
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In the realm of risk assessment and management, traditional tools like Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and risk matrices have been widely accepted as the norm. However, beneath the surface of these established methods lie hidden flaws of FMEA and risk matrices that can significantly impact the effectiveness of risk analysis and decision-making processes. The latest podcast episode takes a deep dive into these issues, offering listeners an exploration of the challenges posed by conventional risk assessment techniques.
The episode emphasizes the importance of staying informed and adapting to new methods in the ever-evolving landscape of risk management. By doing so, professionals can ensure that they are not only equipped to handle current challenges but also prepared to meet the demands of the future.
Ordinal rating scales, commonly utilized in risk assessments, are a fundamental component that often leads to significant errors in analysis. This is because ordinal scales can create differentiated values, compress ranges, and introduce ambiguity compromising the quality of the data and its subsequent interpretation. For example, when values are arbitrarily assigned to categories within a scale, it may not reflect the true magnitude of the risk. Additionally, ambiguous labels can lead to confusion and inconsistent application across different assessments.
Furthermore, the episode scrutinizes the practice of employing ordinal scales to produce risk priority numbers (RPNs), which involves multiplying and summing values that are not designed for such mathematical operations. This can result in misrepresentative risk prioritization, as it doesn’t account for the non-linear and non-continuous nature of the data. It’s crucial to recognize that RPNs are not continuous and that different combinations of severity, occurrence, and detection can yield identical RPNs but hide differing risk implications.
The podcast also brings to light the limitations of risk matrices, another tool frequently used to categorize and prioritize risks. Despite their apparent simplicity and widespread usage, studies have shown that risk matrices may not support effective risk management decisions. They can be inconsistent and arbitrary, leading to decisions that might overlook significant risks. A color-coded matrix or a single cut-off value simplifies the complexity of risk too much, stripping away valuable context and information needed for informed decision-making.
Addressing these criticisms requires a shift in perspective from viewing risks as static point estimates to considering them as probabilities. This probabilistic approach allows for a more nuanced understanding of risks and their potential impacts. Embracing this change is not just about criticism; it’s about evolving our methodologies to improve the robustness of risk assessments.
In this context, the podcast introduces an invaluable resource for professionals eager to advance their skills in risk-based decision-making. The “FMEA in Practice from plan to risk-based decision making” course on Udemy is spotlighted as an exceptional tool to enhance one’s ability to navigate and leverage FMEA effectively. This course embodies the podcast’s ethos of continuous learning and application of best practices in the field of risk assessment.
Overall, the podcast episode serves as a clarion call for professionals to rethink and refine their approach to risk assessment. By understanding and addressing the weaknesses of traditional tools, one can make better-informed decisions that will ultimately lead to more successful outcomes in design, development, and beyond.
Cox, L.A. Jr. “What’s Wrong with Risk Matrices?” Risk Analysis, vol. 28, no. 2, 2008, doi:10.1111/j.1539-6924.2008.01030.x
Hubbard, Douglas W. How to Measure Anything: Finding the Value of Intangibles in Business. Wiley, 2014, pp. 25, 238-240.
Hubbard, D. W. The Failure of Risk Management: Why It's Broken and How to Fix It, 2nd ed. Wiley, 2020, pp. 55.
Schwartz, Norbert, Barbel Knauper, et. al. Rating Scales Numeric Values May Change the Meaning of Scale Labels. Public Opinion Quarterly, Volume 55, Issue 4, WINTER 1991, Pages 570 582, doi:10.1086/269282.
Thomas, Philip, Reidar B. Bratvold, J. Eric Bickel. The Risk of Using Risk Matrices. SPE Economics & Management, September 2013, doi:10.2118/166269-MS.
Getting Started with FMEA It All Begins with a Plan
The post QDD 141 Exposing The Hidden Flaws of FMEA and Risk Matrices: Advancing Your Risk Assessment appeared first on Accendo Reliability.
This episode was recorded at SMTA’s Pan Pacific Strategic Electronics Symposium on the big island of Hawaii.
My guests on this episode are Dr. Chuck Bower, founder of PanPac, Keith Bryant, and Dr. Ron Lasky.
We discussed the history of PanPac, technologies introduced at PanPac, and what makes PanPac so unique. We also discuss Dartmouth College’s unique engineering innovations program.
The post RM 142: Live from SMTA’s Pan Pacific Strategic Electronics Symposium (PanPac) appeared first on Accendo Reliability.
In this episode, our host Wim Vancauwenberghe explores the transformative impact of digitisation on industrial maintenance. Join us for an insightful conversation with Kourosh Bahrami and Michael Honné from Henkel Adhesive Technologies, along with Peter Gijbels of Endress & Hauser. Our discussion sheds light on how technology is reshaping maintenance practices, addressing sustainability challenges, and bridging skills shortages in industrial settings. Discover the future of maintenance in the digital age.otes go here
This podcast is powered by Pinecast.
The post AP 004: The Digital Transformation of Industrial Maintenance with Focus on Sustainability and Skills appeared first on Accendo Reliability.
In this episode, I spoke with CMDR Simon Moore from the Royal Australian Navy and Truong Nguyen from Babcock. We discussed what drives a Reliability Culture in the Navy and how it can be improved. Additionally, we explore the differences between Maintenance and Reliability in the defense industry compared to Mining or Oil and Gas, and the starkly different consequences they entail
If you would like to join the RAN and work with amazing people like CMDR Moore then you can find additional information here.
The post RiM 30: Naval Reliability: A Cultural Voyage with CMDR Moore appeared first on Accendo Reliability.