The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Wanted: Mental Health Program Manager at Rethink Wellbeing by Inga
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Wanted: Mental Health Program Manager at Rethink Wellbeing, published by Inga on April 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Are you an experienced coach, or therapist interested in taking on a new challenge? Then this is for you! You can apply here (<20min). Soft deadline: 10.4. You can ask for an extension if needed.
    Background
    Our emerging organization, Rethink Wellbeing aims to improve mental resilience and productivity at scale, starting in the Effective Altruism Community. We plan to do so by developing an integrative stepped-care system that, among others, includes peers to train psychological skills together, combined with accountability schemes and proven digital courses, and workbooks.
    We’d love your support as a program manager and “super”-facilitator to co-create, test and run our first batch of programs, as well as the corresponding training of other facilitators. The job opening is for someone with 50–100% FTE, working as a contractor or employee, preferably full-time, starting as soon as possible. Funding is available until the end of Aug, and we are fundraising to extend this period.
    What we offer you
    A high-impact job opportunity
    An opportunity to work with a great team and community (short-term or long-term)
    Plenty of scope to shape the future of the programs and organization
    Flexible remote work
    Lots of learning and self-development
    Competitive salary that depends on the level of experience, need, and responsibility
    What the program manager ideally brings
    preferably a degree in psychology/ psychotherapy or a comparable one,
    track record of an extraordinarily high participant or client ratings,
    experience with group facilitation, e.g., moderation, workshops, hosting events, or similar, ideally online,
    experience with treatment methods that foster mental health, connection, or productivity,
    experience with developing programs or trainings, ideally online,
    bonus: experience with training of facilitators, therapists, or coaches,
    bonus: experience in community building, working with Effective Altruism, Rationalist, or adjacent communities.
    Programs we run
    We run online groups of 4–6 participants, running 1.5 - 2 hours sessions per week for ~ 6 weeks. In these groups, participants boost their mental wellbeing or productivity together, applying proven psychological techniques such as:
    Cognitive Behavioral Therapy,
    Accountability, and Behavior Change,
    Compassion, and mindfulness,
    Inner-Parts Work, such as Internal Family Systems.
    The facilitators of these groups do not teach the group but rather operate as moderators, enablers of structure and owner of vibes. Participants learn about the techniques and contents with the help of selected high-quality material such as online workbooks and online courses in between the sessions as homework. You can learn more about our programs on our website and by talking to us.
    The mission of our program manager
    prepare and run some pilot sessions and workshops to test what works best,
    (help to) create and iterate the program structure and content,
    test and run the first program versions with the highest quality possible (together with other super-facilitators),
    co-create the training for later facilitators to run these programs (optional),
    build the community of facilitators and participants (optional)
    We have an evaluation system in place to measure the success of sessions and the programs' pre-post.
    You can learn more about us on our website and about the job here.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • LW - Consider applying to a 2-week alignment project with former GitHub CEO by jacobjacob
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Consider applying to a 2-week alignment project with former GitHub CEO, published by jacobjacob on April 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Signal-boosting this tweet from Nat Friedman, former github CEO, who says:
    I'm seeking a researcher/journalist with an interest in AI/rationalism/xrisk for a 1-2 week project. To apply please email [email protected] with evidence that you (a) read scifi and (b) understand this tweet:
    Linked tweet says:
    What's you response to Orthogonality Thesis+Instrumental Convergence+AI arms race+ likely Mesa Optimization+ rapid recent progress in AI via ML = we are likely doomed? I have a PhD in econ so I do understand risk.
    I don't know much about this nor I do have any affiliation with it. But it seems pretty cool to me and at least worth considering for people in the target reference class!
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Rebooting Tyve, an effective giving startup by Raoul
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Rebooting Tyve, an effective giving startup, published by Raoul on April 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    In January this year, I took over running Tyve, a start-up that promotes workplace giving. Through Tyve, employees set up recurring monthly donations to charity. The donations are simple to administer. And they come straight from their pre-tax earnings. So they save the average employee hundreds of pounds a year.
    Ben Clifford (@Clifford), Ben Olsen and Sam Geals in 2019 founded Tyve in 2019. After strong initial growth, Tyve they put Tyve into ‘maintenance mode’ in late 2021. Ben Clifford talks about these initial years in Lessons learned from Tyve, an effective giving startup.
    In this post, I’m going to cover:
    why I got involved in Tyve;
    why I believe Tyve could raise large sums for effective charities;
    what we’re doing differently this time around; and
    how you could help (if you were so inclined).
    TL;DR
    If you don’t want to read the whole thing, here’s a short summary.
    Only a fraction of adults in the UK who give to charity do it through the workplace (many more do in the US). Workplace giving seems a relatively undertapped channel.
    When Tyve launches at companies it gets high participation rates and is very sticky (high retention rates).
    Most donations are “new money” that would not otherwise have been donated to charity. This is especially true for the ~40% of donations that go to Tyve’s recommended (effective) charities.
    We’re making changes to make Tyve more attractive to companies to adopt. These include: making it free to use, adding impact reporting and testing donation matching for recommended (effective) charities.
    There are several (known) reasons why we may fail to get more companies using Tyve. These include charitable giving been seen as a ‘nice to have’ and there being a high hurdle for companies to do anything new.
    There’s an easy (and high EV) way you could help: introduce us to the company you work at!
    How I got involved
    I’ve spent most of the last decade leading product and design teams at tech scale ups. Late last year, the most recent of these scale-ups went (the bad ‘boom’, not the good one, like at the end of a fist bump). I took it as a opportunity to look beyond the commercial tech world. I'd spent years with the next startup funding round as a key factor behind almost every decision. I was ready for something a bit different.
    I started to speak to some people in the EA community, talking through options, understanding where they saw the most potential impact.
    In parallel, I was wondering why smaller companies weren't offering ‘payroll giving’ to their employees. (This is the mechanism that enables employees to give to charity from pre-tax earnings.)
    At this point, I’d been giving a % of income to effective charities for several years. It felt meaningful and important. But it also required a fair bit of admin. I had a spreadsheet for tracking what I'd earned and logging donations (across multiple charities). And then trying to work out what this meant from a tax perspective (after accounting for GiftAid).
    I’d had access to payroll giving a decade ago when I’d worked at a massive company and it had made giving so simple. No need to track earnings and donations—and the tax benefits were automatic.
    With modern tech we must be able to make this available to all companies, even those without huge HR teams?
    Meeting Ben Clifford was serendipitous. Ben had already founded Tyve. Working with Ben O and Sam, he'd built pretty much the exact the product that I’d started sketching out in my mind (and in my terrible handwritten notes).
    I sat down with Ben in a bakery in what looked like an abandoned parking lot (his idea). After about 15 minutes, he asked me if I wanted to take over Tyve. Even better, him and Ben O were able to continue to he...
    18 min
  • LW - Complex Systems are Hard to Control by jsteinhardt
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Complex Systems are Hard to Control, published by jsteinhardt on April 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    The deployment of powerful deep learning systems such as ChatGPT raises the question of how to make these systems safe and consistently aligned with human intent. Since building these systems is an engineering challenge, it is tempting to think of the safety of these systems primarily through a traditional engineering lens, focusing on reliability, modularity, redundancy, and reducing the long tail of failures.
    While engineering is a useful lens, it misses an important part of the picture: deep neural networks are complex adaptive systems, which raises new control difficulties that are not addressed by standard engineering methodology. I’ve discussed some particular examples of this before, but here I want to focus on the broader underlying intuition that generated them.
    A complex adaptive system is a system with many interacting components that adapt to their environment and co-evolve over time (in our case, the weights / layers of the neural network). Beyond neural networks, other examples of complex adaptive systems include firms, financial markets, political parties, culture, traffic flows, pathogens, ecosystems, human brains, the Earth’s climate, and the Internet.
    A common thread in all these systems is that straightforward attempts to control their behavior lead to unintended consequences. I’ll demonstrate this through concrete examples, then step back and consider the broader properties that make these systems difficult to control, including emergent goals. Finally, I’ll propose safety measures that account for the complex adaptive nature of deep learning systems.
    Many of the ideas in this post have been discussed before, and my thinking owes significantly to Dan Hendrycks, who was an early proponent of the complex systems perspective as a PhD student in my lab (see e.g. Unsolved Problems in ML Safety, the lecture on accident models from Dan’s course, or this blog post).
    Control Difficulties in Complex Systems
    Let’s examine several examples of complex systems, and see why each is difficult to control, in the sense that they either resist or respond unpredictably to external feedback.
    Traffic. A city builds new highways to reduce traffic congestion. The newly increased road capacity attracts new drivers, leading to worse levels of congestion than before. The adaptive behavior leads to unintended consequences.
    Ecosystems. A park introduces a predator to reduce the population of an invasive species. The predator also preys on native species, disrupting the ecosystem balance. The dense network of interactions makes it difficult to predict all consequences ahead of time.
    Financial markets. Central banks lower interest rates to stimulate economic growth. Funders thus make riskier investments leading to asset bubbles, which later burst and destabilize the financial system. In this case, both adaptivity and multi-step interactions come into play.
    Culture. The government implements public awareness campaigns to promote environmental conservation. These efforts encounter resistance from workers whose jobs rely on non-renewable fuel sources, and are appropriated by fashion brands and other consumer products through greenwashing.
    Further examples include pathogens evolving drug resistance, firms relocating to avoid regulations, and positive feedback loops from climate change. I elaborate on these and other examples in the appendix.
    Traditional Engineering Does not Address these Difficulties
    Why are complex adaptive systems hard to control? There are two key hallmarks of complex adaptive systems:
    Emergence: behavior at one scale cannot be easily reduced to behavior at smaller scales, i.e. “More is Different”.
    Feedback loops: different components of the system continually influence ...
    19 min
  • EA - GiveWell's updated estimate of deworming and decay by GiveWell
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: GiveWell's updated estimate of deworming and decay, published by GiveWell on April 3, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Author: Alex Cohen, GiveWell Senior Researcher
    This document describes the rationale for the decay adjustment in our deworming cost-effectiveness analysis. We have incorporated this adjustment thanks to criticism from the Happier Lives Institute.
    In a nutshell
    The main piece of evidence we use for the long-term effects of deworming is an RCT in Kenya with follow-ups at ~10 years (KLPS-2), ~15 years (KLPS-3) and ~20 years (KLPS-4) after children received deworming treatment. While these surveys show decline in effect on ln earnings and consumption over time, we have typically viewed the different estimates across surveys as noisy estimates of the same effect and assumed the effects of deworming are constant throughout a person’s working life.
    We now think we should account for some decay in benefits over time. We incorporate this decay by making the following key assumptions:
    We put 50% weight on the interpretation that the different estimates over time are capturing true differences in effect size. While the data point to an estimate of decline, the confidence intervals are wide and there are differences in how data were collected over time, which make us reluctant to put full weight on KLPS 2-4 capturing true decay over time.
    We set a prior that the effects are constant over time. This is based on a shallow literature review of studies of interventions during childhood where researchers reported at least two follow-ups on income during adulthood. We find a similar number of studies finding a decline in effect as an increase in effect over time.
    We update from that prior at each time period (10-years, 15-years, and 20-years), using the informal Bayesian adjustment approach we’ve used previously.
    We then extrapolate effects through the rest of the individual’s working life based on the measured decline from 10-year to 20-year follow-up.
    Our best guess is that we should apply a -10% adjustment due to the possibility of decay in effects over time. While the decline in effects in later years leads to lower cost-effectiveness, this is partially counterbalanced by higher estimated effects in earlier years and by our putting only 50% weight on the interpretation that declines in measured effects across follow-ups reflects a true decline in effect over time.
    We have several uncertainties about this analysis:
    This decay adjustment builds on top of our current Bayesian approach for estimating the effect of deworming. As a result, it's subject to the same limitations of that approach. It’s possible that in the future we should overhaul our approach, which could lead to meaningful differences in how we incorporate decay.
    The model is sensitive to our prior on whether effects should decay or not, and our current prior is based on a shallow literature review. If we expected effects to decay, we would include a stricter adjustment because we would (i) be updating from a prior where decay was already occurring and (ii) put more weight on the decay interpretation. We could potentially refine this estimate with a more thorough review of the literature and additional data analysis.
    The weight we put on whether these are noisy estimates of the same effect or different effects over time is based on a qualitative and highly subjective assessment. Putting higher weight on the surveys capturing different effects over time, for example, would lead to a stronger discount.
    What we did previously
    The main piece of evidence we use for the long-term effects of deworming is an RCT in Kenya that measures effects on income at ~10 years (KLPS-2), ~15 years (KLPS-3) and ~20 years (KLPS-4) after children receive deworming treatment.[1]
    Our typical approach has been to pool effects...
    22 min
  • LW - AI Summer Harvest by Cleo Nardo
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI Summer Harvest, published by Cleo Nardo on April 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Trending metaphor
    I've noticed that AI Notkilleveryonists have begun appealing to a new(?) metaphor of an AI Summer Harvest.
    Here's the FLI open letter Pause Giant AI Experiments:
    Humanity can enjoy a flourishing future with AI. Having succeeded in creating powerful AI systems, we can now enjoy an "AI summer" in which we reap the rewards, engineer these systems for the clear benefit of all, and give society a chance to adapt. Society has hit pause on other technologies with potentially catastrophic effects on society.[5] We can do so here. Let's enjoy a long AI summer, not rush unprepared into a fall.
    (source)
    And here's Yud talking on the Lex podcast:
    If it were up to me I would be like — okay, like this far and no further.
    Time for the Summer of AI, where we have planted our seeds and now we wait and reap the rewards of the technology we've already developed, and don't do any larger training runs that that."
    (source, time-stamped)
    Maybe I'm out-of-the-loop, but I haven't seen this metaphor until recently.
    Brief thoughts
    I really like the metaphor and this post is a signal-boost. It's concise, easily accessible, and immediately intuitive. It represents a compromise (Hegelian synthesis?) between decelerationist and acelerationist concerns.
    We should call it a "AI Summer Harvest" because "AI Summer" is an existing phrase referrring to fast AI development — trying to capture an existing phrase is difficult, confusing, and impolite.
    Buying time is more important than anything else, including alignment research! I believe we should limit AI development to below 0.2 OOMs/year. This metaphor succicintly expresses why slowing down won't impose significant economic costs.
    The benefits of an AI Summer Harvest should be communicated clearly and repeatedly to policy-makers and the general public. It should be the primary angle by which we communicate decelerationism to the public.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • LW - Communicating effectively under Knightian norms by Richard Ngo
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Communicating effectively under Knightian norms, published by Richard Ngo on April 3, 2023 on LessWrong.
    tl;dr: rationalists concerned about AI risk often make claims that others consider not just unjustified, but unjustifiable using their current methodology, because of high-level disagreements about epistemology. If you actually want to productively discuss AI risk, make claims that can be engaged with by others who have a wide range of opinions about the appropriate level of Knightian uncertainty.
    I think that many miscommunications about AI risk are caused by a difference between two types of norms for how to talk about the likelihoods of unprecedented events. I'll call these "inside view norms" versus "Knightian norms", and describe them as follows:
    Inside view norms : when talking to others, you report your beliefs directly, without adjusting for "Knightian uncertainty" (i.e. possible flaws or gaps in your model of the world that you can't account for directly).
    Knightian norms: you report beliefs adjusted for your best estimate of the Knightian uncertainty. For example, if you can't imagine any plausible future in which humanity and aliens end up cooperating with each other, but you think this is a domain which faces heavy Knightian uncertainty, then you might report your credence that we'll ever cooperate with aliens as 20%, or 30%, or 10%, but definitely nowhere near 0.
    I'll give a brief justification of why Knightian norms seem reasonable to me, since I expect they're counterintuitive for most people on LW. On a principled level: when reasoning about complex domains like the future, the hardest part is often "knowing the right questions to ask", or narrowing down on useful categories at all. Some different ways in which a question might be the wrong one to ask:
    The question might have important ambiguities. For example, consider someone from 100 years ago asking "will humans be extinct in 1000 years?" Even for a concept like extinction that seems very black-and-white, there are many possible futures which are very non-central examples of either "extinct" or "not extinct" in the questioner's mind (e.g. all humans are digital; all humans are dramatically genetically engineered; all humans are merged with AIs; etc). And so it'd be appropriate to give an answer like "X% yes, Y% no, Z% this is the wrong question to ask".
    The question might be confused or ill-posed. For example, "how heavy is phlogiston?"
    You might be unable to conceptualize the actual answer. For example, suppose someone from 200 years ago asks "will physics be the fastest-moving science in the year 2023?" They think about all the sciences they know of, and all the possible future sciences they can imagine, and try to assign credences to them being the fastest-moving. But they'd very likely just totally fail to conceptualize the science that has turn out to be the fastest-moving: computer science (and machine learning more specifically). Even if they reason at a meta level "there are probably a bunch of future sciences I can basically not predict at all, so I should add credence to 'no'", the resulting uncertainty is Knightian in the sense that it's generated by reasoning about your ignorance rather than your actual models of the world.
    I therefore consider Knightian norms to be appropriate when you're reasoning about a domain in which these considerations seem particularly salient. I give some more clarifications at the end of the post (in particular on why I think Knightian norms are importantly different from modesty norms). However, I'm less interested in debating the value of Knightian norms directly, and more interested in their implications for how to communicate. If one person is following inside view norms and another is following Knightian norms, that can cause serious miscommunication...
    10 min
  • LW - If interpretability research goes well, it may get dangerous by So8res
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: If interpretability research goes well, it may get dangerous, published by So8res on April 3, 2023 on LessWrong.
    I've historically been pretty publicly supportive of interpretability research. I'm still supportive of interpretability research. However, I do not necessarily think that all of it should be done in the open indefinitely. Indeed, insofar as interpretability researchers gain understanding of AIs that could significantly advance the capabilities frontier, I encourage interpretability researchers to keep their research closed.
    I acknowledge that spreading research insights less widely comes with real research costs. I'd endorse building a cross-organization network of people who are committed to not using their understanding to push the capabilities frontier, and sharing freely within that.
    I acknowledge that public sharing of research insights could, in principle, both shorten timelines and improve our odds of success. I suspect that isn’t the case in real life.
    It's much more important that blatant and direct capabilities research be made private. Anyone fighting for people to keep their AI insights close to the chest, should be focusing on the capabilities work that's happening out in the open, long before they focus on interpretability research.
    Interpretability research is, I think, some of the best research that can be approached incrementally and by a large number of people, when it comes to improving our odds. (Which is not to say it doesn't require vision and genius; I expect it requires that too.) I simultaneously think it's entirely plausible that a better understanding of the workings of modern AI systems will help capabilities researchers significantly improve capabilities. I acknowledge that this sucks, and puts us in a bind. I don't have good solutions. Reality doesn't have to provide you any outs.
    There's a tradeoff here. And it's not my tradeoff to make; researchers will have to figure out what they think of the costs and benefits. My guess is that the current field is not close to insights that would significantly improve capabilities, and that growing the field is important (and would be hindered by closure), and also that if the field succeeds to the degree required to move the strategic needle then it's going to start stumbling across serious capabilities improvements before it saves us, and will need to start doing research privately before then.
    I reiterate that I'd feel ~pure enthusiasm about a cross-organization network of people trying to understand modern AI systems and committed not to letting their insights push the capabilities frontier.
    My goal in writing this post, though, is mostly to keep the Overton window open around the claim that there is in fact a tradeoff here, that there are reasons to close even interpretability research. Maybe those reasons should win out, or maybe they shouldn't, but don't let my praise of interpretability research obscure the fact that there are tradeoffs here.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • AF - If interpretability research goes well, it may get dangerous by Nate Soares
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: If interpretability research goes well, it may get dangerous, published by Nate Soares on April 3, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    I've historically been pretty publicly supportive of interpretability research. I'm still supportive of interpretability research. However, I do not necessarily think that all of it should be done in the open indefinitely. Indeed, insofar as interpretability researchers gain understanding of AIs that could significantly advance the capabilities frontier, I encourage interpretability researchers to keep their research closed.
    I acknowledge that spreading research insights less widely comes with real research costs. I'd endorse building a cross-organization network of people who are committed to not using their understanding to push the capabilities frontier, and sharing freely within that.
    I acknowledge that public sharing of research insights could, in principle, both shorten timelines and improve our odds of success. I suspect that isn’t the case in real life.
    It's much more important that blatant and direct capabilities research be made private. Anyone fighting for people to keep their AI insights close to the chest, should be focusing on the capabilities work that's happening out in the open, long before they focus on interpretability research.
    Interpretability research is, I think, some of the best research that can be approached incrementally and by a large number of people, when it comes to improving our odds. (Which is not to say it doesn't require vision and genius; I expect it requires that too.) I simultaneously think it's entirely plausible that a better understanding of the workings of modern AI systems will help capabilities researchers significantly improve capabilities. I acknowledge that this sucks, and puts us in a bind. I don't have good solutions. Reality doesn't have to provide you any outs.
    There's a tradeoff here. And it's not my tradeoff to make; researchers will have to figure out what they think of the costs and benefits. My guess is that the current field is not close to insights that would significantly improve capabilities, and that growing the field is important (and would be hindered by closure), and also that if the field succeeds to the degree required to move the strategic needle then it's going to start stumbling across serious capabilities improvements before it saves us, and will need to start doing research privately before then.
    I reiterate that I'd feel ~pure enthusiasm about a cross-organization network of people trying to understand modern AI systems and committed not to letting their insights push the capabilities frontier.
    My goal in writing this post, though, is mostly to keep the Overton window open around the claim that there is in fact a tradeoff here, that there are reasons to close even interpretability research. Maybe those reasons should win out, or maybe they shouldn't, but don't let my praise of interpretability research obscure the fact that there are tradeoffs here.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - Write more Wikipedia articles on policy-relevant EA concepts by freedomandutility
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Write more Wikipedia articles on policy-relevant EA concepts, published by freedomandutility on April 3, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    One way I think EA fails to maximise impact is by its focus on legible, clear and attributable impact over actions where the impact is extremely difficult to estimate.
    Writing Wikipedia articles on and around important EA concepts (except perhaps on infohazardous bioterrorism incidents) has low downside risk and extremely high upside risk, making these ideas much more easy to understand for policymakers and other people in positions of power who may come across them and google them. However, the feedback loops are virtually non-existent and the impact is highly illegible.
    For example, there is currently no dedicated Wikipedia page for “Existential Risk” and “Global Catastrophic Biological Risk”.
    Writing Wikipedia pages could be a particularly good use of time for people new to EA and people in university student groups who want to gain a better understanding of EA concepts or of EA-relevant policy areas.
    Some other ideas for creating new Wikipedia articles or adding more detail to existing ones:
    International Biosecurity and Biosafety Initiative for Science
    Alternative Proteins
    Governance of Alternative Proteins
    Global Partnership Biological Security Working Group
    Regulation of gain-of-function biological research by country
    Public investment in alternative proteins by country
    Space governance
    Regulation of alternative proteins
    UN Biorisk Working Group
    Political Representation of Future Generations
    Political Representation of Future Generations by Country
    Political Representation of Animals
    Joint Assessment Mechanism
    Public investment in AI Safety research by country
    International Experts Group of Biosafety and Biosecurity Regulators
    Tobacco taxation by country
    Global Partnership Signature Initiative to Mitigate Biological Threats in Africa
    Regulations on lead in paint by country
    Alcohol taxation by country
    Regulation of dual-use biological research by country
    Joint External Evaluations
    Biological Weapons Convention funding by country
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min