related core objectives:
    Develop and deploy methods to interrogate and interpret advanced AI systems for safety, while devising regulatory approaches in tandem. This should also include development of measures to control and contain these systems, as well as design of new algorithms and models that may be more interpretable and controllable. Some starting-point evaluations do already exist, but part of Sentinel’s mission would be to work out which are the right evaluations, create new methods, as well as which can be public and which have to be private (to prevent future AI models from being trained on our evaluations and then being able to evade scrutiny). Built into the core mission of Sentinel is the expectation that it will focus on safety measures for the most capable current models.
    Keep the UK and its partners’ understanding and capabilities in advanced AI systems close to the cutting edge of AI-relevant technology, and serve as a trusted source of advice on this to these nations. Sentinel could, for example, perform assessments of when advanced super-intelligent capabilities are likely to be accomplished within a two-year window, and help coordinate a slowing-down of capabilities. Crucially, the purpose of Sentinel should be to help to assess and understand the frontier of current capabilities, rather than push the frontier further in terms of capability absen...
    10 min
  • EA - <$750k grants for General Purpose AI Assurance/Safety Research by Phosphorous
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: <$750k grants for General Purpose AI Assurance/Safety Research, published by Phosphorous on June 13, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Georgetown University's Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) is accepting applications for AI Safety / AI Assurance research grants.
    They are offering up to $750k per project accepted, expended over 6-24 months.
    1-2 page expression of interest due August 1.
    Applicants should be based at an academic institution or nonprofit research organization.
    More information here.
    From CSET "We’re using 'assurance' here in a broad sense, meaning roughly 'the generation of evidence that an ML system is sufficiently safe for its intended use.'"
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    1 min
  • LW - TASRA: A Taxonomy and Analysis of Societal-Scale Risks from AI by Andrew Critch
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: TASRA: A Taxonomy and Analysis of Societal-Scale Risks from AI, published by Andrew Critch on June 13, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Partly in response to calls for more detailed accounts of how AI could go wrong, e.g., from Ng and Bengio's recent exchange on Twitter, here's a new paper with Stuart Russell:
    Discussion on Twitter... comments welcome!
    arXiv draft:"TASRA: A Taxonomy and Analysis of Societal-Scale Risks from AI"
    Many of the ideas will not be new to LessWrong or the Alignment Forum, but holistically I hope the paper will make a good case to the world for using logically exhaustive arguments to identify risks (which, outside LessWrong, is often not assumed to be a valuable approach to thinking about risk).
    I think the most important figure from the paper is this one:
    ... and, here are some highlights:
    Self-fulfilling pessimism:#page=4
    Industries that could eventually get out of control in a closed loop:#page=5...as in this "production web" story:#page=6
    Two "bigger than expected" AI impact stories:#page=8
    Email helpers and corrupt mediators, which kinda go together:#page=10#page=11
    Harmful A/B testing:#page=12
    Concerns about weaponization by criminals and states:#page=13
    Enjoy :)
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • LW - The Dial of Progress by Zvi
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The Dial of Progress, published by Zvi on June 13, 2023 on LessWrong.
    “There is a single light of science. To brighten it anywhere is to brighten it everywhere.” – Isaac Asimov
    You cannot stand what I’ve becomeYou much prefer the gentleman I was beforeI was so easy to defeat, I was so easy to controlI didn’t even know there was a war
    – Leonard Cohen, There is a War
    “Pick a side, we’re at war.”
    – Steven Colbert, The Colbert Report
    Recently, both Tyler Cowen in response to the letter establishing consensus on the presence of AI extinction risk, and Marc Andreessen on the topic of the wide range of AI dangers and upsides, have come out with posts whose arguments seem bizarrely poor.
    These are both excellent, highly intelligent thinkers. Both clearly want good things to happen to humanity and the world. I am confident they both mean well. And yet.
    So what is happening?
    A Theory
    My theory is they and similar others believe discourse in 2023 cannot handle nuance.
    Instead, effectively there is a single Dial of Destiny Progress, based on the extent our civilization places restrictions, requires permissions and places strangleholds on human activity, from AI to energy to housing and beyond.
    If we turn this dial down, and slow or end such progress across the board, our civilization will perish. If you turn the dial up, we will prosper.
    In this view, any talk of either extinction risks or other AI downsides is functionally an argument for turning the dial down, saying Boo Progress, when we instead desperately need it turn the dial up, and say Yay Progress.
    It would, again in this view, be first best to say Yay Progress in most places, while making a careful narrow exception that lets us guard against extinction risks. Progress is no use if you are dead.
    Alas, this is too nuanced, and thus impossible. Trying will not result in the narrow thing that would protect us. Instead, trying turns the dial down which does harm everywhere, and also does harm within AI because the new rules will favor insiders and target mundane utility without guarding against danger, and the harms you do elsewhere inhibit sane behavior.
    Thus, the correct thing to do is shout Yay Progress from the rooftops, by whatever means are effective. One must think in terms of the effects of the rhetoric on the dial and the vibe, not on whether the individual points track underlying physical reality. Caring about individual points and how they relate to physical reality, in this model, is completely missing the point.
    This doesn’t imply there is nothing to be done to reduce extinction risks. Tyler Cowen in particular has supported at least technical private efforts to do this. Perhaps people in National Security or high in government, or various others who could help, could have their minds changed in good directions that would let us do nuanced useful things. But such efforts must be done quietly, among the cognoscenti and behind the scenes, a la ‘secret congress.’
    While I find this model incomplete, and wish for higher epistemic standards throughout, I agree that in practice this single Dial of Progress somewhat exists.
    Also Yay Progress.
    Robin Hanson explicitly endorses the maximalist Yay Progress position, expecting human extinction but considering the alternative even worse.
    This post fleshes out the model, its implications, and my view of both.
    Consider a Dial
    What if, like the metaphorical single light of science, there was also a single knob of (technological, scientific, economic) progress?
    Collectively, the sum of little decisions, the lever is moved.
    If we turn the dial up, towards Yay Progress, we get more progress.
    If we turn the dial down, towards Boo Progress, we get less progress.
    As the dial is turned up, people are increasingly empowered to do a wide variety of useful and productive things, without ...
    18 min
  • EA - Improving EA Communication Surrounding Disability by MHR
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Improving EA Communication Surrounding Disability, published by MHR on June 13, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Epistemic Status: Low-to-medium confidence, informed by my experience with having a disability as an EA. I think the included recommendations are reasonable best practices, but I’m uncertain as to whether they would make a tangible change to perceptions of the EA movement.
    Summary
    The EA movement has historically faced criticism from disability rights advocates, potentially reducing support for EA and limiting its ability to do good. This tension between EA and disability advocacy may be as much a matter of poor EA communication around issues of disability as a matter of fundamental philosophical disagreement. Changes to communications practices regarding disability might therefore deliver major benefits for relatively little effort. Particular recommendations for improving communications include:
    Avoiding unnecessarily presenting EA and disability advocacy as being in opposition
    Being careful to only use DALYs when appropriate and when properly contextualized
    Increasing the quantity and diversity of EA writing on disability
    Introduction
    The Effective Altruism movement has had a somewhat contentious relationship with the disability advocacy community. Disability advocates have critiqued EA via protests, articles, and social media posts, arguing that the movement is ableist, eugenicist, and/or insufficiently attentive to the needs of disabled individuals. Yet the EA community is often substantially more inclusive than society at large for people with many disabilities, through aspects such as availability of remote work, social acceptance of specialized dietary needs, and provision of information in a wide variety of formats. Moreover, while there are some areas in which EA’s typical consequentialism may have fundamental conflicts with theories of disability justice, these areas are likely much more limited than many would assume.
    In fact, since people with disabilities tend to be overrepresented among those living in extreme poverty and/or experiencing severe pain, typical EA approaches that prioritize these problems are likely to be substantially net beneficial to the lives of disabled individuals. Given this context, I think it is likely that the conflict between disability advocates and effective altruists is as much a problem of poor EA communication as it is a problem of fundamental philosophical difference. This breakdown implies that conflicts between EAs and disability advocates might be substantially reduced via changes to EA communications practices.
    While changes to communication approaches carry some costs, I believe the benefits from improved communications around disability would probably outweigh them. There are three potential areas in which I think the status quo hurts the EA movement. First of all, it likely drives off potential donors, employees, and advocates with disabilities, reducing the resources with which the EA movement is able to do good. Second, it may prevent dialogue between the EA and disability advocacy communities that might productively identify effective interventions focused on people with disabilities. Finally, it may reduce support for the EA movement among the wider community of people who care about the interests and concerns of the disabled community. In comparison to these harms, I think the modest efforts required to improve on current EA communications around disability issues are likely to be noticeably less costly.
    In the next section, I identify three practical areas in which communications could likely be substantially improved.
    Suggested Methods of Improving Communication
    Avoiding Unnecessarily Presenting EA and Disability Advocacy as being in Opposition
    In What We Owe the Future, Will MacAskill descri...
    12 min
  • AF - MetaAI: less is less for alignment. by Cleo Nardo
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: MetaAI: less is less for alignment., published by Cleo Nardo on June 13, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Summary
    In May 2023, MetaAI submitted a paper to arxiv called LIMA: Less Is More for Alignment. It's a pretty bad paper and (in my opinion) straightforwardly misleading. Let's get into it.
    The Superficial Alignment Hypothesis
    The authors present an interesting hypothesis about LLMs
    We define the Superficial Alignment Hypothesis: A model’s knowledge and capabilities are learnt almost entirely during pretraining, while alignment teaches it which subdistribution of formats should be used when interacting with users.
    If this hypothesis is correct, and alignment is largely about learning style, then a corollary of the Superficial Alignment Hypothesis is that one could sufficiently tune a pretrained language model with a rather small set of examples.
    We hypothesize that alignment can be a simple process where the model learns the style or format for interacting with users, to expose the knowledge and capabilities that were already acquired during pretraining.
    (1) This hypothesis would have profound implications for AI x-risk
    It suggests that we could build a safe competent oracle by pretraining an LLM on the entire internet corpus, and then finetuning the LLM on a curated dataset of safe competent responses.
    It suggests that we could build an alignment researcher by pretraining an LLM on the entire internet corpus, and then finetuning the LLM on a curated dataset of alignment research.
    (2) Moreover, as by Ulisse Mini writes in their review of the LIMA paper,
    Along with TinyStories and QLoRA I'm becoming increasingly convinced that data quality is all you need, definitely seems to be the case for finetuning, and may be the case for base-model training as well. Better scaling laws through higher-quality corpus? Also for who haven't updated, it seems very likely that GPT-4 equivalents will be essentially free to self-host and tune within a year. Plan for this!
    (3) Finally, the hypothesis would've supported many of the intuitions in the Simulators sequence by Janus, and I share these intuitions.
    So I was pretty excited to read the paper! Unfortunately, the LIMA results were unimpressive upon inspection.
    MetaAI's experiment
    The authors finetune MetaAI's 65B parameter LLaMa language model on 1000 curated prompts and responses (mostly from StackExchange, wikiHow, and Reddit), and then compare it to five other LLMs (Alpaca 65B, DaVinci003, Bard, Claude, GPT4).
    Method:
    To compare LIMA to other models, we generate a single response for each test prompt. We then ask crowd workers to compare LIMA outputs to each of the baselines and label which one they prefer. We repeat this experiment, replacing human crowd workers with GPT-4, finding similar agreement levels.
    Results:
    In a controlled human study, responses from LIMA are either equivalent or strictly preferred to GPT-4 in 43% of cases; this statistic is as high as 58% when compared to Bard and 65% versus DaVinci003, which was trained with human feedback.
    Conclusion:
    The fact that simple fine-tuning over so few examples is enough to compete with the state of the art strongly supports the Superficial Alignment Hypothesis, as it demonstrates the power of pretraining and its relative importance over large-scale instruction tuning and reinforcement learning approaches.
    Problems with their experiment
    (1) Human evaluators
    To compare two chatbots A and B, you could ask humans whether they prefer A's response to B's response across 300 test prompts. But this is pretty bad proxy, because here's what users actually care about:
    What's the chatbots' accuracy on benchmark tests, e.g. BigBench, MMLU?
    Can the chatbot pass a law exam, or a medical exam?
    Can the chatbot write Python code that actually matches the specification?
    Can the chatbot per...
    12 min
  • EA - AMA: Luke Freeman, ED of Giving What We Can (GWWC) by Luke Freeman
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AMA: Luke Freeman, ED of Giving What We Can (GWWC), published by Luke Freeman on June 13, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I’m Luke Freeman, and I currently serve as the executive director of Giving What We Can (GWWC). You’re welcome to ask me anything! I’ll start answering questions on Thursday June 15th.
    Logistics/practical instructions:
    Please post your questions as comments on this post. The earlier you share your questions, the easier it will be for me to get to them.
    Please upvote questions you'd most like answered.
    I’ll start answering questions on June 15th. Questions posted after that are less likely to get answers.
    I’m excited about this, but can’t commit to answering all the questions. If you want to share many questions, consider sharing and/or upvoting which ones you’re particularly interested in.
    (This is an “AMA” — you can explore others here.)
    Some context:
    I’ve been leading the team at Giving What We Can since 2020.
    I’ve been giving based on EA principles myself since about 2011 (pledger at both GWWC and Founders Pledge) and actively engaged with the EA community since 2016.
    GWWC is a community of effective givers who are on a mission to create a culture where giving effectively and significantly is a norm.
    GWWC hosts several giving pledges (best known for The Pledge to give 10% of lifetime earnings to effective charities), hosts a multi-country cause-diverse donation platform, provides advice on effective giving, and hosts popular tools and resources such as the How Rich Am I calculator, Giving Games and Charity Elections.
    GWWC does work to help support the broader effective giving community (e.g. information sharing, coordination and incubation of projects, research projects like evaluating the evaluators).
    GWWC helped to found the EA community and what is now called Effective Ventures Foundation (formerly Centre for Effective Altruism). I can speak about my experience running a project housed within EV.
    Read more about GWWC’s direction and strategy
    I’ve advocated for “big tent” effective altruism.
    I feel that EA could learn a lot from other sectors and could benefit from engaging more deeply with them.
    I feel strongly that effective giving should be a key part of effective altruism and likely has a broader appeal and accessibility.
    Prior to GWWC I worked predominantly in tech entrepreneurship and marketing (across private and public sectors) with a focus on growth.
    Outside of Giving What We Can I’ve been in leadership positions in Effective Altruism Australia, EAGxAustralia (organised two conferences) Good Ancestors Project & Good Ancestors Policy, Global Shapers Community (Sydney chapter), EA Sydney, Heart for the Homeless, Australian Skeptics, and advised or volunteered with various other social-impact focused projects.
    My academic background is in media and communications (did my thesis on political communication focusing on deliberative democracy and voting reform).
    Other than these things I’d be happy to talk about:
    Managing or working in a remote international team (based outside of EA hub cities) based in Australia.
    My experience going from employee #1 to larger teams (multiple times in different contexts).
    My experience volunteering and/or managing volunteers
    My experience in for-purpose entrepreneurship.
    Challenges and strategies for mental/physical health and wellbeing (e.g. recovering from and mitigating burnout, managing EA/non-EA life, starting a family etc).
    My experiences coming from a non-typical academic background for EA leadership (e.g. not a major in philosophy, economics, or science).
    My views on EA topics/cruxes.
    Dropping out of school at age 15 and pursuing non-traditional career paths
    Anything else that takes your fancy based on GWWC’s work, my post history, my LinkedIn or personal website.
    Thanks for listening. To hel...
    4 min
  • LW - UFO Betting: Put Up or Shut Up by RatsWrongAboutUAP
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: UFO Betting: Put Up or Shut Up, published by RatsWrongAboutUAP on June 13, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Are you confident in your current ontology? Are you convinced that ultimately all ufos are prosaic in nature?
    If so, do you want some immediate free money?
    I suspect that LW's are overconfident in their views on ufos/uap. As such, I'm willing to offer what I think many will find to be very appealing terms for a bet.
    The Bet
    Essentially, I wish to bet on the world and rationalists eventually experiencing significant ontological shock as it relates to the nature of some ufos/uap.
    Offer me odds for a bet, and the maximum payout you are willing to commit to. I will pick 1+ from the pool and immediately pay out to you. In the event that I ultimately win the bet, then you will pay out back to me.
    I'm looking to give out between $5k-10k, but depends on what kinds of offers I get, could be more or less.
    The Terms
    I Send you $X Immediately, You pay out OddsX if I win
    ie, You offer 200:1 odds with max payout $20,000 and I will send you $100 immediately.
    5 year time horizon starting from the date we confirm our bet.
    You offer the odds and maximum payout, I will pick from the available offers to maximize my expected returns, subject to my financial constraints.
    Resolution Criteria
    Two Worlds: All-ufos-are-ultimately-prosaic, and Not-all-ufos-are-ultimately-prosaic. I win the bet if we come to believe we likely live in the latter world. I win the bet if the ufo story ultimately gives us LW's a significant ontological shock. I win the bet if the ufo story ultimately causes the LW community to stop, melt, and catch fire. I've found it difficult to precisely nail down how to phrase this, so I hope its clear what kind of criteria I'm trying to get at.
    Examples of things where if we come to believe at least one of them likely explain >0 ufo/uap cases, then I win the bet:
    Aliens / Extraterrestrials
    Biological
    Machines (Von Neumann probes, for instance)
    Actual magic/spiritual/paranormal/psychic phenomenon
    This explicitly does NOT include merely advanced "mentalist" type things / show magic
    ie, things like ESP, astral projection, demons, god(s), angels, ghosts, remote viewing, fairy's (actually anomalous, not just new kind of bird), etc.
    Basically, the kinds of things that standard atheist materialists would reject as not being real.
    Time travel
    ie, future human activities (or otherwise)
    Leftovers of an ancient civilization
    Some other unknown non-human advanced civilization on earth
    Matrix Glitches / The simulators have a sense of humor
    Some other explanation I'm missing that's of a similar level of "very weird"
    Merely advanced "normal" human tech would NOT count (+2 gens stealth aircraft/drones, advanced holograms/spoofing, etc)
    What WOULD count is if the story is significantly weird enough to cause ontological shock.
    example: Secret Manhattan style project with beyond next gen physics, that we had back in the 60's
    Important Note: The bet resolve in my favor if we think that one of the "weird hypotheses" is likely (>50%) true, NOT that we are confident in which specific explanation is true. Essentially, the bet resolves in my favor if we agree with the statement: "Whatever these most perplexing ufo/uap cases represent, they are likely something beyond our current paradigm"
    Further Details
    I hereby forfeit any "gotcha" cases.
    I'm not trying to be slick or capitalize on technicalities. A world in which I win is one where the community would broadly agree that I won.
    Determination of resolution in my favor is left up to you.
    I reserve the right to appeal to the LW community to adjudicate resolution if I believe I am being stiffed.
    I hereby commit to not abusing this right. I don't expect that I would ever have to invoke it, I suspect it would be very obvious if I win or not to everyone.
    If these t...
    5 min