The Weekly Eudemon
Download on the App Store

The Weekly Eudemon episodes

  • The Elf Lays Down His Harp to Kill an Orc
    Synopsis: Owen Barfield wrote about the importance of pre-rational thought and language. It heavily influenced Tolkien’s work. Iain McGilchrist has written about the same thing in The Master and His Emissary and the importance of the brain’s right hemisphere.
    10 min
  • How to Break a Maniac

    My daughter sent this Existential Comic to me. It shows three ancient philosophers competing in the Philosophy event at the Greek Olympics: Thales, who declares everything is water. Zeno, who declares motion is impossible. Socrates, who declares they’re full of bulls***.

    Socrates won.

    But of course, he didn’t really win: he refuted nothing.

    His refutation was even worse than Samuel Johnson’s stone-kicking “refutation” of George Berkeley.

    It’s a well-worn anecdote: Samuel Johnson and his companion, James Boswell, stood outside church in 1763, talking about George Berkeley’s startling philosophical conclusion that matter doesn’t exist.

    Here’s how it works: We only perceive matter’s characteristics. That green thing has four legs, a flat surface, and a horizontal surface. Our mind then combines those things to declare “chair.” But we don’t perceive chair. We only perceive the things that comprise the chair and, therefore, the chair itself doesn’t really exist. Since all things are mere combinations of other things that we perceive in their relation to other things, nothing really exists. Everything is just our ideas. All is mind. There is no matter.

    Boswell said, though it can’t be true, it’s impossible to refute.

    “Johnson,” Boswell wrote in his famous biography, “answered, striking his foot with mighty force against a large stone . . . ‘I refute it thus.’”

    That ended the discussion, but Boswell concluded the story by noting that he would’ve loved to have seen a genius like Johnson contend with Berkeley since Berkeley’s ideas could not be “answered by pure reasoning.” David Hume reached a similar conclusion about Berkeley’s ideas: “they admit of no answer and produce no conviction.”

    They cannot be answered by pure reasoning

    Zeno: There is no motion. Berkeley: There is no matter. We could add a few other philosophers into this tradition: Parmenides: There is no change. Derrida: There is no reality.

    None of them could be refuted but none of them convinced anyone with a shred of ingenuousness or common sense. They probably didn’t even believe their own conclusions, and I can guaran-freakin’-tee to you that they didn’t live by their own conclusions.

    But they couldn’t be refuted.

    Why?

    I think that lecher (and tosspot) Boswell hit on the answer: they could not “be answered by pure reasoning.”

    There is something about reality that transcends reason: something not subject to reason, something that can’t be defined, something that defies capture by words.

    Enter the realm beyond language and reason

    This piece is a follow-up of sorts to last week’s post: “Are You Engaged in the Act of Existence? Then You’re a Man of the Tao.”

    The “Act of Existence,” I pointed out last week, is prior to all else. The Act of Existence is prior to essence and attributes, which are prior to existence itself. Because the Act of Existence is prior to all else, it informs all else.

    Importantly, all else doesn’t inform it. The part doesn’t capture the whole, the son doesn’t define the father.

    So the world of essence and existence isn’t going to define the Act of Existence.

    Words and reason are the tools of the world of essence. Essence is prior to existence, so essence’s tools paint existence as well.

    But the Act of Existence is prior to it all.

    That’s how Berkeley and Zeno and Derrida can be 100% logical and 100% wrong at the same time.

    Ah, a paradox! Now we’re getting someplace

    It’s a paradox.

    Get used to it.

    Everything informed by reality (the “Reality Spectrum,” I called it last week) is a paradox. I remember listening to an interview with Ian McGilchrist last year. He was describing a roundtable discussion with other heavyweight intellectuals that hit upon two contradictory statements that were both true. One of the participants lit up and said, “Ah, a paradox! Now we’re getting someplace.”

    Exactly.

    The Reality Spectrum is someplace. It’s everyplace. If you deny it, you’ll never get anyplace. You’ll reach conclusions: but nothing will be concluded. You’ll be right: but you’ll be wrong.

    If you deny the Reality Spectrum, you’re playing poker without the face cards. You might draw a straight flush, 6 through 10, and reach for the pot, then the other guy will lay down four kings. You’ll see that you lost, but you won’t understand why. The full deck of the Reality Spectrum transcends your partial deck of essence/existence only. The partial deck can win hands, but in the long game, the full deck will win.

    Maniacs are commonly great reasoners

    In Chapter II of his classic book, Orthodoxy, G.K Chesterton describes “the maniac.”

    “Maniacs,” GKC observed, “are commonly great reasoners.”

    But they’re still maniacs because they reason within a very closed circle.

    The maniac’s explanation of a thing is always complete, and often in a purely rational sense satisfactory.

    If the maniac says six guys have a conspiracy against him, then you tell him, “I spoke to each one of them. They assure me they don’t,” the maniac says, “That’s what conspirators would say.”

    And he’d be right.

    The argument itself can’t be broken. In order to get anywhere with the maniac, you have to break open his little world.

    For the maniac who relies solely on reason, you have to break open his reality of essence à existence only. You have to get him to see the Act of Existence: the Tao. You need to get him on the Reality Spectrum.

    But you can’t use reason to do it.

    Something else is needed.

    It’s sometimes humor. When you juxtapose something next to the maniac’s stilted reality that he didn’t expect, he might laugh and inadvertently let in more reality.

    But sometimes something harsher is needed. A jolt of sorts. Maybe a near-death experience. Maybe the birth of a child.

    Or maybe someone wise just telling him he’s full of bulls*** and kicking a rock at him.

    8 min
  • Are You Engaged in the Act of Existence? Then You're a Man of the Tao

    My daughter runs.

    She runs in the morning, she runs at night. Runs, runs, runs.

    People around town see her and go, “Look at that girl! She’s a runner.”

    But I know she’s more than that.

    My daughter breathes. She breathes in the morning, she breathes at night. Breathes, breathes, breathes. She’s a breather.

    And you know what else?

    She exists. She exists in the morning, she exists at night. Exists, exists, exists. She’s an exister . . . a being.

    It’s All Absurdly Axiomatic

    It’s all common sense, right? Almost so obvious that it borders on stupidity?  

    “Scheske, we get it: Your daughter engages in the act of running, so we know she’s a runner. She engages in the act of breathing, so we know she’s a breather. She engages in the act of existing, so we know she’s a being. It’s axiomatic to the point of absurd common sense.”

    Perhaps.

    But just grant me this: There’s something different between “engaging in the act of running/breathing/existing” and “being a runner/breather/being.”

    I don’t even want you to explain what the difference is. Just concede the point: they’re different somehow.

    And then focus on the “being” part.

    Let Me Hurt Your Brain a Little

    Each person is engaged in the act of existence. Therefore, each person exists. We know a person exists by seeing her (and the traits that distinguish her from other things), so in that sense, her distinguishing traits are prior to her existence (we know the traits before we know the being), but even before the traits can be seen, she is engaged in the act of existence. If she weren’t, there would be nothing for the traits to latch onto.

    Now let me give you a simple formula:

    Act of existence–>essence–>being.

    I call it the “Reality Spectrum.” It’s the full spectrum, in three points of reference, of our reality. We are engaged in the act of existence, which allows essences (attributes, traits, characteristics, “accidents”) to attach, which then makes our being accessible to the rest of the world.

    A lot of philosophers have rejected it. They reject the “act of existence” altogether, either saying that it’s synonymous with “being” and therefore isn’t even a thing, or saying that it’s axiomatic to the point of absurd common sense.

    But they’re obviously wrong. We know my daughter is a runner because she engages in the act of running. They’re different things.  

    It’s Not Even Worth Talking About

    Well, the axiomaticians aren’t really wrong. They have a point. It is axiomatic (one thing necessarily leading to the other).

    In fact, the axiomaticians might be the most correct. The whole thing is so axiomatic, there’s nothing left to be said about the “act of existence.”

    “Okay, Scheske. We know your daughter is a runner because she’s engaged in the act of running. Everything else about the condition—her personal best, her preferred running shoes, her form, how it makes her feel, how it affects her other life activities—all focus on the attributes of running or her. To explore her running, we don’t ever have to revisit the premise that ‘she’s engaged in the act of running.’ So drop it. We don’t give a s*** about the act of running.”

    And they’d be right. The Running Reality Spectrum for purposes of everything we know (for purposes of observation, discussion, debate, data, experimentation, records, the Olympics, TV, a varsity letter, etc.) looks like this: Attributes of Running–>Runner.

    No “Act of Running.” It’s there, yes, but it’s not even worth talking about, so it can be properly (efficiently) discarded from our mental view.

    When it comes to the Act of Existence, we tend to do the same thing. The Reality Spectrum is just Attributes of Existing–>Being. Everything we can see, hear, talk about, and measure pertains to one of those two things. The Act of Existence is prior to all that, of course, but so what? It’s not worth talking about.

    But I’d take the axiomaticians one step further:

    It’s not that it’s not worth talking about.

    It’s that we can’t talk about it.

    Enter the Tao

    The first line of Lao Tzu’s Tao Teh Ching tells us that “The Tao that can be put into words is not the real Tao.”

    The Zen master, Wen-yu, when asked for the First Principle of Zen, echoed Lao Tzu: “If words could tell you, it would become the Second Principle.”

    The Tao. The First Principle of Zen. There’s nothing to be said about them. In fact, if you try, you eliminate them. You can’t talk about them any more than you can catch your shadow. The mere attempt to catch it is a failure to appreciate what a shadow is. The same with the Tao and the First Principle of Zen: The mere attempt to talk about them (to catch them) is a failure to appreciate what they are.

    The Tao. The First Principle of Zen. They are labels for the Act of Existence.

    The Tao, the First Principle of Zen, and the Act of Existence can’t be defined because they are prior to the world of essence and being. Language defines subjects and objects. The Tao comes first, before language, before subject-object. The mere attempt to talk about it is a failure to appreciate what the Tao is.

    But that doesn’t mean the Tao is irrelevant.

    Far from it. It’s the most important thing, even if we can’t articulate how and must try to obtain glimpses of it in ways that don’t use the world of subject-object and language.

    I’ll write more about those ways in future pieces.

    9 min

About The Weekly Eudemon

From the publisher's feed

Widely-published author, speaker, and lawyer, Eric Scheske, offers weekly commentary on a host of matters, ranging from current events to philosophy to religion.