Under Further Review

We start this episode with a fun (and heated) debate: How many quarterbacks can we name that are better than Arch Manning heading into fall 2026?

There is serious talent at the QB position, and we break down whether any of these names truly belong in the same category as Manning: Dante Moore, Trinidad Chambliss, Drew Mestemaker, Brendan Sorsby, Sam Leavitt, LaNorris Sellers, Julian Sayin, CJ Carr, Jayden Maiava, and Darian Mensah.

From there, we create our contenders and sleepers list for the 2026 season. Indiana Hoosiers is fresh off the program’s first-ever National Championship — but are they still the standard? We also identify sleeper teams that could mirror last season’s surprise runs.

Next up, we rank our Top 5 edge rushers heading into the 2026 NFL Draft. We include Arvell Reese because we believe he has Micah Parsons–type upside, along with David Bailey, Ruben Bain Jr., Keldric Faulk, Akheem Mesidor, Cashius Howell, TJ Parker, R Mason Thomas, Derrick Moore, and Zion Young.

After that, we shift to high-impact players — ranking the top 5 best players in the draft, regardless of positional value.

Our final debate centers on Fernando Mendoza, who many project as the No. 1 pick to the Las Vegas Raiders. We continue the conversation sparked on The Todd McShay Show: Mendoza is “a guy… but is he the guy?” Let’s just say we didn’t all agree.

We close the episode with an epic interview featuring Miami’s own Bryce Fitzgerald. The true freshman breaks down:
• His breakout season (6 INTs)
• The clutch end-zone pick vs Texas A&M Aggies in the CFP
• Changing Miami’s culture • Playing alongside Bain and Mesidor 
• The moment he knew he belonged
• His relationship with Malachi Toney
• Miami’s unforgettable playoff run

👍 Like, subscribe, and drop your takes in the comments.

This week’s episode is loaded. Not one, but two massive interviews — plus the usual chaos, hot takes, and passionate sports talk you've come to expect. First up, we sit down with Christian Benford, starting cornerback for the Buffalo Bills and now, children’s book author! He talks about his new book, Stylish Safari: The Adventures of Being You, and the message behind it. Then we dive into his football journey — from FCS days at Villanova, to being a 6th-round draft pick, to becoming one of the most consistent corners in the league. His story is inspiring, and his mindset is pure gold. Then, we’re joined by Jared Carrabis, co-host of Baseball is Dead and Section 10. Jared brings the heat with some of the sharpest insight in baseball media today. We get personal about his rise in the podcasting world, how he keeps baseball fun and accessible, and what it’s like being a diehard Red Sox fan while speaking to a national audience. Oh — and yes, we ask him about the legendary “The Yankees Lose” Big Papi video. He doesn’t hold back. But wait — that’s just the interviews. We kick things off by diving into our sports obsession (read: sickness), and how wins and losses totally hijack our moods. Then, we take a look at the upcoming NFL Draft — with each of us picking three first-round talents to watch (some bold choices in there). And finally, we wrap with a discussion on the Denver Nuggets and the shocking news of Michael Malone’s firing. Yep… wild times. This is one you don’t want to miss.

March Madness is heating up as we gear up for an exhilarating Final Four weekend! For only the second time in history, and the first since 2008, all four teams vying for the championship are No. 1 seeds. The KenPom era, which began in 1996, has showcased the dominance of these programs as they all fall in the top 10 teams historically since it was created. We dive into a heated debate about which team stands the best chance against a formidable Duke squad that looks poised for victory.

Florida entered the tournament riding high after a tough SEC championship and looked like a team that could strike down Duke, but now the Blue Devils face a potential roadblock in Houston. Under the leadership of head coach Kelvin Sampson, Houston has transformed into a defensive powerhouse, bolstered by sharp shooters when on offense. Meanwhile, Duke, led by poised freshman Cooper Flagg, has made their journey look effortless, recently overwhelming an Alabama team that drained 25 threes in the Elite 8. This prompts us to reflect on past freshmen who have left a mark on the tournament.

In the second half of the episode, we welcome Skylar Thompson, who shares insights about his foundation, "The Sky's the Limit," created in honor of his grandfather and mother. He discusses the foundation's community initiatives and his journey through college football at Kansas State and his time with the Miami Dolphins, including a playoff appearance and a Wild Card game against the Buffalo Bills. Now with the Pittsburgh Steelers, Skylar is excited for this new chapter.

We also tackle the current quarterback situations in New York. The Giants have signed Russell Wilson, while the Jets have named Justin Fields their starter. With fresh leadership in both franchises, we explore what this means for their future.

The conversation shifts to Sauce Gardner's potential contract, which makes us talk about another Jets legend, Darrelle Revis, and what other cornerbacks in NFL history matched the performance of "Revis Island."

We wrap up with a lively debate on the new torpedo bat in MLB and its implications for player performance. Tune in for an engaging mix of basketball, football, and more!

In this exciting episode, hosts Steve and Joe dive headfirst into the thrilling world of March Madness! They discuss the powerhouse teams dominating the tournament, spotlighting the consistent excellence of Duke and Florida, while also analyzing the unexpected downturn of St. John's. The episode features two engaging segments: Joe shares his favorite first matchups that are sure to get fans buzzing, while Steve takes on the challenge of ranking the top Cinderella runs in NCAA tournament history. It’s a nostalgic look back at some of the most inspiring underdog stories in the sport! To wrap things up, the boys shift gears and take a look at the current NBA playoff picture, providing insights and predictions as the season heats up.

In this week’s episode, we kick things off with an in-depth discussion on the latest NBA news. With Kyrie Irving sidelined due to an ACL injury and Anthony Davis likely shutting it down for the season, we explore how Luka Doncic is spearheading the Lakers' push to the No. 2 seed in the Western Conference. We revisit the controversial trade from a few weeks ago, revealing just how grim things look for the Mavericks. As Mike aptly puts it, perhaps it's time for a complete overhaul from the front office to the coaching staff. Could the potential lottery pick, Cooper Flagg, be the solution for Dallas? Meanwhile, the Lakers are solidifying their status as title contenders. Plus, we delve into the Golden State Warriors and how Steph Curry has found new motivation with a fresh star addition. After our NBA segment, we welcome rookie wide receiver Jaylin Noel from Iowa State to the show! We discuss his impressive NFL combine performance, his journey with the Cyclones, and share insights about playing alongside quarterbacks Brock Purdy and Rocco Becht. Jaylin also reflects on finishing his college career with an 11-3 season and a victory in the Pop-Tarts Bowl. Finally, we transition into NFL talk, tackling Travis Hunter's bold comparison of playing both sides of the ball to Shohei Ohtani's dual-threat role in baseball. The crew weighs in on this hot topic before wrapping up with a look at Saquon Barkley’s groundbreaking contract with the Philadelphia Eagles—arguably a deserving reward after an incredible season with over 2,000 rushing yards and unforgettable plays in crucial moments. Tune in for another packed episode filled with insights, interviews, and the latest sports buzz!

We’ve got a fun one for you this week on Under Further Review. The New York Knicks are making waves as a local favorite and a legitimate title contender in the NBA. But can they break through that dreaded second-round wall? With an 0-7 record this season against top teams like the Cleveland Cavaliers, Boston Celtics, and Oklahoma City Thunder, the question remains: What’s holding them back from making a deep playoff run? We discuss how Coach Tom Thibodeau’s love for heavy minutes for his starters could be a blessing and a curse, especially when it comes to player fatigue and injuries come postseason time. With superstars regularly sitting out games in today’s NBA, we try to find the balance that keeps players fresh while maintaining team chemistry. After that, we’ve got an amazing interview with Los Angeles Rams defensive back, Quentin Lake. He takes us inside his hybrid position, growing up with an NFL father, his journey from UCLA to the Rams, and what it was like going from a 1-4 start to a playoff berth. Quintin’s insight is invaluable, especially for anyone interested in the evolving roles on defense in today’s NFL. Next up, it’s time for our weekly Blind Draft—with a twist. This week, Steve throws random quarterbacks at Joe and Mike, and they go head-to-head, drafting the most unusual Top 10 quarterbacks you can imagine. Spoiler alert: things get wild. We wrap up the episode with an NFL-focused discussion. From Matthew Stafford’s recent move to the Rams, to what the Jets and Giants should target in the draft, we touch on all the offseason drama. We also dive into Sportico’s list of the most expensive sports franchises—who made the cut, and who just missed out? What You’ll Hear in This Episode: Knicks: Can they break the second-round curse? Thibodeau’s minutes: Are they too much, or just what the Knicks need? Interview with Rams defensive back Quintin Lake: Growing up in football, hybrid positions, and the Rams’ playoff push. Blind Draft: Joe and Mike face off in a wild QB ranking challenge. NFL Talk: Stafford's future with the Rams, draft needs for the Jets and Giants, and the world’s most expensive sports teams. Subscribe & Follow: Be sure to subscribe to Under Further Review for your weekly dose of sports banter, hot takes, and interviews with some of the biggest names in the game. From hoops to football, we’ve got you covered.

In this episode, we kick things off with a spirited discussion about the recent 4 Nations Face-Off, where Canada claimed victory but the U.S. made a strong statement. We analyze Team USA’s impressive run to the championship game, spotlighting the crucial contributions from the Tkachuk brothers and the depth of their lineup. Join us as we explore the shifting landscape of hockey and how the influx of international players in the NHL is shaping the future of American hockey.

Next, we’re thrilled to welcome Cesar Ruiz of the New Orleans Saints! He shares insights from his journey starting in Camden, NJ, all the way to the NFL, discussing the current state of the Saints and his experiences on and off the field.

To wrap things up, we bring back our fan-favorite segment, the "blind draft," where we rank our top-10 SNL talents in honor of SNL’s 50th anniversary. And of course, we dive into the latest NFL coaching hires, sharing our thoughts on each move.

Tune in for an episode packed with sports insights, laughs, and engaging conversations!

Super Bowl Recap – Eagles vs. Chiefs

In this episode of Under Further Review, the football season may be over, but we’re keeping the party alive with an in-depth Super Bowl recap! Join us as we break down everything that went down in the big game between the Philadelphia Eagles and Kansas City Chiefs.

We start by highlighting the Eagles' dominance, with Jalen Hurts continuing his precise passing performance that began in the NFC Championship and carried into the Super Bowl. The Chiefs’ defense tried to stack the box, but that only allowed the Eagles to make the most of their passing game. We analyze the key players on the Eagles defense, like Jalen Carter, Nolan Smith, Josh Sweat, and Cooper DeJean, who stepped up and helped secure the win.

Here’s the shocking part — the Eagles didn’t blitz a single time during the game! We dive deep into how their defensive line made that possible and completely shut down Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs’ offense. Speaking of Mahomes, we discuss the real issue for the Chiefs — it wasn’t Mahomes’ performance, but the lack of protection in the pocket. We also talk about how All-Pro guard Joe Thuney had to step into the tackle position, a move that clearly disrupted their rhythm.

We also look ahead to the future: What’s next for the Eagles after this stellar season, given the incredible drafting and free-agent signings that have them set up for success? And for the Chiefs, could this Super Bowl have been Travis Kelce’s last big game as he looks ahead to his next chapter in podcasting?

And don’t miss our “blind draft” where we each pick the best defenses of all-time — who came out on top? You’ll have to listen to find out.

Finally, we touch on some news from around the league, including the Jets closing the door on Aaron Rodgers and the Giants showing interest in Matt Stafford.Tune in now for all this and more in our action-packed Super Bowl recap episode!

Super Bowl Week is HERE! Our Super Bowl preview episode is LIVE!  Before we dive into the biggest game of the year, we had to take a quick detour to talk about the Luka Doncic & Anthony Davis trade—a 20-minute emergency breakdown of why both teams made the move, who won the trade, and our grades for the deal. Then, we jump right into the Chiefs vs. Eagles showdown! 
We break down the Chiefs’ wild AFC Championship win over the Bills—including that insane 4th-down blitz call by Spagnuolo, the controversial stop on Allen’s QB sneak, and Mahomes playing his best game of the year. On the NFC side, we’re all about Saquon Barkley’s dominance and the Eagles’ young, revamped defense. Plus, Jalen Hurts and AJ Brown are clicking at the perfect time!  We close out with our keys to the game and Super Bowl picks for what promises to be an unforgettable final game of the season.

This week on Under Further Review, we’re diving into the action-packed divisional round of the NFL playoffs and also discuss the college football playoffs!

Here’s what we’re breaking down: 

College Football Championship: Ohio State's loaded roster proves too much for Notre Dame. We discuss where standout athletes like Will Howard, Jack Sawyer, Denzel Burke, Emeka Egbuka, and JT Tuimoloau might land in the draft.

NFL Playoff Highlights:

• Commanders upset the Lions 
• Jayden Daniels' legacy game
• The Bills vs. Ravens drama, including Mark Andrews’ crucial drop
• The Chiefs' referee fueled win over the Texans. Playoff Travis Kelce is alive and well!
• Eagles soar past the Rams and a spotlight on the incredible Saquon Barkley

Plus, Mike shares his thoughts on the Jets' new HC, Aaron Glenn, and we wrap up with our championship weekend picks!