What happens to a young athlete's mental health when the label the world gave them stops being true?
In Episode #10 of The Pressure Lab, Keith Wilford sits down with Philadelphia Union midfielder Ben Bender for one of the most honest conversations about athlete identity, injury, and resilience The Pressure Lab has produced.
Ben Bender was the first overall selection in the 2022 MLS SuperDraft. He was 20 years old. The expectations attached to that number, to being chosen first above every other player in the country, are enormous and immediate. He contributed 8 goals and 8 assists in 61 matches for Charlotte FC before a meniscus root tear in September 2023 changed everything.
Bender underwent surgery to repair the meniscus root tear in October 2023 and spent the next year and a half fighting to feel like himself again. "I didn't start feeling like myself until this off-season," Bender said. "So it basically took almost a year and a half." He struggled to regain his form quickly enough under a new manager at Charlotte, and by April 2025 the club waived its former number one overall pick.
For many players, that is the beginning of the end. For Bender, it was a door reopening. The Philadelphia Union signed him in May 2025, the club that had first introduced him to professional soccer as a teenager, now offering him a chance to revive his career. He posted a career-best 82% pass completion rate across 320 minutes in MLS play that season. He was part of the Union's 2025 Supporters' Shield-winning season and re-signed through June 2027.
In February 2026, when Bender struck from 18 yards out against Defence Force in the Concacaf Champions Cup, he described the relief of scoring after nearly two years without a goal: "Even though we were up six or seven on aggregate at the time, it was still a relief to get a goal after not having scored in almost two years."
This is not an episode about soccer. It is an episode about what happens inside a young athlete's mind when the identity built around them, number one pick, rising star, the guy everyone expected, collides with the reality of injury, roster decisions, and starting over.
What does it do to a young athlete's mental health to carry a number one pick label?
Bender was 20 when he was drafted first overall. Before he played a single professional minute the narrative about who he was supposed to be had already been written by others. This episode explores what it means to perform inside a label you didn't choose and what happens to your sense of self when the performance doesn't match the expectation.
How do athletes maintain identity during long-term injury recovery?
Seventeen months is a long time to not feel like yourself. Bender speaks to the specific mental experience of injury recovery that most sports content skips over: not just the physical rehabilitation but the psychological work of staying connected to who you are when the thing that defines you has been taken away.
What does being waived by your club actually feel like?
Being waived is one of the most psychologically brutal moments a professional athlete can experience. It is public, it is final, and it arrives with a clear message: you are not what we need anymore. Bender talks about that moment with a honesty that most professional athletes never allow publicly.
What is the mental experience of starting over at a new club?
Bender described landing in Philadelphia as a "full circle" moment. His parents live just over an hour away. He spent a year in the Union Academy as a teenager. He even suffered his knee injury playing against the Union. The symmetry is remarkable. But beyond the narrative, what does it actually take mentally to walk into a new locker room, prove yourself again, and rebuild confidence from scratch?
What does resilience actually look like from the inside of a professional athlete's experience?
Bender's story is not a redemption arc told from the finish line. He is still in it, still rebuilding, still earning his place. This episode captures resilience not as a completed chapter but as a daily choice, which is exactly the message young athletes need to hear.
What this episode covers:
- Athlete identity and mental health when attached to a high-profile label
- Long-term injury recovery and the psychology of coming back
- What being waived from a professional club does to a young athlete's confidence
- How professional athletes rebuild identity after major career setbacks
- The mental experience of starting over at a new club
- What resilience actually looks like from the inside, not the highlight reel
- How personal stability, family, and environment affect athletic performance
- The difference between surviving a setback and finding genuine forward momentum
- What the number one draft pick label costs a young athlete mentally
- Full circle moments: how returning to a familiar environment can restore confidence
Guest: Ben Bender, Philadelphia Union Midfielder, 2022 MLS SuperDraft #1 Overall Pick, Former Charlotte FC
Host: Keith Wilford
Subscribe to The Pressure Lab on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube. New episodes every week.