In Episode 15 of The YDisciple Podcast, Annie and Pete are joined by Father Chad Van Hoose, chaplain of NET Ministries, to wrestle with a question that many ministry leaders quietly (or loudly) ask: Should Catholic Youth Ministry exist?
Rather than offering easy answers, this conversation dives into the real tensions, objections, and assumptions behind the question. Together, they unpack:
The claim that “youth ministry has failed”Whether declining Church engagement proves anything about ministry modelsIf youth ministry isolates teens from parish lifeHow peer community fits into Christian maturityThe truth behind “parents are the primary educators”Whether youth ministry competes with family ministryThe role of emotions in faith formationIf the Church is just “one more demand” on teens’ timeFather Chad offers a grounded pastoral perspective, reframing many objections by asking deeper questions:
“How should the Church love, form, and accompany young people today?”
Connect with Us
Have questions? Email us at [email protected]Book your free call with a YDisciple Coach at ydisciple.com/coachingPlease take a moment to rate & review on Apple PodcastsVisit https://theydisciplepodcast.fireside.fm/ to learn more about the podcastReflection for This Week
Take a moment to reflect:
Which objections to youth ministry resonate with me most?Do my frustrations come from youth ministry itself — or how it’s been implemented?How integrated is youth ministry within the broader parish community?Am I forming disciples… or just running programs?How am I helping young people reorder their time around Christ?Ask the Holy Spirit to renew your vision for ministry —
not as maintenance, but as mission.