The Subway Series ended with a shocker, as the Mets pulled off the kind of ninth inning comeback their fans had been conditioned not to expect. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Tyrone Taylor’s stunning homer, the empty seats at Citi Field, and the rare feeling of the Mets actually delivering a magical late game moment.

The guys also break down why the loss should worry Yankees fans beyond just one ugly afternoon. David Bednar’s latest collapse, Austin Wells’ growing struggles, Aaron Judge’s quiet series, and a rough road trip all become part of a bigger conversation about a Yankees team that is still in good shape but suddenly has real problems to solve.