Amid the pine trees and cedars on Bainbridge Island, Washington, near Seattle, you'll find a little church. In here the faithful practiced a Christianity that embraced what could be called the supernatural. They called it super spiritual. It was an emotional and visceral faith, and a faith that believed in hearing messages, prophecies directly from God. Some of this story is about God, and some of it isn't.-JOSH MANKIEWICZ reporting

Kimberly and Katie are making their not so triumphant return with a super-duper-uber-extra-extra-readallaboutit- most special of special episodes. This is a true Kimberly's favorite and the question is… will it be Katie's as well? Or will they get into a nasty land battle over a lamb and is the friendship pushed to the brink of collapse? Thank you for joining us and please enjoy the latest Date with Dateline.

Official Description from NBC:

A pastor's dark secret casts a long shadow across his entire congregation.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices