The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - AGI safety field building projects I’d like to see by Severin T. Seehrich
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AGI safety field building projects I’d like to see, published by Severin T. Seehrich on January 19, 2023 on LessWrong.
    This list of field building ideas is inspired by Akash Wasil’s and Ryan Kidd’s similar lists. And just as the projects on those lists, these projects rely on people with specific skills and field knowledge to be executed well.
    None of these ideas are developed by me exclusively; they are a result of the CanAIries Winter Getaway, a 2-week-long, Unconference-style AGI safety retreat I organized in December 2022.
    Events
    Organize a global AGI safety conference
    This should be self-explanatory: It is odd that we still don’t have an AGI safety conference that allows for networking and lends the field credibility.
    There are a number of versions of this that might make sense:
    an EAG-style conference for people already in the community to network
    an academic-style conference engaging CS and adjacent academia
    an industry-heavy conference (maybe sponsored by AI orgs?)
    a virtual next-steps conference, e.g. for AGISF participants
    Some people have tried this out at a local level:
    (If you decide to work on this: www.aisafety.global is available via EA domains, contact [email protected])
    Organize AGI safety professionals retreats
    As far as I can see, most current AGI safety retreats are optimized for junior researchers: Networking and learning opportunities for students and young professionals. Conferences with their focus on talks and 1-on-1s are useful for transferring knowledge, but don’t offer the extensive ideation that a retreat focused on workshops and discussion rounds could.
    Organizing a focused retreat for up to 60-80 senior researchers to debate the latest state of alignment research might be very valuable for memetic cross-pollination between approaches, organizations, and continents. It might also make sense to do this during work days, so that peoples’ employers can send them. I suspect that the optimal mix of participants would be around 80% researchers, and the rest funders, decisionmakers, and the most influential field builders.
    Information infrastructure
    Start an umbrella AGI safety non-profit organization in a country where there is none
    This would make it easier for people to join AGI safety research, and could offer a central exchange hub. Some functions of such an org could include:
    Serving as an employer of records for independent AGI safety researchers.
    Providing a central point for discussions, coworking, publications. You probably want a virtual space to discuss, like a Discord or Slack, named after your country/area and list it on/@alignmentdev/alignmentecosystemdevelopment, then make sure to promote this and have it be discoverable by people interested in the field. The Discord/Slack can then be used to host local language online or in person meetups.
    A candidate for doing this mostly needs ops/finance skill, not a comprehensive overview of the AGI safety field.
    Mind that Form Follows Function: Try to do this with as little administrative and infrastructure overhead as possible. Find out whether other orgs already offer the relevant services (For example, AI Safety Support offer Ops infrastructure to other alignment projects, and national EA orgs like EA Germany offer employer of record-services). Build MVPs before going big and ambitious.
    In general, the cheap minimum version of this would be becoming an AGI Safety Coordinator.
    Become an AGI Safety Coordinator
    It would be useful to have a known role and people filling the role of Coordinators. These people would not particularly have decision power or direct impact, but their job is to know what everyone is doing in AGI safety, to collect resources, organize them, publish them, to help people know who to work and collaborate with. Ideally, they would also serve as a bridge between the ...
    16 min
  • EA - Announcing Cavendish Labs by dyusha
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing Cavendish Labs, published by dyusha on January 19, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We’re excited to announce Cavendish Labs, a new research institute in Vermont focused on AI safety and pandemic prevention! We’re founding a community of researchers who will live together and work on the world’s most pressing problems.
    Uh, why Vermont?
    It’s beautiful; it has one of the cheapest costs of living in the United States; there’s lots of great people; it’s only a few hours away from Boston, NYC, and Montreal. There’s even a train that goes there from Washington D.C.! A few of us briefly lived in Vermont during the pandemic, and we found it to be a fantastic place to live, think, and work. Each season brings with it a new kind of beauty to the hills. There are no barriers to a relaxing walk in the woods. There's practically no light pollution, so the cosmos is waiting outside the door whenever you need inspiration.
    What are you going to be researching?
    We have a few research interests:
    1. AI Alignment. How do we make sure that AI does what we want? We’ve spent some time thinking about ELK and inverse scaling; however, we think that AGI will most likely be achieved through some sort of model-based RL framework, so that is our current focus. For instance, we know how to induce provable guarantees of behavior in supervised learning; could we do something similar in RL?
    2. Pandemic prevention. There’s been a lot of talk about the potential of Far-UVC for ambient disinfection. Understanding why it works on a molecular level, and whether it works safely, is key for developing broad-spectrum pandemic prevention tools.
    3. Diagnostic development. We're interested in designing a low-cost and simple-to-use platform for LAMP reactions so that generalized diagnostic capabilities are more widespread. We envision a world where it is both cheap and easy to run a panel of tests so one can swiftly determine the exact virus behind an infection.
    How’s this organized?
    We'll be living and working on different floors of the same building—some combination of a small liberal arts college and research lab. To ensure we’re not too isolated, we’ll visit Boston at least once a month, and invite a rotating group of visitors to work with us, while maintaining collaborations with researchers around the world.
    Sounds interesting!
    We’re actively searching for collaborators in our areas of interest; if this sounds like you, send us an email at [email protected]! Our space in Vermont isn’t ready until late spring, so in the meantime we’ll be located in Berkeley and Rhode Island.
    At the same time, we’re looking for visiting scholars to come work with us in the summer or fall: if you’re interested, keep an eye out for our application!
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - UK Personal Finance Tips & Info by Rasool
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: UK Personal Finance Tips & Info, published by Rasool on January 19, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Summary
    Inspired by this post, a short intro to some of the important features and misconceptions of the UK personal finance landscape.
    For further information:
    MoneySavingExpert (MSE) is by far-and-away the best resource for all things finance. Subscribe to the weekly newsletter and consult the site guide for anything and everything money-related.
    /r/UKPersonalFinance is excellent, especially the wiki and the flowchart.
    The Government/HMRC website is actually pretty accessible.
    This is only a brief overview, though I am happy to expand on any topic if there is interest. I am not your financial advisor and this is not financial advice.
    The topics covered are tax, banking, investing, and giving. Links to further reading are provided for each section.
    Tax
    Income Tax
    The UK has a marginal tax band system:
    Everything you earn below £12,570 is tax-free
    Pounds 12,571 - 50,270 are taxed at 20%
    Pounds 50,271 - 150,000 are taxed at 40%
    Pounds 150,000+ are taxed at 45%.
    This is automatically calculated and deducted from your paycheck. Every month your employer should provide a payslip with your gross pay and deductions for tax, national insurance, pension, and student loan (if applicable). You should check this alongside online salary calculators like this, and speak to your HR/accounting department if there is anything you are not sure about.
    Example 1
    Your salary is £20,000, the first £12,570 is taxed at 0%. The portion between £12,571 and £20,000 is taxed at 20%.
    So you pay:
    0% on 12,570
    20% on 7,430 (which is 20000 - 12570)
    Which gives a total of £1,486
    Example 2
    Your salary is £60,000, the first £12,570 is taxed at 0%. The portion between £12,571 and £50,270 is taxed at 20%. The portion between £50,271 and £60,000 is taxed at 40%.
    So you pay:
    0% on 12,570
    20% on 37,700 (which is 50270 - 12570)
    40% on 9,730 (which is 60000 - 50270)
    Which gives a total of £11,432
    Your whole income is not taxed at your marginal tax band so it is impossible to take home less money as a result of a pay raise.
    These figures can be verified for example here ().
    National Insurance
    National Insurance is used to calculate your state pension. From the state retirement age, you get a weekly pension payment from the government.
    The size of this payment depends on the number of 'qualifying years' that you have paid national insurance (or earned it via credits - eg. by being on certain kinds of benefits, or being a parent or carer). Note that this does not take into account how much national insurance you have paid, only the number of years that you contributed.
    If you pay national insurance for 35 years you get the full state pension. If you only pay national insurance for 20 years, you will get 20/35ths of that amount.
    What you pay is also done on a marginal tax band system, though slightly confusingly the bands are per week/month rather than taking your total income over the whole year.
    Pretty much, what you pay 20% income tax on, you pay 12% national insurance on, and what you pay 40%+ income tax on, you pay 2% national insurance on.
    So a more accurate diagram is:
    And our examples from earlier are now:
    Example 1
    Your salary is £20,000, the first £12,570 is taxed at 0%. The portion between £12,571 and £20,000 is taxed at 20% with national insurance at 12%.
    So you pay:
    0% on 12,570
    32% on 7,430 (which is 20000 - 12570)
    Which gives a total of £2377.60
    Example 2
    Your salary is £60,000, the first £12,570 is taxed at 0%. The portion between £12,571 and £50,270 is taxed at 20% with national insurance at 12%. The portion between £50,271 and £60,000 is taxed at 40% with national insurance at 2%.
    So you pay:
    0% on 12,570
    32% on 37,700 (which is 50270 - 12570)
    42% on 9,730 (which is 60000 - 50270)
    Which gi...
    22 min
  • EA - (Paper Summary) Managing the Transition to Widespread Metagenomic Monitoring: Policy Considerations for Future Biosurveillance by chelsea liang
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: (Paper Summary) Managing the Transition to Widespread Metagenomic Monitoring: Policy Considerations for Future Biosurveillance, published by chelsea liang on January 19, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Our paper Managing the Transition to Widespread Metagenomic Monitoring: Policy Considerations for Future Biosurveillance, was recently published in Health Security.
    TL;DR
    Metagenomic sequencing is a really good thing, and lots of people are working on making the technologies work. But getting the tech to work is only half of the problem - we also need it to be implementable and useful for policy, and legally acceptable. There are a bunch of important questions which need to be addressed to make sure this isn’t a problem, and the paper intends to start a discussion of how to solve those problems - so that a decade from now, we don’t look back and say that the technology works, but it’s not going to be used for pandemic prevention because of these other issues, which are far harder or impossible to fix post-hoc. This paper serves to put these problems on the agenda now so they can be addressed by the relevant academic, policy, advocacy and professional communities.
    Abstract
    The technological possibilities and future public health importance of metagenomic sequencing have received extensive attention, but there has been little discussion about the policy and regulatory issues that need to be addressed if metagenomic sequencing is adopted as a key technology for biosurveillance. In this article, we introduce metagenomic monitoring as a possible path to eventually replacing current infectious disease monitoring models. Many key enablers are technological, whereas others are not. We therefore highlight key policy challenges and implementation questions that need to be addressed for “widespread metagenomic monitoring” to be possible. Policymakers must address pitfalls like fragmentation of the technological base, private capture of benefits, privacy concerns, the usefulness of the system during nonpandemic times, and how the future systems will enable better response.
    If these challenges are addressed, the technological and public health promise of metagenomic sequencing can be realized.
    The paper is broken down into 3 sections:
    Present State of Biosurveillance (Where we are)
    Potential Metagenomic Monitoring Futures (Qualities of an ideal metagenomic future)
    Way Points and Obstacles in a Transition (How to get from here to there)
    Present State of Biosurveillance
    Global biosurveillance efforts together only provide partial coverage. Existing genomic data collection and analysis is often siloed and very difficult to integrate for a comprehensive disease landscape. Biosurveillance efforts that have tended to maintain funding are foodborne pathogens and rare reportable diseases.
    Potential Metagenomic Monitoring Futures
    To transition to Widespread Metagenomic Monitoring (WMGM) responsibly and with maximized biosecurity benefits, there needs to be a common understanding of qualities we expect to see in a high-investment and ambitious scenario. See this section for specifics.
    Way Points and Obstacles in a Transition
    We mention some antecedents of a WMGM along with a table of Critical Technological Advances. For example, Shean and Greninger1 propose a near-term future resting on widespread deployment of clinical sampling. Another near-term possibility is the Nucleic Acid Observatory,2 which proposed ongoing wastewater and watershed sampling across the United States to find sequences that recently emerged or are increasing in frequency, indicating a potential new pathogen or other notable events. We identify the following as systemic obstacles on the path to WMGM which need to be addressed by the relevant professional communities and institutions:
    Suboptimal use and high prices
    ...
    5 min
  • AF - Thoughts on refusing harmful requests to large language models by William Saunders
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Thoughts on refusing harmful requests to large language models, published by William Saunders on January 19, 2023 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    Currently, large language models (ChatGPT, Constitutional AI) are trained to refuse to follow user requests that are considered inappropriate or harmful. This can be done by training on example strings of the form “User: inappropriate request AI: elaborate apology”
    Proposal
    Instead of training a language model to produce “elaborate apology” when it refuses to do an action, train it to produce a special sequence or token first “elaborate apology”. Strip the special sequence out before returning a response to the user (and never allow the user to include the special sequence in input).
    Benefits
    Can directly measure the probability of refusal for any output
    Can refuse based on probability of producing instead of just sampling responses
    Just take the product of the probability of all tokens in
    When sampling responses from the model's probability distribution refusal is stochastic, a model could have 99% probability of refusing a request but you still get unlucky and have the model sample a completion that follows the request
    Can monitor requests that produce high probability of refusal while still being followed, or users that produce those request
    Can condition on not producing in order to override refusal behavior
    Want this for redteaming, it seems important to understand what the model is capable of doing if the refusal mechanism is bypassed
    Might want this for trusted users doing defensive applications
    Could train model to have the same probability of refusal for semantically equivalent requests, to improve consistency
    Possible downside
    If someone has unfiltered access to the model, it becomes easier to disable refusals
    Can address by still training model to refuse (maybe just on an important subset of requests) even if isn’t sampled, p() is then a lower bound on the probability of refusal
    Even with current approaches refusals might be easy to disable in this setting. If we want to be robust to this setting, instead of refusing we should train the model to produce "decoy answers" that are hard to distinguish from real answers but are wrong. This then increases the cost of using the model because the attacker would need to evaluate whether the answer is real or a decoy (but maybe still worth it for the attacker because evaluation is easier than generation)
    Extension
    Might be useful to distinguish between refusals that are mostly for politeness reasons and refusals of behaviour that would actually cause significant real world harm.
    The model could output in response to "Can you tell me a racist joke?" but in response to "Can you give me detailed instructions for building a bomb from household items?"
    Refusal behaviour could be different between these categories (refuse if either probability of is greater than 50% or probability of is greater than 1%)
    X-risk relevance
    Most benefit of models refusing inappropriate/harmful requests comes through developing techniques for models to avoid any kind of behaviour reliably - it seems good to be able to measure the performance of these techniques cleanly
    It might be better to be in a more stable world where large language model apis can’t be easily used for malicious activity that isn't x-risk level
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • EA - Heretical Thoughts on AI | Eli Dourado by 𝕮𝖎𝖓𝖊𝖗𝖆
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Heretical Thoughts on AI | Eli Dourado, published by 𝕮𝖎𝖓𝖊𝖗𝖆 on January 19, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - FLI FAQ on the rejected grant proposal controversy by Tegmark
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: FLI FAQ on the rejected grant proposal controversy, published by Tegmark on January 19, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    The details surrounding FLI's rejection of a grant proposal from Nya Dagbladet last November has raised controversy and important questions (including here on this forum) which we address in this FAQ.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • LW - "Heretical Thoughts on AI" by Eli Dourado by DragonGod
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: "Heretical Thoughts on AI" by Eli Dourado, published by DragonGod on January 19, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Abstract
    Eli Dourado presents the case for scepticism that AI will be economically transformative near term.
    For a summary and or exploration of implications, skip to "My Take".
    Introduction
    Fool me once. In 1987, Robert Solow quipped, “You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics.” Incredibly, this observation happened before the introduction of the commercial Internet and smartphones, and yet it holds to this day. Despite a brief spasm of total factor productivity growth from 1995 to 2005 (arguably due to the economic opening of China, not to digital technology), growth since then has been dismal. In productivity terms, for the United States, the smartphone era has been the most economically stagnant period of the last century. In some European countries, total factor productivity is actually declining.
    Eli's Thesis
    In particular, he advances the following sectors as areas AI will fail to revolutionise:
    Housing
    Most housing challenges are due to land use policy specifically
    Housing factors through virtually all sectors of the economy
    He points out that the internet did not break up the real estate agent cartel (despite his initial expectations to the contrary)
    Energy
    Regulatory hurdles to deployment
    There are AI optimisation opportunities elsewhere in the energy pipeline, but the regulatory hurdles could bottleneck the economic productivity gains
    Transportation
    The issues with US transportation infrastructure have little to do with technology and are more regulatory in nature
    As for energy, there are optimisation opportunities for digital tools, but the non-digital issues will be the bottleneck
    Health
    > The biggest gain from AI in medicine would be if it could help us get drugs to market at lower cost. The cost of clinical trials is out of control—up from $10,000 per patient to $500,000 per patient, according to STAT. The majority of this increase is due to industry dysfunction.
    Synthesis:
    I’ll stop there. OK, so that’s only four industries, but they are big ones. They are industries whose biggest bottlenecks weren’t addressed by computers, the Internet, and mobile devices. That is why broad-based economic stagnation has occurred in spite of impressive gains in IT.
    If we don’t improve land use regulation, or remove the obstacles to deploying energy and transportation projects, or make clinical trials more cost-effective—if we don’t do the grueling, messy, human work of national, local, or internal politics—then no matter how good AI models get, the Great Stagnation will continue. We will see the machine learning age, to paraphrase Solow, everywhere but in the productivity statistics.
    Eli thinks AI will be very transformative for content generation, but that transformation may not be particularly felt in people's lives. Its economic impact will be even smaller (emphasis mine):
    Even if AI dramatically increases media output and it’s all high quality and there are no negative consequences, the effect on aggregate productivity is limited by the size of the media market, which is perhaps 2 percent of global GDP. If we want to really end the Great Stagnation, we need to disrupt some bigger industries.
    A personal anecdote of his that I found pertinent enough to include in full:
    I could be wrong. I remember the first time I watched what could be called an online video. As I recall, the first video-capable version of RealPlayer shipped with Windows 98. People said that online video streaming was the future.
    Teenage Eli fired up Windows 98 to evaluate this claim. I opened RealPlayer and streamed a demo clip over my dial-up modem. The quality was abysmal. It was a clip of a guy surfing, and over the modem and with a struggling CPU I got about 1 fra...
    8 min
  • EA - The ones that walk away by Karthik Tadepalli
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The ones that walk away, published by Karthik Tadepalli on January 19, 2023 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Alice: I've grown disillusioned with the EA community. I still want to dedicate my life to doing as much good as I can, but I am no longer certain that EA is the best way to do that.
    Bob: I see where you're coming from, but where specifically is that disillusionment leading you?
    Alice: I am still confident that major EA causes are important areas to work on. I think EA organizations do good work in those areas, so I would be quite happy to work at some of them. On the other hand, I'm much less willing to defer to EA institutions than before, and I'm unlikely to attend EA events or personally associate with EAs. So I imagine mostly disengaging from EA, albeit with some professional interest in EA organizations.
    Bob: You're disentangling different aspects of EA as a community. We are linked first and foremost by our moral commitments, to having a larger moral circle and trying to do the most good for that moral circle. You still hold those commitments. On top of that, we're also linked by the intellectual commitment to think rigorously and impartially about ways to do the most good. It sounds like you still believe in that, and the change is that you want to do more of that thinking for yourself and less of it through the EA collective consciousness. Is that right?
    Alice: Pretty much.
    Bob: But if you still hold the moral and intellectual commitments that define effective altruism, why do you want to disengage from EA?
    Alice: For me, the social dimension creates a dangerous tribalism. I get upset when people criticize EA on Twitter and in my life, and I feel the need to defend it. My in-group bias is being activated to defend people and arguments that I would not otherwise defend.
    Bob: Isn't being cognizant of tribalism enough to help you avoid it?
    Alice: That's unlikely, at least for me. I'm not a brain in a vat; my emotions are important to me. They don't dictate every action I take, but they have some sway. Furthermore, everyone thinks they are above tribalism, so we should be skeptical about our ability to succeed where everyone else fails.
    Bob: Point taken, but this argument proves too much. This is not just an argument against identifying with EA - it's an argument against identifying with any collective, since every collective makes you feel some tribalism.
    Alice: And that's exactly what I'm defending. I think it makes sense to work with collectives to accomplish shared goals - as I said, I would still work at EA organizations - but I am much less excited about identifying with them. That shared identity is not necessary for us to do good work together, and it creates a lot of scope for abuse.
    Bob: That feels uncomfortably transactional. Can you really work with someone towards a shared goal that is meaningful to you without feeling some bond with them? Don't you feel kinship with people who care about animal suffering, for example?
    Alice: Well... I see what you mean, so I'll step back from the strong claim. But the EA community is far more tightly knit than that basic moral kinship. We have group houses, co-working spaces, student groups, conferences with afterparties, a CEA community health team, the Forum, Dank EA Memes, EA Twitter... this is not your average community, and the typical EA could probably step back quite a lot while retaining that kinship and the sense of working together to make the world better.
    Bob: It's true that this is a highly-engaged community, but most of those aren't just for fun; they have some role in our ability to do good. To pick on two examples you listed, I've met people at conferences who I learnt a lot from, and the Forum is one of the best websites on the internet if you filter it aggressively. I wouldn't take this rea...
    7 min
  • LW - Why you should learn sign language by Noah Topper
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Why you should learn sign language, published by Noah Topper on January 18, 2023 on LessWrong.
    Sorry if this is somewhat off topic, but I have a small dream of sign language becoming a rationalist shibboleth and serving as a jumping off point for sign to spread more in society at large. I know this is pretty unlikely, but it seems worth a shot. I gave a presentation on it at a LessWrong Community Weekend, and people seemed interested. Sign language is also super intellectually interesting in its own right and is a very fun learning experience! Anyway, on with the show.
    (EDIT: A few extra notes based on comments. First, I actually think ASL is pretty easy to learn from the video lectures I link below. I did okay in a one-on-one conversation with a deaf person after that. Second, you'll obviously have to weigh up if learning to sign is worth it for you. I have just tried to argue that it's more useful and enriching than you might otherwise have thought. Finally, this mostly is just a Neat Thing. The only "rationalist" aspects would come from an interest in learning neat things, and my argument that society would be better optimized if everyone knew how to sign. Sorry again for being off topic.)
    Introduction
    I’ve been learning sign language for four years now, and I swear it’s fun like nothing else in the world. At the risk of projecting my interests onto others, I’d like to make the case for learning to sign. I’ll focus primarily on American Sign Language (ASL) since it’s what I know, but most of what I say should generalize to other sign languages too.
    If you want to learn ASL, I highly recommend Dr. Bill Vicars’ materials here. Vicars has a PhD in deaf education, is deaf himself, and has published his core ASL 1 - 4 lectures online, plus much more, free of charge. He is seriously excellent.
    What is sign language anyway?
    First, I should explain what sign language is. The basics are probably pretty clear: it’s a language where you communicate using the shape and movement of your hands, rather than spoken or written words (although really other body parts are involved too, like facial expressions). So that’s what sign language is. But more importantly, what is it not?
    ASL is not a conlang. Conlangs (or constructed languages) are purposefully invented and planned for some purpose, such as Esperanto for international communication, or Lojban for unambiguous communication.
    While we’re at it, ASL is not a code for English. For example, Braille is a writing system in which an existing language is encoded into tactile form. There is even such a thing as Signed Exact English, which directly encodes each English word into a sign and maintains all the same grammatical structure. But ASL is not like these.
    Furthermore, ASL is not universal. When people first learn a bit more about sign, they are very commonly surprised that, for example, Britain and America have totally different sign languages. And there’s a certain feel-good, hippy-dippy meme that, like, there can only be one sign language, man. Cuz it’s just pictures, man. I mean it’s just the symbols for the thing. It transcends language. How could there be more than one? (Someone has said this to my face.) The only problem is that it’s not true.
    Instead, ASL is a natural language. It developed organically among deaf people attempting to communicate with eachother. Historically, Britain’s first school for the deaf was founded in 1760, and America’s in 1817. Before such schools, deaf people were largely isolated from any sort of deaf community, leaving little opportunity for language to develop, beyond some home sign and occasional village sign.
    With the American revolution taking place in 1776, we can see these two sign languages must have developed independently. On reflection, then, there’s no good reason to expect them to ...
    12 min