The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Polis (Cluster) Poll: What are our opinions on EA, governance and FTX? (Now with visualisation) by Nathan Young
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Polis (Cluster) Poll: What are our opinions on EA, governance and FTX? (Now with visualisation), published by Nathan Young on November 19, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Tl;dr
    I am editing this as I go
    Polis is a tool for understanding community opinion
    It allows us to see clusters of similar opinions
    It not a representative poll nor does it claim to be- it's not saying how many people think X just that the cluster exists.
    What are people's views on community/governance/FTX in EA?
    It creates a fun/interesting visualisation when enough people have voted. I think it will be about the most useful way to understand what different groups feel right now.
    Add your own comments
    It was mentioned on the 80k podcast (by Audrey Tang)
    It is anonymous unless you log in
    I will add the visualisations when we have enough votes. Polis is being a bit slow today so this may be delayed.
    Link here:
    Report here (this now works):
    Longer intro
    It is easy to have a false sense of what people think. But we don't have to - we have tools that allow us to hear what people actually think. One is representative polling. This isn't that. Here we can do cluster analysis (not a technical term) and look at what opinions are held in common. Do those who think Longtermisms is true tend to think that certain solutions are better than others? If so, why.
    It shouldn't be used to say X% of EAs think this. That's not what this tool is for. Instead, it should suggest interesting questions to ask in future.
    It would be very easy to use the loudest voices to decided what EAs really think. But that is unwise. Instead, if we want community input we should try and understand what groups form the community as a whole and understand what underlies the desires of each group.
    Example question
    Report
    Clusters and visualisation (Coming when Polis decides to work)
    There are three clusters currently:
    Group A largely think this is overrated and want clear suggestions
    Group B wants more robust internal mechanisms and hold EA responsible for not spotting this
    Group C is similar to group A but is more likely to hold those views. They also thinks that flirting at EAGs during the day time should be okay
    The majority views:
    Note that the red bars are thing that everyone disagrees with.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - First FDA Cultured Meat Safety Approval by Ben West
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: First FDA Cultured Meat Safety Approval, published by Ben West on November 19, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    In a major first, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration just offered its safety blessing to a cultivated meat product startup. It completed its first pre-market consultation with Upside Foods to examine human food made from the cultured cells of animals, and it concluded that it had “no further questions” related to the way Upside is producing its chicken.
    Note: I don't fully understand all the legal hoops that a cultured meat company has to jump through; it seems like this is a major one, but by no means the last.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • LW - When should we be surprised that an invention took “so long”? by jasoncrawford
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: When should we be surprised that an invention took “so long”?, published by jasoncrawford on November 16, 2022 on LessWrong.
    My first highly popular essay was “Why did we wait so long for the bicycle?” I’ve asked the same question of the cotton gin and the threshing machine. Others have asked it of the steam engine and the wheel. Recently Brian Potter asked it about wind power and Anton Howes about semaphore signaling systems. See more examples here.
    When asking these questions, we should think about when the question even needs an answer. That is, “why did it take so long” is only interesting if it took an abnormally long amount of time.
    Here’s my model for this.
    First, an invention is not going to happen at all if (1) it’s not technically possible or (2) there’s no market for it.
    Gate (1), technical possibility, could include, for example:
    Scientific foundations. No light bulb before electromagnetism, no antibiotics before the germ theory.
    Components. Airplanes were not possible before the internal combustion engine.
    Materials. Skyscrapers could only be built once cheap steel girders were available.
    Manufacturing techniques. Precision machining was necessary to make the gears, sprockets, chains, bearings, and other parts for a wide variety of inventions, probably including the threshing machine and the bicycle.
    Gate (2), the market, is whether it can be done commercially at a price that anyone will pay. If someone does make an invention there is no market for, it doesn’t go anywhere, and we might not even hear about it, because it is unlikely to make the history books. In any case, it wouldn’t affect the world, because it wouldn’t get distribution, and so it wouldn’t be historically relevant for our purposes. You see examples of this from time to time, such as the Korean movable-type printing press that predated Gutenberg.
    Note that the bar inventions have to meet is not just a proof of concept: they have to be sufficiently powerful, efficient, and reliable to be of practical use. Early computing machines were too slow; early threshing machines broke down too frequently; early light bulbs burned out too quickly. These are technically interesting prototypes, but not true inventions. An invention does not merely demonstrate a concept, it solves a problem—the whole problem, not just a part of it, even if it is the most visible or obvious part. An invention has to be practical. (See more discussion of this here.)
    Once something is technically possible and economically viable, then the clock starts ticking on how long we “waited” for it. But invention is a human process, and it’s not instantaneous. There is no perfectly efficient market in which an invention springs to life immediately as soon as it’s viable. It takes time, effort, trial and error. People have to decide to do something—they have to get the idea, and be sufficiently inspired and motivated to devote full-time efforts to something unknown, with an indefinite timeline and uncertain rewards. (Only a minority of people even have the temperament for this; in this sense, I agree with Anton Howes that innovation is not simply “in human nature.”) Then they have to get free to do it: at any given time, most inventors will be busy with projects, and only a subset will be looking for something new to do. They may have to acquire resources or recruit help, which takes time.
    Once they finally get to work, they have to experiment with approaches, discard failures, get new ideas, iterate.
    Given the nature of that process, there are several factors that affect the time that elapses before an invention. I have written about many of them before in the context of “flywheels of progress.” Here are some that I would call out specifically regarding the invention process:
    Total amount of R&D effort in the world, or in a specifi...
    8 min
  • EA - My takes on the FTX situation will (mostly) be cold, not hot by Holden Karnofsky
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: My takes on the FTX situation will (mostly) be cold, not hot, published by Holden Karnofsky on November 18, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    The FTX situation is raising a lot of good questions. Could this have been prevented? What warning signs were there, and did people act on them as much as they should have? What steps could be taken to lower the odds of a similar situation in the future?
    I want to think hard about questions like these, and I want to have a good (and public) discussion about them. But I don’t want to rush to make sure that happens as fast as possible. (I will continue to communicate things that seem directly and time-sensitively action-relevant; what I don’t want to rush is reflection on what went wrong and what we can learn.)
    The overarching reason for this is that I think discussion will be better - more thoughtful, more honest, more productive - to the extent that it happens after the dust has settled a bit. (I’m guessing this will be some number of weeks or months, as opposed to days or years.)
    I’m hearing calls from various members of the community to discuss all these issues quickly, and concerns (from people who’d rather not move so quickly) that engaging too slowly could risk losing the trust of the community. As a sort of compromise, I’m rushing out this post on why I disprefer rushing.1My guess is that a number of other people have similar thoughts to mine on this point, but I’ll speak only for myself.
    I expect some people to read this as implicitly suggesting that others behave as I do. That’s mostly not right, so I’ll be explicit about my goals. My primary goal is just to explain my own behavior. My secondary goal is to make it easier to understand why some others might be behaving as I am. My third goal is to put some considerations out there that might change some other people’s minds somewhat about what they want to do; but I don’t expect or want everyone to make the same calls I’m making (actually it would be very weird if the EA Forum were quiet right now; that’s not something I wish for).
    So, reasons why I mostly expect to stick to cold takes (weeks or months from now) rather than hot takes (days):
    I think cold takes will be more intelligent and thoughtful. In general, I find that I have better thoughts on anything after I have a while to process it. In the immediate aftermath of new information, I have tons of quick reactions that tend not to hold up well; they’re often emotion-driven, often overcorrections to what I thought before and overreactions to what others are saying, etc.
    Waiting also tends to mean I get to take in a lot more information, and angles from other people, that can affect my thinking. (This is especially the case with other people being so into hot takes!)
    It also tends to give me more space for minimal-trust thinking. If I want to form the most accurate possible belief in the heat of the moment, I tend to look to people who have thought more about the matter than I have, and think about which of them I want to bet on and defer to. But if I have more time, I can develop my own models and come to the point where I can personally stand behind my opinions. (In general I’ve been slower than some to adopt ideas like the most important century hypothesis, but I also think I have more detailed understanding and more gut-level seriousness about such ideas than I would’ve if I’d adopted them more quickly and switched from “explore” to “exploit” mode earlier.)
    These factors seem especially important for topics like “What went wrong here and what can we learn for the future?” It’s easy to learn the wrong lessons from a new development, and I think the extra info and thought is likely to really pay off.
    I think cold takes will pose less risk of doing harm. Right now there is a lot of interest in the FTX situation,...
    8 min
  • EA - Take the EA Forum Survey and Help us Improve the Forum by Sharang Phadke
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Take the EA Forum Survey and Help us Improve the Forum, published by Sharang Phadke on November 18, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    The EA Forum Team is running a survey of Forum users to help us improve our strategy and better serve the EA Community. We invite you to take this 10-minute survey here by the end of the day on Friday, December 9.
    Everyone who engages with the Forum is encouraged to take the survey — even if you don’t have an account, look at the Forum very rarely, or feel like you’re not a frequent user. You can also take the survey anonymously.
    We are offering free books to the first 200 respondents to encourage newcomers (and anyone who likes reading!) to participate. If you complete the survey, you will be given a link to claim any one of the books listed on effectivealtruism.org and we will ship it to you with our gratitude.
    Feel free to ask any questions in the comments below. Thank you in advance for your time and feedback!
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Moderator Appreciation Thread by Ben West
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Moderator Appreciation Thread, published by Ben West on November 18, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    You might have noticed that the EA Forum has gotten more engagement recently:
    A sudden 10x increase engagement would be a strain under the best of circumstances, but the moderation load has been even more than the increased engagement would imply, because recent topics of conversation have been unusually heated and targeted by spam, trolls, etc.
    Thank you to Lorenzo Buonanno and Ryan Fugate, who joined the moderation team a few weeks ago without expecting this, but have hugely stepped up; Amber Dawn, who has tirelessly flagged trolls, spam, and tagged posts; our long time moderators Edo Arad and Julia Wise and moderation advisor Aaron Gertler, who have taken substantial time out from their extremely busy other jobs to help; and of course Lizka Vaintrob for being the non-technical Forum lead.
    (For those who don’t know me: I manage CEA’s Online team, which includes the EA Forum.)
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - A long-termist perspective on EA's current PR crisis by Geoffrey Miller
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: A long-termist perspective on EA's current PR crisis, published by Geoffrey Miller on November 18, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    EAs seem so good at taking long-termist perspectives on everything -- other than our own movement's public relations (PR) issues.
    Let's try to apply some of our long-termist perspective-taking and future point-of-view imagination to the current situation.
    In ten years, we'll still remember the FTX/SBF crisis as a dramatic betrayal, a public relations (PR) crisis, and a significant financial and reputational setback.
    However, I'm also confident that in ten years, EA will still exist, will have restored its reputation, will still be attracting great talent, resources, and ideas, and will be doing more good than ever in the world.
    When we happen to find ourselves living in 'interesting times', it's useful to remember the age-old wisdom: the dogs bark, but the caravan moves on. This too shall pass. Think about all the 'huge crises!!!' that the news has covered over the last few years -- and how quickly each news story died down when the news media shifted to some new crisis narrative that carries enough monetizable outrage potential that it could attract clicks, subscribers, and advertisers.
    We are part of this week's monetizable outrage narrative. Every other week, ever since the development of the 24-hour news cycle, has had its own monetizable outrage narrative. If you've never been part of an outrage narrative before, welcome to the club. It sucks. It leaves scars. But it is survivable. (Speaking as someone who has survived my own share of public controversy, cancellation, and outrage narratives, and who has worked in several academic subfields that are routinely demonized by the press.)
    Also, haters gonna hate. Many people resent EA because it makes their warm-glow virtue-signaling seem superficial, irrational, and performative. They know deep in their hearts that it's hard to argue with the core EA values that we should use reason, evidence, and open debate to try to reduce suffering, and to promote a better long-term future. They've been waiting for an opportunity to attack EA as hypocritical or hyper-earnest, as hyper-rational or irrational, as hyper-nerdy or suspiciously cool, as hyper-sexual or incel-adjacent asexual -- anything they can think of. Just remember -- if you wouldn't have taken any misguided, uninformed, snarky critiques of EA seriously last month, don't take them seriously this week. Haters gonna hate.
    None of this is to minimize the actual, real-world impact of the current crisis. Many people lost of lot of money to a company they trusted. A major tech industry (crypto) will be handicapped for a while. Our organizations face real losses of resources, for a while. These are real problems, but I think they are not existential threats to EA as a movement, and they are certainly not good counter-arguments against EA principles and insights.
    There will come a time, maybe in the 2050s, when you may be sitting in front of a cheerful Christmas fireplace, a grandkid bouncing on your knee, and your adult kids may ask you to tell them once more the tale of the Great FTX Crisis of 2022, and how it all played out, and died down, and how EA survived and prospered. You won't remember all the breathless EA forum posts, the in-fighting, and the crisis management. You'll just remember that you either kept your faith in the cause and the community -- or you didn't.
    I hope more of us can take this kind of long-term perspective on the current situation.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • LW - Covid 11/17/22: Slow Recovery by Zvi
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Covid 11/17/22: Slow Recovery, published by Zvi on November 17, 2022 on LessWrong.
    While the news has been fast and furious on many fronts, Covid is not one of them.
    Except that, this week, I got it.
    On Monday evening, I started having chills. They seem better during the day, worse at night, slowly improving.
    That night, I was almost entirely unable to sleep. I would lie down to sleep, and my body would be having none of it, I’d simply be lying down in bed for the whole night for multiple nights straight. The third night was somewhat better. The third night did finally include a lot of coughing, which for now seems to have gone away.
    I thank everyone on Twitter and elsewhere for the well wishes.
    Needless to say, I am somewhat tired and not at full capacity. That is the main thing I am feeling right now – very, very tired and low energy. Other aspects are manageable.
    You do not want to get this. It sucks. It is a bad time.
    It also is something that ultimately has not been so bad. It will pass. Life goes on.
    My main writing focus this week until I got sick was assembling my post on everything that happened with FTX. I hope people find it helpful.
    Executive Summary
    I have Covid. It is no fun, but I should be fine.
    Remarkably little broader Covid news.
    Beijing seeing a spike in cases.
    Let’s run the numbers.
    The Numbers
    Predictions
    Predictions from Last Week: 250k cases (+4%) and 2,400 deaths (+20%).
    Results: 244k cases (+0%) and 2,139 deaths (+7%).
    Predictions for Next Week (not a holiday yet): 250k cases (+2%) and 2,250 deaths (+5%)
    There was some bounce back in deaths, but it still looks like the break in southern cases was for real. A combination of weather and variants seems like it should push case counts up slightly. For now, all seems quiet.
    Deaths
    Cases
    Physical World Modeling
    Oh look, we are intentionally creating strains of Covid-19 resistant to Paxlovid. Great.
    Oh look, another study that says that people who get Covid-19 will later be in poorer health than people who did not get Covid-19, without controls, so thanks for that.
    Paxlovid rebounds in 19% of study, versus 7% rebounds for controls (study).
    In Other Covid News
    White House seeks more Covid funding in lame-duck session. I don’t know why it would be forthcoming.
    White House extending ‘Covid emergency’ until at least April. Still finding it useful, likely because Congress tied policy to the state of emergency. Seems like somthing to avoid.
    Beijing reports 462 Covid cases on 11/14. It is very much Lucy and the Football territory at this point to assume Chinese Zero Covid will fail, yet they have weakened controls recently so it does seem highly plausible this has pushed them over the edge.
    Other Medical and Research News
    Open offices lead to 62% more sick days than individual offices, six person rooms lead to 30% less sick days than open plans. My guess is these ratios are a lot narrower with kids involved, a lot more important without them.
    I am seeing stories about the Canadian legalization of assisted suicide that suggest it is turning into something deeply scary. Some reports say it already accounts for 5% of Canadian deaths, and there are things like this.
    Some anecdotes about clinical trials and how impossible we have made doing them at any reasonable cost, with typical prices at hundreds of thousands of dollars per patient.
    The story starts with incestuous, insider-only requests for proposals that include fifty pages of useless boiler plate, followed by 20-person meetings in which firms defend their breakdown of costs and every little decision they are making, then a vibes-based final verdict among those who meet the criteria, so the whole process was meaningless from the start except as negative selection for extreme inadequacy.
    Now we have a vendor to do the trial. Then they have to do a similar...
    7 min
  • EA - Introducing the Animal Advocacy Bi-Weekly Digest (Nov 4 - Nov 18) by James Ozden
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Introducing the Animal Advocacy Bi-Weekly Digest (Nov 4 - Nov 18), published by James Ozden on November 18, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We are launching the Animal Advocacy Digest, a project aimed at collating and distributing the best research, news, and updates in animal advocacy on a bi-weekly cadence. Our goal with the project is to help people in the animal advocacy community quickly keep up with the most important information in the space even if they don’t browse the EA Forum or other sources daily. We’ll post the digest as an EA Forum post, as well as distribute it on this public email distribution - so you should sign up if you're interested! To start with, we'll only compile content posted on the EA Forum. This project will run as an experiment for 3 months, at which point we’ll evaluate how useful it is to users.
    Without further ado, here are the following posts summarised in this digest:
    Does the US public support radical action against factory farming in the name of animal welfare? by Neil Dullaghan (Rethink Priorities)
    Subsidies: Which reforms can help animals? by Ren Springlea (Animal Ask)
    The Welfare Range Table by Bob Fischer (Rethink Priorities)
    Theories of Welfare and Welfare Range Estimates by Bob Fischer (Rethink Priorities)
    What matters to shrimps? Factors affecting shrimp suffering in aquaculture by Lucas Lewit-Mendes & Aaron Boddy (Shrimp Welfare Project)
    Local Action for Animals as a Stepping Stone to State Protections by Precious Hose (original author, Faunalytics)
    (Bonus extra summary of interesting research) Low-cost climate-change informational intervention reduces meat consumption among students for years - Jalil et. al (2022)
    Does the US public support radical action against factory farming in the name of animal welfare? By Neil Dullaghan (Rethink Priorities)
    A pre-registered and US nationally representative survey by Rethink Priorities found approximately ~20% of respondents supported a ban on slaughterhouses when presented with arguments for and against. This number dropped to ~8% when participants were asked to explain their reasoning. Previous surveys by the Sentience Institute in the US found ~40% supported banning slaughterhouses or said ‘don’t know / no opinion’ to questions, highlighting a large discrepancy.
    Rethink Priorities suggests that previous polls which determined attitudes in response to broad questions (e.g. “I support a ban on slaughterhouses”) may not be accurate indicators of support for certain policies. These findings are notable for animal advocates as previous findings had been cited as support for bold reforms.
    Neil also notes that for future research, it might be useful to test a radical ask (ban factory farming) and a moderate ask (labelling for cage-free eggs, say) each with a radical message ("meat is murder") versus a moderate one ("human/consumer welfare") somewhat similar to this paper.
    Subsidies: Which reforms can help animals? - Ren Springlea (Animal Ask)
    A report by Animal Ask examines different subsidies reforms and how impactful these could be as campaign options for animal advocacy organisations. The five options examined are:
    Promoting welfare-conditional subsidies
    Abolishing or reducing subsidies for meat production
    Subsidies for feed crops
    Promoting subsidies for plant-based foods
    Abolishing subsidies for fisheries
    The authors say that they believe promoting welfare-conditional subsidies is the most promising campaign for animal advocacy organisations. They also believe reducing subsidies for meat production could be promising, however they suggest additional research to ensure that this doesn’t lead to an increase in the number of chickens (and overall animals) killed. They also note that they don’t believe options 3-5 above are promising campaigns, and encourage organisations to stee...
    9 min
  • AF - Updates on scaling laws for foundation models from ' Transcending Scaling Laws with 0.1% Extra Compute' by Nick Greig
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Updates on scaling laws for foundation models from ' Transcending Scaling Laws with 0.1% Extra Compute', published by Nick Greig on November 18, 2022 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    I am not sure if this paper is flying under the radar for many people, but has anyone read Transcending Scaling Laws with 0.1% Extra Compute? If so, how do you think it compares to the scaling laws presented by Deepmind's An empirical analysis of compute-optimal large language model training? Does it make you rethink the importance of dataset size (again)?
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min