The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - Modal Fixpoint Cooperation without Löb's Theorem by Andrew Critch
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Modal Fixpoint Cooperation without Löb's Theorem, published by Andrew Critch on February 5, 2023 on LessWrong.
    TL;DR: This post introduces a novel logical approach to achieving group-scale cooperation, based on modal fixpoint theory. This approach is both easier to understand and roughly 3x more efficient than previous approaches that factored through Löb's Theorem, measured in terms of the length / complexity of the proofs involved.
    The following lemma is due to James Payor:
    Lemma: If ⊢x↔□(□xx)) then ⊢x .
    Proof: The proof uses the same modal rules of inference for □ as Löb's theorem, namely, necessitation and distributivity:
    ⊢x↔□(□xx)), by assumption.
    ⊢x(□xx), by tautology (A(BA)).
    ⊢□x□(□xx), from 2 by □ necessitation and distributivity.
    ⊢□xx, from 3 and 1 by modus ponens.
    ⊢□(□xx), from 4 by □ necessitation.
    ⊢x, from 4 and 1 by modus ponens.[end proof]
    Sweet! In comparison to Löb's Theorem, two things are beautiful about the lemma above:
    This lemma sidesteps the use of an auxiliary fixed point ⊢Ψ↔(□Ψx), by examining a proposition of interest (x) that itself has the fixpoint structure needed to self-validate; and
    It also allows the construction of unexploitable modal agents without Löb's Theorem; as follows...
    The following theorem was inspired by Scott Garrabrant, and uses Payor's Lemma in place of Löb's Theorem to prove cooperation between a group of agents. I'll state the theorem for three agents because that's most illustrative of what's going on:
    Theorem: Suppose A,B, and C are agents that return "true" to signify cooperation and "false" to signify defection. Let E=A∧B∧C, so E is the statement that "everyone cooperates". Let □A, □B, and □C denote proof systems that extend Peano Arithmetic, let □EX stand for □AX∧□BX∧□CX, and suppose the agents behave according to the following strategies:
    ⊢A↔□A(□EEE)
    ⊢B↔□B(□EEE)
    ⊢C↔□C(□EEE)Then it follows that ⊢E. Proof: Again we use the modal inference rules underlying Löb's theorem, but not Löb's Theorem itself:
    ⊢A∧B∧C↔□A(□EEE)∧□B(□EEE)∧□C(□EEE), by combining 1, 2, and 3 with ∧.
    ⊢E↔□E(□EE), from 4 by the definition of E and □E.
    ⊢E, by Payor's Lemma from 5, with x=E.[end proof]
    Intuitively, the strategy of the agents in this theorem is to check that the group is trustworthy in a certain way before joining (cooperating with) the group. The theorem, using the six steps of Payor's lemma, shows that the collective check on trustworthiness nests inside itself in a way that self-validates and yields cooperation.
    Discussion
    In the proof of the Theorem, you might be wondering if it really makes sense to be thinking of □E as a logical system of its own. The answer is yes, and the axioms E are just [the conjunction of axioms of □A]∨[the conjunction of axioms of □B] ∨ [the conjunction of axioms of □C].
    You also might wonder if an alternative approach to group cooperation might be to instead use the following strategies:
    ⊢A↔□(□AB∧C)
    ⊢B↔□(□BA∧C)
    ⊢C↔□(□CA∧B)
    Then you'd be right! Here it also follows that ⊢A∧B∧C. However, the proof involves a lot more nesting, with A thinking about what B's thinking about what C's thinking about (etc.), and it's not as easy or short as the proof of the Theorem above.
    Conclusion
    In my opinion, what's great about the lemma and theorem above is that they're both relatively short and simple (relative to proving and using Löb's Theorem), and they allow a proof of unexploitable group cooperation that's roughly three times shorter than than one that starts by proving Löb's Theorem (only ~6 lines of logic, vs ~18).
    PS James says his next idea will be even better ;)
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    5 min
  • AF - Evaluations (of new AI Safety researchers) can be noisy by Lawrence Chan
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Evaluations (of new AI Safety researchers) can be noisy, published by Lawrence Chan on February 5, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Related work: Hero Licensing, Modest Epistemology, The Alignment Community is Culturally Broken, Status Regulation and Anxious Underconfidence, Touch reality as soon as possible, and many more.
    TL;DR: Evaluating whether or not someone will do well at a job is hard, and evaluating whether or not someone has the potential to be a great AI safety researcher is even harder. This applies to evaluations from other people (e.g. job interviews, first impressions at conferences) but especially to self-evaluations. Performance is also often idiosyncratic: people who do poorly in one role may do well in others, even superficially similar ones. As a result, I think people should not take rejections or low self confidence so seriously, and instead try more things and be more ambitious in general.
    Epistemic status: This is another experiment in writing fast as opposed to carefully. (Total time spent: ~4 hours) I think this probably also applies in general, but I’m much less sure than in the case of AI research. As always, the law of equal and opposite advice applies. It’s okay to take it easy, and to do what you need to do to recover. I also don’t think that everyone should aim to be an AI safety researcher – my focus is on this field because it’s what I’m most familiar with. If you’ve found something else you’re good at, you probably should keep doing it. Please don’t injure yourself using this advice.
    Acknowledgements: Thanks to Beth Barnes for inspiring this post and contributing her experiences in the addendum, and to Adrià Garriga-Alonso, Erik Jenner, Rachel Freedman, and Adam Gleave for feedback.
    Introduction: evaluating skill is hard, and most evaluations are done via proxies
    I think people in the LessWrong/Alignment Forum space tend to take negative or null evaluations of themselves too seriously. For example, I’ve spoken to a few people who gave up on AI Safety after being rejected from SERI MATS and REMIX; I’ve also spoken to far too many people who are too scared to apply for any position in technical research after having a single negative interaction with a top researcher at a conference. While I think people should be free to give up whenever they want, my guess is that most people internalize negative evaluations too much, and would do better if they did less fretting and more touching reality.
    Fundamentally, this is because evaluations of new researchers are noisier than you think. Interviews and applications are not always indicative of the applicant’s current skill. First impressions, even from top researchers, do not always reflect reality. People can perform significantly differently in different work environments, so failing at a single job does not mean that you are incompetent. Most importantly, people can and do improve over time with effort.
    In my experience, a lot of updating so hard on negative examples comes from something like anxious underconfidence as opposed to reasoned arguments. It’s always tempting to confirm your own negative evaluations of yourself. And if you’re looking for reasons why you’re not “good enough” in order to handicap yourself, being convinced that one particular negative evaluation is not the end of the world will just make you overupdate on a different negative evaluation. Accordingly, I think it’s important to take things a little less seriously, be willing to try more things, and let your emotions more accurately reflect your situation.
    Of course, that’s not to say that you should respond to any negative sign by pushing yourself even harder; it’s okay to take time to recover when things don’t go well. But I strongly believe that people in the community give up a bit too easily, and are a bit too sc...
    26 min
  • LW - I hired 5 people to sit behind me and make me productive for a month by Simon Berens
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: I hired 5 people to sit behind me and make me productive for a month, published by Simon Berens on February 5, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Warning: this is not in typical LessWrong "style", but nevertheless I think it is of interest to people here.
    Most people approach productivity from the bottom up. They notice something about a process that feels inefficient, so they set out to fix that specific problem. They use a website blocker and a habit tracker, but none of these tools address the root problem. Personally, I even went as far as making my own tools, but they yielded only marginally more productive time. I craved more, and I was willing to go as far as it takes. I wanted to solve productivity top down—with a system that would enforce non stop productivity with zero effort on my part.
    I had tried less intense “watch you work” solutions before. Sharing a screen with someone through FocusMate coworking was great, but I had problems scheduling and keeping consistent sessions because of my chaotic calendar. StudyTogether’s leaderboard was a great way to push myself to spend hours in the server, but I found myself eating dinner or napping instead of being productive with nobody the wiser.
    I decided it was time to try the nuclear option: having people physically sit behind me to keep me on task. And if I was going to do that I was going to do it right: they’d be there 16 hours a day and only leave for me to sleep. (I have an endlessly growing list of projects I want to make, books I want to read, and skills I want to learn, so productivity means a lot to me!)
    It fit my chaotic schedule well, because if I had a call or appointment I would step out, and then go right back to work when I would get back. There was also no way to game the system because they could see everything I was doing.
    Hiring
    I made the following Craigslist post and eagerly refreshed my inbox:
    At first, I interviewed applicants about their data entry and cooking skills, but realized it was far more important to get a feel for how comfortable we were working around each other. I moved all but one of the interview candidates who actually showed up (which was only ⅓!) to the trial stage and, in the end, chose three people, with two others as backups.
    This is what the shift schedule looked like (not their real names):
    (I didn’t mean to only hire women; it just turned out that way. One guy actually canceled at the last minute. For reference, ~70% of my applicants were women.)
    The Setup
    The Experience
    Sunday night, before the first day, I was also so scared of sleeping through my alarm—and failing my first productivity test—that I almost didn't get any sleep. I woke up at 6:55, threw on my clothes, double checked that my room wasn’t a horrible mess and raced downstairs to meet Sophia by 7.
    Walking up the stairs, we exchanged morning pleasantries as best as one can at 7am in the morning. To my surprise, we were both less nervous than I had expected. Sophia actually seemed excited about the experiment, talking about her own journey with productivity and how she thought this was a smart thing to do. Upstairs, I let Sophia get situated at the desk, and we were off to the races!
    The first thing I immediately noticed was I felt uncomfortable going to the bathroom because the assistants were effectively right outside my bathroom door. Aside from that, the first day was unquestionably a success. In the morning session, I did yoga, went to the gym, started two blog posts, and did some work for my job. The thought of doing happy baby in full view of someone else mildly unsettled me, so I asked Sophia not to watch my yoga. I asked her to prepare a post-workout smoothie to be ready before I came back from the gym.
    I was unjustifiably worried about an assistant crossover, so near the end of the session I asked Sophia to leave ...
    15 min
  • AF - Modal Fixpoint Cooperation without Löb's Theorem by Andrew Critch
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Modal Fixpoint Cooperation without Löb's Theorem, published by Andrew Critch on February 5, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    TL;DR: This post introduces a novel logical approach to achieving group-scale cooperation, based on modal fixpoint theory. This approach is both easier to understand and roughly 3x more efficient than previous approaches that factored through Löb's Theorem, measured in terms of the length / complexity of the proofs involved.
    The following lemma is due to James Payor:
    Lemma: If ⊢x↔□(□xx)) then ⊢x .
    Proof: The proof uses the same modal rules of inference for □ as Löb's theorem, namely, necessitation and distributivity:
    ⊢x↔□(□xx)), by assumption.
    ⊢x(□xx), by tautology (A(BA)).
    ⊢□x□(□xx), from 2 by □ necessitation and distributivity.
    ⊢□xx, from 3 and 1 by modus ponens.
    ⊢□(□xx), from 4 by □ necessitation.
    ⊢x, from 4 and 1 by modus ponens.[end proof]
    Sweet! In comparison to Löb's Theorem, two things are beautiful about the lemma above:
    This lemma sidesteps the use of an auxiliary fixed point ⊢Ψ↔(□Ψx), by examining a proposition of interest (x) that itself has the fixpoint structure needed to self-validate; and
    It also allows the construction of unexploitable modal agents without Löb's Theorem; as follows...
    The following theorem was inspired by Scott Garrabrant, and uses Payor's Lemma in place of Löb's Theorem to prove cooperation between a group of agents. I'll state the theorem for three agents because that's most illustrative of what's going on:
    Theorem: Suppose A,B, and C are agents that return "true" to signify cooperation and "false" to signify defection. Let E=A∧B∧C, so E is the statement that "everyone cooperates". Let □A, □B, and □C denote proof systems that extend Peano Arithmetic, let □EX stand for □AX∧□BX∧□CX, and suppose the agents behave according to the following strategies:
    ⊢A↔□A(□EEE)
    ⊢B↔□B(□EEE)
    ⊢C↔□C(□EEE)Then it follows that ⊢E. Proof: Again we use the modal inference rules underlying Löb's theorem, but not Löb's Theorem itself:
    ⊢A∧B∧C↔□A(□EEE)∧□B(□EEE)∧□C(□EEE), by combining 1, 2, and 3 with ∧.
    ⊢E↔□E(□EE), from 4 by the definition of E and □E.
    ⊢E, by Payor's Lemma from 5, with x=E.[end proof]
    Intuitively, the strategy of the agents in this theorem is to check that the group is trustworthy in a certain way before joining (cooperating with) the group. The theorem, using the six steps of Payor's lemma, shows that the collective check on trustworthiness nests inside itself in a way that self-validates and yields cooperation.
    Discussion
    In the proof of the Theorem, you might be wondering if it really makes sense to be thinking of □E as a logical system of its own. The answer is yes, and the axioms E are just [the conjunction of axioms of □A]∨[the conjunction of axioms of □B] ∨ [the conjunction of axioms of □C].
    You also might wonder if an alternative approach to group cooperation might be to instead use the following strategies:
    ⊢A↔□(□AB∧C)
    ⊢B↔□(□BA∧C)
    ⊢C↔□(□CA∧B)
    Then you'd be right! Here it also follows that ⊢A∧B∧C. However, the proof involves a lot more nesting, with A thinking about what B's thinking about what C's thinking about (etc.), and it's not as easy or short as the proof of the Theorem above.
    Conclusion
    In my opinion, what's great about the lemma and theorem above is that they're both relatively short and simple (relative to proving and using Löb's Theorem), and they allow a proof of unexploitable group cooperation that's roughly three times shorter than than one that starts by proving Löb's Theorem (only ~6 lines of logic, vs ~18).
    PS James says his next idea will be even better ;)
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    5 min
  • EA - Thank you so much to everyone at CEA who helps with our community's health and forum. by Arvin
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Thank you so much to everyone at CEA who helps with our community's health and forum., published by Arvin on February 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Overflowing with gratefulness thinking about the crucial work they do while going through so many hard times. I'm emotional and loss for words so all I can say is thank you, thank you, thank you so much for your efforts Julia Wise, Catherine Low, Chana Messinger, Eve McCormick, Nicole Ross, Lorenzo Buonanno, Ryan Fugate, Amber Dawn, Edo Arad, Aaron Gertler, Lizka Vaintrob, Ben West, JP Addison and everyone else who helps with our forum. You folks work insanely hard through recent crazy circumstances. I'm so grateful our community has all of you. Thank you, thank you.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - [Atlas Fellowship] Why do 100 high-schoolers need $50k each from Open Philanthropy? by Sparcalum2
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: [Atlas Fellowship] Why do 100 high-schoolers need $50k each from Open Philanthropy?, published by Sparcalum2 on February 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Note this is a sincere question. Not intended to cause controversy. It was inspired by this post questioning another OP Grant.
    Full Disclosure
    I applied to the Atlas Fellowship but was rejected. However, I attended SPARC, a free in-person program that teaches rationality tools to high schoolers (and follows a similar structure to Atlas Fellowship's camp). I'm friends with many Atlas Fellows.
    What is the Atlas Fellowship?
    For those newer to the EA Community, the Atlas Fellowship is a competitive program for high schoolers. If you are awarded it, you receive,
    A $50k scholarship (or $12,000 for Atlas India).
    Atlas Fellows can spend this money on anything considered an "academic expense". This includes travel expenses if justification can be provided.
    A fully-funded 11-day summer program in the Bay Area in a large former fraternity on UC Berkley's campus.
    College admissions preparation for top universities. (The admissions tutors are paid $200-300/hr).
    Access to the $1m Atlas Fund to learn, experiment, and build impactful projects.
    For 500 finalists, they receive $1,000 and 5 free books.
    Total Cost of Prizes
    $50k x 100 + $12k x 20 + $1k x 500 = $5.74m
    This does not include the instructors, venue, or travel costs.
    What made me write this post?
    This came to my attention after reading EA London's monthly newsletter. It highlighted new grants that Open Philanthropy made. I learnt that OP made an additional $1.8m grant to the Atlas Fellowship in December 2022
    This is on top of a $5m grant they made in March 2022 and a $5m grant that the FTX Future Fund made.
    There is much discussion (even amongst Atlas Fellows) that it is not a good use of money and that high schoolers don't need $50k scholarships; therefore, I felt raising this question is worthwhile and of interest to the wider community.
    Questions I have for Open Philanthropy and the Atlas Fellowship
    Why do high schoolers need $50k scholarships? If the reason is to attract talent, why is this required when programs such as SPARC and ESPR do an excellent job of attracting talented high schoolers?
    Note that SPARC and ESPR have been running for close to a decade. Many alumni go to top universities worldwide (MIT, Stanford, Oxford, etc.)
    I estimate each Atlas Fellow costs $80-90k, given you need to divide the total costs by the number of fellows (i.e., instructor cost should be considered).
    If the answer is to attract better talent, is there a significant difference in talent between Atlas Fellows and those attending SPARC and ESPR that makes this $80-90k money worthwhile? (Note that this would be over 20 lives saved through the Against Malaria Foundation).
    Why was a $50k scholarship offered if a $25k scholarship would attract, say, 80-90% of the same applicants?
    I suspect that a $5k unconditional grant that they can spend on whatever would attract just as many quality applications and be much cheaper.
    What is the breakdown of the socioeconomic background of Atlas Fellows? What countries are all Atlas Fellows from? What about the finalists?
    Atlas says they're doing "talent search". This connotes finding talent from under-resourced communities or poor students. Do the statistics match this?
    From friends who are Atlas Fellows, they said many Atlas Fellows do not require the scholarship as their parents earn a lot and can already pay for college. This makes me question why some people are accepted as $50k to the Against Malaria Foundation, which would save over ten lives. (Even more, if you consider it $80-90k). What are the Atlas Fellows spending the money on if their parents have more than enough to pay for college?
    What measures do they have to identify talent that ot...
    6 min
  • AF - Mech Interp Project Advising Call: Memorisation in GPT-2 Small by Neel Nanda
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Mech Interp Project Advising Call: Memorisation in GPT-2 Small, published by Neel Nanda on February 4, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    I've recently been having advising calls with REMIX teams (Redwood's interpretability sprint) trying to give advice & feedback on projects. As an experiment, I've published a recording of one advising call (with Tessa Barton & Kushal Jain on memorisation in GPT-2 Small), I'm curious whether this is useful to anyone! IMO getting detailed feedback from a more experienced research is one of the best ways to improve at research, but have no idea whether someone else's feedback is comparatively useful, or whether my advice is good enough lol. Thanks to the team for being down to publish this, and the work!
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Criticism Thread: What things should OpenPhil improve on? by anonymousEA20
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Criticism Thread: What things should OpenPhil improve on?, published by anonymousEA20 on February 4, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    This post was prompted by three other posts on the EA forum. A recent post raises the alarm about abuse of power and relationships in the EA community. An earlier post suggested that the EA community welcomes shallow critiques but is less receptive to deep critiques. Dustin Moskovitz has recently mentioned that the EA forum functions as a conflict of interest appeals board for Open Philanthropy. Yet on the EA forum, there doesn’t seem to be many specific criticisms of Open Philanthropy.
    For the sake of epistemics, I wanted to create this post and invite individuals to voice any issues they may have with Open Philanthropy or propose potential solutions.
    I’ll start by discussing the funding dynamics within the field of technical alignment (alignment theory, applied alignment), with a particular focus on Open Philanthropy.
    In the past two years, the technical alignment organisations which have received substantial funding include:
    Anthropic (The president of Anthropic is the wife of Open Philanthropy’s CEO. The CEO of Anthropic is the brother-in-law of Open Philanthropy’s CEO.)
    ARC (The CEO is married to an Open Philanthropy grantmaker, according to facebook.)
    CHAI
    SERI MATS (A director/main leader has had a relationship with an Open Philanthropy grantmaker.)
    Redwood Research (A director/main leader is engaged to an Open Philanthropy grantmaker, according to facebook. Open Philanthropy’s main technical alignment funders are also working out of their office.)
    All of these organisations are situated in the San Francisco Bay Area. Although many people are thinking about the alignment problem, there is much less funding for technical alignment researchers for other locations (e.g., the east coast of the US, the UK, or other parts of Europe).
    This collectively indicates that, all else being equal, having strong or intimate connections with employees of Open Philanthropy greatly enhances the chances of having funding, and it seems almost necessary. As a concerned EA, this seems incredibly alarming and in need of significant reform. Residency in the San Francisco Bay Area is also a must. A skeptical perspective would be that Open Philanthropy allocates its resources to those with the most political access. Since it's hard to solve the alignment problem, the only people grantmakers end up trusting to do so are those who are very close to them.
    This is a problem with Open Philanthropy’s design and processes, and points to the biases of the technical alignment grantmakers and decision makers. This seems almost inevitable given (1) community norms around conflicts of interest and (2) Open Philanthropy’s strong centralization of power. This is not to say that any specific individual is to blame. Instead processes, structure, and norms are more useful to direct reforms towards.
    Right now, even if a highly respected alignment researcher thinks what you do is extremely valuable, the decision ultimately can be blocked by an Open Philanthropy grantmaker, which could cause people to leave alignment altogether.
    One common suggestion involves making the grantmaking process more democratic or less centralised. For example, the “regranting” approach has been successful for other grantmakers. This involves selecting a large pool of grantmakers or regrantors who have the autonomy to make their own decisions. With more grantmakers, there is less potential for Goodharting by individuals and reduces the likelihood of funding only those who are known best by a few Open Philanthropy staff. Additionally, Open Philanthropy can still choose regrantors who are more aligned with EA values or have previously demonstrated good judgement. A smaller thing that could help...
    5 min
  • LW - Small Talk is Good, Actually by Gordon Seidoh Worley
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Small Talk is Good, Actually, published by Gordon Seidoh Worley on February 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    You all liked the last two, so I'm going to keep it going so long as I have ideas and time. This is another casual post in the spirit of what I wish someone had told me when I was younger.
    Some people really hate small talk. I never really did. Mostly small talk just confused me or I barely registered the difference between small talk and big talk. So I never really cared about it one way or another.
    Then I moved to the Bay Area and lived with a bunch of rationalists and found out some people really hate small talk.
    I remember one time carpooling to a party. The party was in Palo Alto and we were driving down from Berkeley. As we started to cross the Dumbarton bridge we got on the topic salt flats. After a couple minutes one of my fellow passengers cried out:
    enough of this small talk! i could have this conversation with anyone! we're all thoughtful, interesting people! surely we can talk about something more interesting!
    And then sat in silence for a couple minutes trying to come up with a good enough topic of conversation.
    The standard arguments against small talk go like this:
    Small talk is too shallow. Only deeper conversations are worth having.
    Small talk is boring. It doesn't convey new information.
    Small talk is fake and full of bullshitting and hyperbole as people try to make themselves look good.
    Small talk asks people to casually share too much about their personal lives.
    Small talk demands people be constantly ready to say mildly interesting things.
    People value different things, and I'm sure some people legit don't value small talk and there's no convincing them. But our values are also informed by our skills. Sometimes what we think is a deeply held value is actually just a defense mechanism because we aren't good at a skill. So in this case, opposing small talk is sometimes the result of:
    being introverted and overloaded and not wanting to talk at all,
    being socially nervous or shy,
    having had bad experiences making small talk as a kid and getting excluded from groups because of it,
    having said something embarrassing or awkward or rude during small talk and fearing making the same mistake again,
    and so on.
    There's plenty of reason to find small talk hard. That's different from claiming it to be bad except in the narrower sense of being a bad experience for you. But that's rarely how "small talk is bad" is proclaimed. Usually it's someone who wants to get out of small talk and then makes a bigger claim that small talk is a bad norm.
    But there's actually lots of reason to think that small talk is good. Lots of people engage in small talk, and they do it for good reason.
    The main purpose of small talk is building social bonds. It's the verbal equivalent of primates grooming each other. We can use those increased bonds for various purposes. Sometimes that's getting to know more about someone so you can ask them more interesting questions. Sometimes it's building a network of friends you can call on for things. And sometimes it's setting up the trust needed to engage in deeper conversations.
    Small talk is often a necessary prelude to deeper conversation. Most people can't engage in deep conversations without first establishing a level of trust with the people they're talking with. They don't feel comfortable sharing until they know how others will react.
    So even if you don't like small talk, it's good to get good at small talk because many people like small talk and even need it to have the bigger conversations you may want to have. You might try to avoid people who like small talk, but that only kind of works. Eventually you need to interact with the wider majority of society that wants to engage in small talk, so learning how to talk small is a useful life ski...
    6 min
  • LW - Fucking Goddamn Basics of Rationalist Discourse by LoganStrohl
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Fucking Goddamn Basics of Rationalist Discourse, published by LoganStrohl on February 4, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Don't say false shit omg this one's so basic what are you even doing. And to be perfectly fucking clear "false shit" includes exaggeration for dramatic effect. Exaggeration is just another way for shit to be false.
    You do NOT (necessarily) know what you fucking saw. What you saw and what you thought about it are two different things. Keep them the fuck straight.
    Performative overconfidence can go suck a bag of dicks. Tell us how sure you are, and don't pretend to know shit you don't.
    If you're going to talk unfalsifiable twaddle out of your ass, at least fucking warn us first.
    Try to find the actual factual goddamn truth together with whatever assholes you're talking to. Be a Chad scout, not a Virgin soldier.
    One hypothesis is not e-fucking-nough. You need at least two, AT LEAST, or you'll just end up rehearsing the same dumb shit the whole time instead of actually thinking.
    One great way to fuck shit up fast is to conflate the antecedent, the consequent, and the implication. DO NOT.
    Don't be all like "nuh-UH, nuh-UH, you SAID!" Just let people correct themselves. Fuck.
    That motte-and-bailey bullshit does not fly here.
    Whatever the fuck else you do, for fucksake do not fucking ignore these guidelines when talking about the insides of other people's heads, unless you mainly wanna light some fucking trash fires, in which case GTFO.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min