The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - Things I Learned by Spending Five Thousand Hours In Non-EA Charities by jenn
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Things I Learned by Spending Five Thousand Hours In Non-EA Charities, published by jenn on June 1, 2023 on LessWrong.
    From late 2020 to last month, I worked at grassroots-level non-profits in operational roles. Over that time, I’ve seen surprisingly effective deployments of strategies that were counter-intuitive to my EA and rationalist sensibilities.
    I spent 6 months being the on-shift operations manager at one of the five largest food banks in Toronto (~50 staff/volunteers), and 2 years doing logistics work at Samaritans (fake name), a long-lived charity that was so multi-armed that it was basically operating as a supplementary social services department for the city it was in(~200 staff and 200 volunteers). Both of these non-profits were well-run, though both dealt with the traditional non-profit double whammy of being underfunded and understaffed.
    Neither place was super open to many EA concepts (explicit cost-benefit analyses, the ITN framework, geographic impartiality, the general sense that talent was the constraining factor instead of money, etc). Samaritans in particular is a spectacular non-profit, despite(?) having basically anti-EA philosophies, such as:
    Being very localist; Samaritans was established to help residents of the city it was founded in, and now very specialized in doing that.
    Adherence to faith; the philosophy of The Catholic Worker Movement continues to inform the operating choices of Samaritans to this day.
    A big streak of techno-pessimism; technology is first and foremost seen as a source of exploitation and alienation, and adopted only with great reluctance when necessary.
    Not treating money as fungible. The majority of funding came from grants or donations tied to specific projects or outcomes. (This is a system that the vast majority of nonprofits operate in.)
    Once early on I gently pushed them towards applying to some EA grants for some of their more EA-aligned work, and they were immediately turned off by the general vibes of EA upon visiting some of its websites. I think the term “borg-like” was used.
    Over this post, I’ll be largely focusing on Samaritans as I’ve worked there longer and in a more central role, and it’s also a more interesting case study due to its stronger anti-EA sentiment.
    Things I Learned
    Long Term Reputation is Priceless
    Non-Profits Shouldn’t Be Islands
    Slack is Incredibly Powerful
    Hospitality is Pretty Important
    For each learning, I have a section for sketches for EA integration – I hesitate to call them anything as strong as recommendations, because the point is to give more concrete examples of what it could look like integrated in an EA framework, rather than saying that it’s the correct way forward.
    1. Long Term Reputation is Priceless
    Institutional trust unlocks a stupid amount of value, and you can’t buy it with money. Lots of resources (amenity rentals; the mayor’s endorsement; business services; pro-bono and monetary donations) are priced/offered based on tail risk. If you can establish that you’re not a risk by having a longstanding, unblemished reputation, costs go way down for you, and opportunities way up. This is the world that Samaritans now operate in.
    Samaritans had a much better, easier time at city hall compared to newer organizations, because of a decades-long productive relationship where we were really helpful with issues surrounding unemployment and homelessness. Permits get back to us really fast, applications get waved through with tedious steps bypassed, and fees are frequently waived. And it made sense that this was happening! Cities also deal with budget and staffing issues, why waste more time and effort than necessary on someone who you know knows the proper procedure and will ethically follow it to the letter?
    It’s not just city hall. A few years ago, a local church offered up their...
    13 min
  • LW - Change my mind: Veganism entails trade-offs, and health is one of the axes by Elizabeth
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Change my mind: Veganism entails trade-offs, and health is one of the axes, published by Elizabeth on June 1, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Introduction
    To me, it is obvious that veganism introduces challenges to most people. Solving the challenges is possible for most but not all people, and often requires trade-offs that may or may not be worth it. I’ve seen effective altruist vegan advocates deny outright that trade-offs exist, or more often imply it while making technically true statements. This got to the point that a generation of EAs went vegan without health research, some of whom are already paying health costs for it, and I tentatively believe it’s harming animals as well.
    Discussions about the challenges of veganism and ensuing trade-offs tend to go poorly, but I think it’s too important to ignore. I’ve created this post so I can lay out my views as legibly as possible, and invite people to present evidence I’m wrong.
    One reason discussions about this tend to go so poorly is that the topic is so deeply emotionally and morally charged. Actually, it’s worse than that: it’s deeply emotionally and morally charged for one side in a conversation, and often a vague irritant to the other. Having your deepest moral convictions treated as an annoyance to others is an awful feeling, maybe worse than them having opposing but strong feelings. So I want to be clear that I respect both the belief that animals can suffer and the work advocates put into reducing that suffering. I don’t prioritize it as highly as you do, but I am glad you are doing (parts of) it.
    But it’s entirely possible for it to be simultaneously true that animal suffering is morally relevant, and veganism has trade-offs for most people. You can argue that the trade-offs don’t matter, that no cost would justify the consumption of animals, and I have a section discussing that, but even that wouldn’t mean the trade-offs don’t exist.
    This post covers a lot of ground, and is targeted at a fairly small audience. If you already agree with me I expect you can skip most of this, maybe check out the comments if you want the counter-evidence. I have a section addressing potential counter-arguments, and probably most people don’t need to read my response to arguments they didn’t plan on making. Because I expect modular reading, some pieces of information show up in more than one section. Anyone reading the piece end to end has my apologies for that.
    However, I expect the best arguments to come from people who have read the entire thing, and at a minimum the “my cruxes” and “evidence I’m looking for” sections. I also ask you to check the preemptive response section for your argument, and engage with my response if it relates to your point. I realize that’s a long read, but I’ve spent hundreds of hours on this, including providing nutritional services to vegns directly, so I feel like this is a reasonable request.
    My cruxes
    Below are all of the cruxes I could identify for my conclusion that veganism has trade-offs, and they include health:
    People are extremely variable. This includes variation in digestion, tastes, time, money, cooking ability.
    Most people’s optimal diet includes small amounts of animal products, but people eat sub-optimally for lots of reasons and that’s their right. Averting animal suffering is a better reason to eat suboptimally than most.
    Average vegans and omnivores vary in multiple ways, so it’s complicated to compare diets. I think the relevant comparison healthwise is “the same person, eating vegan or omnivore” or “veganism vs. omnivorism, holding all trade-offs but one constant”.
    For most omnivores who grew up in an omnivorous culture, going vegan requires a sacrifice in at least one of: cost, taste (including variety), health, time/effort.
    This is a mix of capital investments and ongoing costs – you ...
    30 min
  • EA - Probably tell your friends when they make big mistakes by Chi
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Probably tell your friends when they make big mistakes, published by Chi on June 1, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Big mistakes = Doing something that is actively harmful or useless by their own lights and values, i.e. doesn't help them achieve their life goals. (Not: Doing something that isn't in line with your values and goals.)
    A lot of people think that others in the EA-ish community are trying to do something impactful but end up doing something harmful or useless. Sometimes they also work on something that they are just not very good at or make other big mistakes. A lot of people never end up telling the other person that they think they are making big mistakes. Sometimes people also just have one particular argument for why the other might do harmful or useless work but not be sure whether it's a bad overall. This also often goes unsaid.
    I think that's understandable and also bad or at least very costly.
    Epistemic status: Speculation/rant. I know of another person who might post something in this topic that is much more rigorous and has actual background research.
    Upsides of telling others you think they are making big mistakes, wasting their time, or doing harm:
    It's good on a community level because people get information that's useful to decide how to achieve their goals (among them, having impact,) so people end up working on less suboptimal things and the community has better impact overall.
    It's good on a community level because it's pushes towards good intellectual conversations and progress.
    I and probably others find it stressful because I can't rely on others telling me if they think I'm doing a bad job, so I have to try to read between the lines. (I find it much less stressful now but when I was more insecure about my competence, I found it really stressful. I think one of my main concerns was others thinking and saying I'm "meh" or "fine" (with an unenthusiastic tone) but only behind my back.)
    Note that anxiety works differently for different people though and some people might find the opposite is true for them. See reasons against telling people that you think they are wasting their time or worse.
    I and probably others find it pretty upsetting that I can't rely on others being honest with me. It's valuable information and I would like people to act in a way that helps me achieve my stated goals (in this case, doing good), especially if their motivation for not being honest with me is protecting my wellbeing.
    That said, I often don't do a great job at this myself and think telling others you think their efforts would be better spent elsewhere also has significant costs, both personal and on a community level.
    Downsides of telling others you think they are making big mistakes, wasting their time, or doing harm:
    Hearing that somebody thinks you're doing harmful or useless work can be extremely discouraging and can lead people to over-update, especially if they are insecure anyway. (Possibly because people do it so rarely, so the signal can be interpreted as stronger than it's intended.)
    At the same time, we often have noisy information about how good another person's work is, especially how good a fit they are or could be.
    Criticising someone's work could lead to an awkward relationship to them. They might also get angry at you or start talking badly about you. This is especially costly if you have a friendly and or a professional relationship.
    An increase in people telling each other what they think about each other's work could create or amplify a culture in which everyone constantly feels like they have to orient themselves towards impact all the time and justify their decisions. This could lead to feelings of guilt, shame, judgement, higher risk-aversion, and an over-emphasis on doing things that are mainstream approved.
    That said, I thin...
    10 min
  • AF - Uncertainty about the future does not imply that AGI will go well by Lauro Langosco
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Uncertainty about the future does not imply that AGI will go well, published by Lauro Langosco on June 1, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Subtitle: A partial defense of high-confidence AGI doom predictions.
    Introduction
    Consider these two kinds of accident scenarios:
    In a default-success scenario, accidents are rare. For example, modern aviation is very safe thanks to decades of engineering efforts and a safety culture (e.g. the widespread use of checklists). When something goes wrong, it is often due to multiple independent failures that combine to cause a disaster (e.g. bad weather + communication failures + pilot not following checklist correctly).
    In a default-failure scenario, accidents are the norm. For example, when I write a program to do something I haven’t done many times already, it usually fails the first time I try it. It then goes on to fail the second time and the third time as well. Here, failure on the first try is overdetermined―even if I fix the first bug, the second bug is still, independently, enough to cause the program to crash. This is typical in software engineering, and it can take many iterations and tests to move into the default-success regime.
    See also: conjuctive vs disjunctive risk scenarios.
    Default-success scenarios include most engineering tasks that we have lots of experience with and know how to do well: building bridges, building skyscrapers, etc. Default-failure scenarios, as far as I can tell, come in two kinds: scenarios in which we’re trying to do something for the first time (rocket test launches, prototypes, new technologies) and scenarios in which there is a competent adversary that is trying to break the system, as in computer security.
    Predictions on AGI risk
    In the following, I use P(doom) to refer to the probability of an AGI takeover and / or human extinction due to the development of AGI.
    I often encounter the following argument against predictions of AGI catastrophes:
    Alice: We seem to be on track to build an AGI smarter than humans. We don’t know how to solve the technical problem of building an AGI we can control, or the political problem of convincing people to not build AGI. Every plausible scenario I’ve ever thought or heard of leads to AGI takeover. In my estimate, P(doom) is [high number].
    Bob: I disagree. It’s overconfident to estimate high P(doom). Humans are usually bad at predicting the future, especially when it comes to novel technologies like AGI. When you account for how uncertain your predictions are, your estimate should be at most [low number].”
    I'm being vague about the numbers because I've seen Bob's argument made in many different situations. In one recent conversation I witnessed, the Bob-Alice split was P(doom) 0.5% vs. ~10%, and in another discussion it was 10% vs. 90%.
    My main claim is that Alice and Bob don’t actually disagree about how uncertain or hard to predict the future is―instead, they disagree about to what degree AGI risk is default-success vs. default-failure. If AGI risk is (mostly) default-failure, then uncertainty is a reason for pessimism rather than optimism, and Alice is right to predict failure.
    In this sense I think Bob is missing the point. Bob claims that Alice is not sufficiently uncertain about her AI predictions, or has not integrated her uncertainty into her estimate well enough. This is not necessarily true; it may just be that Alice’s uncertainty about her reasoning doesn't make her much more optimistic.
    Instead of trying to refute Alice from general principles, I think Bob should instead point to concrete reasons for optimism (for example, Bob could say “for reasons A, B, and C it is likely that we can coordinate on not building AGI for the next 40 years and solve alignment in the meantime”).
    Uncertainty does not mean you should be more optimistic
    Many people are ...
    12 min
  • LW - Short Remark on the (subjective) mathematical 'naturalness' of the Nanda--Lieberum addition modulo 113 algorithm by Spencer Becker-Kahn
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Short Remark on the (subjective) mathematical 'naturalness' of the Nanda--Lieberum addition modulo 113 algorithm, published by Spencer Becker-Kahn on June 1, 2023 on LessWrong.
    These remarks are basically me just wanting to get my thoughts down after a Twitter exchange on this subject. I've not spent much time on this post and it's certainly plausible that I've gotten things wrong.In the 'Key Takeaways' section of the Modular Addition part of the well-known post 'A Mechanistic Interpretability Analysis of Grokking' , Nanda and Lieberum write:
    This algorithm operates via using trig identities and Discrete Fourier Transforms to map x,ycos(w(x+y)),sin(w(x+y)), and then extracting x+y(modp)
    And
    The model is trained to map x,y to z≡x+y(mod113) (henceforth 113 is referred to as p)
    But the casual reader should use caution! It is in fact the case that "Inputs x,y are given as one-hot encoded vectors in Rp ". This point is of course emphasized more in the full notebook (it has to be, that's where the code is), and the arXiv paper that followed is also much clearer about this point. However, when giving brief takeaways from the work, especially when it comes to discussing how 'natural' the learned algorithm is, I would go as far as saying that it is actually misleading to suggest that the network is literally given x and y as inputs. It is not trained to 'act' on the numbers x, y themselves. When thinking seriously about why the network is doing the particular thing that it is doing at the mechanistic level, I would want to emphasize that one-hotting is already a significant transformation. You have moved away from having the number x be represented by its own magnitude.
    You instead have a situation in which x and y now really live 'in the domain' (its almost like a dual point of view: The number x is not the size of the signal, but the position at which the input signal is non-zero). So, while I of course fully admit that I too am looking at it through my own subjective lens, one might say that (before the embedding happens) it is more mathematically natural to think that what the network is 'seeing' as input is something like the indicator functions t↦1x(t) and t↦1y(t). Here, t is something like the 'token variable' in the sense that these are functions on the vocabulary. And if we essentially ignore the additional tokens for | and =, we can think that these are functions on the group Z/pZ and that we would like the network to learn to produce the function t↦1x+y(t) at its output neurons.In particular, this point of view further (and perhaps almost completely) demystifies the use of the Fourier basis.
    Notice that the operation you want to learn is manifestly a convolution operation, i.e.
    And (as I distinctly remember being made to practically chant in an 'Analysis of Boolean Functions' class given by Tom Sanders) the Fourier Transform is the (essentially unique) change of basis that simultaneously diagonalizes all convolution operations. This is coming close to saying something like: There is one special basis that makes the operation you want to learn uniquely easy to do using matrix multiplications, and that basis is the Fourier basis.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • LW - Work dumber not smarter by lukehmiles
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Work dumber not smarter, published by lukehmiles on June 1, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Is the 12th virtue incompatible with everything else?
    Working smarter is about prioritizing, planning, allocating time & energy, strategizing, and results. See eg Humans are not automatically strategic
    Working dumber is going brrr
    One of the best long-distance runners in the world had part of her brain removed and cannot read a map and frequently goes the wrong direction
    In the service industry it seems like good (co)workers are pretty much just doing the right thing quickly all the time. Rarely see them make a plan or anything. Even in a brand new environment or situation. Even a talented young person with no experience.
    "Just take a love-minus-hate activation and add that to the prompt activation" sounds like an absolute newb idea. I like that idea but if I were trying to find the expert in a room then that statement would've disqualified them.
    ReLU activation is the stupidest ML idea I've ever heard; everyone knows sigmoid um somehow feels optimal you know it is a real function from like real math. (ReLU only survived because it got a ridiculous acronym word thing and sounds complicated so you feel smart.)
    The best drivers literally just like drive lmao. I know some folks who are very very aware on the road: they know who passed who and when, who is on a phone, where the cops are, etc but they cannot just chill out and stop swerving and braking.
    I know >5 good cooks who add ingredients they want until the food is good. I've only met one who can grok a recipe from a book and execute.
    Costs
    All my good work was bad for my career and all my bad work was good for my career. Five different jobs I had with five different bosses:
    During my most productive six months of software dev, my coworkers did not notice I existed because my code worked perfectly. I asked no questions because I knew what to do. I did not bounce any ideas around. I was an apt install to them. I did like a quarter of the total work on multi-million 10-person project and finished everything in my year-long contract several months early. When it ended I was not offered further employment.
    I was a ticket-answering machine on this useless-seeming giant repo I didn't understand. Everything was triaged and so on. I mentioned to my boss that I didn't feel very productive and I wasn't sure what to do. He said my work was above expectations and he went on to help me multiple times in my career. I still do not know what that repo even did.
    For one professor in college I was always philosophizing and asking hard questions and so on but hardly got any work done in two years. She thought I was hot shit and has gone on to help me in numerous ways.
    For another professor I came in to his dying $5M project the summer before the end date and brought my friend in and we kept our heads down and saved the entire fucking thing in two months. This is not an exaggeration. I was paid $10/hour and my request to get a raise to $15/hour was denied. He did not offer me other work or research projects.
    There was one guy at my company who was always grumpy and did all the work. There was another who was always very talkative and strategic. The strategies never manifested of course. The former was fired and the latter still works there.
    Yes the most important thing is often obvious and doing it makes you look simple unless you smartify that simplicity somehow. This ties into a broader challenge:
    Extraneous complexity attractors
    A simple problem-framing with a simple solution has some emotional and social disadvantages against a complex problem with a detailed, piecemeal solution (familiar things):
    Pain concentration: redoing the roof costs more right now than patching the latest leak
    Semantic satiation: "Sure yeah all the political problems boil down to ...
    6 min
  • LW - The challenge of articulating tacit knowledge by NinaR
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The challenge of articulating tacit knowledge, published by NinaR on May 31, 2023 on LessWrong.
    I enjoy eating high-quality baked goods. When visiting a new place, I often spend many hours walking around town, scouting out the best bakeries. In London, where I live, I have explored the whole city, trying to find the best pain au chocolat (Jolene), seeded sourdough loaf (E5), babka (Margot), banana bread (Violet), cheese pretzel (Sourdough Sophia), and many other specific things. By now, I can take one glance at a bakery or cafe, in person or online, and be confident whether or not their baked goods will be to my taste before trying them. However, I'm not good at explaining my flash judgments on bakeries or helping others improve at bakery quality prediction - why?
    This is an example of the more general problem of communicating tacit knowledge and intuitions. Whether explaining what makes good writing, teaching someone to cook well, or describing how to look for mathematical proofs, it is challenging to articulate the many heuristics and automatic thought processes that build up after sufficient experience and deliberate practice.
    However, it's not worth abandoning attempts to communicate such things altogether - succeeding can significantly accelerate another's skill development, reducing the need for time-consuming trial-and-error approaches. To this end, the first stage is acknowledging why you're having trouble articulating some knowledge. Then, once you have identified why you cannot easily verbalize your tacit knowledge, there are various strategies you can use to overcome the barrier, that is, if you decide you want to do so.
    I broadly break down why sharing tacit knowledge is hard into six categories: Complexity, Linguistic Constraints, The Curse of Knowledge, Personal Context-Dependence, Fear of Criticism, and Automaticity.
    Complexity
    Tacit knowledge often involves a complex combination of heuristics, variables, and computations that may be challenging to convey succinctly. For instance, a seasoned paramedic responding to a critical situation will rely on many cues, such as the patient's breathing patterns, skin color, heart rate, and subjective symptoms, to quickly diagnose the problem and provide immediate care. This paramedic's ability to rapidly assess and react to the situation comes from years of hands-on experience and intuition developed over countless emergencies. Conveying this intricate skill set to a novice paramedic is challenging due to the many variables involved.
    To overcome the challenge of complexity, it can be effective to break down the knowledge into smaller sub-components. This approach could involve narrating specific instances where you used your intuition or skill to decide, providing concrete examples of how the process works. For example, the experienced paramedic could start by sharing basic cues they look for in common emergencies such as heart attacks or strokes. They could describe the specific indicators they observe, like facial drooping, arm weakness, and speech difficulties in stroke victims, or chest pain, shortness of breath, and nausea in heart attack victims. They could also detail how they gather these observations quickly and systematically when arriving on the scene of an emergency.
    Linguistic Constraints
    Some forms of tacit knowledge are nearly impossible to articulate in language. For example, describing how to ride a bicycle to someone else in words is problematic because this knowledge is deeply ingrained in our motor skills rather than simply expressed in words.
    To overcome linguistic constraints, one must often "show, not tell" via demonstrations, visuals, and hands-on experience. For instance, teaching someone to ride a bicycle requires less talk and more physical demonstration and guided practice.
    The Curse of...
    9 min
  • EA - Global Innovation Fund projects its impact to be 3x GiveWell Top Charities by jh
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Global Innovation Fund projects its impact to be 3x GiveWell Top Charities, published by jh on June 1, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    The Global Innovation Fund (GIF) is a non-profit, impact-first investment fund headquartered in London that primarily works with mission-aligned development agencies (USAID, SIDA, Global Affairs Canada, UKAID). Through grants, loans and equity investments, they back innovations with the potential for social impact at a large scale, whether these are new technologies, business models, policy practices or behavioural insights.
    Recently, they made a bold but little publicized projection in their 2022 Impact Report (page 18): "We project every dollar that GIF has invested to date will be three times as impactful as if that dollar had been spent on long-lasting, insecticide-treated bednets... This is three times higher than the impact per dollar of Givewell’s top-rated charities, including distribution of anti-malarial insecticide-treated bednets. By Givewell’s estimation, their top charities are 10 times as cost-effective as cash transfers." The report says they have invested $112m since 2015.
    This is a short post to highlight GIF's projection to the EA community and to invite comments and reactions.Here are a few initial points:
    It's exciting to see an organization with relatively traditional funders comparing its impact to GiveWell's top charities (as well as cash transfers).
    I would want to see more information on how they did their calculations before taking a view on their projection.
    In any case, based on my conversations with GIF, and what I've understood about their methodology, I think their projection should be taken seriously. I can see many ways it could be either an overestimate or an underestimate.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    2 min
  • EA - Beyond Cost-Effectiveness: Insights for Effective Altruism from Health Economics by TomDrake
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Beyond Cost-Effectiveness: Insights for Effective Altruism from Health Economics, published by TomDrake on June 1, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Hi Everyone - partly inspired by attending the recent EA Global London conference a couple of weeks ago, I've written a CGD Blog with some thoughts on EA's approach to prioritisation and methods in health economics (specifically Health Technology Assessment). This is a link post and as CGD staff I have to post on our platform, but since the key target audience is EAs, I'd be delighted to hear thoughts from this community. I'll be sure to monitor the comments section and perhaps the discussion will feed into future work.
    The differences between EA and health econ I highlight include:1. Approaches generalising cost-effectiveness evidence 2. Going beyond cost-effectiveness in determining value3. Deliberative appraisal4. Institutionalisation of a participatory process
    Please click through for the full blog.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org
    2 min
  • EA - Taxing Tobacco: the intervention that got away (happy World No Tobacco Day) by Yelnats T.J.
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Taxing Tobacco: the intervention that got away (happy World No Tobacco Day), published by Yelnats T.J. on June 1, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    TL;DR
    The death toll of tobacco dwarfs traditional EA global health focuses (e.g. Malaria).
    Taxing tobacco is the most effective and yet most neglected form of reducing tobacco consumption.
    Multiple EA orgs have ran cost-effectiveness numbers that would put a tobacco taxation NGO on GiveWell’s list (both in expected value and contingent on success) and even at the top in some cases.
    Despite this, no enduring tobacco-taxation advocacy organization has emerged from EA (which would be the only advocacy organization in the world exclusively dedicated to tobacco taxation)
    Join Joel Tan (Founder of CEARCH) and J.T. Stanley, who as incubatees of Charity Entrepreneurship closely examined tobacco taxation, on June 10th (Saturday) at 14:00 UTC for a virtual discussion about the intervention and what’s next to make it a reality.
    Thanks to Moritz von Knebel for providing feedback on the draft.
    Yes, I cite WHO a lot. Not all WHO citations are the same WHO link FYI.
    Problem space
    Tobacco kills over 8 million individuals a year—that’s 13x Malaria (WHO) (CDC).
    Another way of framing it: annually more people are killed by tobacco usage than malaria, HIV, and neonatal deaths combined. twice over. And while the death toll of the latter three has been decreasing over time, death from tobacco is increasing.
    Of the 8 million deaths, 1.2 million are bystanders killed from secondhand smoking (WHO).
    Facts not related to death:
    Tobacco consumption displaces productive forms of spending. Tobacco consumes 1.5 to 17% (with a rough median around 4.5%) of a person’s income depending on country and socioeconomic status (table of results) (de Beyer et al., 2001). Spending on tobacco typically displaces spending on education and nutrition in low-income households (John, 2008) (Nonnemaker and Sur, 2007) (Pu et al., 2008).
    For example, smoking households spent 46% less on education than non-smoking households in surveyed townships in rural China (Wang et al., 2006). Another study states, “Average male cigarette smokers [in Bangladesh] spend more than twice as much on cigarettes as per capita expenditure on clothing, housing, health and education combined” (Efroymson et al., 2001).
    Smoking decreases productivity (Tobacconomics, 2019) (Halpern et al., 2001). One study in the United States found that it cost 1,807 USD per year per smoker in lost productivity compared to non-smokers (Bunn III et al., 2006).
    Tobacco increases individual healthcare costs (Tobacconomics, 2019). A study in China found that individual medical spending attributable to smoking increased the poverty rate by 1.5% in urban areas and 0.7% in rural areas (Liu et al., 2006).
    Tobacco strains the healthcare sector and taxpayers foot the bill (Wunsch and Brodie, 2021) (Tobacconomics, 2019).
    The annual costs of tobacco from healthcare expenditures and losses in productivity are 1.8% of the world GDP, breaking down to 1.1% to 1.7% of LMICs’ GDPs (Goodchild et al., 2018) (Tobacconomics, 2019).
    One last fact: without intervention, tobacco is on track to kill a billion individuals during the 21st century (WHO, 2008) (Savedoff and Alwang, 2015) (Jha, 2012).
    The intervention
    The scientific literature on tobacco consumption is lengthy. The interventions that have the most significant effect on reducing tobacco consumption have been formalized in WHO’s MPOWER framework (Kaleta et al., 2009).
    Of the MPOWER tobacco control measures, taxing tobacco has been demonstrated consistently in the scientific literature to the be the most effective intervention (WHO) (NIH).
    Taxing tobacco has a price elasticity around -0.5, meaning that for a 10% increase in retail price of tobacco, consumption decreases by 5%...
    13 min