Mid-Atlantic - conversations about US, UK and world politics

The US attacks Venezuela, When the Rules Become Optional


Listen Later

Host: Roifield Brown

Producer: Connor Begley

Guests: Mike Donahue, Mike Holden, Tony Alltrade


Episode summary

This week, Mid-Atlantic looks at what happens when the “rules-based international order” stops behaving like a system and starts behaving like a slogan. The conversation centres on the US seizure/extraction of Venezuela’s president and the eerie normalisation of an act that by the usual standards would be labelled rogue behaviour. From there, the panel widens the lens: spheres of influence, NATO’s credibility, Britain’s silence, and the uncomfortable possibility that “rogue state” is becoming a category defined by power, not principle.


What we cover
  • The “rules-based order” feels retired: how language about sovereignty and international law collapses when allies break it.
  • Why Britain went quiet: the panel digs into the significance of Keir Starmer’s (and the UK government’s) muted response—and what that says about the “special relationship.”
  • Foreign policy vs domestic distraction: is this about strategy (oil, BRICS, China/Russia influence), or a political smokescreen (Epstein files, domestic turmoil, midterms)?
  • “Trump pushes until stopped”: the idea that boundary-testing is the method, not a side-effect.
  • Greenland as the next anxiety: not just as a hypothetical, but as a test of whether NATO is a system with teeth or a club with vibes.
  • Spheres of influence, back to the 19th century: are we sliding into a three-bloc world and if so, what replaces the pretence of universal rules?
  • NATO: paper, system, or faith?: argument over whether annexation would shatter the alliance or merely bruise it.
  • The “moral high ground” problem: what the West can and can’t say about Russia/Ukraine or China/Taiwan after a precedent like this.
  • Can US institutions stop a rogue executive?: sharp disagreement on whether the military, courts, Congress, or wider civil society can meaningfully constrain Trump.
  • Consequences if the order collapses: sanctions, trade wars, defence spending spikes, market shock, and realignment away from US leadership.
  • A little football palate cleanser: Arsenal title optimism, Burnley survival nerves, Portsmouth loyalty, and a classic Mid-Atlantic sign-off.

Key moments & quotes (highlights)
  • Ro: “If that doesn’t count as rogue behaviour, then the term has become meaningless.”
  • Mike Donahue: “He’ll push and push and push boundaries until someone actually stops him.”
  • Mike Holden: “Yes, any maniac looks strong. But that doesn’t mean they’re trustworthy.”
  • Tony: “We’re almost having to reset… we have no semblance of what is right again.”
  • On NATO/Europe’s response: “Very strongly worded diplomatic messages… very strongly worded.”

Big questions the episode asks
  • What does a world look like when rules become optional?
  • Who gets to break the rules and who gets punished for trying?
  • If the old system is dead, what replaces it: blocs, spheres, or chaos?
  • How does the West criticise Russia or China after this precedent?
  • Is the real battle now internal to the US rather than international?

People & accounts mentioned
  • Mike Donahue — (social: discussed on-air)
  • Mike Holden@MikeHolden42
  • Tony (“Alltrade”)@alltrade_ (Twitter) / Tony on the… / alt aLT (as mentioned)

Closing beat

The episode ends where it began: with disbelief, unease, and a running (and increasingly personal) disagreement between Ro and Donahue about whether anyone can stop Trump or whether the rest of the world is simply getting a late invitation to the chaos Americans have already been living through.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Mid-Atlantic - conversations about US, UK and world politicsBy Roifield Brown

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

63 ratings


More shows like Mid-Atlantic - conversations about US, UK and world politics

View all
10 American Presidents Podcast by Roifield Brown

10 American Presidents Podcast

527 Listeners

Politics Weekly UK by The Guardian

Politics Weekly UK

283 Listeners

How Jamaica Conquered the World by Roifield Brown

How Jamaica Conquered the World

70 Listeners

Daily Politics from the New Statesman by The New Statesman

Daily Politics from the New Statesman

151 Listeners

Brown People by Roifield Brown

Brown People

8 Listeners

The Race Directors Podcast - F1 by Roifield Brown

The Race Directors Podcast - F1

16 Listeners

DumTeeDum - A show about BBC Radio's 'The Archers' by Dumteedum

DumTeeDum - A show about BBC Radio's 'The Archers'

128 Listeners

Intelligent Speech - interviews, conversations and presentations of ideas by Roifield Brown

Intelligent Speech - interviews, conversations and presentations of ideas

13 Listeners

Newscast by BBC News

Newscast

696 Listeners

Tides of History by Audible /  Patrick Wyman

Tides of History

6,308 Listeners

Today in Focus by The Guardian

Today in Focus

1,045 Listeners

Americast by BBC News

Americast

771 Listeners

The Bunker – News without the nonsense by Podmasters

The Bunker – News without the nonsense

105 Listeners

The Rest Is History by Goalhanger

The Rest Is History

15,859 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics

3,555 Listeners

The News Agents by Global

The News Agents

1,167 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics: Leading by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics: Leading

819 Listeners

The News Agents - USA by Global

The News Agents - USA

391 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics: US by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics: US

2,361 Listeners

The Rest Is Classified by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Classified

1,270 Listeners