The Payoff Pitch

By GitGudNick

Three brothers who have no business discussing roster construction in MLB The Show are doing just that. It's going about as well as you can expect.

Hosted on Acast. See

... more

Download on the App Store

Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play

FAQs about The Payoff Pitch:

How many episodes does The Payoff Pitch have?

The podcast currently has 43 episodes available.

The Payoff Pitch episodes:

April 12, 2025 The Payoff: First Impressions
As the First Inning draws to a close, the High Council meets to discuss The Good, The Bad, and The Broken of MLB The Show 25. Demands are being made for 2026. RIP to Conquest, you were too beautiful for this world. It's Nerf'd or it's nothing. Also, you probably shouldn't be cutting corners. We're really bad with names. Hey, we know those guys! Bonus: We find the best Two for Tuesday.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
45min
March 19, 2025 The Payoff: The Best of The Best of The Show
Season Five is upon us as your Favorite Podcast's eighth most liked podcast of 2024 kicks off MLB The Show 25 with a bang! It's an all new The Show. The strike zone is very wrong. It's just Baseball Dungeons and Dragons. So we're Next Gen-ish now? Also, the real Ambush Hitting. We're going back to school. And we're about to be owed some royalties. Bonus: It turns out Slugging percentage is hard to figure out.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
47min
October 07, 2024 The Payoff: Peaks and Valleys
Your favorite podcast is back to cover everything in Season 2 and we mean everything. 83 days or 83 weeks? Sometimes we get caught up on the disrespect. We're not falling for these mind games. Less of a grind or more XP? Also, Wrong Place Raffy. Swimming in shallow pools. Shared IP or great idea? Bonus: We have our first ever guest!

Music: Gaston A-P from Pixabay
Michael on Twitter: @michaelgoldbel12

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
53min
June 17, 2024 The Payoff: The Cubnundrum
84 days later, we're wrapping up Set 1 the only way we know how. We didn't even close to the million. Being a Cubs fan sure is expensive this year. Not one, but two surprises for us? The Math continues to not Math. Also, is anybody listening? Please support the San Diego Legal Defense Fund -- it's probably a thing. Bonus: It's so hard to say goodbye to 21.

Music: Gaston A-P from Pixabay

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
47min
May 13, 2024 The Payoff: All New and Different
Season 4 finally arrives with a bang! MLB The Show 24 is off to... a... start and we have feelings and opinions. Getting you up to speed on everything. Hey, new year, same Anthony Rizzo demands. We interrupt this podcast to fanboy over 300. Plus, more of the hot dogs you love. And everybody loves to recycle. Bonus: We decided to grade MLB The Show 23 anyway.

Music: Gaston A-P from Pixabay

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
48min
February 07, 2024 The Payoff: The Spider-Men
The penultimate of Season 3 sees your favorite electronic sports baseball video game podcast discussing a surprisingly high number of 99 overalls. OK, but how many is too many? We can't figure out how someone doesn't get a 99. I'm sorry, is Jonathan playing The Show again? Hot Take: This system isn't broken, but it does need some work. Also, shocker, Nick has a problem with some of the Finest Series. Bonus: The numbers suggest someone might have a serious problem with the American League Central.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
42min
December 23, 2023 The Payoff: Surprise Set, Vol. 2
Your favorite Electronic Simulation Baseball Video Game Podcast is back to do the Choose Your Own Adventure we didn't choose last time! We weigh in on the appeal of Sets Collections 1, 2, and 3. The Show Cover Curse. We're still waiting on 99 overall Anthony Rizzo. The Boss Baby is back and what a difference a year makes. Also, how much would you pay for MLB The Show on Nintendo Switch? And we have a problem with short sleeves. Bonus: we're doing The Show Math.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
41min
September 18, 2023 The Payoff: Surprise Set, Vol. 1
We're hosting a Choose Your Own Adventure as we select from one of two shows! One of our favorite cards makes their debut so we naturally have to compare and contrast. Reddit has opinions about everything and so do we. Also, Why won't this card series just die? And everyone's a winner. Bonus: Five pitches might be too many, but ten pitches for this guy isn't enough.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
35min
July 23, 2023 The Payoff: Kaiju and Incognito
The world's most powerful MLB The Show podcast returns to dig through the massive glut of Set 2 cards. We demand a card that was already delivered. We have a real problem with some of these nicknames. Wrestling vs Zelda? Yeah! Also, we're not mad, we're just disappointed. Put some respect on their names. Bonus: Why not, let's just make it a guessing game.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
39min
June 14, 2023 The Payoff: The Charisma Series
A podcast you've familiarized yourself with is back and we're discussing player Charisma. Go ahead and put a ring on it, San Diego. You want to know what really grinds our gears? Is this too many cards? Also, we have a problem with the Set program design. Plus, we don't like fonts. Bonus: We finally have a jingle and there's some ad space available.

------
Music: "You're The Dummy" by Derek Clegg
Bluesky: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitter: @ThisIsThePayoff
TikTok: @ThisIsThePayoff
Twitch: GitGudNick
Email: [email protected]
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
...more
40min

FAQs about The Payoff Pitch:

How many episodes does The Payoff Pitch have?

The podcast currently has 43 episodes available.