The Unintentional Heretic

Did the Apostle Paul fundamentally change the message of Jesus? Explore how Paul helped transform a Jewish messianic movement into a worldwide religion, his disagreements with the original disciples, and the striking similarities and differences between Jesus' teachings and the theology that came to shape Christianity.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

Did Christianity borrow its beliefs about Jesus from earlier pagan religions? Explore the fascinating connections between Christianity and the ancient traditions of Mithras, Osiris, and Dionysus, separating historical evidence from popular myths while examining how religious traditions influence one another and why Christianity's evolving history need not diminish its spiritual truth.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

What happened to Jesus between Good Friday and Easter Sunday? Explore the ancient Christian tradition of the Harrowing of Hell, tracing its roots in Scripture and early Christian theology to a remarkable vision of Christ descending into the realm of the dead, shattering its gates, and liberating those held captive, revealing a radically hopeful understanding of resurrection and a divine love that reaches beyond even death.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

Who were the Knights Templar, and how did an order of warrior monks become one of the most powerful and mysterious institutions in medieval Christianity? This episode of The Unintentional Heretic explores their dramatic rise and fall, the legends of hidden treasures and secret knowledge that surround them, and what their history reveals about Christianity’s complicated relationship with wealth, violence, and political power.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

How did the understanding of God evolve in ancient Israel, and what can history, archaeology, and mythology tell us about that process? In this episode of The Unintentional Heretic, Dr. Justin Sledge, creator of the popular Esoterica YouTube channel, joins me to explore the fascinating evolution of Israelite religion and how we can take our sacred stories seriously without needing them to be literally or historically factual.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

Did the God of the Bible once have a wife? In this episode of The Unintentional Heretic, we uncover the surprising archaeological and biblical evidence surrounding the goddess Asherah, explore how ancient Israel's understanding of God evolved from a world of many gods toward monotheism, and consider what this forgotten history reveals about Scripture, religious certainty, and the mystery of God.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

Was Judas the ultimate villain of the Christian story, or have we misunderstood one of its most tragic and complicated figures? In this episode of The Unintentional Heretic, we reconsider the man who betrayed Jesus, explore the history and theology surrounding his story, and wrestle with what his fate reveals about free will, forgiveness, and the possibility of a love so expansive that even Judas is not beyond its reach.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

Did Jesus expect God’s kingdom—and the end of the present age—to arrive within his generation? This episode explores Jesus’ apocalyptic message, the early Church’s struggle with a delayed ending, and how Christian hope might be less about predicting when Jesus will return and more about embodying God’s future through justice, mercy, and love.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

What if God is not somewhere far off in heaven, but the sacred reality within whom the whole universe lives? Drawing on Scripture, biology, process theology, and Einstein’s “optical delusion” of separateness, this episode explores panentheism and its invitation to recognize that although not everything is God, nothing exists outside God.

Would love to hear your thoughts!

Why did Jesus so often teach in stories that confused his listeners rather than giving them clear and direct answers? This episode explores how the parables disrupt our certainty, expose the limits of our usual ways of seeing, and invite us into the deeper transformation of consciousness that Cynthia Bourgeault identifies with the wisdom tradition of Jesus.

Would love to hear your thoughts!