Toast Sports Baseball

This week on Toast Sports Baseball:
We break down the biggest All-Star snubs and why fan voting still stirs controversy. Then it’s a deep dive into the rise of young pitchers, the Marlins' shock resurgence, and the Mets' ongoing collapse.

We also talk Ohtani’s return and what it means for the Dodgers, plus how teams like the Red Sox and Cubs should approach the trade deadline.

Fantasy updates, injury news, and key midweek matchups round out the episode — including standout performances from Peralta, Fried, and more.

Hit play and stay ahead of everything happening across Major League Baseball.

Timestamps:

00:00 – Intro + All-Star Voting Controversy

06:11 – Who Got Snubbed? Breaking Down the Biggest Omissions

12:09 – Debating Fan Selections vs. Deserving Players

17:20 – The Case for James Wood: Should He Be an All-Star?

23:16 – Old School Baseball: Should Teams Go Back to Basics?

28:36 – Skenes vs. The Miz: A Showdown of Future Aces

33:47 – Are the Marlins for Real? Breaking Down Their Hot Streak

46:19 – Dodgers’ Pitching Woes + The Ohtani Factor

51:49 – Trade Deadline Preview: Bregman, Red Sox, and More

1:04:08 – Evaluating Pitching Talent: Peralta, Fried, and the Aces

1:12:35 – Fantasy Baseball: Buy-Low Targets and Breakouts

1:22:59 – Contenders or Pretenders? Phillies, Jays & More

1:28:00 – Fantasy League Update: Trash Talk + Trade Strategies

1:33:00 – Blockbuster Trades We’d Like to See

1:38:15 – Injury Rundown: Who’s In, Who’s Out

1:44:14 – Hot & Cold: Players Heating Up (or Cooling Off)

1:50:02 – Must-Watch Series This Week + Bold Predictions

Stay Toasty!!

In this week’s episode of Toast Sports Baseball, The crew dives into all the biggest storylines across MLB.

The show opens with a look at Cal Raleigh’s monster season, where he's slugging his way into the AL MVP conversation and chasing home run history. The crew then pivots to Rafael Devers drama, following Big Papi's latest comments and the ongoing tension between the Red Sox star and the media.

We break down the controversy over MLB baseballs, questioning whether the league is once again tinkering with specs and how it's impacting players.

With the MLB Trade Deadline fast approaching, we dig into all the buzz — including big-name rumors like Chris Sale, Sandy Alcantara, Luis Robert, and Manny Machado — plus speculation around whether the Cubs go all-in or pivot.

Later in the episode, we tackle midweek matchups, injury updates, and fantasy baseball insights — including our first trade of the season, hot vs. not players, and bold series predictions heading into the weekend.

If you're a die-hard or casual baseball fan, this is your midweek go-to for everything around the league.

Timestamps:

00:00 Intro
00:21 Is Cal Raleigh the AL MVP?
08:00 Rafael Devers Drama Continues
15:30 Is MLB Messing with the Baseball Again?
22:20 Trade Deadline Buzz: Rumors & Predictions
27:20 Chris Sale: Hottest SP on the Market?
41:25 Cubs’ Kyle Tucker Dilemma
44:40 Top Hitters on the Block (Robert, Suárez, O’Hearn & more)
48:35 Midweek Matchups to Watch
53:10 Buttered, Plain, Burnt: HOF-Bound Pitchers
1:03:00 Current MLB Standings Check-In
1:06:00 Weekend Series Recap & Predictions
1:09:00 Fantasy League Recap
1:13:00 Our First Fantasy Trade!
1:18:30 MLB Injury Roundup
1:20:30 Who’s Hot & Who’s Not
1:24:14 Weekend Series to Watch

Like, Share, & Follow @ToastSportsBaseball on Socials for daily MLB content!

Stay Toasty!

Rafael Devers TRADED?! Ohtani's Value, Braves Concerns, Cubs Rising + “Buttered, Plain, or Burnt” | Toast Sports Ep. 13

In Episode 13 of Toast Sports Baseball, AJ and Joe react to the shocking Rafael Devers trade from the Red Sox to the Giants — breaking down the underwhelming return, fan backlash, and what it signals about Boston’s potential rebuild.

They explore how Devers strengthens the Giants' lineup, while questioning the Red Sox management and long-term vision. The conversation expands across the league with key storylines including:

– Braves bullpen struggles and why it could derail their postseason hopes
– Dave Martinez’s viral comments amid the Nationals’ losing streak
– Zack Wheeler announces plans to retire after 2027
– Rays surging into contender territory
– Yankees potentially facing tough times ahead?

Also featured:– The return of fan-favorite segment “Buttered, Plain, or Burnt” featuring Kevin Brown vs. Nathan Eovaldi
– A breakdown of Shohei Ohtani’s unparalleled value as a two-way player
– Fantasy baseball strategy tips and roster management advice as the season heats up
– Why the Cubs are quietly turning into a real NL threat
– How injuries, trades, and pitching strategy are shaping team success across the league

Whether you're managing your fantasy team or trying to make sense of the standings, this episode has something for every baseball fan.

TimeStamps

00:00 – The Shock of Devers' Departure
06:01 – Red Sox's Future Outlook
11:48 – The Impact on the Giants
17:56 – Dave Martinez's Controversial Comments
33:04 – Zack Wheeler, Retirement, and Family Focus
40:32 – Red Sox Trade Speculations and Long-Term Plans
45:44 – Shohei Ohtani's Return: Risk vs. Reward
51:01 – Pitching Strategy: Bullpen vs. Starting Roles
1:02:53 – MLB Standings Breakdown & Playoff Predictions
1:09:53 – NL Division Races & Surprising Contenders
1:17:51 – Fantasy Baseball: Updates, Injuries & Roster Moves
1:26:39 – Hot & Cold Players of the Week

#MLB #FantasyBaseball #RafaelDevers #ShoheiOhtani #RedSox #Giants #Cubs #Yankees #ButteredPlainBurnt #BaseballPodcast

In this episode of Toast Sports Baseball, AJ and Joe break down a jam-packed week in Major League Baseball:

• Roman Anthony makes his debut in Boston — what does his arrival signal for the Red Sox’s young core?

• Cubs vs. Phillies turns heated in extras after a surprise bunt leaves fans and players scratching their heads.

• Tito Francona returns to Cleveland for an emotional homecoming — and we reflect on his lasting legacy.

• Pete Alonso continues mashing and inches closer to becoming the Mets' all-time home run king.

• We react to the Jomboy Media–MLB partnership — what does it mean for independent baseball media? Are they still a "Fan-First" media company?

• Paul Skenes continues to shove — is he the next face of pitching in MLB?

• Plus: “Buttered, Plain or Burnt” returns, we update our fantasy league, break down current standings, and preview key weekend matchups.

Timestamps:
00:00 – Roman Anthony’s Debut & Red Sox Young Core
05:49 – Cubs vs. Phillies: Extra-Inning Bunt Controversy
11:38 – Terry Francona’s Return to Cleveland
17:33 – Pete Alonso’s HR Tear & Mets History
24:20 – Jomboy Media’s MLB Deal: Sellout or Strategic?
32:40 – Statcast Overperformers & Regression Watch
39:45 – Paul Skenes: MLB’s Next Ace?
46:03 – Buttered, Plain or Burnt: Player Comparisons
54:47 – MLB Standings Check-In
01:01:23 – Division Races & Postseason Predictions
01:10:00 – Fantasy League Chaos
01:16:09 – Weekend Series Preview & Matchups

Follow for more podcasts, clips, and baseball content!

In this episode, AJ and Joe break down the Colorado Rockies' disastrous season, as they spiral toward a potential all-time worst record. They recap the Dodgers’ historic blowout over the Yankees, celebrate Andrew McCutchen tying Roberto Clemente on the Pirates’ all-time home run list, and spotlight Cal Raleigh’s record-setting month at the plate.

The duo delivers key injury updates, including concerns around Corbin Burnes’ elbow and Kyle Tucker’s recent scare, before diving into the Brewers’ red-hot seven-game win streak. They also highlight exciting young talent with Jac Caglianone’s MLB debut and Roman Anthony’s rise through the minors.

A heated discussion unfolds around MLB umpire accountability, followed by a deep dive into elite pitching performances — comparing the peak seasons of Jacob deGrom, Curt Schilling, and rising ace Tarik Skubal.

Later in the episode, the guys analyze the Arizona Diamondbacks’ current state, financial outlook, and promising young core. They wrap up with a full breakdown of the MLB standings, division races, series predictions, and some key fantasy baseball takeaways.

⏱ Episode 11 Timestamps:
00:00 – Rocky Road Ahead for the Rockies
03:28 – Dodgers Dominate: A Tale of Two Teams
06:10 – McCutchen Makes History: A Baseball Icon
08:54 – Cal Raleigh's Explosive Month: A Rising Star
11:57 – Injury Updates: Key Players in Jeopardy
21:19 – Brewers' Winning Streak: A Competitive Central
27:48 – Blue Jays Heat Up: A Team on the Rise
30:20 – FBI Investigation: A Dark Cloud Over Baseball
32:41 – Umpires Under Fire: The Need for Change
36:26 – The Accountability of Umpires
43:10 – Pitching Legends: deGrom vs Schilling
56:27 – The State of the Diamondbacks: Future Prospects
01:06:29 – Emerging MLB Prospects and Team Futures
01:09:54 – Current Standings and Team Performance Analysis
01:13:42 – NL Division Dynamics and Team Strategies
01:17:40 – Predictions and Series Outcomes
01:25:29 – Fantasy League Insights and Player Performances

In this episode of Toast Sports Baseball, AJ and Joe break down a wild week across the MLB.

They dive into Tarik Skubal’s dominant, historic performance, examine Jacob deGrom’s recent struggles, and analyze the ever-tight AL East race. The guys also spotlight the red-hot Phillies, dig into fresh trade rumors swirling around big-name players, and drop valuable insights for fantasy baseball managers.

To close it out, they preview key upcoming series and highlight who's on fire—and who's falling flat—around the league.

🎧 Subscribe, leave a rating, and stay toasty!

TimeStamps

00:00 - Tarik Skubal’s Historic Masterclass

08:07 - Jacob deGrom’s Surprising Struggles

12:12 - The Rays Are Back in the Mix

15:04 - Phillies: The Best Team Nobody’s Talking About

20:54 - Rising Stars: Jack Caglione & the Royals

25:08 - Shohei Ohtani: Unstoppable Yet Again

27:12 - Trade Rumor: Volpe for Albies?!

32:07 - Oakland A’s: New Faces, Same Problems

33:55 - What’s Wrong with the Red Sox?

39:45 - Front Office Accountability & Long-Term Outlook

46:35 - Texas Rangers: What’s the Next Move?

1:00:40 - League Standings Rundown

1:01:43 - Contender or Pretender? Team-by-Team Breakdown

1:04:56 - Star Players & Teams Under the Microscope

1:11:50 - Fantasy Baseball Tips & Value Plays

1:20:50 - Who’s Hot, Who’s Not Around MLB

1:25:26 - Series to Watch & Bold Predictions

In this episode of Toast Sports Baseball, hosts AJ and Joe dive into the growing concerns around Juan Soto’s effort and attitude in Queens, following a lifeless Subway Series performance and internal rumblings from Mets brass.

They break down the wild trade rumors surrounding Pirates ace Paul Skenes and question whether Pittsburgh could actually blow it all up. Plus, the Orioles shock everyone by firing manager Brandon Hyde just a month and a half into the season.

The conversation continues with:

• Cody Bellinger’s grand slam heroics vs. the Mets

• José Alvarado’s 80-game PED suspension and what it means for the Phillies’ bullpen

• Spencer Strider’s return and what to expect in his first start back

• Cal Quantrill’s immaculate inning

• Christian Campbell’s potential switch to first base and what it says about Rafael Devers

• The Twins’ 13-game win streak finally snapped

• Brandon Nimmo’s belt buckle causing chaos on Mets Twitter

• A quick GM spotlight on the Minnesota Twins

• Plus: MLB standings, hot/cold players, and series to watch this weekend

New episodes every Wednesday. Stay toasty.

Timestamp

00:00 – Brandon Hyde’s Firing and Its Implications
04:56 – Cody Bellinger’s Resurgence with the Yankees
10:06 – Paul Skenes Trade Rumors and the Pirates’ Dilemma
14:46 – Dodgers Swept by Angels: A Cause for Concern?
19:17 – José Alvarado’s Suspension and Phillies’ Bullpen Woes
24:10 – Braves’ Spencer Strider Returns and NL East Impact
29:11 – Juan Soto’s Struggles and the Mets’ Future
34:15 – GM Spotlight: The Minnesota Twins' Success
35:55 – Twins Payroll Breakdown and Team Dynamics
39:15 – Are the Twins Legit Playoff Contenders?
43:16 – Current MLB Standings and Division Insights
48:44 – NL East Breakdown: Mets, Braves, and Phillies
51:05 – NL Central and NL West: Team Performances
52:38 – Predictions and Fantasy League Updates
58:43 – Prospect Watch and Notable Player Performances
01:00:38 – Who's Hot and Who's Not in MLB
01:06:26 – Series to Watch: Key Upcoming Matchups

In this episode of the Toast Sports Baseball Podcast, hosts AJ and Joe break down the biggest storylines across MLB. The Cardinals and Twins are red-hot and right back in the division mix, while the Braves are living dangerously with an unprecedented stretch of one-run games. We dive into the latest managerial shakeups in Colorado and Pittsburgh, the controversial reinstatement of Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson, and the growing tension around Rafael Devers and the Red Sox clubhouse.

We also discuss the Orlando Dreamers’ $2.5 billion push for MLB expansion, top prospects like Jordan Lawlar and Moises Ballesteros making their debuts, and what it all means for the future of the league. Plus, we hit on current standings, fantasy league drama, and weekend series predictions.

Follow us on social media and be sure to rate and follow the show on Spotify and Apple Podcasts — it really helps us grow the pod!

00:00 – Red Hot Cardinals and Twins
03:18 – Braves' Unprecedented One Run Streak
06:21 – Injury Updates and Team Dynamics
09:11 – Managerial Changes in MLB
12:13 – Rockies and Pirates' Struggles
15:09 – Fan Interactions and Player Reactions
18:25 – Orlando Dreamers and MLB Expansion
21:13 – Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson Reinstated
24:12 – Rafael Devers Drama in Boston
33:25 – Red Sox Turmoil: A Cloud Over the Organization
36:17 – Prospect Watch: Rising Stars in MLB
39:28 – The Business of Baseball: Service Time Manipulation
41:33 – Current Standings: Surprises and Disappointments
46:31 – Fantasy Baseball Drama: League Controversies
56:17 – Who's Hot and Who's Not: Player Performances
01:02:05 – Weekend Series Predictions: Key Matchups

In Episode 7 of Toast Sports Baseball, AJ and Joe break down the juiciest MLB headlines of the week:
Roki Sasaki’s contract details leak, revealing his demand for eight luxury Japanese smart toilets — and he’s already pitching like a Cy Young contender for the Dodgers.
Riley Greene’s monster week, including a ultra rare two-homer ninth inning, has him breaking out as one of the AL’s most dangerous hitters.
Nolan Arenado’s name is everywhere in trade rumors — could the Yankees or Dodgers land him and shake up the postseason race?
Mike Trout heads back to the IL — are we watching the final stretch of his superstar run?
Cade Horton is rising fast in the Cubs system, and his electric stuff could give Chicago a huge boost as Shōta Imanaga recovers.

Follow @toastsportsbaseball for fearless MLB takes, fresh stats, and can’t-miss baseball talk all season long.

Time Stamps

00:00 Injury Impacts and Lineup Changes
05:14 Contractual Quirks in Baseball
10:06 Trade Rumors and Player Movements
15:11 Emerging Talents and Team Dynamics
20:06 Free Agent Signings and Their Impact
25:05 Current Standings and Team Performances
30:04 Rangers' Struggles and Future Outlook
31:04 Optimism Amidst Challenges
32:02 National League Dynamics
33:13 Central Division Showdown
35:21 AL West: A Competitive Landscape
37:00 Series Predictions Recap
39:32 Fantasy Baseball Insights
41:18 Who's Hot and Who's Not
48:22 Buy Low, Sell High Strategies
52:58 Weekend Series Predictions

Shohei Ohtani’s pitching future sparked debate this week after a respected coach suggested he should give up the mound for good. The Rockies are putting together one of the worst starts in MLB history, and Jarren Duran nearly came to blows with a fan after an awful comment from the stands. AJ and Joe break down a wild week around the league — from historic individual performances to serious clubhouse questions.

⏱️ Timestamps
00:00 – Rockies’ historically awful start (4–24)
03:10 – Padres get swept at home, Rays dominate
06:05 – Eugenio Suarez hits 4 homers in a loss
09:10 – Brandon Nimmo’s breakout performance
12:22 – Devin Williams removed from closer role
15:17 – Altuve speaks up, Astros underperform
18:10 – Jarren Duran held back from fighting fan
21:10 – Dodgers rotation injuries mounting
24:11 – Ohtani’s pitching future in serious doubt
26:59 – Current standings + biggest surprises
38:49 – Division predictions & early playoff outlook
42:50 – Orioles in trouble despite new ownership
50:34 – Fantasy baseball risers, fallers, pickups
56:15 – Who’s hot and who’s not this week
01:03:32 – Fantasy matchup recap & series to watchTap follow, drop a 5⭐ rating if you’re riding with us, and catch all the chaos weekly each Wednesday!!