Welcome back to This Day in Scottish History. I’m your host, Colin MacDonald. Today, we journey back to October 28, 1854, to Dunkeld, Scotland, where a fascinating yet often overlooked figure in Jacobite history, Charles Edward Stuart, Count Roehenstart, met his end. Roehenstart’s life story is one of remarkable lineage, lost fortunes, and a quiet yet determined claim to the Stuart legacy.
Charles Edward Augustus Maximilian Stuart, more commonly known as Count Roehenstart, was born around May 1784 in Paris, to a heritage that tied him to one of the most romanticized figures in Scottish history: his grandfather, Charles Edward Stuart, the famous “Young Pretender” or Bonnie Prince Charlie. Roehenstart’s mother, Charlotte Stuart, Duchess of Albany, was the illegitimate daughter of Prince Charles and Clementina Walkinshaw, who were lovers in the midst of the Jacobite cause. Although born out of wedlock, Charlotte was later legitimized and given the title of Duchess by her father.
The name "Roehenstart" itself reflects Charles Edward’s complex heritage. It’s a blend of “Rohan,” from his father, Prince Ferdinand de Rohan, and “Stuart,” an homage to his mother’s royal lineage. Given the politics and sensitivities of the time, it was wise for the young Charles to bear a name that nodded to his roots without fully revealing them.
From an early age, Charles Edward Roehenstart’s life was marked by displacement and a struggle for security. After his mother Charlotte’s passing in 1789, he was raised by his maternal grandmother, Clementina, who moved to Switzerland. Following her death in 1802, Roehenstart was left with a significant inheritance—though that, too, would soon be lost in the turbulent financial world of the early 19th century. He pursued his education in Germany, supported by his father, but the French Revolution and Napoleonic Wars created further instability in his life.
Roehenstart’s journey took him to the courts of Europe, where he sought to establish a career as a soldier. He briefly served as a commissioned officer in the Russian army, rising to the rank of lieutenant colonel before leaving in 1806. His life story paints him as a man constantly in search of stability and recognition, yet one beset by ill-fated attempts and, at times, star-crossed romances. He once fell in love with the sister of an heiress intended for him—a costly emotional blunder, as it turned out. These personal misfortunes were compounded by financial ruin; he faced bankruptcy when his Russian banker defaulted and his inherited investments in London were lost due to a financial collapse.
Undeterred by these setbacks, Roehenstart set sail for America in 1811, hoping to reclaim some of his fortune from a former business partner who had fled to Philadelphia. During his time in the United States, Roehenstart lived an adventurous life and built connections in high society, although ultimately his quest to recover lost wealth proved unsuccessful.
In 1816, Roehenstart returned to Britain and pursued an unusual mission: he sought the historical dowry of his great-great-grandmother, Queen Mary of Modena, widow of James II of England. Though the pursuit was fruitless, it marked a period in which Roehenstart reconnected with his Jacobite ancestry and the legacy of the Stuarts. In later years, Roehenstart openly asserted his royal descent, though few were inclined to take his claims seriously. He laid a passive claim to the Jacobite succession but never took active steps to restore his family’s lost throne. Instead, he attempted to maintain ties with Scotland’s noble families, including visiting the Duke of Atholl at Blair Castle.
Though he traveled across Europe, his life remained tinged with tragedy and loss. His first marriage, to Maria Antonietta Sofia Barberini, ended in heartbreak with her untimely death. His second marriage to Louisa Constance Bouchier Smith brought some companionship but no children, leaving him the last of his line. He settled in Paris but continued to visit Scotland in his later years, perhaps in search of the connection that the land of his grandfather held for him.
It was on one of these visits that he met his tragic end. In 1854, during a journey from Blair Castle, Roehenstart’s carriage overturned, resulting in injuries that would prove fatal. He passed away in Dunkeld on October 28, 1854. His gravestone in Dunkeld Cathedral bears a simple but poignant inscription: “Sacred to the memory of General Charles Edward Stuart Count Roehenstart… Sic transit gloria mundi”—meaning, “Thus passes the glory of the world.”
In death, as in life, Roehenstart’s story remained one of quiet perseverance. He held onto his identity and his heritage, embodying the enduring allure of the Jacobite legacy, even if it was as an obscure claimant rather than a powerful pretender. Roehenstart’s life speaks to the broader story of the Stuarts, who, despite their dreams of restoring their throne, found themselves scattered, impoverished, and reliant on the kindness of others.
In the 20th century, Roehenstart’s forgotten story was uncovered by historians, who examined his surviving papers and letters. His life, while largely overshadowed by his more famous ancestors, offers a unique window into the afterlives of the Jacobite cause and the personal toll that being “royal” in exile could exact.
As we remember Count Roehenstart on this day, October 28, we also reflect on the final echoes of the Stuart legacy. Though his claim to the throne was only ever a distant hope, his life captures the quiet persistence of a family whose story has left an indelible mark on Scottish history.
Thank you for joining us for This Day in Scottish History. I’m Colin MacDonald. Tune in tomorrow for more captivating tales from Scotland’s past. Haste ye back!
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com