Most employees dread one-to-one meetings. They often feel like a tick-box exercise, a telling-off, or a waste of time that could be spent doing actual work. In fact, Gallup reports that only 14% of employees find performance reviews inspiring.
In a small business, you cannot afford to have your team dreading time spent with you. These meetings should be the engine room of your culture, not a source of anxiety.
In this episode, we ditch the fancy forms and HR software to focus on the human conversation that turns a meeting into a highlight. We look at how to build trust, spot issues early, and ensure your team leaves feeling supported rather than scrutinised.
One Step at a Time: The Actionable Tip
Stop doing all the talking. The biggest mistake leaders make in one-to-ones is treating them like a monologue. These meetings are about them, not you. If you are doing more than 20% of the talking, you are doing it wrong. This week, try asking a question and then—crucially—learning to live with the silence. Give them the space to think and speak; you might be surprised by what they tell you.
What We Cover:
- The Dread vs. The Highlight: Why most meetings fail (rushed, cancelled, or ill-prepared) and how to change the vibe from the start.
- Set the Tone: Why opening with a genuine "How are you?" beats a checklist every time.
- Recognition vs. Challenge: How to give specific praise ("I appreciated how you handled that client") while framing improvement as support ("How can I help you feel more confident?").
- Create a Rhythm: Why consistency matters more than duration—even 10 minutes every week is better than a skipped hour once a month.
- The Agenda: Why sharing a simple agenda in advance stops your employee from feeling put on the spot.
By showing up consistently and listening properly, you build a layer of trust that makes it impossible for PMT (Predatory, Manipulative, Toxic) behaviours to fester unnoticed.
Enjoyed the episode?
Most people problems weren't caused today.
They've usually been building quietly through decisions, assumptions, overlooked signals, and behaviours that seemed easier to ignore than address.
If this episode gave you something to think about, here are a few ways to continue the conversation:
Work with Me, The People Navigator®
Visit thepeoplenavigator.com
Advisory, project consultancy, or embedded support for leaders who want to make better people decisions before issues become bigger than they need to be.
My weekly email sharing practical insights on hiring, behaviour, leadership, accountability, and building workplaces people genuinely want to be part of.
Practical tools to help you hire well, lead well, and deal with people problems earlier.
Ongoing support for leaders who don't want people issues left to drift.
About Cathy Doherty
I'm Cathy Doherty, The People Navigator®, based in Northern Ireland.
I help leaders avoid hiring and holding on to horrible people so they can build workplaces people genuinely want to be part of.
Connect with me on LinkedIn and YouTube.
Disclaimer
This podcast is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, HR, or professional advice. Always seek advice appropriate to your circumstances and jurisdiction.