Trustworthy

Send us Fan Mail

Inspired by the powerful stories heard at a Celebrate Recovery open house, Sarah and Mary Beth dive into the essential Christian practices of vulnerability, confession, and community. They grapple with the uncomfortable truth of what holds us back (fear, pride, shame) and share deeply personal "quiet parts" out loud, revealing struggles with self-righteousness, comparison, and deflection.

Drawing on a powerful Tim Keller quote—"To be fully known and truly loved is, well, a lot like being loved by God"—Sarah and Mary Beth discuss how real connection and healing only happen when we break down the walls we build. They challenge listeners to embrace humility, confess their sins to one another as commanded in James 5:16, and seek out confessional community for the freedom and joy found on the other side.

Key Takeaways & Resources:

• The Power of Being Known: The core human desire to be fully known and truly loved is a reflection of God's love for us.
• The First Step is Humility: Confession and vulnerability require agreeing with God about who you are: a beloved, but imperfect, sinner in need of a Savior.
• Freedom is on the Other Side: As Proverb 28:13 states, "whoever confesses and renounces [their sins] finds mercy."

Mentioned in this Episode: 

Brandon Lake's "Hard Fought Hallelujah" 

Celebrate Recovery

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of Trustworthy, Sarah and Mary Beth pour a cup and settle in for a cozy conversation about one of the most beloved “third places” in modern life: coffee shops.

From open mic nights in the 90s to driveway coffee gatherings during the pandemic, they trace how these spaces have shaped their sense of community, creativity, and connection. Along the way, they share listener reflections on what “community” really means—and how something as simple as sharing a cup of coffee can create moments of belonging, healing, and grace.

They also spotlight a few unforgettable stops from Sarah’s travels—from Blueprint Coffee Project in Sacramento to Blackbird Espresso in South Dakota—and talk about how many local coffee shops, including those started by churches and ministries, are helping people find real connection in a fast-paced world.

Whether you’re sipping a latte or chai, this episode invites you to slow down and reflect on where you’ve found community—and how you might help create it.

Resources:

Dosie Dough has been a part of the Lititz, PA community for almost 30 years! They had an outpost in Lancaster for some time, which is the one Sarah was referring to! https://dosiedough.com/about/

https://www.alabastercoffee.com Williamsport, PA

https://www.spearfishblackbird.com Spearfish, SD

​Elmisa Cafe | Rancho Bernardo Breakfast & Lunch Cafe

​blueprint coffee project

​chaddsford.coffeehouse (@chaddsford.coffeehouse)

​Local Bakery | OsoSweet | United States

Other coffee shops we have loved…

Lancaster, PA

​Square One Coffee Roasters

​Meancup Coffee -- Lancaster PA

​Cultivate Better | Copper Cup

Kennett Square

​Kennett Square Pennsylvania Coffee Shop

​Farmer & Co

​Talula's Table

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of Trustworthy, Sarah and Mary Beth continue their conversation about culture and community by interviewing Sarah's former youth group student, Lucely Tapia, whose story embodies what happens when intentional community and discipleship take root. Mary Beth and Sarah start by talking about the culture of Friday night football, where small-town spirit and shared connection come alive and then move into a heartfelt interview with Lucely who is now in college. 

This episode shows how mentorship, vulnerability, and time have transformed Sarah & Lucely's friendship into something lasting and life-giving. Through laughter, reflection, and a few tears, this conversation highlights how God uses relationships across generations to strengthen faith, deepen trust, and remind us what it means to live in true Christian community.

Resources:

The Gentle Art of Discipling Women: Nurturing Authentic Faith in Ourselves and Others

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

Sarah and Mary Beth launch Season Three of Trustworthy with a look at how culture shapes community. We ask: What kind of culture helps community flourish, and how can we shape it as followers of Christ?  

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

Sarah and Mary Beth had the opportunity to do a live version of the podcast with a group of women at our church. This bonus episode is full of good questions from the group gathered that evening about finding community and embracing different stages of life and seasons of change.

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

Another season of trustworthy is wrapped! What did we learn this season and what are some things you may not know about us? It’s Q&A time on our Season 2 finale! 

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

What does following where God leads look like? We talked with Jessica Zubrod about how being open to the small ways God leads us shape how we live and parent and work. Listen in to how we can find glory in the ordinary.

Mentioned in this episode:

Gerard Manley Hopkins poem

IF Gathering

International Justice Mission

Africa New Life

Andrew Peterson music

MomCo at Willowdale Chapel (formerly MOPS)

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

We all want to be great, right? What does greatness even mean? What if a life that looks repetitive and unimpressive to the world is great for God's glory? 

Vocabulary Resources:

This week, I, Mary Beth was struggling with some words and phrases! I couldn't let the episode pass without acknowledging the correct words and meanings. 

Quelch: It is in fact a word that means squelch! (To fall or stamp on so as to crush)

Trudgery: Not a word, But trudge is, which means "to walk or march steadily and usually laboriously." Drudgery is the word I probably meant, which means "fatiguing work." 

Could care less: I fell victim to this common error! The correct phrase is "couldn't care less." 

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

How can we engage the next generation of the church right now? We turned to an expert for an interview! She's in the thick of youth ministry and has wisdom to share on how to empower and engage the next generation of the church. Meet Sara Boninu. 

Resources:

Sara's sermon on keychain leadership

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]

Send us Fan Mail

Plants are growing, birds are singing, spring is here! What lessons can we learn about life, death and resurrection from the natural world around us?

Resources

Resurrection Letters - Andrew Peterson

Sing: Spring Songs - Ellie Holcomb

Doug Tallamy and Homegrown National Park

@thisistrustworthy

trustworthypodcast.com 

 Email us [email protected]