The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - Basics of Rationalist Discourse by Duncan Sabien
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Basics of Rationalist Discourse, published by Duncan Sabien on January 27, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Introduction
    This post is meant to be a linkable resource. It contains a short list of guidelines that are intended to be fairly straightforward and uncontroversial, for the purpose of nurturing and strengthening a culture of clear thinking, clear communication, and collaborative truth-seeking.
    "Alas," said Dumbledore, "we all know that what should be, and what is, are two different things. Thank you for keeping this in mind."
    There is also (for those who want to read past the simple list) substantial expansion/clarification of each specific guideline, along with justification for the overall philosophy behind the set.
    Prelude: On Shorthand
    Once someone has a deep, rich understanding of a complex topic, they are often able to refer to that topic with short, simple sentences that correctly convey the intended meaning to other people with similar context and expertise.
    However, those same short, simple sentences are often dangerously misleading, in the hands of a novice who lacks the proper background. Dangerous precisely because they seem straightforward and comprehensible, and thus the novice will confidently extrapolate outward from them in what feel like perfectly reasonable ways, unaware the whole time that the concept in their head bears little or no resemblance to the concept that lives in the expert's head.
    Good shorthand in the hands of an experienced user need only be an accurate fit for the already-existing concept it refers to—it doesn't need the additional property of being an unmistakeable non-fit for other nearby attractors. It doesn't need to contain complexity or nuance—it just needs to remind the listener of the complexity already contained in their mental model. It's doing its job if it efficiently evokes the understanding that already exists, independent of itself.
    This is important, because what follows this introduction is a list of short, simple sentences comprising the basics of rationalist discourse. Each of those sentences is a solid fit for the more-complicated concept it's gesturing at, provided you already understand that concept. The short sentences are mnemonics, reminders, hyperlinks.
    They are not sufficient, on their own, to reliably cause a beginner to construct the proper concepts from the ground up, and they do not, by themselves, rule out all likely misunderstandings.
    All things considered, it seems good to have a clear, concise list near the top of a post like this. People should not have to scroll and scroll and sift through thousands of words when trying to refer back to these guidelines.
    But each of the short, simple sentences below admits of multiple interpretations, some of which are intended and others of which are not. They are compressions of complex points, and compressions are inevitably lossy. If a given guideline is new to you, check the in-depth explanation before reposing confidence in your understanding. And if a given guideline stated-in-brief seems to you to be flawed or misguided in some obvious way, check the expansion before spending a bunch of time marshaling objections that may well have already been answered.
    Further musing on this concept: Sazen
    Guidelines, in brief:
    0. Expect good discourse to require energy.
    Don't say straightforwardly false things.
    Track (for yourself) and distinguish (for others) your inferences from your observations.
    Estimate (for yourself) and make clear (for others) your rough level of confidence in your assertions.
    Make your claims clear, explicit, and falsifiable, or explicitly acknowledge that you aren't doing so (or can't).
    Aim for convergence on truth, and behave as if your interlocutors are also aiming for convergence on truth.
    Don't jump to conclusions—maintain at least two hypotheses...
    55 min
  • LW - AI Risk Management Framework | NIST by DragonGod
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI Risk Management Framework | NIST, published by DragonGod on January 26, 2023 on LessWrong.
    On January 26, 2023, NIST released the AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0) along with a companion NIST AI RMF Playbook, AI RMF Explainer Video, an AI RMF Roadmap, AI RMF Crosswalk, and various Perspectives. Watch the event here.
    In collaboration with the private and public sectors, NIST has developed a framework to better manage risks to individuals, organizations, and society associated with artificial intelligence (AI). The NIST AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF) is intended for voluntary use and to improve the ability to incorporate trustworthiness considerations into the design, development, use, and evaluation of AI products, services, and systems.
    Released on January 26, 2023, the Framework was developed through a consensus-driven, open, transparent, and collaborative process that included a Request for Information, several draft versions for public comments, multiple workshops, and other opportunities to provide input. It is intended to build on, align with, and support AI risk management efforts by others.
    A companion NIST AI RMF Playbook also has been published by NIST along with an AI RMF Roadmap, AI RMF Crosswalk, and various Perspectives. In addition, NIST is making available a video explainer about the AI RMF.
    FLI also released a statement on NIST's framework:
    FUTURE OF LIFE INSTITUTE
    Statement
    The Future of Life Institute applauds NIST for spearheading a multiyear and stakeholder initiative to improve the management of risks in the form of the Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF). As an active participant in its development process, we view the AI RMF as a crucial step in fostering a culture of risk identification and mitigation in the US and abroad.With this launch, NIST has created a global public good. The AI RMF decreases barriers to examining the implications of Al on individuals, communities, and the planet by organizations charged with designing, developing, deploying, or using this technology. Moreover, we believe that this effort represents a critical opportunity for institutional leadership to establish clear boundaries around acceptable outcomes for Al usage. Many firms have already set limitations on the development of weapons and on activities that lead to clear physical or psychological harm, among others.
    The release of version 1.0 of the AI RMF is not the conclusion of this effort. We praise NIST's commitment to update the document continuously as our common understanding of Al's impact on society evolves. In addition, we appreciate that stakeholders will be given concrete guidance for implementing these ideas via the agency's efforts in the form of a "playbook." External to NIST, our colleagues at the University of California, Berkeley are complementing the AI RMF with a profile dedicated to increasingly multi or general-purpose Al systems.
    Lastly, we recognize that for the AI RMF to be effective, it must be applied by stakeholders. In a perfect world, organizations would devote resources to identifying and mitigating the risks from Al intrinsically. In reality, incentives are needed to push this process forward. We/you/society can help to create these incentives in the following ways:
    Making compliance with the AI RMF a submission requirement at prestigious Al conferences;
    Having insurance companies provide coverage benefits to entities that evaluate Al risks through the AI RMF or another similar instrument;
    Convincing local, state, or the federal government to prioritize Al procurement based on demonstrable compliance with the AI RMF; and,
    Generating positive consumer sentiment for organizations that publicly express devoting resources to the AI RMF process.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinea...
    4 min
  • EA - AI Risk Management Framework | NIST by 𝕮𝖎𝖓𝖊𝖗𝖆
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI Risk Management Framework | NIST, published by 𝕮𝖎𝖓𝖊𝖗𝖆 on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - AI Risk Management Framework | NIST by 𝕮𝖎𝖓𝖊𝖗𝖆
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI Risk Management Framework | NIST, published by 𝕮𝖎𝖓𝖊𝖗𝖆 on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - A new framing to replace "Welfarism vs. Abolitionism" by Aidan Kankyoku
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: A new framing to replace "Welfarism vs. Abolitionism", published by Aidan Kankyoku on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Inspired by what seems like a recent détente between different factions in animal advocacy, I just posted this two-part article to paxfauna.org and wanted to share it here as well. It has more of a narrative form but I try to present a new way of thinking about these different roles in the movement. Hope you find it useful or at least enjoyable!
    Part 1: "Welfarism Vs. Abolitionism" Is Obsolete
    The Gist
    Animal advocates have been divided over pursuing more or less radical demands, leading to a conflict often framed as welfarism vs. abolitionism.
    This framing obscures the fact that all strategies used by animal advocates are incremental; we merely focus on different increments.
    Existing evidence does not support some of activists’ most common concerns about incremental welfare campaigns.
    A more sophisticated view of the different roles necessary in a movement ecology can resolve these conflicts.
    An Innocent Question
    When I was in college, around 2016, my campus animal rights club hosted a talk by the local representative of The Humane League (THL). As she stood facing about two dozen college students interested in animal activism, she began her talk with a question:
    “What goal should animal activists pursue?”
    After several seconds of silence, I threw out an answer that reflected my background as an organizer with Direct Action Everywhere (DxE for short). DxE had a notorious flair for dramatic confrontations with the public, using disruptive protest to demand a complete dismantling of the legal systems abetting the exploitation of other animals for the benefit of humans. My answer, one of DxE’s slogans, was shorthand for that:
    “Total animal liberation.”
    The THL rep (I’ll call her Kristy since I haven’t asked permission to use her name) endured an awkward silence waiting to see if anyone else would respond. Kristy had been working for THL about as long as I’d been organizing with DxE. Her job was to mobilize volunteers to support THL’s signature tactics: handing out leaflets to the public about meatless diets, and pressuring corporations like Mcdonald's to set animal welfare standards for their supply chains. When she clicked to the next slide, the answer waiting there was, like mine, a reflection of her organization’s ethos:
    “Reduce the greatest amount of suffering for the greatest number of animals we can.”
    Them’s Fightin’ Words
    For an outsider to the world of animal advocacy, these two answers would probably seem perfectly compatible. Yet from the moment they were spoken, room 217 of the Hellems Arts & Sciences building was filled with a palpable tension. A conflict much larger than us had asserted itself.
    The humans that make up both THL and DxE share the extremely uncommon view that farming animals is a grievous moral harm, and the even less common conviction to dedicate their lives to opposing it. Yet back in 2016, this didn’t seem to be worth much. The relationship between the organizations was racked with mutual distrust, even disdain. And this malaise was merely a microcosm for a larger conflict among animal advocates, one that had been playing out for years in vicious comment threads across social media. To at least one side, this was known as the battle of welfarists vs. abolitionists.
    In a moment, I’ll explain why I hope this dichotomy will finally be relegated to the dustbin of history. In fact, I believe it was as useless and misleading back then as it is now. But that’s not what I thought at the time.
    As soon as Kristy’s answer appeared on the screen, a familiar narrative was racing through my brain. I had labeled her a welfarist, and as fast as my neurons could fire, this label was joined by a series of harsh judgments. K...
    31 min
  • EA - A new framing to replace "Welfarism vs. Abolitionism" by Aidan Kankyoku
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: A new framing to replace "Welfarism vs. Abolitionism", published by Aidan Kankyoku on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Inspired by what seems like a recent détente between different factions in animal advocacy, I just posted this two-part article to paxfauna.org and wanted to share it here as well. It has more of a narrative form but I try to present a new way of thinking about these different roles in the movement. Hope you find it useful or at least enjoyable!
    Part 1: "Welfarism Vs. Abolitionism" Is Obsolete
    The Gist
    Animal advocates have been divided over pursuing more or less radical demands, leading to a conflict often framed as welfarism vs. abolitionism.
    This framing obscures the fact that all strategies used by animal advocates are incremental; we merely focus on different increments.
    Existing evidence does not support some of activists’ most common concerns about incremental welfare campaigns.
    A more sophisticated view of the different roles necessary in a movement ecology can resolve these conflicts.
    An Innocent Question
    When I was in college, around 2016, my campus animal rights club hosted a talk by the local representative of The Humane League (THL). As she stood facing about two dozen college students interested in animal activism, she began her talk with a question:
    “What goal should animal activists pursue?”
    After several seconds of silence, I threw out an answer that reflected my background as an organizer with Direct Action Everywhere (DxE for short). DxE had a notorious flair for dramatic confrontations with the public, using disruptive protest to demand a complete dismantling of the legal systems abetting the exploitation of other animals for the benefit of humans. My answer, one of DxE’s slogans, was shorthand for that:
    “Total animal liberation.”
    The THL rep (I’ll call her Kristy since I haven’t asked permission to use her name) endured an awkward silence waiting to see if anyone else would respond. Kristy had been working for THL about as long as I’d been organizing with DxE. Her job was to mobilize volunteers to support THL’s signature tactics: handing out leaflets to the public about meatless diets, and pressuring corporations like Mcdonald's to set animal welfare standards for their supply chains. When she clicked to the next slide, the answer waiting there was, like mine, a reflection of her organization’s ethos:
    “Reduce the greatest amount of suffering for the greatest number of animals we can.”
    Them’s Fightin’ Words
    For an outsider to the world of animal advocacy, these two answers would probably seem perfectly compatible. Yet from the moment they were spoken, room 217 of the Hellems Arts & Sciences building was filled with a palpable tension. A conflict much larger than us had asserted itself.
    The humans that make up both THL and DxE share the extremely uncommon view that farming animals is a grievous moral harm, and the even less common conviction to dedicate their lives to opposing it. Yet back in 2016, this didn’t seem to be worth much. The relationship between the organizations was racked with mutual distrust, even disdain. And this malaise was merely a microcosm for a larger conflict among animal advocates, one that had been playing out for years in vicious comment threads across social media. To at least one side, this was known as the battle of welfarists vs. abolitionists.
    In a moment, I’ll explain why I hope this dichotomy will finally be relegated to the dustbin of history. In fact, I believe it was as useless and misleading back then as it is now. But that’s not what I thought at the time.
    As soon as Kristy’s answer appeared on the screen, a familiar narrative was racing through my brain. I had labeled her a welfarist, and as fast as my neurons could fire, this label was joined by a series of harsh judgments. K...
    31 min
  • EA - Getting Actual Value from “Info Value”: Example from a Failed Experiment by Nikola
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Getting Actual Value from “Info Value”: Example from a Failed Experiment, published by Nikola on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    TL;DR: Experiments that generate info value should be shared between EA groups. Publication bias makes it more likely that groups repeat each other’s mistakes. Doing things “for the info value” produces info value only insofar as 1) you actually try to do them well and 2) you process and share the information that they generate. As an example, we present a failed experiment we ran in the Spring of 2022 where we changed the format of our Precipice Reading Group, which had very low attendance due (we think) to a structure that felt impersonal and unaccountable. This, among other experiences, has taught us that personalization and accountability is very important for the success of a program. We invite other group organizers (or anyone else who does things “for the info value”) to share potentially helpful results of failed experiments in the comments.
    How “Info Value” Experiments Lose Their Potential Value
    EA group organizers often consciously change a program’s setup, or run an unusual program, “for the info value” – that is, they might not have high expectations that it will succeed, but “at least we’ll know if something like this works.” It is very valuable to try new things; EA groups have explored very little of the space of field-building programs, and good discoveries can be scaled up!
    But we want to raise two caveats:
    Running things “for the info value” is often paired with “80-20’ing,” where organizers run low-overhead versions of programs and don’t sweat the details. But if you actually expect a program to be impactful, you might not want to “80-20 it” – you might want to make the operations smooth, pay lots of attention to participants, and so on. This means that even while piloting a program, you get much worse info value if the program is understaffed or otherwise badly run and understaffed. If the program works anyway, this can indeed signal to organizers that an even better version could be great, but often the program goes poorly and fails to generate the info value of whether a well-executed version of the program would have worked. (We think our Precipice group described below mostly executed everything except the format reasonably well and does not fit in this category, but have witnessed this a few times, including in our own programs.)
    People seem much more likely to post on the forum about their groups’ successful experiments than their failed experiments, which might be resulting in lots of wasted effort. It’s understandable not to want to write a whole post about a failed experiment, though, so we’d like to invite group organizers to post about other things that didn’t work but generated useful information value in the comments!
    Example: Precipice Reading Group Format Change
    Harvard organizers have been doing Precipice reading groups every semester since the Fall semester of 2021. Their format was similar to an introductory fellowship: specific people were assigned to cohorts with an assigned discussion leader, and they were to meet at specific times and locations. There wasn’t an extensive application form, just a sign up form, and people were automatically admitted to the program.
    Dropoff rates were pretty high (~60% of signups came to the first meeting, and as we got more into the semester, only around 15% of signups would actually finish the reading group). This dropoff seems to widely apply to reading groups/book clubs. For example, a remote summer book club hosted by the Harvard Data Science Initiative went from around 15-20 participants to around 5-7 regulars. For comparison, in the Fall 2022 Arete Fellowship (with a more formal syllabus and application process), ~90% of admitted students atten...
    6 min
  • EA - Getting Actual Value from “Info Value”: Example from a Failed Experiment by Nikola
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Getting Actual Value from “Info Value”: Example from a Failed Experiment, published by Nikola on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    TL;DR: Experiments that generate info value should be shared between EA groups. Publication bias makes it more likely that groups repeat each other’s mistakes. Doing things “for the info value” produces info value only insofar as 1) you actually try to do them well and 2) you process and share the information that they generate. As an example, we present a failed experiment we ran in the Spring of 2022 where we changed the format of our Precipice Reading Group, which had very low attendance due (we think) to a structure that felt impersonal and unaccountable. This, among other experiences, has taught us that personalization and accountability is very important for the success of a program. We invite other group organizers (or anyone else who does things “for the info value”) to share potentially helpful results of failed experiments in the comments.
    How “Info Value” Experiments Lose Their Potential Value
    EA group organizers often consciously change a program’s setup, or run an unusual program, “for the info value” – that is, they might not have high expectations that it will succeed, but “at least we’ll know if something like this works.” It is very valuable to try new things; EA groups have explored very little of the space of field-building programs, and good discoveries can be scaled up!
    But we want to raise two caveats:
    Running things “for the info value” is often paired with “80-20’ing,” where organizers run low-overhead versions of programs and don’t sweat the details. But if you actually expect a program to be impactful, you might not want to “80-20 it” – you might want to make the operations smooth, pay lots of attention to participants, and so on. This means that even while piloting a program, you get much worse info value if the program is understaffed or otherwise badly run and understaffed. If the program works anyway, this can indeed signal to organizers that an even better version could be great, but often the program goes poorly and fails to generate the info value of whether a well-executed version of the program would have worked. (We think our Precipice group described below mostly executed everything except the format reasonably well and does not fit in this category, but have witnessed this a few times, including in our own programs.)
    People seem much more likely to post on the forum about their groups’ successful experiments than their failed experiments, which might be resulting in lots of wasted effort. It’s understandable not to want to write a whole post about a failed experiment, though, so we’d like to invite group organizers to post about other things that didn’t work but generated useful information value in the comments!
    Example: Precipice Reading Group Format Change
    Harvard organizers have been doing Precipice reading groups every semester since the Fall semester of 2021. Their format was similar to an introductory fellowship: specific people were assigned to cohorts with an assigned discussion leader, and they were to meet at specific times and locations. There wasn’t an extensive application form, just a sign up form, and people were automatically admitted to the program.
    Dropoff rates were pretty high (~60% of signups came to the first meeting, and as we got more into the semester, only around 15% of signups would actually finish the reading group). This dropoff seems to widely apply to reading groups/book clubs. For example, a remote summer book club hosted by the Harvard Data Science Initiative went from around 15-20 participants to around 5-7 regulars. For comparison, in the Fall 2022 Arete Fellowship (with a more formal syllabus and application process), ~90% of admitted students atten...
    6 min
  • EA - Moving money from fashion week to effective causes by Vincent van der Holst
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Moving money from fashion week to effective causes, published by Vincent van der Holst on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I apologize in advance for asking the EA forum to help us activate a campaign, but because I believe this to be an effective, new and interesting way to build the community and get more incremental money to effective charities, I have written the post nonetheless. If you feel this is inapproriate, please let us know in the comments.
    Fashion week is next month. The week where hip people wear overpriced clothing persuading normal looking people to buy the same clothing, resulting in lots of profits for shareholders. That got us thinking: can we create a fashion collection that is overpriced, worn by hip people, but where the status comes from the amount of good you do rather than the [insert luxury brand we can't name because we might be sued] logo on your chest?
    And so we created the "This is..." collection, a collection of t-shirts where all profits go to effective causes rather than shareholders of rich luxury fashion brands. We have the "This is malaria prevention" shirt donating to the malaria consortium, the "This is Eyesight" t-shirt, donating all profits to the Fred Hollows foundation and a bunch of other shirts. And we've created the most expensive t-shirt in the world, one that is estimated to save a hundred kids lives through malaria protection.
    With this campaign, we've tried to make effective giving appealing to the masses, by creating something they want (a high quality overpriced t-shirt), with a simple message ("This is a company") and we're trying to get hip people (press and influencers) to write about and wear them, so people will want to buy them instead of the garbage we see on fashion week.
    We think this is effective for several reasons
    The majority of the money for each t-shirt will go to effective causes
    This campaign makes effective causes more appealing with simple messages and activation through influencers and press
    Most buyers, press and influencers who will take part in this campaign are non-EAs, so this can help get people acquainted to EA
    Because most buyers will be non-EAs, this will move money to ECs that would have otherwise gone to something ineffective
    The success of the campaign will help our company BOAS get more traction, raise funding and become succesful so we can donate all of our profits to effective charities
    How you can help
    You can buy one of the t-shirts, they ship worldwide
    You can send this to 2 or 3 people who will find this interesting and who might buy it
    If you have the t-shirt, wear it a lot so people scan the QR code on the front, driving more traffic and sales
    Show of your t-shirt on social media
    If you have access to PR or influencers who you think might be interested, or you think you can help in another way, reach out to me on [email protected]
    Some things to consider
    We are operating this at a loss, but we still have to account for the cost of the t-shirt, shipping and VAT. You can see a breakdown of how much will go to charity on each shirt's page. The cheapest t-shirts have the lowest % going to charity because the relative cost is higher.
    We're not sure if you can deduct the donation amount from your taxes. It appears this will differ for each country and we can't say with certainty that you can.
    Right now the t-shirts have VAT on the total price including the donation, lowering the percentage we can donate. We're still figuring out if its possible to charge VAT on just the cost of the T-Shirt and not on the donation amount.
    If you want more information about the campaign, you can check out this onepager or our blog about it. If you have criticism or you're skeptical about this campaign, please let us know in the comments.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlin...
    4 min
  • EA - Celebrating EAGxLatAm and EAGxIndia by OllieBase
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Celebrating EAGxLatAm and EAGxIndia, published by OllieBase on January 26, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    In the first two weeks of January, we had the first EA conferences to take place in Latin America and India: EAGxLatAm in Mexico City and EAGxIndia in Jaipur, Rajasthan.
    Lots of EAGx events happen every year, and we don’t usually post about each one. But I think these events are particularly special as two of the largest EA conferences to take place in LMICs (Low and Middle Income Countries) and the first ever in each region. So, I wanted to share a bit more about how they went.
    Tl;DR: they went well.
    EAGxLatinAmerica
    EAGxLatAm was organised by community builders from the Spanish-speaking EA community with support from CEA. Over 200 people attended the event: ~32% of attendees came from within Mexico, ~13% from the US, ~12% from Colombia, ~7% from Brazil, ~5% from Chile and ~5% from Spain. There were also attendees from several other countries including Argentina, Peru, the Philippines, Canada, and countries in Europe.
    The event hosted talks in English, Spanish, and Portuguese and attendees could mark on their name badges which languages they spoke. Sessions included:
    A talk on the high-impact careers service, Carreras con Impacto;
    A virtual Q&A with Toby Ord to discuss existential risks and the role of LMICs in tackling them;
    Racionalidad para principiantes (Rationality for beginners) by Laura González Salmerón;
    A panel on Riesgos Catastróficos Globales (Global Catastrophic Risks);
    A panel on AI safety with staff from OpenAI, Redwood Research, CSER and Epoch;
    A talk on Animal Welfare cause prioritisation by Daniela Romero Waldhorn (Rethink Priorities);
    A talk by JPAL staff on ‘Applying evidence to reduce intimate partner violence’;
    A talk on local cause prioritisation by Luis Mota (Global Priorities Institute);
    A panel on EA in LMICs with EA community builders from Brazil, the Spanish-speaking community, the Philippines, Nigeria, South Africa, and EA Anywhere;
    A talk by Vida Plena (a new organisation incubated by Charity Entrepreneurship focused on mental health in Latin America);
    Meetups for attendees from Mexico, Chile/Argentina, Colombia/Perú, Brazil and Spain.
    The event received a likelihood to recommend score of 9.07/10 and attendees made an average of 9.37 new connections. Some quotes from the feedback survey I enjoyed reading:
    “I had a 1-1 with someone else interested in nuclear security and nuclear winter research, and we're developing an online reading group curriculum to [ideally] launch in March!"
    “I got convinced on deciding to focus on [sic] direct work on ai safety by talking to [two other attendees].”
    “I met Rob Wiblin at lunch and I didn't recognize him."
    One attendee described the event to a CEA colleague as “the best weekend of their life”.
    The event wasn’t perfect, of course. Several attendees reported that there was too much content in English that some attendees couldn’t follow, and some of the snacks and beverages seemed low quality. We hope to do even better next time!
    EAGxIndia
    EAGxIndia was organised by community builders based in India with support from CEA. 163 people attended: ~70% of attendees came from within India, ~9% from the UK and ~9% from the US. The rest came from Singapore, Indonesia, the Netherlands, Germany, and Brazil.
    The sessions were all in English, and included:
    A talk on South Asian Air Quality by Santosh Harish (Open Philanthropy);
    An AI governance Q&A with Michael Aird (Rethink Priorities);
    An update from the Fish Welfare Initiative, who are based in India;
    A talk on AI safety research agendas and opportunities by Adam Gleave (FAR AI);
    Two sessions led by Charity Entrepreneurship;
    A workshop on what the EA community should look like in India, led by Indian community builders and CEA staff;
    A talk mapping the...
    7 min