Welcome back to This Day in Scottish History. I’m your host, Colin MacDonald. Today, we’re traveling back to the turbulent 14th century—a time when Scotland was engulfed in political strife and power struggles. The date is September 24, 1332, and on this day, Edward Balliol, with the support of the English crown, was crowned King of Scots at Scone. This moment created a Scotland with two kings: Edward Balliol and the young David II, son of the legendary Robert the Bruce.
Today’s episode will explore Edward Balliol’s contested claim to the Scottish throne, his dramatic rise and fall, and how his coronation led to years of conflict during the Second War of Scottish Independence.
Edward Balliol’s Early Life
Edward Balliol was born around 1283, the eldest son of John Balliol, a former King of Scotland who ruled briefly from 1292 to 1296, and Isabella de Warenne. His early life was shaped by the political turmoil that followed his father’s reign. After John Balliol was forced to abdicate the Scottish throne in 1296, Edward spent part of his youth imprisoned in the Tower of London. Upon his release, he was placed under the care of his maternal grandfather, John de Warenne, 6th Earl of Surrey.
Though Edward’s early years were clouded by his father’s failed kingship, he was not without ambition. His link to the Scottish throne remained, and soon enough, powerful forces would call upon him to revive the Balliol claim.
The Road to the Scottish Throne
After the death of Robert the Bruce in 1329, Scotland found itself with a child king, six-year-old David II. Robert’s loyal regent, Thomas Randolph, Earl of Moray, acted as a stabilizing force for the young king. However, Randolph’s death in 1332 opened the door for political opportunism, and this is where Edward Balliol comes into the picture.
Balliol was approached by a group of men known as the disinherited—nobles whose lands had been taken by Robert the Bruce after the Scottish victory at Bannockburn. These men sought to reclaim their lost titles and property, and they saw Edward Balliol as their ticket back into power. Key figures in this group included Henry de Beaumont and David III Strathbogie.
With covert backing from Edward III of England, who had his own ambitions to control Scotland, Balliol and the disinherited launched an invasion. The timing was ideal, with Scotland in political disarray and no clear leadership following Randolph’s death.
Victory and Coronation at Scone
In August 1332, Balliol’s forces, bolstered by English adventurers, met the Scots at the Battle of Dupplin Moor. The Scots, led by the Earl of Mar, were decisively defeated. This victory paved the way for Edward Balliol to march on Scone, the traditional crowning place of Scottish kings. On September 24, 1332, Edward Balliol was crowned King of Scots, claiming his place as ruler, though his grip on the crown would soon be tested.
Scotland with Two Kings
Edward’s reign was fraught with instability from the start. Three months after his coronation, a loyalist force of Bruce supporters attacked his position at the Battle of Annan, forcing Balliol to flee back to England in the dead of night. This marked the beginning of what would be a repeated cycle for Edward Balliol—gaining control of parts of Scotland only to be quickly ousted by forces loyal to David II or other Bruce loyalists.
In 1333, Edward III of England openly declared his support for Balliol, and together they marched into Scotland, capturing Berwick and defeating the Scots at the Battle of Halidon Hill. Following this, Balliol ceded significant territory to Edward III, including the strategically important district of Lothian, in exchange for continued support. But even with English backing, Balliol’s reign remained precarious.
The Fall of Balliol
The Bruce loyalists were determined not to let Edward Balliol secure a lasting hold on the Scottish throne. In 1334, after struggling to consolidate his power, Balliol was once again driven from Scotland. His remaining forces were soundly defeated at the Battle of Culblean in 1335, effectively ending his serious bid for the crown.
Despite multiple invasions and military campaigns, Balliol’s fortunes never improved. In 1346, with David II captured after the Battle of Neville’s Cross, Balliol saw an opportunity to return. Yet, even then, his power was limited to a small region of Galloway, and by 1355, his influence had waned to the point of irrelevance.
The End of the Balliol Claim
In January 1356, after years of fighting a losing battle, Edward Balliol formally surrendered his claim to the Scottish throne. In exchange, he received a pension from Edward III and retired to England, where he lived out the rest of his days in obscurity, dying in 1364 near Doncaster. Despite his early aspirations and brief moments of power, Edward Balliol died childless, his dream of ruling Scotland unfulfilled.
Legacy and Reflection
The crowning of Edward Balliol on September 24, 1332, remains a pivotal moment in Scottish history. It symbolized not only the deep divisions within Scotland but also the ongoing threat of English intervention in Scottish affairs. Though his reign was short-lived and largely unsuccessful, Balliol’s bid for the throne added another chapter to the long and tumultuous history of Scottish independence.
Thank you for joining us today on This Day in Scottish History. I’m Colin MacDonald. Tune in tomorrow as we explore another fascinating moment from Scotland’s past. Until then, Haste Ye Back!
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com