The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - RIP Bear Braumoeller by Stephen Clare
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: RIP Bear Braumoeller, published by Stephen Clare on May 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Professor Bear Braumoeller passed away earlier this week. Bear was a political scientist who studied the likelihood and causes of catastrophic wars. You may have read his book Only the Dead or heard his appearance on the 80,000 Hours podcast. For a short, recent example of his work I recommend this piece of his about the Russia-Ukraine war.
    Bear’s work on conflict likelihood, escalation, and catastrophic wars is certainly among the best research on major conflict risks. Only the Dead was an important counter to strong claims about the long-term declines in interstate violence. Bear found, in brief, that the data on war severity offer few reasons to think that the risk of huge wars (including much-larger-than-WWII-wars) has declined much. And this risk accumulates catastrophically over time.
    One of my favourite sentences from Bear is his darkly-humorous conclusion to a chapter on war severity (p. 130):
    When I sat down to write this conclusion, I briefly considered typing, “We’re all going to die,” and leaving it at that. I chose to write more, not because that conclusion is too alarmist, but because it’s not specific enough.
    Bear combined expertise in both statistical analysis and the theory of what causes war to great effect. He pushed forward our understanding of not just how the likelihood of major conflict has changed over time, but why. His work was interesting not just to political scientists but to anyone seeking to understand and reduce global risks.
    I’d corresponded with Bear frequently over the last two years while researching catastrophic conflict risks. He was generous and cared deeply about the social impact of his work. Despite my utter lack of credentials and experience, Bear gave me a lot of his time, advice, and connections to other researchers. In my experience academics rarely engage so meaningfully with outsiders. I was grateful.
    Bear’s interest in EA had been piqued and as far as I know he was planning to do more work on catastrophic risks. Last year his lab received a grant from the Future Fund for follow-up research on the themes he wrote about in Only the Dead.
    He is gone far too soon and will be missed.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - Please don’t vote brigade by Lizka
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Please don’t vote brigade, published by Lizka on May 5, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Once in a while, the moderators will find out that something like the following happened:
    Someone posted an update from their organization, and shared it on Slack or social media, asking coworkers and friends to go upvote it for increased visibility.
    Someone saw something they didn’t like on the Forum — maybe comments criticizing a friend, or a point of view they disagree with — and encouraged everyone in some discussion space to go downvote it.
    This is a form of vote brigading. It messes with karma’s ability to provide people with a signal of what to engage with and is against Forum norms.
    Please don’t do it. We might ban you for it.
    If you’re worried that someone else (or some other group) is engaging in vote brigading, bring it up to the moderators instead of trying to correct for it.
    Why is it bad?
    Karma is meant to provide a signal of what Forum users will find useful to engage with. Vote brigading turns karma into a popularity contest.
    Voting should be based on readers’ opinions of the content they’re voting on. If someone convinces you that a post is terrible — or great — it’s fine to downvote or upvote it as a result of that, but you should actually believe that.
    We should resolve disagreements by discussing them, not by comparing the sizes of the groups who agree with each position.
    If people try to hide criticism by downvoting it just because they feel an affinity to the group(s) criticized, the Forum will become predictably biased. We won’t have important conversations, we won’t learn from each others’ mistakes, etc.
    What actions should we avoid? (What counts as vote brigading?)
    If you’re sharing content:
    Don’t encourage people to all go upvote or downvote something (“everyone go upvote this!”) — especially when you have power over the people you’re talking to.
    It’s more ok to say “go upvote this if you think it’s good,” but it’s still borderline, and you should be careful to make sure that it doesn’t feel like pressure on people.
    Be careful with bias: if the content is criticizing your work, or your friend’s work, or something you feel an affinity towards — be suspicious of your ability to objectively engage with it.
    Consider letting other Forum users sort it out or leaving a comment explaining your point of view.
    If you’re voting:
    Please make sure you’re really voting because you think this content is good.
    If your friends or coworker shared their content and that’s the only thing you really engage with and vote on, interrogate your heart or mind about whether you might be biased.
    Please report attempts at vote brigading to us.
    Examples
    There are many borderline cases. Here are some examples, sorted by how fine/bad the action of person sharing the content is:
    The actionIs it ok to do?You share a post (and maybe what you like or dislike about it), without explicitly asking people to upvote or downvote.It’s fine (I’m very happy for people to straightforwardly share posts with people who might find them interesting)You share a post and what you like about it, and say something like “upvote the post if you like it”You share a post that criticizes your work, and write something like “downvote the post if you think it should have less visibility” Not ok — even though there’s an “if.”. Don’t do this, especially if you’re in a leadership role. You share a post and say something like “Everyone: go upvote the post!”Not ok. Once again, it’s even worse if you’re in a leadership role with respect to the people you’re sharing the post with.On a call with other people, and you say, “there’s this post I don’t like / a post that’s criticizing me/us. Could you all upvote / downvote it?”Extremely not ok.
    This has the added harm of making it easy for the asker to see if the other p...
    5 min
  • EA - Orgs & Individuals Should Spend ~1 Hour/Month Making More Introductions by Rockwell
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Orgs & Individuals Should Spend ~1 Hour/Month Making More Introductions, published by Rockwell on May 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Note: This is a post I've talked about writing for >6 months, so I'm giving myself 30 minutes to write and publish it. For context, I'm the full-time director of EA NYC, an organization dedicated to building and supporting the effective altruism community in and around New York City.
    Claim: More organizations and individuals should allot a small amount of time to a particularly high-value activity: 1-1 or 1-org introductions.
    Outside the scope of this post: I'm not going to make the case here for the value of connections. Many in the community already believe they are extremely valuable, e.g. they're the primary metric CEA uses for its events.
    Context: I frequently meet people who are deeply engaged in EA, have ended up at an EAG(x), work for an EA or EA-adjacent organization, or are otherwise exciting and active community members, but have no idea there are existing EA groups located in their city or university, focused on their profession, or coordinating across their cause area. When they do learn about these groups, they are often thrilled and eager to plug in. Many times, they've been engaging heavily with other community members who did know, and perhaps even once mentioned such in passing, but didn't think to make a direct introduction. For many, a direct introduction dramatically increases the likelihood of their actually engaging with another individual or organization. As a result, opportunities for valuable connections and community growth are missed.
    Introductions can be burdensome, but they don't have to be.
    80,000 Hours
    80,000 Hours' staff frequently directly connects me to individuals over email who are based in or near NYC, whether or not they've already advised them. In 2022, they sent over 30 emails that followed a format like this:
    Subject: Rocky [Name]
    Hi both,
    Rocky, meet [Name]. [Name] works in [Professional Field] and lives in [Location]. They're interested in [Career Change, Learning about ___ EA Topic, Connecting with Local EAs, Something Else]. Because of this, I thought it might be useful for [Name] to speak to you and others in the EA NYC community.
    [Name], meet Rocky. Rocky is Director of Effective Altruism NYC. Before that she did [Career Summary] and studied [My Degree]. Effective Altruism NYC works on helping connect and grow the community of New Yorkers who are looking to do the most good through: advising, socials, reading groups, and other activities. I thought she would be a good person for you to speak with about some next steps to get more involved with Effective Altruism.
    Hope you get to speak soon. Thanks!
    Best, [80K Staff Member]
    They typically link to our respected LinkedIn profiles.
    I then set up one-on-one calls with the individuals they connect me to and many subsequently become involved in EA NYC in various capacities.
    EA Virtual Programs
    EA Virtual Programs does something similar:
    Subject: [EA NYC] Your group has a new prospective member
    Hi,
    We are the EA Virtual Programs (EA VP) team. A recent EA Virtual Programs participant has expressed an interest in joining your Effective Altruism New York City group.
    Name: ____Email: ____Background Info: [Involvement in EA] [Profession] [Location] [LinkedIn]
    Note these connections come from the participants themselves, as they nominated they would like to get in touch with your group specifically in our exit survey.
    It would be wonderful for them to get a warm welcome to your group. Please do reach out to them in 1-2 weeks preferably. However, no worries if this is not a priority for you now.
    I hope these connections are valuable!
    Sincerely,EA Virtual Programs
    In both cases, the connector receives permission from both parties, something eas...
    5 min
  • LW - Advice for interacting with busy people by Severin T. Seehrich
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Advice for interacting with busy people, published by Severin T. Seehrich on May 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Over the last year, I have turned from somebody with a lot of time and relatively few social contacts to maintain into someone quite busy and well-networked. I'm by no means close to the top of the busyness hierarchy. But, I've climbed high enough to learn some lessons that I wish I knew before, when I had a lot of time and even more unearned confidence.
    So here you go for what I've found, so that you shall make wiser life decisions than my younger self.
    1. The time and attention of central information nodes is more valuable than ours. Let's not waste it.
    This is the one rule to rule them all - everything else I write here is just variations on it.
    For example: Let's assume world-leading AGI alignment researcher Paul Christiano has put extensive research into finding the optimal soap dispenser, not only in regards to functionality and aesthetics, but also in regards to price. I still shouldn't ask him which soap dispenser to buy.
    For even if he was the world-leading expert on buying cheap high-quality soap dispensers, it would be very unwise of me to waste one of his afternoons on a soap dispenser shopping tour. He is not the only one who could help me with that. And, the question which soap dispenser to pick for my bathroom is not very important in the first place. It would be unfortunate if we were to live in one of the branches of reality where humanity goes extinct because I wasted Paul Christiano's time on soap dispenser advice.
    And, I hope that Christiano thinks the same and would never talk to me again if I were to make such a request. For I, too, care about the survival of humanity, and would prefer others to stop me if I threaten it.
    2. Be swift and clear in your requests.
    In my undergrad years, I studied continental philosophy and classical philology and was very, very proud of the aesthetic quality of my writing. Thus, I annoyed many a professor with way too flowery and way too long walls of text that could have been one sentence. Some professors found me adorable, others didn't quite appreciate me eating pieces of their time that they could have spent on, say, Wittgenstein instead. So don't be me, keep things as concise and clear as possible.
    The complementary failure mode to sending busy people walls of text is giving so little info that they don't know why you reach out in the first place. I usually at least read long messages, though I may not respond. However, I tend to procrastinate responding to "Hi. How are you?" until I forget about it. I usually don't want to expend time on the dance of politeness before you tell me what you want, and it would feel too awkward to respond with a bold "What do you want?" Thus, I'll usually not respond at all and never even get the opportunity to decide whether I can make time for your request.
    3. In case of doubt, ask for resources and introductions, not opinions.
    One of the perks of being around for a while in any field is that over time, you get to know a ton of people, and that these people give you quick summaries of their favorite writings. So, I know a ton of people I could point you towards for all kinds of stuff, and I can recommend orders of magnitude more books to you than I have read myself. Writing lists of names and book titles is quick and easy, writing down my own opinions takes time and effort I, in case of doubt, can't and shouldn't afford.
    So, busy people are way more likely to respond positively if you ask them for a reading list or introductions than for other types of favors. Plus: Others judge us by the quality of the introductions we make. If you filibuster me with lengthy texts, or demand favors from me I can't really squeeze into my schedule, I might be very weary to introduce you to someo...
    6 min
  • LW - A brief collection of Hinton's recent comments on AGI risk by Kaj Sotala
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: A brief collection of Hinton's recent comments on AGI risk, published by Kaj Sotala on May 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Since I've seen some people doubt whether Geoff Hinton is actually concerned about AGI risk (as opposed to e.g. the NYT spinning an anti-tech agenda in their interview of him), I thought I'd put together a brief collection of his recent comments on the topic.
    Written interviews
    New York Times, May 1:
    Dr. Hinton said he has quit his job at Google, where he has worked for more than a decade and became one of the most respected voices in the field, so he can freely speak out about the risks of A.I. A part of him, he said, now regrets his life’s work. [...]
    Dr. Hinton [originally] thought [systems like ChatGPT were] a powerful way for machines to understand and generate language, but [...] inferior to the way humans handled language. [...]
    Then, last year [...] his view changed. He still believed the systems were inferior to the human brain in some ways but he thought they were eclipsing human intelligence in others. “Maybe what is going on in these systems,” he said, “is actually a lot better than what is going on in the brain.” [...]
    Down the road, he is worried that future versions of the technology pose a threat to humanity because they often learn unexpected behavior from the vast amounts of data they analyze. This becomes an issue, he said, as individuals and companies allow A.I. systems not only to generate their own computer code but actually run that code on their own. [...]
    “The idea that this stuff could actually get smarter than people — a few people believed that,” he said. “But most people thought it was way off. And I thought it was way off. I thought it was 30 to 50 years or even longer away. Obviously, I no longer think that.”
    Technology Review, May 2:
    People are also divided on whether the consequences of this new form of intelligence, if it exists, would be beneficial or apocalyptic. “Whether you think superintelligence is going to be good or bad depends very much on whether you’re an optimist or a pessimist,” he says. “If you ask people to estimate the risks of bad things happening, like what’s the chance of someone in your family getting really sick or being hit by a car, an optimist might say 5% and a pessimist might say it’s guaranteed to happen. But the mildly depressed person will say the odds are maybe around 40%, and they’re usually right.”
    Which is Hinton? “I’m mildly depressed,” he says. “Which is why I’m scared.” [...]
    ... even if a bad actor doesn’t seize the machines, there are other concerns about subgoals, Hinton says.
    “Well, here’s a subgoal that almost always helps in biology: get more energy. So the first thing that could happen is these robots are going to say, ‘Let’s get more power. Let’s reroute all the electricity to my chips.’ Another great subgoal would be to make more copies of yourself. Does that sound good?” [...]
    When Hinton saw me out, the spring day had turned gray and wet. “Enjoy yourself, because you may not have long left,” he said. He chuckled and shut the door.
    Video interviews
    CNN, May 2:
    INTERVIEWER: You've spoken out saying that AI could manipulate or possibly figure out a way to kill humans. How could it kill humans?
    HINTON: Well eventually, if it gets to be much smarter than us, it'll be very good at manipulation because it will have learned that from us. And there are very few examples of a more intelligent thing being controlled by a less intelligent thing. And it knows how to program, so it'll figure out ways of getting around restrictions we put on it. It'll figure out ways of manipulating people to do what it wants.
    INTERVIEWER: So what do we do? Do we just need to pull the plug on it right now? Do we need to put in far more restrictions and backstops on this? How do we solve this problem?
    HINTON:...
    8 min
  • LW - Robin Hanson and I talk about AI risk by KatjaGrace
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Robin Hanson and I talk about AI risk, published by KatjaGrace on May 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    From this afternoon: here
    Our previous recorded discussions are here.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • LW - Who regulates the regulators? We need to go beyond the review-and-approval paradigm by jasoncrawford
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Who regulates the regulators? We need to go beyond the review-and-approval paradigm, published by jasoncrawford on May 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    IRBs
    Scott Alexander reviews a book about institutional review boards (IRBs), the panels that review the ethics of medical trials: From Oversight to Overkill, by Dr. Simon Whitney. From the title alone, you can see where this is going.
    IRBs are supposed to (among other things) make sure patients are fully informed of the risks of a trial, so that they can give informed consent. They were created in the wake of some true ethical disasters, such as trials that injected patients with cancer cells (“to see what would happen”) or gave hepatitis to mentally defective children.
    Around 1974, IRBs were instituted, and according to Whitney, for almost 25 years they worked well. The boards might be overprotective or annoying, but for the most part they were thoughtful and reasonable.
    Then in 1998, during in an asthma study at Johns Hopkins, a patient died. Congress put pressure on the head of the Office for Protection from Research Risks, who overreacted and shut down every study at Johns Hopkins, along with studies at “a dozen or so other leading research centers, often for trivial infractions.” Some thousands of studies were ruined, costing millions of dollars:
    The surviving institutions were traumatized. They resolved to never again do anything even slightly wrong, not commit any offense that even the most hostile bureaucrat could find reason to fault them for. They didn’t trust IRB members - the eminent doctors and clergymen doing this as a part time job - to follow all of the regulations, sub-regulations, implications of regulations, and pieces of case law that suddenly seemed relevant. So they hired a new staff of administrators to wield the real power. These administrators had never done research themselves, had no particular interest in research, and their entire career track had been created ex nihilo to make sure nobody got sued.
    Today IRB oversight has become, well, overkill. For one study testing the transfer of skin bacteria, the IRB thought that the consent form should warn patients of risks from AIDS (which you can’t get by skin contact) and smallpox (which has been eradicated). For a study on heart attacks, the IRB wanted patients—who are in the middle of a heart attack—to read and consent to a four-page form of “incomprehensible medicalese” listing all possible risks, even the most trivial. Scott’s review gives more examples, including his own personal experience.
    In many cases, it’s not even as if a new treatment was being introduced: sometimes an existing practice (giving aspirin for a heart attack, giving questionnaires to psychology patients) was being evaluated for effectiveness. There was no requirement that patients consent to “risks” when treatment was given arbitrarily; but if outcomes were being systematically observed and recorded, the IRBs could intervene.
    Scott summarizes the pros and cons of IRBs, including the cost of delayed treatments or procedure improvements:
    So the cost-benefit calculation looks like – save a tiny handful of people per year, while killing 10,000 to 100,000 more, for a price tag of $1.6 billion. If this were a medication, I would not prescribe it.
    FDA
    The IRB story illustrates a common pattern:
    A very bad thing is happening.
    A review and approval process is created to prevent these bad things. This is OK at first, and fewer bad things happen.
    Then, another very bad thing happens, despite the approval process.
    Everyone decides that the review was not strict enough. They make the review process stricter.
    Repeat this enough times (maybe only once, in the case of IRBs!) and you get regulatory overreach.
    The history of the FDA provides another example.
    At the beginning of the 20th century, th...
    22 min
  • LW - Google "We Have No Moat, And Neither Does OpenAI" by Chris Leong
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Google "We Have No Moat, And Neither Does OpenAI", published by Chris Leong on May 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    This (purported) leak is incredibly scary if you're worried about AI risk due to AI capabilities developing too fast.
    Firstly, it suggests that open-source models are improving rapidly because people are able to iterate on top of each other's improvements and try out a much larger number of experiments than a small team at a single company possibly could.
    Secondly, it suggests that data size is less important than you might think from recent scaling laws, as you can achieve high performance with "small, highly curated datasets". This suggests a world where dangerous capabilities are much further distributed.
    Thirdly, it proposes that Google should open-source its AI technology. Obviously, this is only the opinion of one researcher and it currently seems unlikely to occur, but if Google was to pursue this path, this would lead to a significant shortening of timelines.
    I'm worried that up until now, this community has been too focused on the threat of big companies pushing capabilities ahead and not focused enough on the threat posed by open-source AI. I would love to see more discussions of regulations in order to mitigate this risk. I suspect it would be possible to significantly hamper these projects by making the developers of these projects potentially liable for any resulting misuse.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - AI X-risk in the News: How Effective are Recent Media Items and How is Awareness Changing? Our New Survey Results. by Otto
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI X-risk in the News: How Effective are Recent Media Items and How is Awareness Changing? Our New Survey Results., published by Otto on May 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    This is a summary of a follow-up study conducted by the Existential Risk Observatory, which delves into a greater number media items. To access our previous study, please follow this link. The data collected will be presented in two separate posts. The first post, which is the current one, has two parts. The first part examines the key indicators used in the previous research, such as "Human Extinction Events" and "Human Extinction Percentage," along with a new key indicator called "Concern Level." The Concern Level indicator assesses participants' level of concern about AI existential risk on a scale of 0 to 10 before and after the intervention. The second part analyzes the changes in public awareness about AI existential risk over time. It also explores the connection between the effectiveness of different media formats, namely articles and videos, and their length in raising awareness.
    In addition, it investigates how trust levels are related to the effectiveness of media sources in increasing public awareness of AI existential risk. In the second post, the research covers a new aspect of this study: participants' opinions on an AI moratorium and their likelihood of voting for it.
    PART 1: Effectiveness per media item
    This research aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of AI existential risk communication in increasing awareness of the potential risks posed by AI to human extinction.
    Research Objectives: The objective of the study was to determine the effectiveness of AI existential risk communication in raising public awareness. This was done by examining the changes in participants' views on the likelihood and ranking of AI as a potential cause of extinction before and after the intervention. Furthermore, the study evaluated the difference in the level of concern of participants before and after the intervention.
    Measurements and Operationalization: Three primary measurements - "Human Extinction Events," "Human Extinction Percentage," and "Concern Level" - were utilized to examine alterations in participants' perceptions. The coding scheme that was previously used in our research was employed to assess participants' increased awareness of AI. The data was gathered through Prolific, a platform that locates survey respondents based on predefined criteria. The study involved 350 participants, with 50 participants in each survey, who were required to be at least 18 years old, residents of the United States, and fluent in English.
    Data Collection and Analysis: Data was collected through surveys in April 2023. The data analysis comprised three main sections: (1) comparing changes in the key indicators before and after the intervention, (2) exploring participants' views on the possibility of an AI moratorium and their likelihood of voting for it, and (3) assessing the number of participants who were familiar with or had confidence in the media channel used in the intervention.
    Media Items Examined:
    CNN: Stuart Russell on why A.I. experiments must be paused
    CNBC: Here's why A.I. needs a six-month pause: NYU Professor Gary Marcus
    The Economist: How to stop AI going rogue
    Time 1: Why Uncontrollable AI Looks More Likely Than Ever | Time
    Time 2: The Only Way to Deal With the Threat From AI? Shut It Down | Time
    FoxNews Article: Artificial intelligence 'godfather' on AI possibly wiping out humanity: ‘It's not inconceivable’ | Article
    FoxNews Video: White House responds to concerns about AI development | Video
    Results:
    Human Extinction Events
    The graph below displays the percentage of increased awareness across various media sources. The Economist survey showed the highest increase in awareness at 52 ...
    18 min
  • LW - White House Announces "New Actions to Promote Responsible AI Innovation" by berglund
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: White House Announces "New Actions to Promote Responsible AI Innovation", published by berglund on May 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Highlights
    Vice President Kamala Harris will be meeting with officials from Alphabet, Anthropic, Microsoft, and OpenAI to "emphasize the importance of driving responsible, trustworthy, and ethical innovation with safeguards that mitigate risks and potential harms to individuals and our society"
    The White House announced a $140 million dollar investment to launch seven new National AI Research Institutes to "pursue transformative AI advances that are ethical, trustworthy, responsible, and serve the public good."
    They also announced a public assessment of existing generative AI systems. Participants include Anthropic, Google, Hugging Face, Microsoft, NVIDIA, OpenAI, and Stability AI. These evals will be done on a platform hosted by Scale AI
    Full text
    Today, the Biden-Harris Administration is announcing new actions that will further promote responsible American innovation in artificial intelligence (AI) and protect people’s rights and safety. These steps build on the Administration’s strong record of leadership to ensure technology improves the lives of the American people, and break new ground in the federal government’s ongoing effort to advance a cohesive and comprehensive approach to AI-related risks and opportunities.AI is one of the most powerful technologies of our time, but in order to seize the opportunities it presents, we must first mitigate its risks. President Biden has been clear that when it comes to AI, we must place people and communities at the center by supporting responsible innovation that serves the public good, while protecting our society, security, and economy.
    Importantly, this means that companies have a fundamental responsibility to make sure their products are safe before they are deployed or made public.Vice President Harris and senior Administration officials will meet today with CEOs of four American companies at the forefront of AI innovation—Alphabet, Anthropic, Microsoft, and OpenAI—to underscore this responsibility and emphasize the importance of driving responsible, trustworthy, and ethical innovation with safeguards that mitigate risks and potential harms to individuals and our society. The meeting is part of a broader, ongoing effort to engage with advocates, companies, researchers, civil rights organizations, not-for-profit organizations, communities, international partners, and others on critical AI issues.This effort builds on the considerable steps the Administration has taken to date to promote responsible innovation.
    These include the landmark Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights and related executive actions announced last fall, as well as the AI Risk Management Framework and a roadmap for standing up a National AI Research Resource released earlier this year.The Administration has also taken important actions to protect Americans in the AI age. In February, President Biden signed an Executive Order that directs federal agencies to root out bias in their design and use of new technologies, including AI, and to protect the public from algorithmic discrimination.
    Last week, the Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division issued a joint statement underscoring their collective commitment to leverage their existing legal authorities to protect the American people from AI-related harms.The Administration is also actively working to address the national security concerns raised by AI, especially in critical areas like cybersecurity, biosecurity, and safety. This includes enlisting the support of government cybersecurity experts from across the national security community to ensure leading AI companies ...
    7 min