The Progress Educational Trust podcast

The Progress Educational Trust podcast

By Progress Educational TrustBusinessNon-Profit
Download on the App Store

The Progress Educational Trust podcast episodes

  • Fertility Treatment for Single People: Who Should Pay?
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses whether – and in what circumstances – single people should be able to access publicly funded fertility treatment.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Dr Sarah Martins da Silva (Clinical Lead for Fertility Services at NHS Tayside)

    ⚫ Dr Alan Brown (Senior Lecturer in Private Law at the University of Glasgow)

    ⚫ Dr Catherine Jones (Lecturer at King's College London)

    ⚫ Professor Guido Pennings (Director, Bioethics Institute Ghent)

    PET is grateful to the Scottish Government for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 13 min
  • Innovation from the Pandemic: From Video Appointments to Electronic Consent
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses technologies and approaches that helped fertility patients and practitioners during the COVID-19 pandemic, and that are still proving useful now.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Dr Ashleigh Holt-Kentwell (Clinical Research Fellow at Aberdeen Fertility Centre)

    ⚫ Ciara Heatherwick (Specialist Nurse at Glasgow Royal Infirmary)

    ⚫ Lesley Benzie (Fertility Counsellor at Glasgow Royal Infirmary)

    ⚫ Alison Elliot (Fertility Counsellor at Glasgow Royal Infirmary)

    ⚫ George Hughes (Lead Clinical Embryologist at Ninewells Hospital's Assisted Conception Unit)

    ⚫ Dave Wales (Quality Manager at the Edinburgh Fertility Centre)

    Fertility treatment was – like many other areas of healthcare – drastically disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic, causing difficulties for patients and professionals alike.

    However, the pandemic also prompted creative solutions and novel approaches, some of which are still proving useful now.

    In this discussion, a cross-section of fertility professionals – a Clinical Research Fellow, a Specialist Nurse, two Fertility Counsellors, a Clinical Embryologist and a Quality Manager – discuss what has been learned from the pandemic, and the scope for further innovation.

    PET is grateful to the Scottish Government for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 31 min
  • Opening the Register: How to Handle Disclosure of Gamete Donor Information
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses an imminent change that will have consequences for people involved in – and affected by – donor conception.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Rachel Cutting (Director of Compliance and Information at the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority)

    ⚫ Laura Bridgens (donor-conceived person, and Director of Donor Conceived UK)

    ⚫ Rebekah Dundas (mother of three donor-conceived children)

    ⚫ Nina Barnsley (Director of the Donor Conception Network)

    In October 2023, some people who were conceived from donor gametes in the UK – where the relevant sperm or eggs were donated after the UK abolition of donor anonymity came into force – will reach the age of 18.

    From this point forward, a growing number of donor-conceived people will be officially entitled to ask the UK's fertility regulator – the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) – for their donor's full name, date of birth, and last known address.

    The HFEA has launched a campaign to raise awareness of the changing situation, and to encourage relevant donors to ensure that they are contactable. This entails the donor providing up-to-date contact details to the clinic where they donated 18 or more years ago (if that clinic still exists), and/or providing these details to the HFEA.

    In this discussion a donor-conceived person, a parent of donor-conceived children, and representatives of the HFEA and the Donor Conception Network discuss practical, personal and ethical aspects of disclosing donor information.

    PET is grateful to the Scottish Government for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 35 min
  • Small Change: Is It Time to Reconsider Compensation for Gamete Donors?
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses levels of compensation for donors of sperm or eggs.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Nayla Tohme (Patient Engagement Officer at the London Egg Bank)

    ⚫ Hayley King (donor-conceived person, also herself a mother of twins conceived with donor sperm)

    ⚫ Saghar Kasiri (Director of European Operations at Cryos International)

    ⚫ Dr Ben Hurlbut (Associate Professor of Bioscience Ethics at Arizona State University)

    What levels of compensation – financial or otherwise – should be standard, and permissible, for gamete donors? The UK's fertility regulator, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), last addressed this question in 2011.

    Following a public consultation, the HFEA decided that donors could receive fixed sums of money (this had not been permitted previously), with a maximum of £35 per clinic visit for sperm donors and a maximum of £750 per cycle of donation for egg donors. The HFEA arrived at these figures after reviewing policies in 15 other European countries, taking particular inspiration from Danish policy (for sperm donor compensation) and Spanish policy (for egg donor compensation).

    The maximum payments set in 2011 remain in place in the latest edition of the HFEA's Code of Practice (CoP). The CoP also permits egg sharing and sperm sharing arrangements, stating that clinics 'may offer benefits in kind, in the form of reduced-price or free licensed services (for example, fertility treatment or storage) or quicker access to those services, in return for providing eggs or sperm for the treatment of others'.

    12 years on, should compensation for gamete donors be reconsidered, to take account of inflation and the cost-of-living crisis?

    Importantly, those who donate gametes in the UK are only officially permitted to receive 'compensation' for their donation, as distinct from 'payment'. This distinction was originally a requirement of the European Tissues and Cells Directive of 2004, which stipulates that 'member states shall endeavour to ensure voluntary and unpaid donations of tissues and cells' and that 'donors may receive compensation, which is strictly limited to making good the expenses and inconveniences related to the donation'.

    Now that the UK has left the European Union, it might be asked whether the UK is still bound by this particular requirement – and if it is, whether it should be.

    PET is grateful to the Association of Reproductive and Clinical Scientists and the British Fertility Society for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 33 min
  • The Women's Health Strategy
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses the progress that the UK Government has made to date with its Women's Health Strategy for England.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Professor Geeta Nargund (Co-Founder and Medical Adviser at Ginsburg Women's Health Board)

    ⚫ Nickie Aiken (Member of Parliament for the Cities of London and Westminster)

    ⚫ Isaac Barnswell (Research and Policy Officer at Stonewall)

    ⚫ Laura-Rose Thorogood (Founder of LGBT Mummies)

    ⚫ Dr Raj Mathur (Lead for Reproductive Medicine at St Mary's Hospital)

    In July 2022, the UK Government published the first ever Women's Health Strategy for England.

    The section of the Strategy that deals with fertility and pregnancy includes Government commitments to:

    ⚫ 'Work with NHS England to review and address the current geographical variation in access to NHS-funded fertility services across England to ensure all NHS fertility services are commissioned in a clinically justifiable way.'

    ⚫ 'Explore mechanisms to publish data nationally on provision and availability of IVF' and 'improve information provision regarding fertility over the next two years'.

    ⚫ 'Remove non-clinical access criteria to fertility treatment, such as one partner having a child from a previous relationship, to create more equality in access to fertility services.'

    ⚫ Ensure that when it comes to same-sex couples, 'there is no requirement for self-funding and the NHS treatment pathway for female same-sex couples will start with six cycles of artificial insemination, prior to accessing IVF services if necessary'.

    The Government Minister responsible for the Women's Health Strategy, Maria Caulfield, said in the House of Commons in January 2023 that the Government's 'eight priorities for this year' in relation to the Strategy include 'improving and standardising access to in vitro fertilisation for same-sex couples around the country'.

    In July 2023, the same Minister reaffirmed the Government's commitments, saying: 'We will improve access to IVF by removing the additional financial burden on female same-sex couples accessing treatment. We will be working with NHS England to assess fertility provision across ICBs, with a view to removing non-clinical access criteria. We will also work with stakeholders to improve information provision on fertility and fertility treatments, including on the NHS website, and introduce greater transparency of the local provision of IVF.'

    This discussion asks what progress has been made with the Strategy, and what can be done to ensure that the Government honours its commitments.

    PET is grateful to the British Fertility Society and Merck for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 38 min
  • Counselling and Assisted Reproduction: When, Why and by Whom Should It Be Offered?
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses different types of counselling that are sought, offered, recommended or required in relation to fertility treatment, gamete donation, and assisted conception more broadly.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Alison McTavish (Member of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority)

    ⚫ Angela Park (Fertility Counsellor at Aberdeen Fertility Centre)

    ⚫ Lee Noquet (Egg Donor Coordinator at the Edinburgh Fertility Centre)

    ⚫ Professor Jacky Boivin (Professor of Health Psychology at Cardiff University)

    Different types of counselling may be sought, offered, recommended or required in relation to assisted conception. The language around such counselling can sometimes be confusing, leading to mismatched expectations of what counselling entails and who is best placed to deliver or facilitate it.

    Of particular importance are distinctions between:

    ⚫ Information counselling – This involves the provision of medical information. Under UK regulation, such counselling must be provided in order for a fertility patient's consent to be valid. This sort of counselling would usually be provided by a member of the medical team.

    ⚫ Therapeutic counselling – This involves helping a person deal with (current, future or potential) challenges, decisions, difficulties, distress or emotions. Under UK regulation, such counselling is not required in order for consent to be valid (indeed, it is an important principle that such counselling is voluntary). The content and outcome of such counselling is usually confidential.

    ⚫ Implications counselling – This involves the provision or clarification of information about the implications of treatment or donation, and also involves exploring these implications. This has fallen into a grey area. Who is qualified to deliver such counselling? Is such counselling necessary, in order for consent to be valid? Does it, or can it, include a therapeutic element?

    PET is grateful to the Scottish Government for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 37 min
  • NHS Fertility Treatment: Wouldn't It Be NICE to Have a Workable Guideline?
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses proposed changes to the law governing fertility treatment and embryo research.

    The discussion is chaired by Dr Helen O'Neill, with contributions from:

    ⚫ Professor Dame Clare Gerada (President of the Royal College of General Practitioners)

    ⚫ Steve McCabe MP (Member of Parliament for Birmingham Selly Oak)

    ⚫ Penny Mitchell (Director for Population Health Commissioning at NHS North Central London's Integrated Care Board)

    ⚫ Professor Melanie Davies (Professor of Reproductive Medicine at University College London)

    ⚫ Dr Chris Skedgel (Director of the Office of Health Economics)

    ⚫ Dr Catherine Hill (Interim Chief Executive of Fertility Network UK)

    ⚫ Sarah Norcross (Director of PET)

    For 20 years, the UK's National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) has recommended that the NHS should provide up to three full cycles of IVF to a woman (under 40 years of age) undergoing fertility treatment.

    This recommendation has never been met consistently by NHS commissioning bodies in England. Consequently, fertility patients in England have spent the past two decades at the mercy of a 'postcode lottery'.

    This situation did not improve when the NICE Fertility Guideline received its last major update in 2013. It remains to be seen whether the situation will change when a newly updated Guideline, currently under development, is published by NICE in 2024.

    Meanwhile, in July 2022 the UK Government made a commitment – in its Women's Health Strategy for England – 'to greater transparency of the provision of IVF services across the country', and 'to publish data nationally on provision and availability of IVF'. As yet, these things have not happened.

    Then in May 2023, PET published its report The Power of Three IVF Cycles, which distils interviews with 194 GPs and six NHS Commissioners across 40 out of 42 English commissioning areas.

    This research shows that GPs have a poor understanding of the NICE Fertility Guideline, with only half of GPs able to identify the recommendation (now 20 years old) that three full cycles of NHS-funded IVF should be provided.

    Furthermore, around half of GPs believe that their area meets or exceeds the NICE Guideline (even though it has been found that only around one-tenth of areas in England meet this standard), and male GPs are less likely than female GPs to refer eligible patients for IVF.

    The PET research also found widespread confusion, among GPs, about the definition of a single 'full' IVF cycle. According to NICE, a full cycle incorporates all transfers to the patient's womb of viable embryos that have been created earlier in that cycle.

    PET is grateful to Ferring Pharmaceuticals for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 37 min
  • Surrogacy Law: What Is Intended... For Parents? For Surrogates? For Children?
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses proposed changes to the law governing fertility treatment and embryo research.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Professor Gillian Black (Law Commissioner responsible for Surrogacy at the Scottish Law Commission)

    ⚫ Beverley Addison (Senior Solicitor at BTO Family Law)

    ⚫ Dr Alan Brown (Senior Lecturer in Private Law at the University of Glasgow)

    ⚫ Alan Inglis (Barrister and Advocate at Arnot Manderson Advocates)

    Since 2017, the Scottish Law Commission and the Law Commission of England and Wales have been reviewing UK surrogacy law, developing proposals for reform and holding a public consultation on how the law might be changed.

    Now, the Law Commissions have drafted a new Surrogacy Bill and presented it to Government, together with the wide-ranging report Building Families through Surrogacy: A New Law.

    The proposals from the Law Commissions include:

    ⚫ A new pathway to parenthood which, if followed, would enable the intended parents of a child via surrogacy to acquire legal parenthood upon birth of the child (rather than having to wait for months to obtain a parental order).

    ⚫ Maintaining the current requirement that at least one of the intended parents must have a genetic link to the prospective child (this would preclude so-called 'double donation').

    ⚫ Enabling a court to make a parental order where the surrogate withdraws her consent.

    ⚫ Establishing a system whereby surrogacy agreements are overseen and supported by nonprofit organisations, which would themselves be regulated by the UK's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA).

    ⚫ Establishing a new Surrogacy Register, to enable surrogate-born people to access information about their origins.

    ⚫ Continuing the current prohibition on commercial surrogacy, while clarifying rules on payments that intended parents are – and are not – permitted to make to surrogates.

    ⚫ Discouraging international surrogacy arrangements in favour of domestic arrangements, while seeking to add safeguards if international arrangements are made.

    This discussion begins with an overview of the Law Commissions' work, presented by the Scottish Law Commissioner responsible for surrogacy. Other legal experts then offer their perspectives on the Law Commissions' proposals.

    PET is grateful to the Scottish Government for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 36 min
  • Your Chance for Change: Shaping the UK's Fertility and Embryo Law
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses proposed changes to the law governing fertility treatment and embryo research.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Peter Thompson (Chief Executive of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority)

    ⚫ Venessa Smith (Quality Manager for the Assisted Conception Unit at Guy's Hospital)

    ⚫ Dr Rachel Gregoire (Scientific Director of the Hewitt Fertility Centre)

    ⚫ Dr Kay Elder (Senior Research Scientist at Bourn Hall Clinic)

    ⚫ James Lawford Davies (Partner at Lawford Davies & Co)

    Following its consultation on proposed changes to the law, the UK's fertility regulator – the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) – is due to submit recommendations for law reform to the UK Government.

    The main law that governs fertility treatment and embryo research – the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act – was originally passed in 1990, and was last given a thoroughgoing update in 2008. There are many respects in which this law fails to meet the present and prospective needs of patients, practitioners, researchers, regulators and others.

    The HFEA structured its consultation around the following four themes.

    ⚫ Patient safety and promoting good practice (including reference to the Independent Medicines and Medical Devices Safety Review and the Women's Health Strategy for England).

    ⚫ Access to donor information (including reference to the impact of direct-to-consumer genetic testing on the identifiability of sperm/egg/embryo donors, and the identifiability of donor-conceived people).

    ⚫ Consent (including reference to situations where problems with and disagreements about consent have had to be resolved in court).

    ⚫ Scientific developments (including reference to regulatory 'sandboxes' as discussed by the Regulatory Horizons Council, and to the latest guidelines published by the International Society for Stem Cell Research).

    This discussion begins with an overview of the consultation, presented by the Chief Executive of the HFEA. Experts and practitioners in fertility treatment, embryo research and related law then exchange ideas about how to reform the law in this area.

    PET is grateful to Merck for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 31 min
  • Fertility-Friendly Workplaces? Attitudes to Assisted Conception and Employment
    This episode of the Progress Educational Trust (PET) podcast discusses what employees and employers can – and should – expect from one another, if an employee has fertility problems or needs assisted conception.

    The discussion is chaired by Sarah Norcross (Director of PET), with contributions from:

    ⚫ Nickie Aiken MP (Member of Parliament for the Cities of London and Westminster)

    ⚫ Dr Zeynep Gurtin (Lecturer in Women's Health at University College London)

    ⚫ Anya Sizer (Lead for the Fertility in the Workplace initiative at Fertility Network UK)

    ⚫ Becky Kearns (Co-Founder of Fertility Matters at Work)

    ⚫ Natalie Sutherland (Partner at Burgess Mee Family Law, and Trustee at PET)

    These speakers discuss various ways of addressing fertility-related challenges in the workplace, including:

    ⚫ The Fertility Treatment (Employment Rights) Bill that Nickie Aiken is proposing in the UK Parliament.

    ⚫ The Fertility Workplace Pledge, also launched by Nickie Aiken.

    ⚫ The Fertility in the Workplace and Fertility Matters at Work initiatives.

    ⚫ The In/Fertility in the City podcast.

    PET is grateful to Carrot Fertility and Merck for supporting this discussion.

    PET is also grateful to Jon Nicoll, who created the opening and closing music for its podcast.

    Register at https://www.progress.org.uk/events/upcoming-events/ for upcoming PET events.
    1 hr 35 min

About The Progress Educational Trust podcast

From the publisher's feed

PET (the Progress Educational Trust) is an independent charity that improves choices for people affected by infertility and genetic conditions.

On this podcast, you can hear the latest PET…