So… your partner brings up opening the relationship. 👀

And you’re trying to be thoughtful, open-minded, maybe even a little curious…

but there’s also this voice in the background like:

“Wait… do I actually want this?” 🫠

In this episode of But For Real, we’re sitting down with therapist Em Mortenson to get into the real conversation around polyamory and ethical non-monogamy—beyond the labels, beyond the hot takes, and into what this actually looks and feels like in real life.

Because yeah, on paper?

It can sound freeing. Honest. Even aligned. ✨

But in practice?

It can bring up jealousy, fear, uncertainty—and a whole lot of questions about where your “yes” is actually coming from.

We’re talking about what happens when a partner introduces this idea, how to navigate the in-between space of not knowing yet, and why this isn’t something you have to rush to figure out overnight.

And we keep coming back to this:

It’s one thing to understand something intellectually…

and another to feel ready for it in your body.

So if you’ve ever found yourself wondering:

“Am I actually into this… or am I trying to be okay with it?”

“Is jealousy a red flag—or just part of the process?”

“How do I explore this without losing myself?”

…yeah. This one’s for you. 💬

From there, we unpack:

• How to tell if you’re genuinely interested in polyamory—or just trying to be “chill”
• Why jealousy is a normal part of ethical non-monogamy (and what to do with it)
• The difference between curiosity, pressure, and people-pleasing in relationships
• What polyamory and open relationships actually look like in real life
• Why boundaries are essential—and constantly evolving—in non-monogamy
• Common mistakes couples make when opening a relationship
• How fear of losing your partner can shape your decisions
• Why this isn’t a one-time “yes or no” decision—but an ongoing conversation

We talk about:

• 00:00 – Welcome back to But For Real
• 00:50 – Meet Em Mortenson (and the chaotic cat story 🐱)
• 03:20 – Tiny pockets of joy when everything feels heavy
• 05:50 – “My partner wants to open our relationship…” 👀
• 07:10 – Am I open-minded… or just scared to lose them?
• 09:00 – Polyamory vs monogamy: what are we actually talking about?
• 12:30 – Why people jump into this too fast ⚠️
• 15:30 – The biggest misconception about polyamory
• 19:00 – Let’s talk about jealousy (because yeah… it’s coming)
• 22:30 – Is jealousy a dealbreaker—or part of it?
• 26:00 – What healthy polyamory can actually look like
• 30:30 – Boundaries, communication, and real-life dynamics
• 35:30 – When this goes wrong (and why it does)
• 41:30 – Polyamory discourse, TikTok, and moral superiority 🙃
• 47:30 – So… how do you know if this is right for you?

Connect with Us:

• Submit a story for The Lore segment
• Submit a request for advice for our Step Into My office segment
• Reach out: [email protected]
• But For Real on IG: @butforrealpod
• Now That's What I Call... OKAAAAY Playlist
• The Gaia Center on IG: @thegaiacenter
• Val on IG: @valkaymartin
• The Gaia Center website: www.gaiacenter.co

DISCLAIMER: But For Real Podcast is not a substitute for individualized mental health treatment or healthcare. This podcast is solely for entertainment and educational purposes. If you are in crisis, please utilize crisis support services, such as the Crisis Text Line (Text START to 741741 in the US) or the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: (Call 988 in the US), or visit www.findahelpline.com for international resources.