Gerrit Cole won his first ever Cy Young and the guys break down Brian Cashman's confusing comments about Giancarlo Stanton. Also on the show, the Bills fire Ken Dorsey and the boys are sad about their football teams.

On a Football Thursday, the guys share their picks for Week 10 where Luke has a serious chance to gain some ground. Before the picks, the guys run through the Jets QB situation ahead of their game vs. the Raiders and if the Bills can gain back their trust.

The guys open the show talking baseball in November, as the Mets hired their new manager. Brian Cashman ruffled some feathers after speaking to the media. Plus, New York football stinks as the Jets were blown out on Monday Night and the Bills slipped up vs. the Bengals

Matt and Luke whip out the Worry-O-Meter ahead of Bills-Bengals and look ahead to the Jets' Monday night matchup with the Chargers. Also, the Giants play a game and the Week 9 NFL Picks.

Just before Halloween, the Jets and Giants provided us with the scariest game of all time. The guys try to find some takeaways from it other than "punt." Plus, the Bills have their toughest test coming up next week vs. the Bengals and the Commanders sell off at the deadline.

The Jets are healthier coming off the bye as they get set to face the Giants Sunday, but should the Giants have a QB controversy on their hands? Plus, the Bills aren't as good as we thought and a pair of local look-ahead NFL Picks.

Luke is back and has some questions for Matt and his playoff goal for the Jets. Also on the show, Bills-Patriots and if a win does something for the Giants. Plus, it's a significant week for our NFL Picks.

On an Luke-less episode, Matt deems the Jets a playoff team after going through the gauntlet of their first six games and maintaining a .500 record. Also on the show, why injuries derailed the Giants season and what the Bills need to gain some consistency on offense.

Sitting at 1-4, the guys look into the Giants' future and discuss how much of the slow start falls on Daniel Jones. Also on the show, Bills fall in London, the Jets lose AVT in a big win for Nathaniel Hackett and Odd Man Rush.

The guys have some questions when it comes to the timing of Billy Eppler's resignation. Also on the show, it doesn't seem like the Giants will be able to keep it close, the Bills travel to London and the Jets need a win in Denver. Plus the guys have their picks for Week Five.