The Rough Cut

The Rough Cut

Download on the App Store

All The Rough Cut episodes

  • Framing Britney Spears
    Editors - Geoff O'Brien and Pierre Takal

    Framing Britney Spears editors Geoff O'Brien and Pierre Takal joined forces to take on the monumental editorial challenge of compressing twenty years into just over an hour of screen time to tell a story that is both informative and provocative. Released on February 5, 2021 as an edition of The New York Times Presents on FX and FX on Hulu, the documentary explores Spears's rise to fame as a pop star, her treatment by the paparazzi, her highly publicized breakdown in 2007, and her court-mandated conservatorship overseen by her father. The documentary received critical acclaim and garnered two nominations at the 73rd Primetime Emmy® Awards; including a nomination for Geoff and Pierre's work in the cutting room.

    GEOFF O'BRIEN

    Aside from his work on Framing Britney Spears, Geoff has been a major creative contributor and editor for series including The Weekly from The New York Times, Fiasco on Epix and PBS's Frontline. He also worked on three award-winning feature documentaries, Note By Note: The Making of Steinway L1037; Brick By Brick (a documentary that chronicles segregation in the Yonkers public school system) and It Started As A Joke (chronicling Eugene Mirman and his comedy festival).

    PIERRE TAKAL

    In addition to his work on the New York Times Presents series, Pierre has cut for the PBS investigative series, Frontline and on documentaries such as Eagle Huntress, Rats, I am Human and One Direction: This Is Us. But that's not all. Not only does Pierre Takal do Emmy®-worthy work in the editing room, he's also an accomplished composer, at times taking on both composing and editing duties on the same project.

    Editing Framing Britney Spears

    In our discussion with Framing Britney Spears editors Geoff O'Brien and Pierre Takal, we talk about:

    • Utilizing the resources of The New York Times
    • Collaborating remotely during the pandemic
    • Quickly setting the context for the conservatorship controversy
    • Knowing where to stop on a story that is still unfolding
    • How this project evolved their opinions of their own industry
    The Credits

    Get your free 100GB of media transfer at MASV

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Check out the free trial of Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    43 min
  • Billie Eilish: The World's a Little Blurry
    Editors - Greg Finton ACE and Lindsay Utz ACE

    Editors Greg Finton ACE and Lindsay Utz ACE hadn't worked together prior to Billie Eilish: The World's a Little Blurry, but they each had plenty of experience in the world of unscripted storytelling to bring to the table for director R.J. Cutler's film. The story centers around singer-songwriter Billie Eilish and reveals the behind the scenes creation process of her debut studio album When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go? Released in select theaters via Neon and on Apple TV+ on February 26, 2021, the film has garnered four Primetime Emmy® nominations, including Outstanding Picture Editing for Variety Programming for Greg and Lindsay.

    GREG FINTON ACE

    Although Greg had previously worked with "Billie Eilish" director R.J. Cutler on the series American High, Greg's storied career in documentary editing actually began in the film cutting rooms of some legendary scripted editors. Working as an assistant to editors such as Lynzee Klingman ACE (A River Runs Through It) and Sandra Adair ACE (Dazed and Confused), Greg learned first hand how just changing the rhythm and pace of the dialogue can have a big impact on the way a scene felt. Greg took this knowledge into his work on highly acclaimed documentaries such as It Might Get Loud, He Named Me Malala and Robin Williams: Come Inside My Mind.

    LINDSAY UTZ ACE

    Prior to teaming up with Greg and R.J. Cutler for the "Billie Eilish doc", Lindsay had made quite a name for herself in the documentary world, having been nominated for both an Emmy® and an ACE Eddie award for her work on the Oscar®-winning documentary, American Factory. A recipient of the 2012 Karen Schmeer Fellowship, Lindsay's talent as a storyteller can also be seen in the documentary projects; Bully, Quest, Miss Americana, as well as the experimental narrative feature, Buoy.

    Editing Billie Eilish: The World's a Little Blurry

    In our discussion with the editing team of Greg Finton ACE and Lindsay Utz ACE, we talk about:

    • Enjoying the challenge presented by documentary editing
    • The deep reservoir of footage afforded by the cell phone era
    • Lower thirds being a crucial decision in doc filmmaking
    • How award nominations can impact a documentary editor's career
    • The advantages of starting out as an assistant in film cutting rooms
    The Credits

    Get your free 100GB of media transfer at MASV

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Check out the free trial of Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    56 min
  • Loki
    Editors - Paul Zucker ACE, Emma McCleave, Calum Ross PAUL ZUCKER ACE (Classic Loki)

    Prior to making his mark on the MCU, Paul had worked with some of today's most innovative filmmakers; from Harmony Korine (Mister Lonely) and Michel Gondry (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, to Lena Dunham (Girls, Camping). Paul cut his first feature at age 24 for Gus Van Sant (Gerry). Moving easily between independent and studio projects, he has worked with such noted directors as Tom Dicillo, Joel Schumacher, and Mike Judge (the pilot episode of Silicon Valley). He has also edited two films for Judd Apatow (This is 40 and Trainwreck, for which he received an ACE award nomination). Paul is also an accomplished commercial editor and a member of American Cinema Editors.

    EMMA McCLEAVE ("Florida" Alligator Loki)

    Emma McCleave studied at Flinders University Film School in Adelaide, Australia, and within the York University Film program in Canada. On graduation, Emma moved to Sydney where she started her career as a Commercials Assistant Editor, before moving to films in 2008. Through her career Emma trained under some of the most prolific editors in the film industry, including Dody Dorn ACE (Australia, London Boulevard, Fury, Come Away), Michael McCusker ACE (Australia, Captain America: The First Avenger), Chris Dickens ACE (Rocketman), Conrad Buff ACE (Thor: The Dark World, Infinite) and Paul Hirsch ACE (The Mummy).

    CALUM ROSS (The One True Loki)

    Calum Ross has been in TV cutting rooms for fourteen years. Over that time he has routinely taken on one of the most feared genres in editing, comedy. Calum has been in the cutting rooms of shows such as Pixelface, Murder in Successville, Lovesick, Action Team and his latest work featuring the comedy duo of Sue Perkins and Mel Giedroyc, Hitmen. But it was his work on the Netflix original series, Sex Education that first introduced him to director Kate Herron, a job that would ultimate land him on Marvel's Loki, once again working with Kate.

    Editing Loki

    In our discussion with the Loki editing team of Paul Zucker ACE, Emma McCleave and Calum Ross, we talk about:

    • Editorial Easter Eggs
    • The demands of a Marvel series compared to a Marvel feature
    • Integrating footage from Avengers: End Game to set up the pilot
    • Having to let go of The Frog of Thunder
    • Who is the True Loki
    The Credits

    Get your free 100GB of media transfer at MASV

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Hear the podcast with The Falcon and The Winter Soldier team

    Meet the Emmy®-nominated editors of WandaVision

    Check out the free trial of Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    1 hr 3 min
  • Black Widow
    Editors - Matthew Schmidt and Leigh Folsom Boyd

    Editors, Matthew Schmidt and Leigh Folsom Boyd are no strangers to the Marvel Universe, yet Black Widow represents the first time they've ever worked together on a project. It's also the first Marvel film for indie director, Cate Shortland.

    Black Widow is the 24th film in the MCU, but the first in the franchise's "Phase Four". Eagerly awaited since it was announced after Avengers: End Game, the film has suffered multiple delays in its release due to the pandemic. Taking place after the events of Captain America: Civil War, Black Widow delivers the long overdue backstory and greater depth of focus on the character of Natasha Romanoff (aka Black Widow).

    MATTHEW SCHMIDT

    Matthew's career with Marvel dates back to The Avengers. Back then he was an assistant on that film as well as first assistant on Iron Man 3. Matt then made the jump to editor on Captain America: The Winter Soldier and would go on to co-edit the Marvel films, Avengers: Age of Ultron, Captain America: Civil War, Avengers: Infinity War, Avengers: End Game and Black Widow.

    LEIGH FOLSOM BOYD

    Even before joining the Marvel Cinematic Universe to co-edit Ant Man and Spiderman: Far From Home, editor Leigh Folsom Boyd had plenty experience cutting blockbuster action movies. Her impressive resume includes films like Fast & Furious, Fast Five, Fast & Furious 6, Furious 7, Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales and Total Recall (2012).

    Editing Black Widow

    In our discussion with the Black Widow editing team of Matthew Schmidt and Leigh Folsom Boyd, we talk about:

    • Taking advantage of some extra "lockdown" related time to refine the film
    • Making the 24th film in a series understandable to audiences new to the MCU
    • Developing immersive soundscapes
    • The iterations of an action scene
    • Negotiating the workload between two editors
    The Credits

    Get your free 100GB of media transfer at MASV

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Check out the free trial of Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    41 min
  • In The Heights
    Editor, Myron Kerstein ACE

    In The Heights editor, Myron Kerstein ACE had plenty of experience to draw from when tackling the film adaptation of Lin-Manuel Miranda's Broadway hit. Not only had he previously worked with In the Heights director John Chu on their film, Crazy Rich Asians, but Myron had a diverse pool of film and tv projects to draw from as well. Myron's film credits include Garden State, Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist, Little Fockers, The Dukes of Hazard, Fame (2009). On the tv side, he's done shows such as Girls and Home Before Dark.

    Editing In The Heights

    In our discussion with In The Heights editor, Myron Kerstein ACE we talk about:

    • The similarities between musicals and VFX heavy action movies
    • Using ScriptSync to manage lyrical performance takes
    • The roundtrip workflows between picture and sound
    • Cutting with or against the beat of the music
    • The impact musicals impose on spotting sound effects
    The Credits

    Learn how to easily manage and move media everywhere with MASV

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    See the latest Special Offers for Avid Media Composer Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    52 min
  • Small Axe
    Small Axe editor, Chris Dickens ACE

    Small Axe editor, Chris Dickens ACE first made a name for himself cutting director Edgar Wright's zombie comedy, Shaun of the Dead. A few years later Dickens would collaborate with Wright once more on the movie, Hot Fuzz. But it was a film Dickens did in 2008 that would bring him his highest honor to date. Chris was awarded an Oscar® for Best Film Editing for Slumdog Millionaire. In subsequent years Chris would edit such films as Mary Queen of Scots and Rocketman. After wrapping up the Elton John biopic, Chris began discussions with director Steve McQueen (12 Years a Slave) about his upcoming project, Small Axe.

    Small Axe consists of five films that tell distinct stories about the lives of West Indian immigrants in London from the 1960s to the 1980s. The series kicks off with the courtroom drama Mangrove. Next up is Lovers Rock, which takes place over the course of one day at a house party. Next is Red, White and Blue starring John Boyega as a young man who trades a promising career in medicine to become a police officer intent on creating reform from within the department. The fourth film in the series is Alex Wheatle, a historical drama about a novelist sentenced to imprisonment after the 1981 Brixton uprising. The series concludes with the film Education, which takes place in the 70's and addresses the transferring of disproportionate numbers of black children from mainstream education to schools for the so-called "educationally subnormal".

    Editing Small Axe

    In our discussion with Small Axe editor, Chris Dickens ACE we talk about:

    • Editing five different films in different formats
    • Non-linear editing in a linear fashion
    • Why 16mm is shunned by streamers
    • The challenge of editing a "plotless" film
    • The editorial gift of a non-stop musical backdrop
    The Credits

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Hear Chris and Music Editor Andy Patterson talk about making Rocketman

    Check out the free trial for Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    51 min
  • The Mandalorian - Season 2
    Editors - Jeff Seibenick, Andrew S. Eisen ACE, Adam Gerstel

    Editors Jeff Seibenick, Andrew S. Eisen ACE and Adam Gerstel (along with editor Dylan Firshein) joined "forces" to deliver a follow-up season to the Lucasfilm/Disney+ hit that surpassed even the highest expectations from the ardent fanbase.

    Using their now legendary virtual set technology, known as "the volume", the post team was completely integrated into the production process and could help craft and refine the storylines at a highly accelerated rate.

    JEFF SEIBENICK

    With a background rich in comedy tv editing on series such as; Parks and Recreation, Eastbound & Down and Vice Principals, Jeff helped craft one of the more serious aspects of Season 2...getting inside the mind of the imperial troops!

    ANDREW S. EISEN ACE

    Considering the cinematic approach the editing team applies to The Mandalorian, it's no surprise to see Andrew's name in the credits of big sci-fi / action films like Transformers: Age of Extinction and The Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2.

    ADAM GERSTEL

    While Season 2 is Adam's first on The Mandalorian, he's no stranger to virtual set technology or working with showrunner/director, Jon Favreau. Adam edited both The Jungle Book and The Lion King live action remakes with Favreau.

    Editing The Mandalorian - Season 2

    In our discussion with The Mandalorian editing team of Jeff Seibenick, Andrew S. Eisen ACE and Adam Gerstel, we talk about:

    • The differences between using the virtual set process in films vs television
    • Manipulating story lines and character tone through ADR
    • Creating both new sound effects and leveraging the Star Wars Sound Library
    • The scoring process between editor and composer
    • Collaborating with one another through the pre-viz process
    The Credits

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Listen to parts one and two from the Season One interview with The Mandalorian editors

    A New Hope editor, Paul Hirsch ACE on turning a Camaro into Vader's TIE fighter

    The Empire Strikes Back editor, Paul Hirsch ACE reflects on the film forty years later

    Hear editor Bob Ducsay talk about cutting The Last Jedi

    Listen to Maryann Brandon ACE talk about her work on The Force Awakens and The Rise of Skywalker

    Check out the limited time special offer for Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut for more great interviews with the heroes of the editing room!

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube!

    56 min
  • Mythic Quest
    Editors - Josh Drisko, Steve Welch ACE, Trevor Penna

    From the creative team behind It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia comes the AppleTV+ original series, Mythic Quest! Created in part by and starring Rob McElhenney, the series is about a video game studio that produces a popular online role playing game.

    Even though it's a "workplace comedy", the MQ team knows how to surprise an audience every now and then with a dramatic turn. Both seasons one and two featured episodes that were not really part of the show's primary story line nor did they really feature the main characters. In S1 this was an episode called A Dark Quiet Death and in S2 it was an episode called Backstory. Both episodes were standouts in their respective seasons and drew praise from the critics. On top of that, between season one and two Mythic Quest had two special episodes; one of which was not only created during quarantine, it was about the quarantine.

    JOSH DRISKO

    Josh Drisko has an amazing 92 episodes (and counting) of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia under his belt; including the legendary pilot episode of "Sunny" that he cut on a laptop back in 2005. Josh has also worked on the series The Mick, The Grinder and Maron.

    STEVE WELCH ACE

    Steve Welch ACE has had a prolific career in comedy editing with such shows as Malcolm in the Middle, New Girl, Mr. Show with Bob and David and Arrested Development.

    TREVOR PENNA

    While Mythic Quest is the first series where Trevor has been lead editor on multiple episodes, he's been assisting editor Tim Roche on some pretty big shows, including Curb Your Enthusiasm and WandaVision.

    Editing Mythic Quest

    In our discussion with the Mythic Quest editing team of Josh Drisko, Steve Welch ACE and Trevor Penna, we talk about:

    • The challenge of incorporating video game footage into the show
    • Working from home to do a special episode about working from home
    • The power of ScriptSync for cutting comedy
    • Taking a break from the laughter for more dramatic episodes
    • The best things an editor can do besides edit to be a better editor
    The Credits

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Check out the limited time special offer for Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    52 min
  • It's a Sin
    It's a Sin editor, Sarah Brewerton

    It's a Sin editor, Sarah Brewerton said, "Yes!" before ever reading the scripts for the British television miniseries written and created by Russell T. Davies (Queer as Folk). The series follows a group of gay men who each move to London in 1981 as the fast-developing HIV/AIDS crisis in the United Kingdom impacts their lives. Over the five episode arc, the group are shown living through an entire decade as they become determined to live life on their terms despite the threat posed by HIV.

    Pulling off a story like that, honoring and being true to an important era in our shared history, is never easy. On top of that, in regards to the actual post process, more often than not on a series you have multiple editors in some kind of rotation to handle the editorial duties. That is not the case with It's a Sin. Sarah and her assistant editor (Daniel Gale-Coyne) did the entire series themselves. They also did it without a music editor. Considering how prominent a role music plays in setting the scene for England in the 80's, that should tell you just how much care and effort Sarah and Daniel had to put into every aspect of the series.

    Editing It's a Sin

    In our discussion with It's a Sin editor, Sarah Brewerton we talk about:

    • The burdens and blessings of cutting a series on your own
    • Letting the material lead the edit
    • The opportunities for finding work in 2021
    • Making the jump from assistant to lead editor
    • Giving back to the next generation of editors
    The Credits

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    Check out the limited time special offer for Media Composer | Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    38 min
  • Cruella
    Editor, Tatiana Riegel ACE

    Cruella editor, Tatiana Riegel ACE and director Craig Gillespie were already quite familiar with one another prior to their work on Disney's most recent reimagining of its iconic I.P.. Starting with Lars and the Real Girl in 2007, the two also worked together on Fright Night, Million Dollar Arm, The Finest Hours and the critically acclaimed I, Tonya. I, Tonya also notched Tatiana an ACE Eddie award and an Oscar® nomination for Best Film Editing.

    Set in 1970s London amidst the punk rock revolution, Cruella follows a young grifter named Estella. Recently orphaned, Estella befriends a pair of juvenile thieves and together they are able to build a life for themselves on the streets of London. One day, while toiling away in London's Liberty department store, Estella's flair for fashion catches the eye of legendary designer, Baroness von Hellman, but their relationship sets in motion a course of events and revelations that will cause Estella to become the raucous and revenge-bent "Cruella".

    Editing Cruella

    In our discussion with Cruella editor, Tatiana Riegel ACE we talk about:

    • The sometimes necessary evil of voice overs
    • Delaying the use of audio until later in the edit
    • Keeping an eye on continuity in the quiet scenes
    • Eavesdropping on conversations between Quentin Tarantino and editor Sally Menke during Pulp Fiction
    The Credits

    Visit ExtremeMusic for all your production audio needs

    See the latest Special Offers for Avid Media Composer Ultimate

    Subscribe to The Rough Cut podcast and never miss an episode

    Visit The Rough Cut on YouTube

    47 min