The Truth About Reselling

We’re back! Well, kind of. This is a quick bonus episode to catch you up on where we’ve been. We spent an amazing weekend in Dallas with Vendoo and a group of resellers. Becca, Amanda, and I met in person for the first time (and shared a hotel room). Then we all came home and got sick.

We also talk about something we keep coming back to: we started reselling to be flexible for our families, not to burn ourselves out. With Q4 in full swing, it’s easy to push too hard, so this is your reminder to give yourself some grace.

Coming up: Wild Ginger on luxury secondhand on Whatnot, a Dallas recap with Becca Thrifts, plus Amber from Nashville, Scuba Steve, part-time resellers, a former high-end designer, and folks building sustainable and repair-focused businesses.

Want to come to a reseller brunch near you? Email us, DM us, or comment on Spotify and tell us your city.

A quick bonus update: our Dallas trip with Vendoo, the post-trip sick week that followed, and a Q4 reminder about why we started reselling in the first place. We also share who’s coming up on the pod and how to request a reseller brunch in your city.

The Real Real Resale Report, Plus Vinted wins, bad pallets, a Poshmark suspension, and our Dallas thrift brunch with Vendoo.

Vendoo is sponsoring our Dallas event! Want to get involved, be interviewed, or help two very non–Type A hosts with admin? Email us at [email protected]

Amanda and Sam are back from summer break and going through The RealReal's 2026 Resale Report as they read it. They cover vintage demand, the brands and bags heating up, why "fair condition" is a real search strategy, and what it all means for your keywords. They also share their reseller highs and lows: a $500 Vinted sale with no fees, a run of bad pallets, and a 24-hour Poshmark suspension.

We're back! After a summer that nearly took us out, Amanda and Sam catch up on Whatnot life, 1,500 unlisted Vendoo drafts, and the brunch and thrift event we're hosting in Dallas with #Vendoo.

Then we open The RealReal's 2026 Resale Report together for the first time, live. Vintage demand is up 432% since 2020, and the '90s are still on top. Shoppers are searching for "fair" condition on purpose so they can get worn-in leather for less. Matthieu Blazy's searches are up almost 11,000% since he joined Chanel. And the Louis Vuitton Neverfull everyone keeps calling "basic"? Still going up. We also get into the city-by-city trends, the bags predicted to be future resale stars, and why the report convinced us to put celebrity names and aesthetic keywords in your listings.

We also cover whether Q4 is really slow for resellers (not for us), picking up Shein at the thrift, and how to build a natural-fiber fall wardrobe. Our tips: feel everything, check the tags, and stop buying polyester sweaters.

We close with our reseller highs and lows. Amanda finally broke through on Vinted, and Sam scored a Vera Wang wedding dress at a half-off sale in Colorado. The lows: back-to-back bad pallets and another 24-hour Poshmark suspension, which is exactly why you should be cross-listing.

Whether you're flipping for profit on Poshmark, eBay, Depop, Whatnot, or Vinted, or just thrifting smarter for yourself, this one's full of data you can use.

Morgan (Effies Home https://www.tiktok.com/@effieshome?lang=en) spent seven years teaching high school history — 40 kids in a classroom, no support from administration, and a take-home salary of about $23,000 a year. She was also seven years into an undiagnosed Lyme disease infection. Then she found a vintage Escada skirt at a thrift store, figured out she could sell it, and resigned in 2022.
Follow us: @effieshome @amanda.commonthreads @samanthastorms

Shop Morgan's Poshmark here https://poshmark.com/closet/effieshome

Shop our Poshmarks & eBays here!

Amanda eBay

Sam Poshmark

Three and a half years later she's doing around $60,000 a year in sales out of one guest bedroom, with about 1,630 items listed across Poshmark, eBay, and Depop — and she's aiming for $100K.

We get into the stuff resellers usually skip: what it actually costs to scale, why buying pallets is a worse starting point than everyone on TikTok makes it look, and the five things genuinely worth investing in (a CPA, cross-listing and automation software, a real storage system, good lighting, and a thermal printer that does not need to be expensive).

Morgan also talks about why reselling works so well for people with chronic illness, the ADHD-versus-OCD diagnosis mess she's currently untangling, and how a master's in history turned into an edge for dating vintage pieces.

Plus: why you should have your fall and Halloween inventory listed already, the eBay sell-through rate trap nobody warns you about (you're only seeing 90 days, so off-season comps lie to you), whether to claim inventory the year you buy it or the year it sells, and an honest conversation about spouse income — because all three of them have one, and pretending otherwise is how reselling content gets sold as something it isn't.

Topics: reselling, thrifting, vintage clothing, side hustle, Poshmark, eBay, Depop, Etsy, Vestiaire, cross-listing, Vendoo, PrimeLister, sell-through rate, flipping for profit, quitting teaching, chronic illness and self-employment.Morgan left high school teaching in 2022 with seven years of experience and a $23K take-home salary. She now sells vintage full-time out of a guest bedroom and makes nearly double that. She, Sam, and Amanda talk about what it really costs to scale, why pallets are a trap for beginners, the five things worth spending money on, reselling with a chronic illness, and why your fall inventory should already be listed.


reselling, vintage reselling, quitting teaching, thrifting, side hustle, Poshmark, eBay, Depop, reseller podcast, flipping clothes for profit

how much do resellers actually make, is reselling worth it, quitting teaching for reselling, best cross-listing app for resellers, when to list fall inventory, does sell-through rate work for seasonal items

Mmuso of Bolo Trends on titling smarter with real search data, the $1,000+ Persian rug flip, and why "style-based selling" beats brand names

Follow Bolo Trends across social media and sign up for the free newsletter at bolotrends.com for weekly keyword insights straight to your inbox.

Summary:
Data analyst and Bolo Trends founder Mmuso joins Sam and Amanda to break down how actual Google search data — not vibes, not AI guessing — should be driving your titles and sourcing decisions. Plus: the wild story behind his wife's four-figure Persian rug flip, found through a niche Facebook group before they even won the auction.

Description:

Sam runs her reselling business off pure vibes. Mmuso runs his off fifteen months of search data across nearly 5,000 keywords. This episode is what happens when those two philosophies collide — and honestly, Sam walks away converted.

Mmuso, a business intelligence data analyst by trade and founder of Bolo Trends, explains how he's building what he calls the world's largest reseller demand intelligence database — tracking exactly what buyers are typing into Google, down to the difference between "graduation dress" (600K+ monthly searches) and "off-shoulder top" (a fraction of that). No AI guessing, no generic keyword tools spitting out "corporate chic minimalist" nonsense — just real buyer demand signals resellers can actually use to title and price smarter.

The conversation dives into style-based selling: why leading with a brand name like Forever 21 or Shein can actually hurt your listing, and why construction, material, and fit often sell better than a logo ever will. Mmuso also shares the incredible story of his wife's Persian rug flip — sourced through a niche Facebook group, sold to a buyer before the estate sale auction even closed, netting over $1,000 with zero money fronted.

Whether you're deep into flipping for profit on Poshmark, eBay, or Depop, or you're just trying to stop guessing on your titles and keywords, this episode is full of practical, data-backed strategy for your reselling side hustle. Mmuso also talks about where the industry might be headed next, from Substack to potential paid tiers for deeper keyword data.

Amanda and Sam tackle reseller 101 — the advice they'd give a friend who wants to start. Amanda's approach: start on Poshmark, sell what's already in your closet, roll that money into sourcing, never go into debt for inventory. Sam's counterpoint: invest early in a thermal printer, cross-listing software, and dedicated storage, because the up-front $150 pays for itself.

The bulk of the episode is tactical — photo setup, title formulas (Amanda's is brand-forward, Sam's leans style and fabric), keyword strategy for platform search, and how much detail is actually worth your time. Amanda makes the case that she did all the "right" things for two years, then stripped back to the bare minimum and still sells. Sam runs measurements on everything after learning the hard way that people tailor their jeans.

They compare PrimeLister, Nifty, and Vendoo honestly, including the sales dip Amanda saw after switching, and both land on PrimeLister as the beginner recommendation. Amanda's best reframe of the episode: stop resenting platform fees — you're paying for a built-in audience you'd otherwise spend thousands acquiring.

Also covered: PO boxes and seller safety, the laundering debate, delisting discipline and what a below-standard eBay rating costs you, and why ambassador and star seller badges matter more than the "it doesn't matter" crowd claims. Closes with crowdsourced advice from listeners — hire a CPA, learn your fabrics, and check sell-through before you buy the 99-cent find.

__________________

A friend texts you: "I want to start reselling — where do I even begin?" This episode is our answer.

Amanda and Sam break down reseller 101 from two very different angles. Amanda starts everyone on Poshmark and preaches selling what you already own before you spend a dollar sourcing. Sam went the other way, invested up front, and has opinions about thermal printers, storage units, and why your tech stack matters more than you think.

We get into: which platform to start on and why (Poshmark, eBay, Depop, Mercari, Vinted, Vestiaire, Etsy), the cross-listing software debate — PrimeLister vs. Nifty vs. Vendoo, and what happened when Amanda switched — how to take listing photos that don't get you a return, title formulas and keyword strategy for platform SEO, whether measurements are worth your time, the perspective shift on platform fees that'll stop you resenting that 20%, why you need a PO box before you share your closet publicly, the laundering debate (and why we've both mostly stopped), delisting, bans, and how to protect your seller rating, and the ambassador and star seller badges people say don't matter — but do.

Plus crowdsourced advice from the reselling community: hire a CPA, learn your fabrics, and remember that a 99-cent thrift find still costs you time.

We're not experts. We just have receipts.

Coming up: monthly lives on our Substack, plus Musso from Bolo Trends next week.

Consignment splits, celebrity closet cleanouts, and quitting your 9-5 with no plan — with Jen

Ever wonder who's actually selling those influencer closet cleanouts? It's Jen — and she's never once reached out to a client to get there.

Jen consigns for influencers and celebrities in LA, and this week she's telling us everything: how her first client found her by literally Googling "clothing seller in LA," the closet organizer connection that opened the door to celebrity clients, and why word of mouth built her entire business.

We get into the numbers too:

✔️ Her exact consignment splits (and why luxury items flip the math)
✔️ Making six figures a year without spending a dime on inventory
✔️ Why she doesn't do contracts — and it's worked for four years
✔️ The text she sends every new client before a single pickup
✔️ Batching six consignment pickups in one day, two hours from LA
✔️ Why we all keep saying we'll hire help... and never do

Plus: storage unit confessions, the $3,000 wedding dress that got away, and thrift stores selling their best stuff on Whatnot before it ever hits the floor.

Follow Jen: @laposherjen & Shop her Poshmark @jenkramirez
Follow us: @amanda.commonthreads @samanthastorms

Shop our Poshmarks & eBays here!

Amanda eBay

Sam Poshmark

A $2K Maui Jim pallet flip, selling to a Juicy Couture co-founder, and the ebbs and flows nobody talks about — plus Whatnot's shipping change and meetups on the way.

Amanda opened a pallet expecting junk sunglasses and found hundreds of Maui Jims: $2,000 in 24 hours on eBay, whole pallet paid off in eight hours. Sam had her own peak — a thrifted skirt that sold to a Juicy Couture co-founder — the night after she'd convinced herself she was bad at this.

This week the two get into the reality of the ebbs and flows: why one bad show doesn't mean you're failing, why Sam doesn't look at comps (and how that got her $2,100 for a fur coat), and how pricing with a little audacity pays off.

Plus: the Whatnot flat rate box change hitting August 1st, the consignment rule you should never break, and a few big things coming — a pallet giveaway, a monthly live pod, and a Dallas reseller meetup in September.

New episodes weekly.

Follow Amanda: @amanda.commonthreads

Shop Amanda's Ebay

Shop Amanda's Whatnot

Follow Sam: @samanthastorms

Shop Sam's Etsy

Shop Sam's Poshmark

Shop Sam's Depop (stuff is cheaper here!)

Takeaways

• The ebbs and flows are real — one bad show doesn't mean you're failing
• Price on gut, not comps (comps only tell you the past)
• Luxury and one-of-a-kind pieces let you price with audacity
• Whatnot is getting rid of flat rate shipping Aug 1 — shows are about to change
• Reselling is weirdly good for connection and community
• Big things coming: a pallet giveaway, live pod, and Dallas meetup

This week we're sitting down with Julie Shapiro of Casa Chic — a reseller who's been doing this since 2000, long before anyone called it a side hustle. Julie left her career as a trial lawyer (she still practices on the side) to stay home with her kids, started selling her own clothes on eBay, told a few friends on a park bench, and never looked back. Now over two decades later, her kids are grown, her January just hit her second-highest Poshmark month ever, and she's still going strong.

In this episode we get into everything: how Julie built a word-of-mouth consignment reselling business from the ground up, why she's selective about who she takes on as consignment clients (and why "desperate" sellers are a red flag), and how she went from knowing nothing about thrifting to treating it like surgery — focused, intentional, and no filming allowed. We also get into the messy financial reality behind flashy six-figure seller claims, why retail arbitrage math doesn't always add up the way people think, and whether sharing everything on social media is cannibalizing our own market.

Plus, Julie shares her controversial reseller habits — three-day handling, no returns on eBay, and trusting her gut over comps — and why they work for her after 25 years of flipping for profit. If you're a mom wondering how to start reselling, trying to figure out if reselling is worth it, or a seasoned thrifter looking to sharpen your sourcing strategy, this episode is for you.

For the high/low of the week: a tricky Poshmark case, a record-breaking January, an eBay return that's probably a lie, and the garage that is finally — finally — clean.

Follow Julie on TikTok

Shop Julie's Closet

Sam and Amanda discuss the challenges of reselling during the summer, including the impact on family life and the summer slowdown in sales. They also explore the balance between running a reselling business and spending time with family, gaining perspective on business challenges and the importance of prioritizing family time. The conversation covers parenting challenges, summer activities, membership costs, summer reselling strategy, ethical considerations in thrifting and reselling, and a consignment client's personal impact. We delve into the impact of consignment, the ethical approach to thrifting, innovative selling methods, the thrill of travel thrifting, and the value of flexibility. It also highlights the joy of reselling and the dopamine of shopping, along with upcoming episodes and busy schedules. The speakers express gratitude and emphasize the importance of balancing work and enjoyment.

Takeaways

• Reselling in the summer presents unique challenges, including the impact on family time and the summer slowdown in sales.
• Balancing a reselling business with family life requires perspective, flexibility, and the ability to prioritize family time during busy periods. Parenting challenges and the need for engaging summer activities
• Consideration of membership costs for family activities
• Strategic approach to summer reselling
• Ethical considerations in thrifting and reselling
• Personal impact of a consignment client's situation Impact of consignment on individuals and communities
• The joy and flexibility of reselling

Chapters

• 00:00 Summer Reselling Challenges
• 06:17 Balancing Business and Family
• 18:18 Parenting Challenges and Summer Activities
• 24:16 Summer Reselling Strategy
• 33:13 Ethical Considerations in Thrifting and Reselling
• 39:13 Donating to Those in Need
• 44:23 Thrifting as a Profitable Venture
• 50:14 The Dopamine of Shopping
• 57:43 Closing Remarks

What does it actually look like to go from selling clothing & accessories on Instagram stories to $345,000 in sales on Whatnot in under a year — while being a mom, running a business with your husband, and pivoting from clothing to vintage jewelry mid-stream? Kelsey from Lucky in Love joins Sam and Amanda to tell us everything.
Kelsey started reselling as a teenager on Craigslist and eBay, turned it into a side hustle through Instagram story sales as a wedding photographer in Oregon, and watched it explode the moment she joined Whatnot. Now she and her husband run it full-time — and she has zero regrets.
In this episode we cover:

- How Kelsey went from $1-2K per Instagram drop to $345K on Whatnot in her first 8 months
- Why she ditched clothing entirely and went all-in on vintage jewelry reselling

- When Kelsey knew it was time for her husband to quit his job and go all-in with her
- The number one piece of advice for anyone thinking about starting to resell
- The real numbers: what $345K in gross sales actually looks like after sourcing costs
- How to get started on Whatnot with no following — and why you can't skip the learning curve
- The mental toll of live selling and how to stop taking slow shows personally
- Why being authentically yourself isn't just good advice — it's a business strategy
- Safety tips every live seller needs: PO boxes, blocking creeps, and protecting your privacy

Whether you're a beginner reseller just starting out, thinking about selling on Whatnot, or already live selling and hitting a wall — this episode is honest, funny, and genuinely useful.

Follow Kelsey on TikTok

Shop Kelsey's Whatnot
🎧 New episodes every week. Follow so you never miss one.