The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - Announcing Apollo Research by Marius Hobbhahn
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing Apollo Research, published by Marius Hobbhahn on May 30, 2023 on LessWrong.
    TL;DR
    We are a new AI evals research organization called Apollo Research based in London.
    We think that strategic AI deception – where a model outwardly seems aligned but is in fact misaligned – is a crucial step in many major catastrophic AI risk scenarios and that detecting deception in real-world models is the most important and tractable step to addressing this problem.
    Our agenda is split into interpretability and behavioral evals:
    On the interpretability side, we are currently working on two main research bets toward characterizing neural network cognition. We are also interested in benchmarking interpretability, e.g. testing whether given interpretability tools can meet specific requirements or solve specific challenges.
    On the behavioral evals side, we plan to build up a full-stack suite of evaluations for deception and other misaligned behavior consisting of behavioral, finetuning, and interpretability-based methods.
    As an evals research org, we intend to use our research insights and tools directly on frontier models by serving as an external auditor of AGI labs, thus reducing the chance that deceptively misaligned AIs are developed and deployed.
    We also intend to engage with AI governance efforts, e.g. by working with policymakers and providing technical expertise to aid the drafting of auditing regulations.
    We have starter funding but estimate a $1.4M funding gap in our first year. We estimate that the maximal amount we could effectively use is $4-6M in addition to current funding levels (reach out if you are interested in donating). We are currently fiscally sponsored by Rethink Priorities.
    Our starting team consists of 8 researchers and engineers with strong backgrounds in technical alignment research.
    We are interested in collaborating with both technical and governance researchers. Feel free to reach out at [email protected].
    We intend to hire once our funding gap is closed. If you’d like to stay informed about opportunities, you can fill out our expression of interest form.
    Research Agenda
    We believe that AI deception – where a model outwardly seems aligned but is in fact misaligned and conceals this fact from human oversight – is a crucial component of many catastrophic risk scenarios from AI (see here for more). We also think that detecting/measuring deception is causally upstream of many potential solutions. For example, having good detection tools enables higher quality and safer feedback loops for empirical alignment approaches, enables us to point to concrete failure modes for lawmakers and the wider public, and provides evidence to AGI labs whether the models they are developing or deploying are deceptively misaligned.
    Ultimately, we aim to develop a holistic and far-ranging suite of deception evals that includes behavioral tests, fine-tuning, and interpretability-based approaches. Unfortunately, we think that interpretability is not yet at the stage where it can be used effectively on state-of-the-art models. Therefore, we have split the agenda into an interpretability research arm and a behavioral evals arm. We aim to eventually combine interpretability and behavioral evals into a comprehensive model evaluation suite.
    On the interpretability side, we are currently working on a new unsupervised approach and continuing work on an existing approach to attack the problem of superposition. Early experiments have shown promising results, but it is too early to tell if the techniques work robustly or are scalable to larger models. Our main priority, for now, is to scale up the experiments and ‘fail fast’ so we can either double down or cut our losses. Furthermore, we are interested in benchmarking interpretability techniques by testing whether given tools me...
    14 min
  • AF - Boomerang - protocol to dissolve some commitment races by Filip Sondej
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Boomerang - protocol to dissolve some commitment races, published by Filip Sondej on May 30, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Work done during SERI MATS 3.0 with mentorship from Jesse Cliffton. Huge thanks for all the feedback and discussions to Anthony DiGiovanni, Daniel Kokotajlo, Martín Soto, and Rubi J. Hudson! Also posted to EA forum.
    Daniel's post about commitment races motivates why they may be a severe problem. Here, I'll describe a concrete protocol that if adopted, would let us avoid some cases of miscoordination caused by them.
    TL;DR
    The key ingredient is having a mandatory time delay, during which the commitments aren't yet binding. At the end of that delay, you decide whether to make your commitment binding or revert it, and this decision can be conditional on previous decisions of other participants. This in itself would give rise to new races, but it can be managed by adding some additional rules.
    I think the biggest challenge would be to convince the "commitment infrastructure" (which I describe below) to adopt such a protocol.
    Benefits
    In the case of the game of chicken, the 3 rules listed below should often push whoever committed later to Swerve.
    In simple games like chicken it may be achieved easier, just by relying on conditional commitments (“If I came second, I Swerve”). But here we add another mechanism: tentative commitment period, which gives us another nice feature:
    In the real world it can be not so obvious that some commitments are incompatible. The tentative period gives the agents time to analyze the situation in depth and check if any commitments are clashing. This is especially useful in highly multipolar cases where multiple parties try to commit at the same time or where actions have complex consequences and interactions.
    We also don't need to know in advance all the actions the others can take - we can analyze their actions after they've already tentatively committed to them.
    Even if participants manage to coordinate (so one Dares and one Swerves), the solution found hastily during a commitment race can still be quite poor. Boomerang enables bargaining that can Pareto improve on this hasty solution.
    Necessary ingredients
    The protocol relies on some mechanism M on which agents can make commitments - a "commitment infrastructure". M could be something like the Ethereum network, or some powerful international body.
    We require that:
    When someone publishes a commitment, M arrives at a consensus about the time at which the commitment was published.
    It’s more convenient/cheap/credible to do some commitments on M that outside of it.
    2. is needed because the protocol relies on certain commitments being forbidden. Agents could decide to do those forbidden commitments outside of M, so we need to make that as hard as possible for them, compared to committing on M. I think this is the hardest part of the whole proposal. M would need to be locked into place by a network effect - everyone is using M because everyone else is using M.
    Protocol
    Here are the rules:
    R1: All commitments have a mandatory tentative period, meaning that they only become binding after some fixed time T (we can say that freeze_time = publish_time + T).
    So you have no way to make a commitment credible before freeze_time (if you were allowed to end the tentative period, we would create a new race to end the tentative period as soon as possible).
    R2: During the tentative period, you can still decide to revert your commitment.
    Somewhere before the freeze_time you send to M your final decision (whether you revert or not), but hashed.
    You also need to add random salt to your decision before hashing, so that it cannot be revealed through brute-forcing.
    After freeze_time you reveal the decision (and it must match the previously sent hash, otherwise M would reject your commitment).
    So...
    15 min
  • AF - Announcing Apollo Research by Marius Hobbhahn
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing Apollo Research, published by Marius Hobbhahn on May 30, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    TL;DR
    We are a new AI evals research organization called Apollo Research based in London.
    We think that strategic AI deception – where a model outwardly seems aligned but is in fact misaligned – is a crucial step in many major catastrophic AI risk scenarios and that detecting deception in real-world models is the most important and tractable step to addressing this problem.
    Our agenda is split into interpretability and behavioral evals:
    On the interpretability side, we are currently working on two main research bets toward characterizing neural network cognition. We are also interested in benchmarking interpretability, e.g. testing whether given interpretability tools can meet specific requirements or solve specific challenges.
    On the behavioral evals side, we are conceptually breaking down ‘deception’ into measurable components in order to build a detailed evaluation suite using prompt- and finetuning-based tests.
    As an evals research org, we intend to use our research insights and tools directly on frontier models by serving as an external auditor of AGI labs, thus reducing the chance that deceptively misaligned AIs are developed and deployed.
    We also intend to engage with AI governance efforts, e.g. by working with policymakers and providing technical expertise to aid the drafting of auditing regulations.
    We have starter funding but estimate a $1.4M funding gap in our first year. We estimate that the maximal amount we could effectively use is $4-6M in addition to current funding levels (reach out if you are interested in donating). We are currently fiscally sponsored by Rethink Priorities.
    Our starting team consists of 8 researchers and engineers with strong backgrounds in technical alignment research.
    We are interested in collaborating with both technical and governance researchers. Feel free to reach out at [email protected].
    We intend to hire once our funding gap is closed. If you’d like to stay informed about opportunities, you can fill out our expression of interest form.
    Research Agenda
    We believe that AI deception – where a model outwardly seems aligned but is in fact misaligned and conceals this fact from human oversight – is a crucial component of many catastrophic risk scenarios from AI (see here for more). We also think that detecting/measuring deception is causally upstream of many potential solutions. For example, having good detection tools enables higher quality and safer feedback loops for empirical alignment approaches, enables us to point to concrete failure modes for lawmakers and the wider public, and provides evidence to AGI labs whether the models they are developing or deploying are deceptively misaligned.
    Ultimately, we aim to develop a holistic and far-ranging suite of deception evals that includes behavioral tests, fine-tuning, and interpretability-based approaches. Unfortunately, we think that interpretability is not yet at the stage where it can be used effectively on state-of-the-art models. Therefore, we have split the agenda into an interpretability research arm and a behavioral evals arm. We aim to eventually combine interpretability and behavioral evals into a comprehensive model evaluation suite.
    On the interpretability side, we are currently working on a new unsupervised approach and continuing work on an existing approach to attack the problem of superposition. Early experiments have shown promising results, but it is too early to tell if the techniques work robustly or are scalable to larger models. Our main priority, for now, is to scale up the experiments and ‘fail fast’ so we can either double down or cut our losses. Furthermore, we are interested in benchmarking interpretability techniques by testing whether given tools ...
    14 min
  • LW - Reply to a fertility doctor concerning polygenic embryo screening by GeneSmith
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Reply to a fertility doctor concerning polygenic embryo screening, published by GeneSmith on May 29, 2023 on LessWrong.
    New LessWrong user grll_nrg, a fertility doctor, left a comment on my post about how to have polygenically screened children that brought up many of the common objections raised to polygenic embryo screening. I've heard these concerns brought up many times at conferences and in talks by professionals in the fertility industry. I thought other people might be interested in the discussion, so I decide to make a stand-alone post.
    Here's grll_nrg's original comment:
    Great post. Thank you. Fertility doctor here and a supporter of ART (assisted reproductive technologies) in general. A few thoughts (although you touched on a few of these below, worth emphasizing in my opinion):
    PGT-P has not been validated yet, which may take decades to do, if ever.
    The science in terms of GWAS isn't quite there yet IMHO - we don't know all the genes that are important for most traits and we may be inadvertently selecting against some desirable traits, for example.
    Comparing clinic success rates using CDC data is imperfect because of different patient characteristics, patient selection, and reporting bias.
    IVF pregnancies carry a significantly higher complication rate (hypertensive disorders, preterm birth, placental abnormalities, etc.) compared to spontaneous pregnancies - unclear if this is due to IVF or underlying infertility diagnosis.
    The risk-benefit calculus of PGT-P is going to be different for a couple who already needs to do IVF anyway to have a baby (low additional risk/cost) compared to a couple doing IVF just so that they can do PGT-P (higher additional risk/cost).
    IVF is notoriously inefficient at present. Depending on female partner age, each cycle may yield only very few embryos making the benefit and utility of PGT-P limited. It may not be practical, safe, or financially feasible to do multiple cycles of IVF to increase the cohort of transferable embryos.
    IVF is expensive and often not covered by insurance which creates access disparities. PGT-P would exacerbate these disparities in access. This is not unique to IVF I realize.
    Slippery-slope eugenics and discrimination are real ethical concerns that would need to be mitigated.
    In-vitro gametogenesis (IVG) would be a game-changer. The utility of PGT-P would be greatly enhanced if suddenly you had thousands of eggs and hundreds of embryos to select from.
    Thanks for the reply. I'm glad professionals from the ART field are reading this.
    PGT-P has not been validated yet, which may take decades to do, if ever.
    I think the ART field should probably reconsider what it considers acceptable evidence of "validation". In my mind, the question of "Has PGT-P been validated" should hinge on whether or not we can be confident that embryos selected via polygenic scores will display different trait values than those selected at random. For example, we want to know whether an embryo that has a low polygenic risk score for hypertension will indeed go on to develop hypertension at a lower rate.
    All the people I've heard criticize PGT-P seem to think that the ONLY way to do this is with some kind of randomized control where some embryos with certain polygenic risk scores are implanted and others are not, and we then wait 20-70 years to see whether or not the polygenically screened group develops diseases at a different rate than the control group. I think this view is incorrect and is only taken because people are blindly applying traditional validation methodology to PGT-P without asking whether it is necessary.
    Genes have a very special property that gives us a huge advantage over researchers trying to test whether or not a medication works; nature has already conducted a randomized control trial for us!
    From the section in ...
    14 min
  • EA - Statement on AI Extinction - Signed by AGI Labs, Top Academics, and Many Other Notable Figures by Center for AI Safety
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Statement on AI Extinction - Signed by AGI Labs, Top Academics, and Many Other Notable Figures, published by Center for AI Safety on May 30, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Today, the AI Extinction Statement was released by the Center for AI Safety, a one-sentence statement jointly signed by a historic coalition of AI experts, professors, and tech leaders.
    Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio have signed, as have the CEOs of the major AGI labs–Sam Altman, Demis Hassabis, and Dario Amodei–as well as executives from Microsoft and Google (but notably not Meta).
    The statement reads: “Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.”
    We hope this statement will bring AI x-risk further into the overton window and open up discussion around AI’s most severe risks. Given the growing number of experts and public figures who take risks from advanced AI seriously, we hope to improve epistemics by encouraging discussion and focusing public and international attention toward this issue.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • AF - Statement on AI Extinction - Signed by AGI Labs, Top Academics, and Many Other Notable Figures by Dan H
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Statement on AI Extinction - Signed by AGI Labs, Top Academics, and Many Other Notable Figures, published by Dan H on May 30, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Today, the AI Extinction Statement was released by the Center for AI Safety, a one-sentence statement jointly signed by a historic coalition of AI experts, professors, and tech leaders.
    Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio have signed, as have the CEOs of the major AGI labs–Sam Altman, Demis Hassabis, and Dario Amodei–as well as executives from Microsoft and Google (but notably not Meta).
    The statement reads: “Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.”
    We hope this statement will bring AI x-risk further into the overton window and open up discussion around AI’s most severe risks. Given the growing number of experts and public figures who take risks from advanced AI seriously, we hope to improve epistemics by encouraging discussion and focusing public and international attention toward this issue.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - List of Masters Programs in Tech Policy, Public Policy and Security (Europe) by sarahfurstenberg
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: List of Masters Programs in Tech Policy, Public Policy and Security (Europe), published by sarahfurstenberg on May 29, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We created this non-exhaustive List which was inspired and based on Konstantins personal research into Masters programmes. We expanded it with the help of others across the policy community. It was created for the 2023 cohort of fellows of the EU Tech Policy Fellowship hosted by Training for Good and includes a list of Masters in Europe, the UK and the US. CLICK HERE for the list.
    Limitations and Epistemic Status
    The list is based on personal experience, research, and limited feedback from others in the community.
    It is curated from a European perspective. Thus, the numbers and deadlines take European/EEA citizens as a reference point. Furthermore, whilst Masters from Europe, the UK and the US are listed, we have focussed on researching Masters in Europe. The latter lists are currently very incomplete.
    It's important to emphasise that this list is not exhaustive and may not represent all options of Masters in this Field.
    Additionally, the quality and relevance of each program may vary depending on individual needs, goals, and interests.
    Therefore, we recommended that individuals interested in pursuing a career in tech policy or policy in general conduct their own research, explore various programs, and consider multiple sources of information before making a decision! Ultimately, the decision to pursue a particular graduate program should be based on a thorough evaluation of individual goals, resources, and circumstances.
    What this post is not
    This post does not outline what to study and what to aim for in choosing your Masters Degree. It is supposed to help people who have already decided that they want to pursue a Masters in Tech Policy, Security Studies or Public Policy but does not mean to imply that these are your only or even best options if you want to enter the Tech Policy field. A possibly safer and more classical approach of entering EU policy is to study basic law and economics subjects as they still hold a high standing across departments and fields in policy (See this article on “Joining the EU bubble”). This would also give you more flexible career capital than tech policy degrees.
    To elaborate on these different paths a detailed post (such this one) outlining what to aim for in your studies if you want to contribute to tech policy, would be incredibly valuable and we encourage you to write this up and share your perspective if you have spent some time thinking about this!
    Created for who?
    This list is aimed at people interested in working in public policy (especially in Europe) and in tech policy with a potential to specialise in AI but only provides a very narrow selection of options. Degrees with "tech" or "AI'' related words in the name are helpful to quickly signal your relevance on these topics. Many of the Masters in this list are geared towards people with a non-technical undergraduate degree in social sciences, economics etc. Thus, it excludes many Masters on Artificial Intelligence and Tech Policy that require you to have had a Computer Sciences or technical background. We wanted to share the list to help with some of the preliminary research in choosing a Masters programme.
    The inclusion of Security Studies Masters programmes comes from the argument that it seems like a viable path from which to enter inter/national think tanks or institutions working on relevant AI policy without having technical specialisations beforehand.
    Other considerations
    Besides studying in Europe, studying in the US can be a great and high-impact option since many degrees are both highly regarded in Europe as well as allowing you to potentially work in US policy. We highly encourage you to read this post on worki...
    6 min
  • LW - Sentience matters by So8res
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Sentience matters, published by So8res on May 29, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Short version: Sentient lives matter; AIs can be people and people shouldn't be owned (and also the goal of alignment is not to browbeat AIs into doing stuff we like that they'd rather not do; it's to build them de-novo to care about valuable stuff).
    Context: Writing up obvious points that I find myself repeating.
    Stating the obvious:
    All sentient lives matter.
    Yes, including animals, insofar as they're sentient (which is possible in at least some cases).
    Yes, including AIs, insofar as they're sentient (which is possible in at least some cases).
    Yes, even including sufficiently-detailed models of sentient creatures (as I suspect could occur frequently inside future AIs). (People often forget this one.)
    There's some ability-to-feel-things that humans surely have, and that cartoon drawings don't have, even if the cartoons make similar facial expressions.
    Not knowing exactly what the thing is, nor exactly how to program it, doesn't undermine the fact that it matters.
    If we make sentient AIs, we should consider them people in their own right, and shouldn't treat them as ownable slaves.
    Old-school sci-fi was basically morally correct on this point, as far as I can tell.
    Separately but relatedly:
    The goal of alignment research is not to grow some sentient AIs, and then browbeat or constrain them into doing things we want them to do even as they'd rather be doing something else.
    The point of alignment research (at least according to my ideals) is that when you make a mind de novo, then what it ultimately cares about is something of a free parameter, which we should set to "good stuff".
    My strong guess is that AIs won't by default care about other sentient minds, and fun broadly construed, and flourishing civilizations, and love, and that it also won't care about any other stuff that's deeply-alien-and-weird-but-wonderful.
    But we could build it to care about that stuff--not coerce it, not twist its arm, not constrain its actions, but just build another mind that cares about the grand project of filling the universe with lovely things, and that joins us in that good fight.
    And we should.
    (I consider questions of what sentience really is, or consciousness, or whether AIs can be conscious, to be off-topic for this post, whatever their merit; I hereby warn you that I might delete such comments here.)
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • LW - Wikipedia as an introduction to the alignment problem by SoerenMind
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Wikipedia as an introduction to the alignment problem, published by SoerenMind on May 29, 2023 on LessWrong.
    AI researchers and others are increasingly looking for an introduction to the alignment problem that is clearly written, credible, and supported by evidence and real examples. The Wikipedia article on AI Alignment has become such an introduction.
    Link:
    Aside from me, it has contributions from Mantas Mazeika, Gavin Leech, Richard Ngo, Thomas Woodside (CAIS), Sidney Hough (CAIS), other Wikipedia contributors, and copy editor Amber Ace. It also had extensive feedback from this community.
    In the last month, it had ~20k unique readers and was cited by Yoshua Bengio.
    We've tried hard to keep the article accessible for non-technical readers while also making sense to AI researchers.
    I think Wikipedia is a useful format because it can include videos and illustrations (unlike papers) and it is more credible than blog posts. However, Wikipedia has strict rules and could be changed by anyone.
    Note that we've announced this effort on the Wikipedia talk page and shared public drafts to let other editors give feedback and contribute.
    I you edit the article, please keep in mind Wikipedia's rules, use reliable sources, and consider that we've worked hard to keep it concise because most Wikipedia readers spend <1 minute on the page. For the latter goal, it helps to focus on edits that reduce or don't increase length. To give feedback, feel free to post on the talk page or message me. Translations would likely be impactful.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Obstacles to the Implementation of Indoor Air Quality Improvements by JesseSmith
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Obstacles to the Implementation of Indoor Air Quality Improvements, published by JesseSmith on May 29, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    1. Tl;dr
    Many reports indicate that indoor air quality (IAQ) interventions are likely to be effective at reducing respiratory disease transmission. However, to date there’s been very little focus on the workforce that will implement these interventions. I suggest that the US Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) and building maintenance workforces have already posed a significant obstacle to these interventions, and broad uptake of IAQ measures will be significantly hindered by them in the future. The impact will vary in predictable ways depending on the nature of the intervention and its implementation. We should favor simple techniques with improved oversight and outsource or crosscheck technically complex work to people outside of the current HVAC workforce. We should also make IAQ conditions and devices as transparent as possible to both experts and building occupants.
    To skip my bio and the technical horrors section, proceed to the recommendations in section 4.
    2. Who am I? Why do I think This? How Certain am I?
    I began working in construction in 1991. I did a formal carpentry apprenticeship in Victoria BC in the mid-90s and moved to the US in ‘99. Around 2008 I started taking greater interest in HVAC because - despite paying top dollar to local subcontractors - our projects had persistent HVAC problems. Despite protestations that they were following exemplary practices, our projects were plagued with high humidity, loud noise, frequent mechanical failure, and room-to-room temperature differences. This led me to first learn all aspects of system design and controls, and culminated in full system installations. Along the way I obtained a NJ Master HVAC license, performed the thermal work of ~2k light-duty energy retrofits, obtained multiple certifications in HVAC and low-energy design, and became a regional expert in building diagnostics. Since 2010 I’ve worked as a contractor or consultant to roughly a dozen major HVAC contractors and hundreds of homeowners.
    I’m reasonably certain that the baseline competence of the HVAC workforce is insufficient to broadly and reliably deploy IAQ interventions and that this is a serious obstacle. My comments are specific to the US. I’ve discussed these problems extensively with friends and acquaintances working at a national level and in other parts of the US and believe them to be common to most of the country. The problems are specific to the light commercial and residential workforce, but not domains that are closely monitored by mechanical engineering teams (e.g. hospitals). Based on some limited experience I suspect these problems are also common to Canada, but I’m less certain about their severity.
    3. Technical Horrors: Why is This so Difficult?
    Within HVAC, many important jobs are currently either not performed or delegated to people who are largely incapable of performing them. Many people convincingly lie about their capacity to perform a job they’re incapable of, report having done things they haven’t, or even make statements at odds with physics.
    Examples include:
    Accurate heat load/loss calculations: These are used to size heating and cooling systems, and in most areas are code mandated for both new and replacement systems. Competent sizing (Manual J for residential) is viewed as highly important by virtually all experts within HVAC. However, despite decades of investment in training and compliance, a lead technical manager of a clean energy program reported to me that >90% of Manual Js reviewed by his program had significant errors made apparent due to internal inconsistency (eg duct load on a hydronic system) or obvious inconsistencies with public information on zi...
    13 min