
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Rethinking our physical therapy approach (Redux)
This was an inspiring conversation. We covered so much ground and this just reflects the expertise of our guests today.
Diane has been such a driving force for evidence based interventions. Her work has significantly influenced global practices and her passion was so tangible throughout this conversation.
Ginny’s perspective is incredibly refreshing and honest. I love how she seeks out interventions when they look promising but “when it doesn’t pan out”, she has the ability to move on.
There is so much to take away from this episode! The main theme that runs through the conversation is essentially the importance of evidence based practice. It is our professional duty to keep up with the evidence and provide the best level of care. Diane reminds us that there is an urgency in rehab because we have children before us that have developing muscles and brains that need the right input. Science doesn’t compete and this compels us to provide green light interventions because there are so many options now!
The question is - why are non-evidence based interventions still available?
We explored this topic and the persistence of therapists in continuing to provide red light interventions or interventions that use red light intervention principles. For sure, the time, money and personal investment therapists put into their profession are factors that can limit the ability to change their practice.
We are a medical profession and with that, comes a responsibility to follow the science. We are a great source of information for the families that need our services and they would hope that we are up to date with the latest and the best. We have evidence now, and this is different from 50 years ago or even 20 years ago. We can’t simply be doing whatever we want anymore because unlike decades ago when there wasn’t anything guiding us, we now have the evidence. Therefore, we can no longer say there isn’t enough evidence or that we are waiting for more evidence to come. We can start now.
The more I work in this industry and the more I speak with researchers and leading therapists, I too want our profession to grow in effectiveness, influence and impact. The advertising we see online with therapists using moving surfaces and manoeuvres that attempt to integrate reflexes (of which there is no evidence for despite what is said in the advertising) under the banner of manual facilitation techniques, are all part of the red light intervention family. Even when the approach is rebranded from 50 years ago, there is still no grounding or evidence to support its thought processes.
This contrasts so significantly with the green light interventions which are all based on decades of knowledge on motor learning principles. The difference here with the red light interventions is that these principles have been repeatedly proven, time and time again. The science is very clear on this. There is no argument to the contrary so again, why are we still providing red light interventions when we have so many options in the green light family?
I have come to learn that following the science isn’t personal. Saying that an intervention has red light features isn’t personal. Critically evaluating our practices isn’t personal but our professional responsibility. What we provide in our care, as health professionals shouldn’t be personal and based on personal preferences. As a medical profession, if that is what we want it to be, we need a concerted effort by all to ensure that it remains that way.
As Diane said, we’re not done yet and we are continually trying to push the boundaries and find better interventions. To be ready for that though, we need to catch up and not be left in thought processes of 50 years ago. Let’s do this together!
Bhooma R Aravamuthan, Toni S Pearson, Keisuke Ueda, Hanyang Miao, Gazelle Zerafati-Jahromi, Laura Gilbert, Cynthia Comella, Joel S Perlmutter
Affiliations expand
Abstract
Aim: To determine the movement features governing expert assessment of gait dystonia severity in individuals with cerebral palsy (CP).
Method: In this prospective cohort study, three movement disorder neurologists graded lower extremity dystonia severity in gait videos of individuals with CP using a 10-point Likert-like scale. Using conventional content analysis, we determined the features experts cited when grading dystonia severity. Then, using open-source pose estimation techniques, we determined gait variable analogs of these expert-cited features correlating with their assessments of dystonia severity.
Results: Experts assessed videos from 116 participants (46 with dystonia aged 15 years [SD 3] and 70 without dystonia aged 15 years [SD 2], both groups ranging 10-20 years old and 50% male). Variable limb adduction was most commonly cited by experts when identifying dystonia, comprising 60% of expert statements. Effect on gait (regularity, stability, trajectory, speed) and dystonia amplitude were common features experts used to determine dystonia severity, comprising 19% and 13% of statements respectively. Gait variables assessing adduction variability and amplitude (inter-ankle distance variance and foot adduction amplitude) were significantly correlated with expert assessment of dystonia severity (multiple linear regression, p < 0.001).
Interpretation: Adduction variability and amplitude are quantifiable gait features that correlate with expert-determined gait dystonia severity in individuals with CP. Consideration of these features could help optimize and standardize the clinical assessment of gait dystonia severity in individuals with CP.
Georgia McKenzie, Nora Shields , Claire Willis
Affiliations expand
Abstract
Purpose: To understand the factors influencing participation in community-based gym exercise for young adults with cerebral palsy (CP).
Methods: A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews was conducted. Interviews were completed with 39 young adults with CP (15-30 years, GMFCS I-IV) following a peer-supported, gym-based exercise program called FitSkills.
Results: "Finding what works for me" was the overarching theme. Through their gym experiences, young adults with CP identified four interrelated main themes that influenced whether gym participation "worked" for them, or not: (i) psychological factors, (ii) a "social" participation context, (iii) organisational and logistical support, and (iv) cost. The social context of FitSkills was perceived to positively influence psychological health outcomes and attenuate perceived barriers to participation. Organisational support facilitated their initial attendance, while logistical effort and cost affected ongoing or future gym participation.
Conclusions: Social involvement plays a critical role in positive participation experiences in community exercise settings for young adults with CP. Clinicians supporting exercise participation for this group should prioritise intervention strategies that promote social engagement and mental wellbeing. Collaboration between clinicians, community leisure organisations, and funding bodies may be essential to overcome logistical and financial barriers during the transition to adulthood. Implications for rehabilitation.
The main factor influencing the attendance, involvement, and ongoing exercise preferences of young adults with cerebral palsy (CP) was the social context of the participation experience.Altering the social environment through peer-mentoring can facilitate participation in the gym.Young adults with CP consider mental wellbeing to be an important motivator and outcome of gym-based exercise participation.Mental wellbeing should be prioritised for health promotion for this group.Collaboration between recreation organisations, health services, clinicians, and consumers to address logistical and financial factors can facilitate positive physical activity participation experiences in community settings.
Keywords: Disability; adolescent; inclusion; physical activity; social context.
Watch the video-cast at the ResearchWorks Podcast YouTube Channel!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0dzGX1k3bs
Roslyn Ward, Elizabeth Barty, Neville Hennessey, Catherine Elliott, Jane Valentine
Affiliations expand
Free PMC article
Abstract
The implementation of an intervention protocol aimed at increasing vocal complexity in three pre-linguistic children with cerebral palsy (two males, starting age 15 months, and one female, starting age 16 months) was evaluated utilising a repeated ABA case series design.
The study progressed until the children were 36 months of age. Weekly probes with trained and untrained items were administered across each of three intervention blocks. Successive blocks targeted more advanced protophone production and speech movement patterns, individualised for each participant.
Positive treatment effects were seen for all participants in terms of a greater rate of achievement of target protophone categories and speech movement patterns. Tau coefficients for trained items demonstrated overall moderate to large AB phase contrast effect sizes, with limited evidence of generalisation to untrained items. Control items featuring protophones and speech movements not targeted for intervention showed no change across phases for any participant.
Our data suggest that emerging speech-production skills in prelinguistic infants with CP can be positively influenced through a multimodal intervention focused on capitalising on early periods of plasticity when language learning is most sensitive.
Keywords: cerebral palsy; early intervention; infant vocalisations; infants; single-subject research design.
Watch the video-cast at the ResearchWorks Podcast YouTube Channel!
https://youtu.be/hO7VkbrVZoE
Among the most common questions we are asked when it comes to therapy for autistic children is how much therapy should a child be receiving.
This is a really logical question to ask. It reflects the love and concern that parents have for their child, and their strong desire to make decisions that will best support their child now and into the future.
What does the research evidence tell us?
Considerable research over the past three decades have provided good evidence that start to help us understand more about this area. Four clear facts have emerged:
1. Early therapies and supports are important.
Early experiences, including therapy early in a child’s life can help shape early brain development, and this early foundation provides a ‘springboard’ for the development of more advanced skills. Early therapy can also provide a way for parents to receive important advice and guidance at a time when this is particularly needed. Importantly, a focus on early therapies doesn’t mean that supports at later ages are not important or effective as well – they are. Both are important.
2. There is no ‘standard amount’ of therapy.
There is no set amount of therapy that will lead to better outcomes for all children. Some children will require what we call ‘intensive’ supports, which involves substantial amount of time with a practitioner each week. However, many children do not require such intensive supports, and may benefit best from only a small amount time with a practitioner weekly, fortnightly, monthly or just on occasion as required.
3. ‘More’ does not necessarily mean ‘better’.
Research evidence does not indicate that more therapy leads to better outcomes for all children.
4. Quality is as important as quantity.
A focus on asking ‘how much’ can sometimes mean that we don’t focus enough on the critical factor of therapy ‘quality’. Having practitioners who are qualified, with current knowledge and skills, and who have access to supervision, are key elements of good practice. The quality of therapy is every bit as important as the amount of therapy a child receives.
What is a better question to ask?
The research evidence tells us that when we ask ‘how much’, we are actually asking the wrong question.
Instead, a better question to ask is: How much is the right amount of therapy for my child and family, right now.
An answer to this question emerges through a partnership between the child, their family and the practitioner. Each person brings unique knowledge and skills to that decision.
How much therapy is needed is determined by the child’s goals, strengths, challenges, and family context. It is only by weighing up all of the information available that a shared decision can be made as to what is the right amount of support now. Ongoing monitoring and review of support gaps or successes, can then decide what, if anything, needs to change to better suit the needs of the child and family.
For those interested in the video-cast, our entire conversation is now available to view on our YouTube page.
https://www.youtube.com/@researchworkspodcast
Watch the video-cast at the ResearchWorks Podcast YouTube Channel!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fNMsXKfCHkc
Sarah McIntyre, Shona Goldsmith, Annabel Webb, Virginie Ehlinger, Sandra Julsen Hollung, Karen McConnell, Catherine Arnaud, Hayley Smithers-Sheedy, Maryam Oskoui, Gulam Khandaker, Kate Himmelmann; Global CP Prevalence Group*
Free PMC article
Abstract
Aim: To determine trends and current estimates in regional and global prevalence of cerebral palsy (CP).
Method: A systematic analysis of data from participating CP registers/surveillance systems and population-based prevalence studies (from birth year 1995) was performed. Quality and risk of bias were assessed for both data sources. Analyses were conducted for pre-/perinatal, postnatal, neonatal, and overall CP. For each region, trends were statistically classified as increasing, decreasing, heterogeneous, or no change, and most recent prevalence estimates with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated. Meta-analyses were conducted to determine current birth prevalence estimates (from birth year 2010).
Results: Forty-one regions from 27 countries across five continents were represented. Pre-/perinatal birth prevalence declined significantly across Europe and Australia (11 out of 14 regions), with no change in postneonatal CP. From the limited but increasing data available from regions in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), birth prevalence for pre-/perinatal CP was as high as 3.4 per 1000 (95% CI 3.0-3.9) live births. Following meta-analyses, birth prevalence for pre-/perinatal CP in regions from high-income countries (HICs) was 1.5 per 1000 (95% CI 1.4-1.6) live births, and 1.6 per 1000 (95% CI 1.5-1.7) live births when postneonatal CP was included.
Interpretation: The birth prevalence estimate of CP in HICs declined to 1.6 per 1000 live births. Data available from LMICs indicated markedly higher birth prevalence.
What this paper adds:
* Birth prevalence of pre-/perinatal cerebral palsy (CP) in high-income countries (HICs) is decreasing.
* Current overall CP birth prevalence for HICs is 1.6 per 1000 live births.
* Trends in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) cannot currently be measured.
* Current birth prevalence in LMICs is markedly higher than in HICs.
* Active surveillance of CP helps to assess the impact of medical advancements and social/economic development.
* Population-based data on prevalence and trends of CP are critical to inform policy.
Peter L Rosenbaum, Monika Novak-Pavlic
Watch the video-cast at the ResearchWorks Podcast YouTube Channel!
https://youtu.be/MUfMh5lYk_I
Free PMC article
Abstract
Purpose of review: Traditional thinking and focus in 'childhood disability' have been on the child with the impairment - with the imperative to make the right diagnosis and find the right treatments. The implicit if not direct expectation was that interventions should aim to 'fix' the problems. Professionals have led the processes of investigation and management planning, with parents expected to 'comply' with professionals' recommendations. Much less attention has been paid to parents' perspectives or their wellbeing.
Recent findings: In the past two decades, we have seen a sea change in our conceptualizations of childhood disability. The WHO's framework for health (the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (aka ICF)) and CanChild's 'F-words for Child Development' inform modern thinking and action. We now recognize the family as the unit of interest, with parents' voices an essential element of all aspects of management. The goals of intervention are built around the F-words ideas of function, family, fun, friendships, fitness and future.
Summary: There has been world-wide uptake of the F-words concepts, with increasing evidence of the impact of these ideas on parents and professionals alike. There are important implications of these developments on the structure, processes and content of services for children with neurodevelopmental disorders, their families and the services designed to support them.
Keywords: Child and family development; Childhood disability; F-words in child development; Family wellbeing; ICF.
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2021.
Conflict of interest statement
Conflict of InterestIn this article, Peter Rosenbaum and Monika Novak-Pavlic present and discuss CanChild’s F-words for Child Development and describe the CIHR-funded ENVISAGE study. Dr. Rosenbaum is the lead author of the original F-words paper that reported these concepts.
All the F-words materials discussed in this paper are available for free on the authors’ website: www.canchild.ca/f-words.
ENVISAGE is a research study underway as this paper was being written, and there are no financial implications of this work.
Peter Rosenbaum and Monika Novak-Pavlic declare no conflicts of interest relevant to this manuscript.
This clinical practice guideline is for the identification, diagnosis, and treatment of people with ADHD.
It outlines a roadmap for ADHD clinical practice, research and policy, now and in the future, with a focus on everyday functioning and quality of life for people who are living with ADHD and those who support them.
The Guideline includes eight chapters covering the identification, diagnosis, and treatment of people with ADHD, as well as considerations for subgroups, service & policy and further research.
1. Identification
2. Diagnosis
3. Treatment & Support
4. Non-Pharmacological Interventions
5. Pharmacological Interventions
6. Considerations – Subgroups
7. Considerations – Service & Policy
8. Considerations – Research
Approvals
This guideline has been approved by the NHMRC and endorsed by APS, RACP, RACGP, Speech Pathology Australia, Occupational Therapy Australia, ACPA, AAPI, ADHD WA, ADHD Foundation, RANZCP, ADHD Australia and the World Federation of ADHD.
The guidelines can be downloaded at the link below:
https://aadpa.com.au/guideline/
Watch the video-cast at the ResearchWorks Podcast YouTube Channel!
https://www.youtube.com/@researchworkspodcast
The ResearchWorks Team is back for Season 3 with an all-star lineup of brilliant researchers - starting with Professor Mark Bellgrove, Professor Peter Rosenbaum, Professor Andrew Whitehouse and Dr Sarah McIntyre!
The episodes will release from March 5, 2023.
For more information on the pod, or to catch up on previous seasons and episodes - visit our website:
www.researchworks.net
From the publisher's feed
The Research Works podcast is designed for health professionals in the area of child health, where we discuss emerging, modern, evidence based research - the behind the scenes stories, interviews…