Trial Lawyer Confidential

Trial Lawyer Confidential

By Elena Saris | Criminal Defense Lawyer, Speaker and TrainerSociety & CultureBusinessEducationHistoryCareers
Download on the App Store

Trial Lawyer Confidential episodes

  • TLC_029: DESIGNER DRUGS and MEDIA PANIC
    In This Episode:I pull back the curtain on Designer Drugs and Media Panic. In the wake of the tragic death of actor, Philip Seymour Hoffman, the media latched on to speculation that designer drugs were likely to blame for the … Continue reading →
    41 min
  • TLC_028: MANSLAUGHTER

    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on the laws relating to the LAW OF MANSLAUGHTER.

    There are 3 types of manslaughter: Voluntary, Involuntary and Vehicular.  Within these categories we find issues of reckless disregard for human life and acts committed during misdemeanors and non-dangerous felonies. The main distinction between a charge of murder and a charge of manslaughter is the lack of the element of malice in the killing. The distinctions within the manslaughter laws themselves have to do with the intentionality of the killing itself.

    Manu cases have been in the news in the past several years involving the charges of manslaughter. Some of the more famous include the case of Dr. Conrad Murray convicted of involuntary manslaughter in the death of Michael Jackson, Josh Brent, the former Dallas Cowboy convicted of vehicular manslaughter in the death of his friend and teammate Jerry Brown and the case of George Zimmerman where some felt that if charges were going to be filed at all that murder was inappropriate and manslaughter was the appropriate charge.

    The punishment for manslaughter is ofter drastically lower than the punishment for murder, especially involuntary manslaughter. The law recognizes that the circumstances surrounding the act of killing determine a person’s culpability. The role of the defense lawyer is to investigate those circumstances and present them to the trier of fact in such a way as to argue for the appropriate charge and punishment for the unlawful killing.

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Some ideas about making your presentation more relatable and thereby more persuasive. We talk about how you can incorporate “universal” examples, metaphors and analogies into your talk to hook the audience and get them to relate to your speech. Also, a brief tip on finding “universals” within small niches.

     LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial. And be sure to check back soon for a special offer exclusively for attorneys!

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

     

     
    0 min
  • TLC_027: MURDER

    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on the laws relating to the LAW OF MURDER.

    First degree murder is the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought carried out in a willful, premeditated and deliberate manner. 2nd Degree murder lacks the willfulness, premeditation and deliberation but malice is implied by the conduct, the circumstances or the conscious disregard to human life.

    Murder trials are often viewed by trial lawyers as the pinnacles of their career. If television shows and infotainment “news” programs are any indication, the general public is fascinated by these unique, often complicated and dramatic trials as well. In states where the death penalty is used, there are very specific circumstances (often called special circumstances) under which a murder is committed that allow the state to seek to impose the ultimate punishment. Some of these have to do with the actor himself, such as a repeat offender, others have to do with motive, as in murder for financial gain, murder that is racially motivated. Some have to do with the actions themselves being above and beyond what is necessary to kill a person, such as torture. And still others have to do with the identity of the victim, such as the killing of a police officer, an elected official, a witness, a juror or a judge.  Some states still have a catch-all circumstance that the murder was particularly heinous or horrendous.

    There are also specified felonies that if a killing during the course of their commission, the murder is deemed first degree even if a killing was not the original intent of the perpetrators. In California, these include: murder by weapon of mass destruction, by an explosive device, murder with a weapon whose ammunition is designed to pierce metal or armor, poisoning, lying in wait (ambush) and torture. Other states will list different felonies but all will be crimes that in their commission evidence that violence and harm could result form their commission.

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Quick Tip for keeping in check your perspective when dealing with situations that may be considered minor or less important than other situations and how refusing to “call it in” will make your presentation or relationship more compelling.

     LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial. And be sure to check back soon for a special offer exclusively for attorneys!

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

     

     
    0 min
  • TLC_026: OBJECTIONS and SIDEBARS

    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on the laws relating to OBJECTIONS and SIDEBAR CONFERENCES.  The law allows both sides in a criminal or civil case to object to certain questions or answers that are being asked or elicited in open court. There are Rules of Evidence that govern what the jurors can and cannot hear.  When one side feel the other is violating those rules, an objection is posed. If the objection is “overruled” that means that the Court is disagreeing with the side making the objection and the judge will allow the question or the answer to stand. If the objection is “sustained” that means that the Court is agreeing with the party making the objection and the question will not be allowed or the answer (if already given) will be struck from the record. 

    Sidebar conferences occur at the discretion of the court. The judge can order the parties to “approach the bench” to discuss a matter to be heard outside the presence of the jurors and the lawyers can also request a “sidebar” to argue a point of law. Many times the sidebars are for the purpose of arguing legal issues that the jurors cannot be privy to, but just as often they are for the more mundane purposes of scheduling or requesting bathroom breaks.

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Quick Tip for giving your audience an “insider’s” secret that will help make your presentations more compelling and your message more memorable.

     LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial. And be sure to check back soon for a special offer exclusively for attorneys!

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

    0 min
  • TLC_025: DOMESTIC VIOLENCE LAWS

    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on the laws relating to Domestic Violence. We explore how and why it is treated differently than other types of assault. We also discuss why these cases are difficult for all participants in the legal system. Frequently prosecutors are unwilling to negotiate a plea bargain for fear that if the perpetrator reoffends, they will be held accountable. Prosecutors are faced with recanting witnesses who through fear, love or financial need will often come to court and ask that the charges be dropped, despite serious injuries in some cases. When the allegations are falsely made, which does happen more often than many care to admit, the lives of the accused can be ruined by the fact of the allegation itself.

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Quick Tip for finding the context, focus and perspective when you are crafting your next persuasive presentation.

     LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial. And be sure to check back soon for a special offer exclusively for attorneys!

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

    0 min
  • TLC_024: DURESS/NECESSITY

    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on the concepts of Duress and Necessity. In Duress, the law recognizes that there are times are free will may be so compromised by threat of bodily harm or death that we should not be held criminally liable for crimes we commit while under the influence of these threats. Further and even a more radical notion, Necessity shows that there are times when the system allows our individual judgement to supersede the law when the harm we create is less than the harm we are trying to prevent under exceptional circumstances. Obviously very specific circumstances must be met to benefit from these concepts, but its important to note the fact that our criminal justice system does take context and circumstances surrounding our crimes into account when deciding not only punishment, but guilt itself.

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Quick Tip for establishing context in your presentation to make it more real and persuasive to your audience.

     LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial. And be sure to check back soon for a special offer exclusively for attorneys!

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

     

    0 min
  • TLC_023: PROSECUTORIAL MISCONDUCT

    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on Prosecutorial Misconduct.  Recently a Texas Judge was disbarred, sentenced to 10 days in jail and 500 hours of community service for criminal contempt.  He was accused of lying to a judge in 1987 while he was a prosecutor trying the murder case of Michael Morton.  Mr. Morton spent 25 years in prison for a crime he did not commit. After DNA tests exonerated him of the crime, his lawyers obtained the original files which showed that the detective and the prosecutor had in their possession witness statements which tended to show Mr. Morton’s innocence and they failed to turn those over to the defense. Beyond that breach of ethical duty, the prosecutor was accused of lying to the Judge about the existence of these statements just before the original trial.  This is just one recent example of the system being corrupted by a corrupt prosecutor. What sets this case apart is not the egregiousness of the conduct (unfortunately such conduct is not rare) but that the prosecutor was actually punished for this conduct.

    We will explore the Brady Rule and the new proposals that are being set forth to try to prevent these gross and deliberate miscarriages of justice. For a look at some other examples of prosecutorial misconduct see the following: 

    The Untouchables: America’s Misbehaving Prosecutors and the System that Protects Them

    LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial.

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

     

     
    0 min
  • TLC_022: WHO’S WHO IN COURT
    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on Who’s Who in a criminal courtroom. What are the various roles and responsibilities of all the players. Most of us know the basic functions but you might be surprised to learn lesser known duties of the various court personnel. From bailiffs, court reporters, judicial assistants, interpreters, lawyers judges and commissioners all the courtroom personnel play a myriad of roles in the system. Find out what the difference is between a commissioner and a judge and what it takes to run for or be appointed to these judicial positions

    LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial.

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

     

     
    0 min
  • TLC_O21: ENTRAPMENT
    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on Entrapment. How far can a government agent go to induce an ordinary citizen to commit a crime.  Some states focus on the predisposition of the defendant, while other focus solely on the actions of the government.  The issue of whether it was outrageous police misconduct or merely legal deception by law enforcement is one for the jury to decide based on the facts and circumstances of each individual case.

    Courts have stated that “a line must be drawn between a trap for the unwary innocent and a trap for the unwary criminal.”  Here is a fascinating expose on one federal agency’s program that purports to target violent drug dealers and robbers.  View the video below of USA Today’s coverage of the ATF sting operations and read more about it here:

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Quick Tip for using props in your next persuasive presentation.

    LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial.

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

     

     
    0 min
  • TLC_020: EYEWITNESS IDENTIFICATION
    In This Episode:

    I pull back the curtain on Eyewitness Identification. Often the most powerful evidence presented in a criminal trial, mistaken identification is the overwhelming cause of the majority of wrongful convictions in this country. Jurors put a great deal of weight on this type of evidence yet in many jurisdictions there are very few protocols in place to ensure that this evidence is “collected,” “preserved” and “untainted” like there are for physical evidence.

    Click here to read an article by Elizabeth Loftus and Gary Wells: “Eyewitness Memory for People and Events” which makes a compelling argument for the metaphor of treating human evidence like trace evidence in terms of developing guidelines to safeguard its accuracy.

    Click here to read about the wrongful convictions overturned by the Innocence Project that were based on mistaken identification.

    As referenced in the episode Jennifer Thompson was a rape victim who mistakenly identified Ronald Cotton as her attacker. DNA evidence cleared him and they forged a friendship that transcends their case as they work together for eyewitness identification reform.  Their compelling story is told in the book Picking Cotton (mistakenly referred to in the podcast as a movie) See the book trailer below:

     

    TRIAL LAWYER MENTOR Quick Tip:

    Quick Tip for helping you ORGANIZE your next persuasive presentation.

    LAWYERS and LAW STUDENTS:

    Click here to sign up for our free newsletter where I share in depth tips and strategies for mastering the Art of the Jury Trial.

    Download AUDIO here (MP3)

    0 min

About Trial Lawyer Confidential

From the publisher's feed

Pulling Back the Curtain...