Kyle tells the story of the one time he tried alcohol. Nick finds a new addiction in To Catch a Predator. Austin survives a horrifying home invasion. The guys sort of answer a listener question. Nick dreams of being a seaman. Austin tries to shed light on Bigfoot. Closing song: Rugrats Theme Song (Trap Remix), by K. Solis.

Kyle researches new ways to overdose. Nick goes to war with his landlord. Austin regales the groups with his adventurous tales of New York. The guys say goodbye to the creator of SpongeBob SquarePants. Nick and Austin continue stalking a “friend.” Nick calls out Austin in a big way.

Austin and Nick stalk a stranger. The guys talk about their Thanksgivings. Nick invites Kyle to Big Dick Movie Night. Austin and Nick pit two of Walmart’s cheapest wines against each other. A previous spooky story gets an update after Austin drops the ball.

The guys get religious. Everyone says goodbye to Stan Lee, which ends up leading to a phallic conversation. Nick and Austin argue about Zelda. Kyle gets excited about Kurt Russel’s new role. Austin plans a trip to the Big Apple. Kyle goes to two concerts and invites no one. Nick tries to tell a Spooky Story, but Austin’s Big Foot obsession leads to a new challenge.

The guys come back from a break. Austin and Kyle go after Facebook politicians. Nick has an election meltdown. Austin tries to ruin the legacy of the Edmund Fitzgerald. Kyle tries to get on reality TV. The guys drink more cheap wine. Nick falls in love with Red Dead Redemption 2. Kyle finds gifts. Nick brings a Spooky Story to the table that’s just too close to home.

Austin goes to a concert. Nick tries to figure out what Tom Hardy is saying. The guys review the cheapest of wines. The Titanic sets sail again…again. With Halloween right around the corner, everyone reflects on their favorite Christmas movies. Nick calls out IFLScience.com on this week’s spooky story.

Austin’s reliability comes into question. The guys recall the origins of how they all became friends. Nick recounts a frightening concert. Kyle tries to plug a film festival. A Spooky Story takes place on a small island untouched by time.

Nick fears for the future of UFC. Kyle fears for a rock star’s sanity. An unearthed Bill Cosby Show clip makes everyone uneasy. The guys examine the most offensive Halloween costume of 2018. Christopher Walken and Natalie Wood star in this week’s Spooky Story. With special guest Adam “Rumsfield.”

Austin gives a lesson in baseball. Nick considers a retro cruise. Kyle becomes a father. Nick and Austin throw down in the name of Nicolas Cage. A Spooky Story goes full steam ahead, leaving the guys to solve a man’s disappearance.

Nick misses a movie night with Kyle. Austin dives into the judicial system as the guys say good riddance to a legendary comedian. Kyle buys an odd book written about an odd athlete. Nick tells a Spooky Story involving aliens and booze.