Todd and Eric kick off Season 10 by doing what any rational podcast with nearly 500 episodes would do—build a bracket. Inspired by greatest-hits albums and fueled by spreadsheets, vibes, and questionable memory, this episode unveils the Now! That’s What I Call TodCasting project: a full-blown tournament to determine the greatest TodCast episode of all time.
What starts as a simple “best of” idea quickly escalates into remasters, tailored versions, and deeply meta podcasting about podcasting.
• The origin of the TodCast Greatest Hits concept (three spirits may be involved)
• Why nearly 440 episodes required a bracket, not a playlist
• How Todd and Eric independently picked their Top 20 and whittled it down to a Final 16
• The three judging criteria: entertainment, information, and original audio quality
• Confessions about car-recorded episodes, Bluetooth failures, and sirens
• Why bad titles, good vibes, and faulty memory are all part of TodCast lore
• The plan to remaster and re-release the Top 16 as “Tailor's Versions”
• Season 10 goals, Episode 500 hype, and the long-term dream of brackets-of-brackets
This is the roadmap episode. The meta episode. The “we probably didn’t need to do this but absolutely did anyway” episode. If you’ve ever wondered where to start with the TodCast—or why it refuses to be normal—this is your entry point.