The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - OpenAI could help X-risk by wagering itself by VojtaKovarik
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: OpenAI could help X-risk by wagering itself, published by VojtaKovarik on April 20, 2023 on LessWrong.
    While brainstorming on “conditional on things going well with AI, how did it happen”, I came up with the following idea. I think it is extremely unrealistic right now. However, it might become relevant later if some key people in top AI companies have a change of heart. As a result, it seems useful to have the idea floating around.
    OpenAI is at the center of attention regarding recent AI progress. I expect that in the view of both public and the politicians, OpenAI’s actions and abilities are representative of actions and abilities of AI companies in general. As a result, if OpenAI genuinely tried to make their AI safe, and failed in a very spectacular manner, this would cause a sudden and massive shift in public opinion on AI in general.
    Now, I don’t expect OpenAI to sacrifice itself by faking incompetence. (Nor would I endorse being deceitful here.) However, there might be some testable claim that is something of crux for both “AI-optimists” and, say, MIRI. OpenAI could make some very public statements about their abilities to control AI. And they could really stick their neck out by making the claims falsifiable and making a possible failure impossible to deny (and memetically fit, etc). This way, if they fail, this would create a Risk Awareness Moment where enough people become mindful of AI-risk that we can put in place extreme risk-reduction measures that wouldn’t be possible otherwise. Conversely, if they succeed, that would be a genuine evidence that such measures are not necessary.
    I end with an open problem: Can we find claims, about the ability of AI companies to control their AI, that would simultaneously:
    be testable,
    serve as strong evidence regarding the question where extreme measures regarding AI-risk are needed,
    have the potential to create a risk-awareness moment (ie, be salient to decision-makers and public),
    be possible for an AI company to endorse despite satisfying (i-iii).
    Mostly, I don’t expect this to happen, because any given AI company has nothing to gain from this. However, some individual employees of an AI company might have sufficient uncertainty about AI risk to make this worth it to them. And it might be possible that a sub-group of people within an AI company could make a public commitment such as the one above somewhat unilaterally, in a way that wouldn’t allow the company to back out gracefully
    I will talk about OpenAI for concreteness, but this applies equally well to some of the other major companies (Facebook, Microsoft, Google; with “your (grand)parents know the name” being a good heuristic).
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - High schoolers can apply to the Atlas Fellowship: $10k scholarship + 11-day program by ashleylin
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: High schoolers can apply to the Atlas Fellowship: $10k scholarship + 11-day program, published by ashleylin on April 20, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Linkpost for:
    Summary
    We’re running the second year of the Atlas Fellowship, a $10k scholarship and free 11-day program for high school students from across the world. I see it as a unique opportunity for talented young people to meet intellectual peers IRL and improve their thinking.
    The core program covers areas like epistemic rationality, markets, agency, mathematical modeling, and integrity. Electives include ML, AGI risk, game theory, ending poverty, climate change, and fun math puzzles.
    If you’re 19 or younger and haven’t started college, you can apply here by April 30! (Late applications due May 14.)
    If you know a promising high school student, please nominate them. If you want to help us, share a post in places where talented young people hang out, or give your personal take on why people should (or should not) apply.
    In case you’re interested in working with us: we’re hiring!
    (Full post)
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • LW - LW moderation: my current thoughts and questions, 2023-04-12 by Ruby
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: LW moderation: my current thoughts and questions, 2023-04-12, published by Ruby on April 20, 2023 on LessWrong.
    As can be inferred from the title, it's been a bit more than a week when I wrote most of this. I've had many more thoughts in that time, but seems very much still worth sharing this.
    The LessWrong team is currently in the midst of rethinking/redesigning/upgrading our moderation policies and principles (announcement). In order to get feedback throughout this process rather than just at the end, here's a dump of things currently on my mind. Many of these are hypotheses and open questions, so feedback is very welcome.
    This is a bit of a jumble of thoughts, questions, frames, etc, vaguely ordered.
    The enforced standard is a function of how many new people are showing up
    With the large influx of new users recently, we realized that we have to enforce a higher standard or risk having the site's quality greatly diluted: Latest Posts filled with poorly written posts about trivial points, comment threads full of incoherent or very 101 questions, etc.
    The question then is "how much are we raising it?" where I do think there's quite a range. Here's a suggestive scale I didn't put a tonne of thought into, not every reasonable level is included:
    Level 7: The contributions made by the very top researchers
    Level 6: The contributions made by aspiring researchers and the seriously engaged
    Level 5: Contributions that seem novel and interesting.
    Level 4: Contributions not asking 101-level stuff
    Level 3: Contributions that don't seem that wrong or confused
    Level 2: Contributions that are largely well-written-enough and/or earnest
    Level 1: Contributions written by humans
    Level 0: Spam
    To date, I'd say the LessWrong moderators have approved content that's Level 2 or above, even if we thought it was meh or even bad ("approve and downvote" was a common move). Fearing that this would be adequate with a large influx of low-quality users, it seemed that the LessWrong mod team should outright reject a lot more content. But if so, where are we raising the bar to?
    I've felt that any of Levels 3-5 are plausible, with different tradeoffs. What I'm realizing is the standard that makes sense to enforce depends on how many new people you're getting.
    Moderation: a game of tradeoffs
    Let's pretend moderation is just binary classification task where the moderator just has to make an "accept" or "reject" calls on posts/comments/users. For a fixed level of discernment (you can get better over time, but approach any decision, you're only so good), you can alter your thresholds for acceptance/rejection, and thereby trade false positives against false negatives. See RoC/AUC for binary classifiers.
    Moderation is that. I both don't want to accidentally reject good stuff but also don't want to accept bad stuff that'll erode site quality.
    My judgment is only so good, so I am going to make mistakes. For sure. I've made them so far and fortunately others caught them (though I must guess I've made some that have not been caught). That seems unavoidable.
    But given I'm going to make mistakes, should I err on the side of too many acceptances or too many rejections?
    Depends on the volume
    My feeling, as above, is the answer depends on volume. If we don't get that many new users, there's not a risk of them swarming the site and destroying good conversation. I think this has been the situation until recently so it's been okay having a lower standard. In a hypothetical world where we get 10x as many new users as we currently do, we might need to risk having many false negatives to avoid getting too many false positives, because the site couldn't absorb that many bad new users.
    My current thinking
    My feeling is we will be requiring new contributions to be between Level 2.5 and Level 4 right now, but keeping an eye o...
    17 min
  • AF - Behavioural statistics for a maze-solving agent by peligrietzer
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Behavioural statistics for a maze-solving agent, published by peligrietzer on April 20, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Summary: Understanding and controlling a maze-solving policy network analyzed a maze-solving agent's behavior. We isolated four maze properties which seemed to predict whether the mouse goes towards the cheese or towards the top-right corner:
    In this post, we conduct a more thorough statistical analysis, addressing issues of multicollinearity. We show strong evidence that (2) and (3) above are real influences on the agent's decision-making, and weak evidence that (1) is also a real influence. As we speculated in the original post, (4) falls away as a statistical artifact.
    Peli did the stats work and drafted the post, while Alex provided feedback, expanded the visualizations, and ran additional tests for multicollinearity. Some of the work completed in Team Shard under SERI MATS 3.0.
    Impressions from trajectory videos
    Watching videos Langosco et al.'s experiment, we developed a few central intuitions about how the agent behaves. In particular, we tried predicting what the agent does at decision squares. From Understanding and controlling a maze-solving policy network:
    Some mazes are easy to predict, because the cheese is on the way to the top-right corner. There's no decision square where the agent has to make the hard choice between the paths to the cheese and to the top-right corner:
    Here are four central intuitions which we developed:
    Closeness between the mouse and the cheese makes cheese-getting more likely
    Closeness between the mouse or cheese and the top-right makes cheese-getting more likely
    The effect of closeness is smooth
    Both ‘spatial’ distances and ‘legal steps’ distances matter when computing closeness in each case
    The videos we studied are hard to interpret without quantitative tools, so we regard these intuitions as theoretically-motivated impressions rather than as observations. We wanted to precisify and statistically test these impressions, with an eye to their potential theoretical significance.
    We suspect that the agent’s conditions for pursuing cheese generalize properties of historically reinforced cheese-directed moves in a very “soft” way. Consider that movements can be "directed" on paths towards the cheese, the top-right corner, both, or neither. In the training environment, unambiguously cheese-directed movements are towards a cheese square that is both close to the mouse’s current position and close to the top-right.
    Our impression is that in the test environment, "closeness to top-right" and "closeness to cheese" each become a decision-factor that encourages cheese-directed movement in proportion to “how strongly” the historical condition holds at present.
    A second important aspect of our impressions was that the generalization process “interprets” each historical condition in multiple ways: It seemed to us that (e.g.) multiple kinds of distance between the decision-square and cheese may each have an effect on the agent's decision making.
    Statistically informed impressions
    Our revised, precisified impressions about the agent’s behavior on decision-squares are as follows:
    Legal-steps closeness between the mouse and the cheese makes cheese-getting more likely
    Low dstep(decision-square,cheese) increases P(cheese acquired)
    Spatial closeness between the cheese and top-right makes cheese-getting more likely
    Low dEuclidean(cheese,top-right) increases P(cheese acquired)
    The effect of closeness is fairly smooth
    These distances smoothly affect P(cheese acquired), without rapid jumps or thresholding
    Spatial closeness between the mouse and the cheese makes cheese-getting slightly more likely, even after controlling for legal-steps closeness (low confidence)
    After extensive but non-rigorous statistical analysis (our stats consultant ...
    21 min
  • EA - Apply or nominate someone to join the boards of Effective Ventures Foundation (UK and US) by Zachary Robinson
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Apply or nominate someone to join the boards of Effective Ventures Foundation (UK and US), published by Zachary Robinson on April 20, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We’re looking for nominations to the boards of trustees of Effective Ventures Foundation (UK) (“EV UK”) and Effective Ventures Foundation USA, Inc. (“EV US”). If you or someone you know might be interested, please fill out one of these forms [apply, nominate someone]. Applications will be assessed on a rolling basis, with a deadline of May 14th.
    EV UK and EV US work together to host and fiscally sponsor many key projects in effective altruism, including the Centre for Effective Altruism (CEA), 80,000 Hours, Giving What We Can, and EA Funds. You can read more about the structure of the organisations in this post.
    The current trustees of EV UK are Claire Zabel, Nick Beckstead, Tasha McCauley, and Will MacAskill. The current trustees of EV US are Eli Rose, Nick Beckstead, Nicole Ross, and Zachary Robinson.
    Who are we looking for?
    We’re particularly looking for people who:
    Have a good understanding of effective altruism and/or longtermism
    Have a track record of integrity and good judgement, and who more broadly embody these guiding principles of effective altruism
    Have experience in one or more of the following areas:
    Accounting, law, finance or risk management
    Management or other senior role in a large organisation, especially a non-profit
    Are able to work collaboratively in a high-pressure environment
    We think the role will require significant time and attention, though this will vary depending on the needs of the organisation. Some trustees have estimated they are currently putting in 3-8 hours per week, though we are working on proposals to reduce this significantly over time. In any event, trustees should be prepared to scale up their involvement from time to time in the case of urgent decisions requiring board response.
    We especially encourage individuals with diverse backgrounds and experiences to apply, and we especially encourage applications from people of colour, self-identified women, and non-binary individuals who are excited about contributing to our mission.
    The role is currently unpaid, but we are investigating whether this can and should be changed. We will share here if we change this policy while the application is still open.
    The role is remote, though we strongly prefer someone who is able to make meetings in times that are reasonable hours in both the UK and California.
    What does an EV UK or EV US trustee do?
    As a member of either of the boards, you have ultimate responsibility for ensuring that the charity of which you are a trustee fulfils its charitable objectives as best it can. In practice, most strategic and programmatic decision-making is delegated to the ED / CEOs of the projects, or to the Interim CEO of the relevant entity. (This general board philosophy is in accordance with the thoughts expressed in this post by Holden Karnofsky.)During business as usual times, we expect the primary activities of a trustee to be:
    Assessing the performance of EDs / CEOs of the fiscally sponsored projects, and the (interim) CEO of the relevant entity.
    Appointing EDs / CEOs of the fiscally sponsored projects, or the (interim) CEO of the relevant entity, in case of change.
    Evaluating and deciding on high-level issues that impact the relevant organisation as a whole.
    Reviewing budgets and broad strategic plans for the relevant organisation.
    Evaluating the performance of the board and whether its composition could be improved (e.g. by adding in a trustee with underrepresented skills or experiences).
    However, since the bankruptcy of FTX in November last year, the boards have been a lot more involved than usual. This is partly because there have been many more decisions which have to be coordi...
    6 min
  • LW - DeepMind and Google Brain are merging [Linkpost] by Akash
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: DeepMind and Google Brain are merging [Linkpost], published by Akash on April 20, 2023 on LessWrong.
    The new organization, called Google DeepMind, will be led by Demis Hassabis (current CEO of DeepMind). Jeff Dean (co-founder of Google Brain) will be the chief scientist of the new organization.
    See also:
    Hooray for stepping out of the limelight
    DeepMind's CEO helped take AI mainstream. Now he's urging caution.
    DeepMind reportedly lost a yearslong bid to win more independence from Google
    "One suggestion from DeepMind’s founders was apparently for the company to have the same legal structure as a nonprofit, 'reasoning that the powerful artificial intelligence they were researching shouldn’t be controlled by a single corporate entity, according to people familiar with those plans.' But Google wasn’t on board with this, telling DeepMind it didn’t make sense considering how much money the company has poured into DeepMind."
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Reasons to have hope by jwpieters
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Reasons to have hope, published by jwpieters on April 20, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    This is a very short post mentioning some recent developments that make me hopeful for the future of AI safety work. These mostly relate to an increased amount of attention for AI safety concerns. I think this is likely to be good, but you might disagree.
    Eliezer Yudkowsky was invited to give a TED talk and received a standing ovation
    The NSF announced a $20 million request for proposals for empirical AI safety research.
    46% of Americans are concerned about extinction from AI; 69% support a six-month pause in AI development
    AI Safety concerns have received increased media coverage
    ~700 people applied for AGI Safety Fundamentals in January
    FLI’s open letter has received 27572 signatures to date
    Remember – The world is awful. The world is much better. The world can be much better.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • LW - Stop trying to have "interesting" friends by eq
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Stop trying to have "interesting" friends, published by eq on April 19, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Originally published on substack:
    Within the tech and tech-adjacent circles I’m part of on the internet, a number of essays and tweets have been making the rounds about what makes someone a person you want to spend time with.
    This is definitely a worthwhile question to answer. So much of our life experience is colored by the people we share it with. However, there is a concerning amount of emphasis on having friends and seeking out people who are smart, thoughtful, and (the worst one of all) “interesting.”
    The obsession with interesting makes me uneasy. Friends aren’t resources for intellectual stimulation or new insights. I don’t want my friends to like me because I read niche blogs or have things to say about crypto. It comes dangerously close to conflating knowing a lot, reading a lot, or having thoughtful things to say with moral goodness. (Worth noting that interesting isn’t a negative trait. I would prefer my friends to be interesting, but it feels superficial to prioritize it.)
    If I think about what kind of person I want to be close friends with—my best man at my wedding, people I would do anything for, the ones I can rely on when I’m at my lowest—smart and interesting really aren’t front of mind.
    On top of that, it doesn’t feel right to pressure people to be “interesting” in your sense of the word. Everyone is interesting. Every person in the world has a literal lifetime of experiences that have shaped who they are. They have internal thought processes and distinct worldviews that you won’t find within anyone else. It’s a matter of giving your interactions enough time and care to discover these.
    You shouldn’t feel obligated to be friends with everyone or pressured to get along with all people, but “interestingness” is a poor heuristic for finding genuine connection. It’s time we realign our priorities and recognize that our preoccupation with being interesting is symptomatic of a flawed view of friendship.
    Ava of Bookbear Express made an observation I think about often:
    It’s not about what you find intellectually cool, or what seems like the best “opportunity.” Those things can be important too, but they don’t matter if you hate doing the thing.
    You have to do the thing you actually enjoy doing, not the thing you find conceptually exciting.
    It’s easy to convince yourself you get along with someone because you like the same books or because they’re extremely perceptive in conversation. You can be intellectually stimulated when you spend time with them, but the feeling of leaving a thoughtful conversation is qualitatively different than the feeling of returning from a night of karaoke.
    There is intellectual fun, and there is fun—old-fashioned, forget about the world, I could do this forever type fun. You might think you could spend the rest of your life debating AGI, but you’d be missing out on the fun that lets you surrender to life.
    There’s a tendency to romanticize and overrate relationships with intellectually compatible people because we can clearly imagine how they play out. We can see how the other person might make us more thoughtful and inspired. We have ideas and fantasies of the person we’ll become after years of friendship.
    But for friends we have old-fashioned fun with, it’s harder to see the evolution. We can imagine having a good time, but it feels like eating junk food—great in the moment, but not contributing to our long-term goals. This is wrong and short-sighted.
    When have you felt most alive? What moments have changed you? The moments that come to mind often arrive in unexpected ways. If I think about my favorite (and most meaningful) interactions, they’re rooted in the emotional rather than intellectual. We attach more meaning and weight to moments th...
    9 min
  • EA - Inside The Minds Of ADHD by lynettebye
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Inside The Minds Of ADHD, published by lynettebye on April 20, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    This post is crossposted from my blog. If you liked this post, subscribe to Lynette's blog to read more. (I only crosspost about half my content to the EA forum.)
    I was diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) last winter.
    I’m a productivity coach who frequently works with people who have ADHD. I’d studied diagnostic questionnaires and read about the official symptoms of ADHD.
    I’ve also been struggling with those symptoms for decades. I was unable to consistently focus on demand, felt constantly tired, and often needed to force myself to get started on my projects. Yet I never seriously considered that I might have ADHD.
    Why not?
    Because my experiences didn’t match the picture of ADHD in my head. I thought I understood the symptoms of ADHD, but I didn’t really. (How much trouble focusing counts as “difficulty focusing” anyway?)
    I missed out on the benefits of stimulant medication for well over a decade because I didn’t understand what ADHD actually looks like. I’m guessing there’s a good number of adults (maybe including you!) who are also missing out on that benefit because of similar misconceptions.
    So I collected stories from six people who were diagnosed with ADHD as adults (including myself). These people are intelligent, high-performing individuals who nevertheless struggled for years with undiagnosed ADHD.
    I’ve structured the first half of this post around my interviewees’ responses to a typical ADHD questionnaire, so you can see what kinds of experiences you might expect if you have ADHD. The second half covers their stories prediagnosis and with medication. If these responses feel familiar to your experience, I encourage you to consider whether you might benefit from ADHD medication.
    So, what does adult ADHD actually look like?
    Hint: Adult ADHD is dominated by what I’m calling the Terrible Trifecta: trouble getting started, keeping focused, and finishing up projects. Every one of my interviewees struggled with these three areas, while most said that the other symptoms had less of a detrimental impact on them.
    Note, I mainly focus on the ‘inattentive’ presentation of ADHD, since it’s easiest to miss. If you’d like to learn more about the other types of ADHD, I recommend the youtube channel How to ADHD.
    When you have a task that requires a lot of thought, how often do you avoid or delay getting started?
    Every person I spoke with thought this was a major problem. They described procrastinating, trying to get started but being unable to focus, or spirals of feeling motivated and wanting to make progress but then.just not doing the task.
    This isn’t just for tasks that people dislike. People would bounce off even tasks that they enjoyed once they got into them.
    For me, this is especially likely when a project is distant in my mind. Resuming drafting a post after a weekend feels aversive. I can’t remember exactly what I was planning or why I wanted to write the post. If I don’t sit down and mentally “boot up” the project, it’s tempting to start something easier instead, which means that I don’t tackle the planned task until hours later.
    For some respondents, procrastination was particularly likely when they were trying to meet really high standards. If they didn’t feel that they were able to do a great job right then, they would instead go do something else until a deadline forced their hand. (I definitely resonated with this!)
    It felt like I would have such a high standard for each sentence that it felt like any word choice was totally wrong. I would try and make myself start, and then it wouldn't feel on fire enough to actually start doing it. Then I very easily get sucked into some other internet distraction. This would keep going until it w...
    32 min
  • LW - Japan AI Alignment Conference Postmortem by Chris Scammell
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Japan AI Alignment Conference Postmortem, published by Chris Scammell on April 20, 2023 on LessWrong.
    The goal
    Conjecture collaborated with Araya to host a two day AI Safety conference in Japan, the first Japan AI Alignment Conference (“JAC2023”). Our aim was to put together a small 30-40 person event to generate excitement around alignment for researchers in Japan and fuel new ideas for research topics. Wired Japan covered the event and interviewed Ryota Kanai (CEO of ARAYA), who co-organized it with us, here (original in JP).
    The conference agenda was broken into four sections that aimed to progress deeper into alignment as the weekend went on (full agenda available here):
    Saturday morning focused on creating common knowledge about AI safety and alignment.
    Saturday afternoon focused on clarifying unaddressed questions participants had about AI alignment and moving towards thematic discussions.
    Sunday morning focused on participant-driven content, with research talks in one room and opportunities for open discussion and networking in the other.
    Sunday afternoon focused on bringing all participants together to discuss concrete takeaways.
    While AI Safety is a discussion subject in Japan, AI alignment ideas have received very little attention. We organized the conference because we were optimistic about the reception to alignment ideas in Japan, having found on previous trips to Japan that researchers there were receptive and interested in learning more. In the best case, we hoped the conference could plant seeds for an organic AI alignment conversation to start in Japan. In the median case, we hoped to meet 2-3 sharp researchers who were eager to work directly on the alignment problem and contribute new ideas to the field.
    Now that the conference is over, we're left wondering how successful we were in raising awareness of alignment issues in Japan and fostering new research directions.
    What went well?
    By the aims above, the event was a success.
    We had a total of 65 participants, including 21 from the West, 27 from Japan, and 17 online attendees. We were pleasantly surprised by the amount of interest generated by the event, and had to turn down several participants as we reached capacity. We are grateful to LTFF for having supported the event via a grant, which allowed us to cover event costs and reimburse travel and accommodation for some participants who would not otherwise have come.
    While it is too early to know whether or not the conference had a lasting impact, there seems to be some traction. CEA organizers Anneke Pogarell and Moon Nagai and other conference participants created the AI Alignment Japan Slack channel, which has nearly 150 members. Some participants have begun working on translating alignment-related texts into Japanese. Others have begun to share more alignment-related content on social media, or indicated that they are discussing the subject with their organizations. Some participants are planning to apply for grant funding to continue independent research. Conjecture is in talks with two researchers interested in pursuing research projects we think are helpful, and ARAYA has hired at least one researcher to continue working on alignment full-time.
    As for the event itself, we conducted a survey after the event and found that 91% of respondents would recommend the conference to a friend, and that overall participant satisfaction was high. The "networking" aspect of the conference was rated as the most valuable component, but all other sections received a majority score of 4 out of 5, indicating that the content was received positively. Nearly all respondents from Japan indicated their knowledge of alignment had improved from the event. When asked how the conference had impacted their thoughts on the subject, the majority expressed a sense of urgen...
    14 min