Amanda and Sam tackle reseller 101 — the advice they'd give a friend who wants to start. Amanda's approach: start on Poshmark, sell what's already in your closet, roll that money into sourcing, never go into debt for inventory. Sam's counterpoint: invest early in a thermal printer, cross-listing software, and dedicated storage, because the up-front $150 pays for itself.
The bulk of the episode is tactical — photo setup, title formulas (Amanda's is brand-forward, Sam's leans style and fabric), keyword strategy for platform search, and how much detail is actually worth your time. Amanda makes the case that she did all the "right" things for two years, then stripped back to the bare minimum and still sells. Sam runs measurements on everything after learning the hard way that people tailor their jeans.
They compare PrimeLister, Nifty, and Vendoo honestly, including the sales dip Amanda saw after switching, and both land on PrimeLister as the beginner recommendation. Amanda's best reframe of the episode: stop resenting platform fees — you're paying for a built-in audience you'd otherwise spend thousands acquiring.
Also covered: PO boxes and seller safety, the laundering debate, delisting discipline and what a below-standard eBay rating costs you, and why ambassador and star seller badges matter more than the "it doesn't matter" crowd claims. Closes with crowdsourced advice from listeners — hire a CPA, learn your fabrics, and check sell-through before you buy the 99-cent find.
__________________
A friend texts you: "I want to start reselling — where do I even begin?" This episode is our answer.
Amanda and Sam break down reseller 101 from two very different angles. Amanda starts everyone on Poshmark and preaches selling what you already own before you spend a dollar sourcing. Sam went the other way, invested up front, and has opinions about thermal printers, storage units, and why your tech stack matters more than you think.
We get into: which platform to start on and why (Poshmark, eBay, Depop, Mercari, Vinted, Vestiaire, Etsy), the cross-listing software debate — PrimeLister vs. Nifty vs. Vendoo, and what happened when Amanda switched — how to take listing photos that don't get you a return, title formulas and keyword strategy for platform SEO, whether measurements are worth your time, the perspective shift on platform fees that'll stop you resenting that 20%, why you need a PO box before you share your closet publicly, the laundering debate (and why we've both mostly stopped), delisting, bans, and how to protect your seller rating, and the ambassador and star seller badges people say don't matter — but do.
Plus crowdsourced advice from the reselling community: hire a CPA, learn your fabrics, and remember that a 99-cent thrift find still costs you time.
We're not experts. We just have receipts.
Coming up: monthly lives on our Substack, plus Musso from Bolo Trends next week.