The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Democratising risk: a community misled by Throwaway151
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Democratising risk: a community misled, published by Throwaway151 on September 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    In their post on 'Democratising Risk', Zoe Cremer and Luke Kemp argued that they faced threats of censorship and defunding if they published their critique of EA. Cremer has subsequently spoken to journalists about this ordeal. However, they did not disclose that Emile P. Torres (formerly Phil) was a co-author on the article, as Torres recently disclosed on Twitter.
    At this point, Torres had been banned from the EA Forum, they had called many people in the community white supremacists, racists, eugenicists and genocidal, and many people in the community had accused them of harassment.
    It was extremely deceptive of Cremer and Kemp not to disclose this information, because this, rather than the content of what they wrote, may have contributed to the (alleged) reception to their article.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Improving "Improving Institutional Decision-Making": A brief history of IIDM by Sophia Brown
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Improving "Improving Institutional Decision-Making": A brief history of IIDM, published by Sophia Brown on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Note: I’m undertaking a larger project to assess the potential of improving institutional decision-making (IIDM)—sometimes referred to as “institutional decision-making,” “effective institutions”, etc.—as a cause area or strategy within EA. My goal is to have more public discourse about IIDM. This is my first post in a series, which is the product of my conversations with EAs and research over the last 6 months. My conclusions are all tentative, and I invite all to collaborate with me in understanding and improving institution-focused work in EA.
    Thank you to Lizka Vaintrob, Konrad Seifert, John Myers, Nathan Young, Nuño Sempere, Jonathan Schmidt, Ian David Moss, Dan Spokojny, and Nick Whitaker for comments during the writing process. Mistakes are my own.
    Improving institutional decision-making (IIDM) has emerged as a term and point of discussion within EA in the last five years. It’s been discussed both as a cause area in itself and as a strategy within cause areas. It’s associated with other EA areas of interests, such as forecasting and political engagement.
    There’s an obvious guiding intuition here: institutions are powerful forces in world history and drastically affect global well-being and the longterm future. At the same time, many see EA’s emphasis on IIDM, at least in its current state, as highly uncertain, intractable or, if it is tractable, posing downside risks. There’s a lot to disentangle.
    Several long posts and articles take stabs at how to understand IIDM, measure its impact, and where to focus attention. 80,000 Hours considers it among the “second-highest priority areas,” alongside nuclear security and climate change. But in comparison, it has a less certain theoretical basis and has seen few projects involving practice.
    In this post, I trace the development of IIDM in EA. In brief, I believe that, because of its history in EA, IIDM is thought of too much in group rationality and forecasting terms, deemphasizing other tractable and worthwhile institutional reforms.
    Tracing IIDM Origins
    There is a deep literature on how governments function, how companies are organized, etc. Academics, particularly economists, political scientists, and sociologists, have studied institutions. Others in epistemology, psychology, and behavioral science have studied decision-making.
    The general arc of IIDM within EA begins with early conversations about how to engage with institutions broadly, dating back to at least the early 2010s. Around the same time—though as far as I can tell somewhat separately—the Rationality Community began growing in prominence as they investigated how to make better—more rational—decisions. These discussions began in Overcoming Bias (2006), the blog by Robin Hanson and Eliezer Yudkowsky, and later the group blog LessWrong (2009).
    I understand current conceptions of IIDM in EA as blends of these two threads of institutional and decision-making work. The 80,000 Hours problem profile on IIDM—the first big piece making the case for IIDM as an area of interest—drew predominantly from the decision-making thread. But broader notions of institutional work persisted. IIDM was further elevated by the IIDM working group of 2019-2020, which evolved into the Effective Institutions Project (EIP). Since then, several organizations and projects have done explicitly IIDM-branded work, and more have done work that is implicitly or related to IIDM. There has also been a massive growth of adjacent work, like policy advocacy and political engagement.
    I’ll now go a bit more deeply into each of the originating threads.
    Effective Altruism and Institutions
    Early discussion in EA about institutions seems to have...
    22 min
  • LW - [Linkpost] A survey on over 300 works about interpretability in deep networks by scasper
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: [Linkpost] A survey on over 300 works about interpretability in deep networks, published by scasper on September 12, 2022 on LessWrong.
    Toward Transparent AI: A Survey on Interpreting the Inner Structures of Deep Neural Networks
    Tilman Räuker [email protected]
    Stephen Casper [email protected]
    Dylan Hadfield-Menell
    TL;DR: We wrote a survey paper on interpretability tools for deep networks. It was written for the general AI community but with AI safety as the key focus. We survey over 300 works and offer 15 discussion points for guiding future work. Here is a link to a Twitter thread about the paper.
    Lately, there has been a growing interest in interpreting AI systems and a growing consensus that it will be key for building safer AI. There have been rapid recent developments in interpretability work, and the AI safety community will benefit from a better systemization of knowledge for it. There are also several epistemic and paradigmatic issues with much interpretability work today. In response to these challenges, we wrote a survey paper covering over 300 works and featuring 15 somewhat “hot takes” to guide future work.
    Specifically, this survey focuses on “inner” interpretability methods that help explain internal parts of a network (i.e. not inputs, outputs, or the network as a whole). We do this because inner methods are popular and have some unique applications – not because we think that they are more valuable than other ones. The survey introduces a taxonomy of inner interpretability tools that organizes them by which part of the network’s computational graph they aim to explain: weights (S2), neurons (S3), subnetworks (S4), and latent representations (S5). Then we provide a discussion (S6) and propose directions for future work (S7).
    Finally, here are a select few points that we would like to specifically highlight here.
    Interpretability does not just mean circuits. In the survey sections of the paper (S2-S5), there are 21 subsections, and only one is about circuits. The circuits paradigm has received disproportionate attention in the AI safety community, partly due to Distill’s influential interpretability research in the past few years. But given how many other useful approaches there are, it would be myopic to focus too much on them.
    Interpretability research has close connections to work in adversarial robustness, continual learning, modularity, network compression, and studying the human visual system. For example, adversarially trained networks tend to be more interpretable, and more interpretable networks tend to be more adversarially robust.
    Interpretability tools generate hypotheses, not conclusions. Simply analyzing the outputs of an interpretability technique and pontificating about what they mean is a problem with much interpretability work – including AI safety work. There are many examples of when this type of approach fails to produce faithful explanations.
    Interpretability tools should be more rigorously evaluated. There are currently no broadly established ways to do this. Benchmarks for evaluating interpretability tools can and should be popularized. The ultimate goal of interpretability work should be tools that give us insights that are valid and useful. Ideally, interpretations should be used to make and validate useful predictions that engineers can use. So benchmarks should be created which measure how well interpretability tools can help us understand systems well enough to do engineering-relevant things with them. Examples of this could be using interpretability tools for reverse engineering a system, manually finetuning a model to introduce a predictable change in behavior, or designing a novel adversary. The Automated Auditing agenda may offer a useful paradigm for this – judging techniques by their ability t...
    5 min
  • LW - Alignment via prosocial brain algorithms by Cameron Berg
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Alignment via prosocial brain algorithms, published by Cameron Berg on September 12, 2022 on LessWrong.
    In this post, I want to briefly propose a semi-novel direction for alignment research that I'm excited about. Though some of these ideas are not brand new—they purposefully bear resemblance to recent (highly promising) work in SHARD theory and Steve Byrnes’s approach to brain-based AGI safety—I think my emphases are sufficiently different so as to justify a more thorough explanation.
    Why are humans 'worthy' of being in the loop?
    I think the following three claims help motivate the general research direction I have in mind.
    1) Many of the most coherent AI safety strategies proposed to date (e.g., HCH, imitative and approval-based amplification, recursive reward modeling, and more) involve human decision-makers in some meaningful capacity. I claim, therefore, that these proposals implicitly presuppose that there are specific algorithmic properties of the human mind/brain that make us comfortable entrusting these ‘humans in the loop’ with the task of minimizing the likelihood of AI-induced bad outcomes. This idea is demonstrated especially clearly by ‘safety via debate,’ for instance:
    2) I think the special brain algorithms in question—e.g., the ones that make us comfortable entrusting a neurotypical human to decide who won in the set-up above—are more familiarly thought of as prosocial or moral cognition. A claim like this would predict that we would be uncomfortable entrusting humans who lacked the relevant prosocial instincts (e.g., psychopaths) to oversee a safety-via-debate-type set-up, which seems correct. I think the reason that it is a very natural thought to want to incorporate neurotypical human decision-makers into alignment proposals is that we are confident (enough) that such decisions will be made carefully—or at least more carefully than if there were no humans involved.
    In other words, individual humans in the loop are entrusted-by-default to serve as competent advocates for the interests of society at large (and who are more than likely aware of the fact that they are serving this role), able to infer suspicious behavior, evaluate subtle short- and long-term predicted consequences, be humble about said evaluations, probably solicit second opinions, etc.—somehow!
    3) Our understanding of human prosocial cognition is growing increasingly precise and predictive. In cognitive neuroscience writ large, computational modeling has become a dominant approach to understanding the algorithms that the human brain instantiates, with talented researchers like Joshua Tenenbaum, Robb Rutledge, and Anne Collins leading the charge. This work has taken off in recent years and has enabled cognitive scientists to define and test hypotheses that are unprecedented in their mathematical precision and predictive power. Here are two good introductory (1, 2) examples of this sort of work that pertain explicitly to human prosocial cognition. I expect my future writing—and that of others interested in this sort of approach—to feature far more examples of good alignment-relevant computational social neuroscience research.
    With these ideas in mind, my proposal is to conduct technical research to better understand these prosocial brain algorithms with the ultimate goal of instantiating some refined version of them directly into a future AGI (which is likely doing something approximating model-based RL). Here is a pretty straightforward two-step plan for doing so:
    Synthesize high-quality social neuroscience literature—with a particular focus on good computational modeling work—in order to more fully develop a rigorous account of the most important algorithms underlying human prosocial behavior.
    Develop specific corrigibility proposals for instantiating these algorithms in AI systems i...
    12 min
  • EA - What could an AI-caused existential catastrophe actually look like? by Benjamin Hilton
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: What could an AI-caused existential catastrophe actually look like?, published by Benjamin Hilton on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    This article forms part of 80000 Hours's explanation of risks from artificial intelligence, and focuses on how an AI system could cause an existential catastrophe. Our full problem profile on risks from AI looks at why we’re worried things like this will happen.
    At 5:29 AM on July 16, 1945, deep in the Jornada del Muerto desert in New Mexico, the Manhattan Project carried out the world’s first successful test of a nuclear weapon.
    From that moment, we’ve had the technological capacity to wipe out humanity.
    But if you asked someone in 1945 to predict exactly how this risk would play out, they would almost certainly have got it wrong. They may have thought there would have been more widespread use of nuclear weapons in World War II. They certainly would not have predicted the fall of the USSR 45 years later. Current experts are concerned about India–Pakistan nuclear conflict and North Korean state action, but 1945 was before even the partition of India or the Korean War.
    That is to say, you’d have real difficulty predicting anything about how nuclear weapons would be used. It would have been even harder to make these predictions in 1933, when Leo Szilard first realised that a nuclear chain reaction of immense power could be possible, without any concrete idea of what these weapons would look like.
    Despite this difficulty, you wouldn’t be wrong to be concerned.
    In our problem profile on AI, we describe a very general way in which advancing AI could go wrong. But there are lots of specifics we can’t know much about at this point. Maybe there will be a single transformative AI system, or maybe there will be many; there could be very fast growth in the capabilities of AI, or very slow growth. Each scenario will look a little different, and carry different risks. And the specific problems that arise in any one scenario are necessarily less likely to happen than the overall risk.
    Despite not knowing how things will play out, it may still be useful to look at some concrete possibilities of how things could go wrong.
    In particular, we argued in the full profile that sufficiently advanced systems might be able to take power away from humans — how could that possibly happen?
    How could a power-seeking AI actually take power?
    Here are seven possible techniques that could be used by a power-seeking AI (or multiple AI systems working together) to actually gain power.
    These techniques could all interact with one another, and it’s difficult to say at this point (years or decades before the technology exists) which are most likely to be used. Also, systems more intelligent than humans could develop plans to seek power that we haven’t yet thought of.
    1. Hacking
    Software is absolutely full of vulnerabilities. The US National Institute of Standards and Technology reported over 8,000 vulnerabilities found in systems across the world in 2021 — an average of 50 per day.
    Most of these are small, but every so often they are used to cause huge chaos. The list of most expensive crypto hacks keeps getting new entrants — as of March 2022, the largest was $624 million stolen from Ronin Network. And nobody noticed for six days.
    One expert we spoke to said that professional ‘red teams’ — security staff whose job it is to find vulnerabilities in systems — frequently manage to infiltrate their clients, including crucial and powerful infrastructure like banks and national energy grids.
    In 2010, the Stuxnet virus successfully managed to destroy Iranian nuclear enrichment centrifuges — despite these centrifuges being completely disconnected from the internet — marking the first time a piece of malware was used to cause physical damage. A Russian hack in 20...
    17 min
  • EA - Differential technology development: preprint on the concept by Hamish Hobbs
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Differential technology development: preprint on the concept, published by Hamish Hobbs on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Summary
    We have published a preprint of a paper describing the concept of differential technology development and exploring when and how its implementation may be viable. This manuscript has been in the works at FHI for a while, so we would love your feedback!
    Authors: Jonas B. Sandbrink, Hamish Hobbs, Jacob L. Swett, Allan Dafoe, Anders Sandberg
    Further details
    Nick Bostrom articulated the concept of Differential Technological Development in Superintelligence. This concept, and the concept of differential progress more broadly, has already been fairly widely discussed and written about, but within a limited community. This includes here on the EA Forum. The concept is typically used to argue that it would be beneficial to accelerate risk-reducing technological progress and retard risk-increasing technological progress, to manage potentially catastrophic or existential technological risks such as those from advanced AI systems and biotechnologies.
    With this paper, we attempt to thoroughly explore the concept, make it accessible to the broader research and policy community, and explore the contexts in which its implementation is likely to be viable. To our knowledge, this is the first academic article seeking to comprehensively articulate a principle of differential technology development.
    In the paper we argue that:
    Responsible innovation efforts to date have largely focussed on shaping individual technologies.
    However, as demonstrated by the preferential advancement of low-emission technologies, certain technologies reduce risks from other technologies or constitute low-risk substitutes.
    Governments and other relevant actors may leverage risk-reducing interactions across technology portfolios to mitigate risks beyond climate change.
    We adapt Nick Bostrom’s original concept to propose a responsible innovation principle of “differential technology development”, which calls relevant actors to leverage risk-reducing interactions between technologies by affecting their relative timing.
    Thus, it may be beneficial to delay risk-increasing technologies and preferentially advance risk-reducing defensive, safety, or substitute technologies.
    Implementing differential technology development requires the ability to anticipate or identify impacts and intervene in the relative timing of technologies.
    We find that both are sometimes viable and that differential technology development may still be usefully applied even late in the diffusion of some harmful technologies.
    A principle of differential technology development may inform government research funding priorities and technology regulation, as well as philanthropic research and development funders and corporate social responsibility measures.
    Differential technology development may be particularly promising to mitigate potential catastrophic risks from emerging technologies like synthetic biology and artificial intelligence.
    While writing the paper, we considered alternative terms to describe the concept of differential technology development. Our leading alternatives were “responsible innovation sequencing” or “differential progress”. However, in the end we decided that differential technological development was the best fit for integrating this article into the responsible innovation literature. That said, we do see merit to either defining technology broadly to include “not only gadgets but also methods, techniques and institution design principles” or to extending the concept to include forms of differential development beyond technology development.
    Amongst other things, paper outlines four relevant categories of technologies:
    Risk increasing technologies cause negative societal imp...
    5 min
  • EA - "Agency" needs nuance by Evie Cottrell
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: "Agency" needs nuance, published by Evie Cottrell on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I'm trying to overcome perfectionism and post this even though some parts feel incomplete. A quarter of the word count is footnotes that didn't feel relevant enough for the main body of the post, but I wanted to include somewhere.
    Summary
    Recently, “agency” has become heavily encouraged and socially rewarded within EA, and I am concerned about the unintended consequences.
    The un-nuanced encouragement of “social agency” could be harmful for the community; it encourages violating social norms and social dominance. At the extreme, it can feel parasitic, with dominant individuals monopolising resources.
    “Agency” being a high status buzzword incentivises Goodharting– where big and bold actions are encouraged (at the expense of actions that actually achieve an individual's goals).
    I have an impression that, sometimes, people say “agency” and others hear “work more hours; be more ambitious; make bolder moves! Why haven’t you started a project already?!” “Agency” doesn’t entail “hustling hard” – it entails acting intentionally, and these are importantly different. Agency is not a tradeoff against rest; in fact, doing things to high standards and achieving your goals often requires tons of slack.
    My experience and mistakes
    If you feel uncomfortable when violating a social norm or taking a bold move, take this feeling into consideration, there is probably a reason for this feeling.
    It’s not always low cost for others to say no to requests; failing to model this can make others uncomfortable and lead to a relative overconsumption of resources.
    Making authorities upset with you is (emotionally and instrumentally) costly. Don’t ignore this cost when taking big and bold moves.
    Being too willing to ask for help made me worse at solo problem-solving.
    Introduction
    Recently, “agency” has been heavily encouraged within EA. I often feel like it’s become both a status symbol and an unquestionable good.
    I wrote a post on agency a few months ago, which I now think missed important caveats. While I broadly think that the world (and EA) could do with an injection of proactiveness and intentionality, I’m concerned about some of the unintended consequences.
    In this post, I lay out some concerns, some unexpected costs of taking agentic actions for me (and mistakes I’ve made), and things I’ve changed my mind on since my last post.
    Important caveats
    Most people don’t ask for help enough, and this post is applicable to a minority of people;
    This post is many layers of abstraction away from object level issues that improve the world. I’m worried about meta-conversations (like this) taking away attention from more important and relevant topics. If you’ve read the summary, I’m not sure how much benefit you’ll get from the rest of the post. Consider not reading it.
    “Social Agency” in moderation
    I’m going to define “social agency” as a willingness to make bold social moves, leverage social capital, and make trades within your social network to achieve your goals.
    My previous post mostly focused on encouraging social agency – “ask people for help,” “network online,” and “don’t be too constrained by social boundaries,” are some key themes. I am now concerned that this lacked nuance.
    Social agency is a small part of doing good. Having a network and mentors and friends-in-high-places is not enough to actually do meaningful work in the world. The other part of agency is about Actually Doing Things: the nitty-gritty, engagement with reality that actually makes things happen. Taking heroic responsibility; learning about the technical, object level details of important problems; intentionally building models of the world; noticing gaps in existing strategies; developing a plan to solve bottlenecks; executin...
    21 min
  • EA - What We Owe The Future: a Flashcard-based Summary by Florence
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: What We Owe The Future: a Flashcard-based Summary, published by Florence on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Disclaimer: I am building the learning and memory tool called Thought Saver, which allows you to embed flashcards on the forum!
    TL;DR
    You can revise the key takeaways from What We Owe the Future with our new flashcard deck on Thought Saver. Scroll to the end of this post to see the embedded flashcards.
    Will MacAskill's new book What We Owe The Future has been out for a few weeks now. I am sure many of you finished it on the first day, some are reaching the last hurdles, or maybe you've been too busy, and you need that extra push to get the book! We have a set of key facts and takeaways from the book so that you can remember the most important parts after you've read it! After all, how often do you read a book and forget all the key ideas?
    Remembering key facts from WWOTF can help you to set a better mental base rate, enabling you to evaluate how important the magnitude of one problem is compared to another.
    Example of better base rates
    Without a base rate, it's hard to understand the size of a problem. For example, it's very hard to comprehend how important the future lives of humanity are (and how much we should care about future humans) unless we know:
    A) how many humans there are on the earth today (8 Billion) and
    B) how many humans lived across the entirety of humanity (100 Billion)
    However, knowing both of these facts helps us better understand the problem's order of magnitude.
    The team at Thought Saver and I use flashcards to remember the most important things in life, things that we want to recall at the tip of our fingers. We use flashcards when we want to reprogram actions, remember base rates, use a mental model, or put learning into action.
    Why spaced repetition for books?
    Spaced repetition is one of the most effective ways to remember key ideas! When I read a book, I want to make sure I take away the most important information. We already spend ~6 hours reading a book, but if we don’t revise the material again afterward, we often remember very little! Investing a little bit of extra time in spaced repetition can have high payoffs for you in the future. So instead of just reading WWOTF, we suggest you also revise flashcards about it using a spaced repetition system - you could say that you owe it to your future self. :P
    Flashcards
    Here is a sneak peek of our Thought Saver flashcards for each chapter of the book. Thought Saver ranks your flashcards with our algorithm based on an "importance" score, so if a flashcard isn't valuable to you, select "never," and you don't need to remember it forever!
    Chapter 1: The Case for Longtermism
    Chapter 2: You Can Shape the Course of History
    Chapter 3: Moral Change
    Chapter 4: Value Lock-In
    Chapter 5: Extinction
    Chapter 6: Collapse
    Chapter 7: Stagnation
    Chapter 8: Is it Good to Make Happy People?
    Chapter 9: Will the Future Be Good or Bad?
    Chapter 10: What to Do
    Anki Flashcards
    Prefer to use Anki? Get the same set of flashcards in the Anki format here.Note this link won't work for 24 hours as it takes 24 hours to be shareable on Anki Web!
    Acknowledgment
    Thanks to Will MackAskill’s team for all their help in creating this deck!
    Questions
    Is this valuable to you?
    Would you like to see more key takeaways from books in flashcard format? I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments!
    Relevant Links
    Thought Saver Accelerated Learning Article
    People talking about Flashcards
    300 Flashcards to tackle pressing world problems Andre’s flashcard Articles
    "How I use Anki" Article
    Other EA Forum content on SRS
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • EA - Announcing the Space Futures Initiative by Carson Ezell
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing the Space Futures Initiative, published by Carson Ezell on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We are excited to announce the Space Futures Initiative, which has a mission of conducting research, promoting education, and engaging in outreach to improve the long-term future in outer space for humanity and our descendants.
    We believe sharing longtermist ideas within the space community and developing scalable space governance frameworks are currently neglected areas. Conducting these activities requires engagement between the longtermist community, space policy community, space industry, scientific community, and beyond. The Space Futures Initiative aims to engage students and academic researchers, produce valuable long-term space futures research, and collaborate with key stakeholders to discuss and implement plans to improve long-term space futures.
    The ongoing proliferation of space activities has outpaced our ability to develop appropriate norms and governance structures for a sustainable future in outer space. Furthermore, transformative technologies in the relatively near future might allow leading space actors to significantly influence humanity’s long-term trajectory. As a result, right now might be an important opportunity to positively impact long-term space governance frameworks and norms.
    The Space Futures Initiative is intended to be a collaboration among effective altruists, longtermists, astrophysicists, aerospace engineers, legal scholars, social scientists, philosophers, and others interested in long-term space futures. While our primary focus is conducting research, we also interface with key stakeholders in dialogue on outer space, including the commercial sector and advocacy organizations in policy making hubs.
    We are appreciative of our early supporters and excited about further collaboration with organizations including the Center for Space Governance and Simon Institute for Longterm Governance. Our directors are Madeleine Chang, Carson Ezell, and Olaf Willner.
    Our initial activities include the following:
    Developing an initial research agenda and research papers
    Hosting discussion groups at Harvard and MIT based on an upcoming curriculum for space governance and space futures
    Supporting academic research projects related to space technologies, space governance, and space ethics
    We are also excited to collaborate with more organizations and individuals interested in our mission. The following are specific ways in which you may be able to provide support or get involved:
    Send us an academic research proposal related to space futures that you would be interested in pursuing further, or express interest in conducting research with us
    Support space governance and space futures researchers who can contribute to answering questions on our research agenda within other research programs (e.g. CERI, SERI, CHERI, etc.)
    Let us know that you are willing to mentor an undergraduate or graduate student on a space governance/space futures research project
    Express interest in hosting a space governance discussion group within your university or local EA group, using our upcoming curriculum or other space futures related materials
    Send us ideas for new considerations within space futures that might merit further research, or criticisms of priorities within our current research agenda
    Send an email to [email protected], [email protected], or [email protected] to express interest, or share other ideas and feedback
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • EA - The (Allegedly) Best Business Books by Joseph Lemien
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The (Allegedly) Best Business Books, published by Joseph Lemien on September 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Epistemic Status: Mostly my own subjective opinions. You should read this as though each statement has a hidden "in my opinion" or "I think" attached to it.
    TLDR: I've read a lot of business books, and here I share my impressions of some of the most popular ones. Some are definitely worth reading, depending on what you are looking for and what you already know. There are also several which I recommend avoiding because reading them would be a waste of time.
    Intro
    I read a lot, and I often find myself interested in business books. While these books are sometimes directly related to business and can help you be a better manager/leader/employee, some also can help you with self-control, decision making, or other areas of life. This is especially true if you are interested in increasing your competency in some area of life that can be applied to work. Thus, regardless of whether you want to be effective in altruism, in egoism, or in something else, these books might be helpful for you.
    (I put this together fairly quickly without having anyone review it, so I wouldn't be surprised if there are some typos or other simple errors in it. Please do let me know if you notice something like.)
    "Business book" is an odd genre. There are several different types:
    Sometimes it is a sort of curated memoir or biography, either of a company or of a person (like Shoe Dog, or The Ride of a Lifetime)
    Sometimes it is an attempt to distill and portray the underlying ideas behind a person's success or failure (such as Winning, or Billion Dollar Loser)
    Sometimes it is moderately good information but it could have been a 5- to 15-page essay instead of a 200-300 page book (The Checklist Manifesto and Measure What Matters both spring to mind)
    Sometimes it is a slightly more objective/valid/rigorous attempt to share best practices, either as a result of research or experience (First, Break All the Rules is a decent example, as in Work Rules!)
    Sometimes it is more of a general self-help or self-improvement book that happens to be applicable in some professional contexts (such as What Got You Here Won't Get You There, and Never Eat Alone).
    Sometimes it is a summary of research, taking years or decades of scientific investigation and making it palatable/digestible to a popular audience (like Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, and The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and Business)
    Many of the business books I've read didn't provide me with much value. So what should I do? Well, I'm going to offer my perspectives on some of the most popular and well-known business books so that the people reading this can avoid the bad ones and steer toward the good ones. I'll only write a few sentences about each book, but if you have specific questions about any of the books, feel free to let me know and I'll try to elaborate a bit more.
    I'm not being particularly scientific about this. I've found a few lists of "best business books" on Goodreads, looked at which ones I've read, and shared my opinions on them. I'll exclude a few that aren't very related to business, but I'll generally try to cast a fairly wide net. I also should note that I am not really doing research for these beyond skimming some reviews to refresh my memory, so most of what I write is from memory, from my notes, or from cursory Google searches.
    I hate that I feel the need to include a caveat, but this is the internet, so here it goes: just because I dislike a book and you like it, does not mean that you need to get angry and write impolitely. If you loved a book that I hated, that is okay. If you hated a book that I enjoyed, that is okay, too. If you have useful or interesting perspectives to share, please share ...
    24 min