This week’s double bill: Project Hail Mary and Netflix’s I Swear.

We get into the big sci-fi ideas vs the more grounded, messy reality—what lands, what feels off, and what stayed with us after. From isolation and survival to trust and questionable decisions, there’s a lot to unpack.

Plus our weekly watch check-in and what else we’ve been into.

Out now – listen wherever you get your podcasts.

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode of Two Non-Critics and a Cat, we break down the biggest Oscar winners, surprises, and snubs from Hollywood’s biggest night. Did the Academy get it right? Which wins felt inevitable, and which ones shocked us?

From emotional speeches to controversial wins, we’re unpacking everything from the Oscars so you don’t have to.

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode, Marty and Julie dive into Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man and whether the long-awaited film lives up to the legacy of the series.
The first half of the episode is completely spoiler-free, where we share our initial reactions and overall thoughts on the film. Then we ring the spoiler bell 🔔 and move into a full review, breaking down the biggest moments, character arcs, and the ending.
The Shelbys are back and so are we! 



Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

This week on Two Non-Critics and a Cat, we break down our experience attending the Peaky Blinders film Q&A with Cillian Murphy and creator Steven Knight. From the atmosphere in the room to Cillian’s quietly chaotic energy, to Stephen Knight teasing what’s next for Tommy Shelby — we’re unpacking everything: the vibes, the crowd reactions, the behind-the-scenes gems, and what this movie could mean for the Peaky legacy.

In the second half, we shift into full Award Season Mode™ and kick off our Oscar 2026 predictions. Too early? Never. It’s hype. It’s speculation. It’s cinema chaos.
And it’s exactly why we love this time of year.

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

The BAFTAs have spoken… but what does it mean for the Oscars? We’re unpacking the winners, the losers, the chaos, and the “okay, that’s definitely taking the Oscar” moments. Awards season just shifted — and we have thoughts.

Our intro? All about the new Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man Trailer! We haven't been so excited in a while! Tune in and share the excitement! 

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode, we talk about the last of our predicted Best Picture Oscar Frontrunners: One Battle After Another. Directed by Paul Thomas Anderson with Leonardo Di Caprio, Sean Peann, Teyana Taylor and Benicio Del Toro.

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode, the team provides a quick recap of awards season so far.
We cover everything from the Golden Globes and CAA winners to the BAFTA and Oscar nominations, helping you navigate the chaos and unpredictability of this season.

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode, we break down the 16 nominations of the Best Picture nominee Sinners, unpacking its themes, tone, and the reasons why the Academy loved it.
Then we move to 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple, exploring what this new chapter brings to the legacy of the franchise, its atmosphere, and whether it lives up to the weight of its predecessors.



Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode, we talk about the Hamnet adaptation starring Jessie Buckley and Paul Mescal, exploring its awards potential, literary roots, and why it’s already shaping up to be a major contender.

Plus, weekly watches, Marty's obsession with Sinners and early predictions.

THIS EPISODE CONTAINS SPOILERS ON HAMNET.

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹

In this episode, we rave about the movies we can’t wait to see in 2026!
From the return of some of cinema’s greatest directors with new films by Christopher Nolan, Steven Spielberg, and Denis Villeneuve, to the comeback of unforgettable characters, with Tommy Shelby hitting our screens one last time.
Follow us for all the juicy news about this year’s cinematic magic!

Follow us on Instagram and Subscribe to our YouTube Channel! 📹