
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Who is in charge of the English language?
Nobody.
Nobody runs the internet, either. Nobody decides how much bread will be baked or delivered to your town tomorrow. Yet somehow our sentences mean something, our websites work, and you can find bread everywhere.
Now think about the things somebody is in charge of: the currency, the schools, and the federal budget. Those are the things we scream at each other about every election.
One kind of order comes down from commands. Another kind grows up from agreements.
We’ve been trained to trust the first and overlook the second. We resist the idea that there’s nobody at the helm. We assume someone ought to be in charge. But maybe our greatest political mistake is assuming that somebody has to be in charge.
The question is no longer who should rule. It’s how much of our lives we can govern ourselves.
That’s the difference between overthrow and underthrow.
What Is Decentralization?
Let’s begin with two pictures: a tower and a tapestry.
In a tower, information climbs up, somebody makes a decision, and orders come down. A few people at the top decide for everyone beneath them. It’s a system of human subordination—of command and control.
In a tapestry, each thread connects to the threads beside it. No single thread holds it all together. And no single thread can tear it apart.
Decentralization is the move from the tower to the tapestry. It’s the process of moving more decisions toward the people who hold the best knowledge and bear the consequences.
Three important things change when a system decentralizes.
First, authority shifts. Fewer decisions get made for you. More get made by you, or at least near you.
Second, knowledge shifts. We stop pretending those at the top know everything and start leveraging what people down below already know.
Third, there are more exit options. You can leave a set of rules that fails you and join one that serves you. And that third shift is the real test.
A petty local board can still be tyrannical. State governments can drive people away. Power over people who never consented is the same problem, even when it’s close to home.
So when anyone tells you a system is decentralized, ask one question: How easy is it to walk away?
Now let’s clear up a misunderstanding. Decentralization doesn’t mean no rules. A chess club has rules. A marriage has rules. A contract has rules. The difference is that you agree to them.
Call it rules without rulers.
But remember: decentralization isn’t a finished utopia. It’s a direction. So the useful question about any reform or institution is this: Does it move more choices closer to more choosers?
Why Do We Need It?
Four reasons. Let me start with the one I think is hardest to argue with.
1. The world is outgrowing the tower
Complexity theorist Yaneer Bar-Yam makes a simple point: a hierarchy can handle only as much complexity as its leadership can process. Every major decision has to squeeze through one head, or one committee. That might have worked when life was simpler. A pharaoh could run a grain economy. But no one can run 340 million lives, each with its own knowledge, circumstances, plans, and troubles.
Political economist F. A. Hayek saw this eighty years ago. The knowledge a society runs on is scattered among millions of people, and most of it never reaches the capital. So the people at the top just guess. They write one rule for everyone, but it fits almost no one.
There are exceptions, of course. “Drive on the right” is a pretty good rule. So is “Don’t injure anyone.” But simple rules that unleash complexity are not the same as complicated rules that hold people back. The tower specializes in the latter.
2. The tower makes us enemies
I call our current system DOS: the democratic operating system. In the US, it ships with two apps, Red and Blue. Each side believes it holds the One True Way, and every election decides who gets to install its app for everyone else.
Absurd, right?
In a system that raises the cost of losing, people will do almost anything to win. The more decisions we send to the tower, the more your neighbor’s vote becomes a threat, and she becomes an enemy.
Pull those decisions back out, and she’s your neighbor again. She lives her way. You live yours. And neither of you needs the other’s permission.
3. The tower gets captured
A century ago, sociologist Robert Michels described the Iron Law of Oligarchy. Organizations, however democratic at first, tend to drift toward rule by a few insiders. Build one great lever of control at the top, and the people most eager to pull it will find their way to grab it.
So we need more decision-making centers, with competing levers of authority. When one center becomes too oppressive or fails, people can move to another. Failures can stay local instead of becoming catastrophic and system-wide. As Nassim Taleb reminds us, systems become more resilient when they can absorb failures, adapt, and learn from them.
Here’s another way to see it: decentralized systems are more grown than designed.
In northern Guatemala, a partially buried Mayan city called El Zotz remains. It once had temples, plazas, and causeways teeming with people. Today it lies under a thousand years of jungle. The designed thing fell. Yet the grown thing is still growing.
4. Just governance depends on the consent of the governed
We ought to recite that line every July. Decentralization is “consent of the governed” in practice.
What Are Some Good Examples?
Some people will hear all this and say, “Nice theory.” But decentralization isn’t just a theory. We have plenty of examples.
The common law. No legislature designed it from scratch. Judges settled real disputes between real people, one case at a time. Over centuries, their rulings helped form a body of law protecting contracts and property.
Mutual aid. By 1920, on historian David Beito’s count, roughly one American man in three belonged to a fraternal society. Members paid dues and received sick pay, burial insurance, and often medical treatment. Working people wove their own safety net.
Morning Star. This California company processes more tomato products than anyone else in the world, yet operates without conventional managers. Colleagues negotiate their commitments directly with one another, in writing, every year.
Bitcoin. In 2009, thousands of strangers began building a global monetary network with no CEO, president, or master. Nobody gave Bitcoin permission, because nobody could. Cypherpunks took the consent of the governed and turned it into code that still runs seventeen years later.
Próspera. On the island of Roatán, a jurisdiction called Próspera asks residents to sign an Agreement of Coexistence—a real social contract you can actually read before you accept it. The former socialist government in Honduras tried to repeal the legal framework that made it possible, which tells you how incumbents feel about competition.
These examples differ enormously. But they share something important: people coordinating through agreements rather than waiting for commands. They show that decentralization isn’t a fantasy.
It’s already happening.
How Do We Get More Decentralization?
We won’t get it by asking. No tower has ever voted to dismantle itself. And the grand constitutional moment people keep waiting for will almost certainly never come.
We get more decentralization by making new rules to live by—and living by them. I call this method subversive innovation, and it runs on a three-part formula.
* Lower transaction costs. Make it cheaper for people to cooperate directly, without a gatekeeper taking a toll.
* Raise predation costs. Make it more costly for anyone to prey on you, whether that’s a criminal or a bureaucracy. Encryption does this. So does a good lock and a good Glock.
* Reduce switching costs. Make it easy to walk away from a system that fails you. A homeschool co-op does this for a family. A second passport does it for a citizen.
Any innovation that does one of these moves power from the tower to the tapestry. One that does all …
Subscribe and support us at Underthrow.orgHere’s a question people rarely ask themselves anymore: When was the last time you did something good that nobody knew about?
You didn’t vote on it. You didn’t post about it.
Maybe you carried a meal to a neighbor. Maybe you forgave a debt, planted a tree, or showed a kid how to change a tire.
Whatever your answer, hold this question in your mind.
Because over the next several minutes, I’m going to argue that too many of us have traded doing real good for a cheap imitation.
And those who profit from this trade are the last people you should trust to do the right thing.
Lazy Morality
Watch your feed the week before an election. People who would never lecture a stranger about kindness are suddenly willing to lecture everybody.
Your coworker with the bumper sticker. Your cousin with the flag. Each one is certain that their virtue rides on a lever they pull every other November.
In this way, politics has become a team sport. And team sports have an important feature.
They let you feel like you’re on the field as you sit in the bleachers.
You wear the colors. You hate the other side. And you show up on game day, which is insisting everyone else do the right thing.
Sadly, that seems to be the sum of our moral lives now.
Politics has the peculiar power to make people morally superior and mean at the same time. Otherwise, it’s just lazy morality.
It asks virtually nothing of us. It costs an afternoon and a few self-righteous posts. And the reward? Something money can’t buy: the feeling of being one of the good ones.
Remember what morality used to mean? Compassion meant sitting with the sick or showing up to raise a barn. Industry meant building something your family could live on or teaching a kid the value of hard work. Protection meant literally standing between the vulnerable and those who would harm them.
Every one of those virtues is local. Every one requires you to show up.
So what did we do with morality? We outsourced it.
Compassion became a line item in a government budget. Industry became a giveaway to cronies. Protection became another agency with a three-letter acronym.
We outsourced our conscience to a distant capital and asked it to do the work for us. But here’s the trouble with outsourcing: You don’t get to choose who gets the job.
When you hand society’s most important decisions to political candidates and so-called ‘experts’, you have to ask: What kind of person wants to make such decisions for you?
Maybe you already know the answer…
Narcissists. Sociopaths. Dark tetrad types who’d sell your grandma for a committee chair.
That means voting isn't necessarily how good people act. It’s often how good people avoid acting.
Selecting for Sociopaths
Under Poland’s communist regime, a psychiatrist named Andrzej Łobaczewski [lo-bah-CHEF-skee] was subjected to political persecution, and his research was suppressed. After he emigrated, his work eventually appeared in English.
He studied how evil organizes itself and gave it a name:
Pathocracy.
A pathocracy is a system in which people with personality disorders, psychopathy above all, hold power and influence.
Once they’re in, they pull others like themselves behind them.
Łobaczewski was writing about the Soviet bloc. But I want to suggest the mechanism doesn’t care what flag flies over the capitol. Any system that hands power to the winners of a popularity contest creates a particular problem.
Specifically, an evolutionary selection mechanism.
Whether parliamentary or presidential, these systems run on the votes of ignoramuses. Before you take offense, I’m one of them. So are you. We’re ignoramuses about nearly every bill and budget our representatives vote on, and for good reason.
Economists call it rational ignorance.
Your one vote almost never decides anything, so studying the fine print of some bill in committee is time you could spend reading your kids a bedtime story. We’re not stupid. We’re just busy.
But a busy electorate can’t really judge competence all that well. And those who get 90 percent of their understanding of the world from TikTok are living in a Hall of Mirrors. So, people judge a candidate’s performance. And I don’t mean KPIs. I mean all the slick talking, tap-dancing and stump speeches on the campaign trail.
Who performs best?
Psychologists who study psychopathy identify traits that ought to give voters pause.
* Superficial charm.
* A grandiose sense of self-worth.
* Pathological lying.
* Manipulative behavior.
* A lack of remorse.
Seems like a job description for people who want to hold public office. Charm wins the debate. Grandiosity fills the arena. Lying survives the news cycle. Manipulation builds coalitions. And a lack of remorse lets politicians break every promise by noon and sleep like a baby that very same night.
This ain’t just rhetoric.
Researchers have begun studying how dark personality traits operate in politics, from ordinary candidates to heads of state.
In 2012, a team led by Emory psychologist Scott Lilienfeld studied psychopathic personality traits in U.S. presidents through George W. Bush. The boldness associated with psychopathy, which they call “fearless dominance,” was associated with higher ratings of presidential leadership and performance.
Other researchers have examined narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy among politicians more broadly.
The question isn’t whether every politician is a psychopath. It’s whether the pursuit of political power attracts certain types of people—and rewards their worst instincts. There’s a difference between wanting to lead and wanting to rule, after all.
Psychopathy is commonly estimated at around one percent of the population. But you don’t need many of them. You just need a selection mechanism that filters them up to the top. A political system that rewards manipulation, grandiosity, and ruthlessness provides exactly that.
Turns out voters in both parties are suckers for sociopathy.
Even if each side spots the sociopath on the other team in seconds, almost nobody sees the one wearing his favorite jersey. That’s how the selection mechanism hides in plain sight. It turns your partisan loyalty into camouflage.
Walk Away and Get to Work
So here we are—locked in politics’ mental prison. Waiting for the next election to rescue us from the last one.
If I do nothing else today, I want to suggest it’s possible to walk away and get to work. Walking away doesn’t mean watching Netflix. It means doing the good work we outsourced.
If we’re sliding toward pathocracy, the first task is to learn to be good again.
The Greeks called it areté. The Stoics believed virtue was the one true good, grounded in how we exercise our judgment and will. Virtue is a practice, like music or a martial art. You do it with your own hands, and you do it every day.
A signal is aimed at an audience. A practice is aimed at a person.
That’s the difference between virtue signaling and virtuous practice. Virtue lives in your family, your street, and your town. You feed people. You hire people. You show up when the barn burns or the creek floods. You mentor kids in how to create value and serve others. And you do it no matter who sits in the Oval Office.
There’s an old Nike line every philosopher should envy:
Just do it.
But practice alone won’t save us. We also have to see the political apparatus for what it is. Because a pathocracy is more than a cast of bad characters. It’s a system that rewards and reproduces them.
Another reason to start building now: The institutions we’ve entrusted with our moral responsibilities may soon be unable to meet even their financial ones.
And that system is running out of money all over the Western world. The IMF reported this spring that global public debt reached nearly 94 percent of world GDP last year. On the current path, it hits 100 percent by 2029. The last time the world carried that kind of load was after World War II. Interest alone has climbed to nearly three percent of global output.
Debt like that doesn’t just go away.
One by one, governments will discover they can’t keep their…
“We have to face a grim truth,” I recently wrote. “Your vote doesn’t matter. Neither does mine.” You’re taught that voting lets your voice be heard. But isn’t that like telling you the drummer for your favorite band can hear you scream from the cheap seats at Madison Square Garden?
Or, as I like to say: Voting is like crying your teardrop in the ocean and expecting the tide to turn.
But people I know and love, quite fairly, responded: It’s the system we’ve got. Why discourage people from voting if it means the crazies take over?
My point is not to discourage people from voting per se. It’s to encourage people to think outside the ballot box—that is, to topple this ridiculous Golden Calf we’ve been worshipping. And no, I’m not suggesting some goofy Mencius Moldbug monarchy.
I’m probably one of the crazies, but not a crazy who wants to take over. I’m one of the crazy ones who wants to get people to “think different”—like the guys who sent that Declaration to King George III 250 years ago. They weren’t Jacobins prepared to throw everything out or burn it all down. They wanted to keep the wisdom of the past and add the most innovative thinking the Enlightenment had to offer.
I think we can build on that. I not only think we can listen to the Founders’ warnings about demagoguery and majoritarian tyranny, but we can expand on our original republicanism.
System Menu
Imagine living in a world where you can choose your own government the same way you choose your smartphone plan or insurance policy—without having to pack your bags and move to a new country. That is the core idea behind Panarchy, a novel political concept proposed by Belgian economist Paul Émile de Puydt in 1860.
De Puydt asked a simple question: If people can freely choose their religion, profession, and personal lifestyle without geographic restrictions, why shouldn’t they have the same options when it comes to governance?
Under Panarchy, multiple governance associations—from free-market republics to socialist communes—would operate simultaneously within the same territory. Instead of voting every few years and being forced to accept whatever swing states decide, you would simply register with the governance association that best aligns with your values. You’d pay taxes only to your chosen governance association and abide by its specific laws.
Today, you have to load up your U-Haul to escape poorly governed states like New York, California, or Illinois. Under Panarchy, if you ever became dissatisfied with your current government’s services, laws, or tax rates, you could just cancel your membership and switch to a competing one.
The catch?
You could no longer use elections to shove your preferences down anyone else’s throat.
By introducing peaceful competition into governance, de Puydt thought Panarchy would reduce political conflict, civil wars, and revolutions. Ultimately, Panarchy reimagines government not as a monopolistic authority over some piece of land, but as a service provider tailored to the choices of citizen-customers.
Practical Objections
Let’s address some skepticism.
Objection 1When neighbors operate under different legal systems, resolving cross-jurisdictional torts, contract breaches, or crimes becomes too complex without a single territorial authority.
This seems devastating on its face. But international law, maritime law, and commercial arbitration already show how to address this challenge. Under Panarchy, governments would sign choice-of-law agreements and establish neutral, intergovernmental appellate courts to handle cross-system disputes. Standardized conflict-of-laws rules would determine jurisdiction based on where an incident occurred or prior mutual consent.
Just as international transactions and cross-border shipping function smoothly across distinct legal systems now, polycentric legal frameworks would rely on established arbitration protocols and reciprocal enforcement treaties.
Objection 2Essential physical infrastructure—like roads, water mains, power grids, and pollution management—requires spatial continuity and cannot easily be duplicated.
This is a fair concern. However, Panarchy separates governance (laws, civil rights, social safety nets, dispute resolution) from utility provision. Local, property-based management entities, utility cooperatives, or specialized special-service districts can manage physical infrastructure.
A homeowner might contract with a territorial utility provider for road maintenance and water access while choosing an entirely separate non-territorial government for ideological, legal, or social services. Easements, public-private partnerships, and geographic fee-for-service models solve spatial coordination without requiring any monolithic political state. Of course, technology can help some people live “off the grid.”
Objection 3Individuals could game the system by choosing low-tax regimes while young and healthy, then switching to high-benefit welfare states when elderly or sick, bankrupting redistributive systems.
Because these associations would have to remain solvent without printing money or running up debt, we have to assume they would manage their accounts better than monopoly governments. Competing governance associations would almost certainly protect themselves using standard contractual mechanisms like vesting periods, pre-existing condition exclusions, entry buy-ins, or minimum membership commitments that ensure more skin in the game.
Welfare-oriented associations would likely structure their benefits like mutual aid societies or insurance policies, requiring long-term contributions before unlocking full benefits. Competition would force governments to design fiscally sustainable models rather than relying on taxation to cover unfunded liabilities.
In short, unlike today’s monopoly states, competing governance associations would face far stronger incentives to innovate and seek long-term sustainability.
Polycentric Defense
Some countries just don’t worry so much about defense. For example, Costa Rica, Monaco, and Mauritius have no standing armies. Some argue these countries are either free riders or sitting ducks. So we had better envision defense.
Under Panarchy, polycentric defense would replace the state’s military monopoly with a network of competing protection agencies, local militias, and security cooperatives.
Instead of paying taxes for national defense, individuals and communities would contract with defense providers based on their risk tolerance, budgets, and values. These independent providers would protect property, enforce rights, and deter external threats.
Against large nation-state aggressors, they could form mutual defense pacts, pool resources, and share intelligence. Deterrence would depend on a resilient, decentralized network backed by insurance underwriters with a financial stake in preventing conflict. After all, war is expensive, and peace is profitable. War would truly be a last resort.
To overcome the free-rider problem, defense services could be bundled into familiar arrangements like property deeds, insurance policies, and commercial leases. Those who refused to pay could be excluded from certain contractual protections, while insurers would have incentives to spread risk and coordinate defense across jurisdictions.
In short, people would be encouraged to pay for the right amount of defense, rather than bankroll a permanent military-industrial complex.
Failures of Imagination
Look, I grant this is just a sketch of what’s possible. But that’s the point. We overcome failures of imagination by, well, imagining alternatives.
If we want a future where people can live together peacefully beyond democracy, Panarchy lets each of us choose the government we want—without imposing it on everyone else.
The question is not whether such a system would be perfect. Nothing is. The question is whether it would be better.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
Subscribe and support at Underthrow.org
The iconoclasts of the Red-Green alliance aren’t just burning down France. They’re burning down the West. Their iconoclasm is a mélange of resentment, self-loathing, and nihilism. Those who lean Red have infinite wants no redistribution regime can ever supply. Those who lean Green bring a theocratic axe to grind against Western decadence, yet the powers that be have treated even the most militant among them like poor, poor puppies.
So, in Europe’s quasi-socialist countries, the Red-Green alliance doubles down on the idea that destruction brings dignity and taking brings thymos. The welfare state offers material comfort without demanding meaningful contribution. For many, work becomes optional, grievance becomes their vocation, and belonging is found among rioters.
They don’t assimilate. They wander and wait, becoming the dry tinder of a civilization that thought “compassion” and post-colonial self-loathing should order society. And now that tinder is catching fire.
Infrared Loops
I don’t always agree with Nick Land of Dark Enlightenment fame, but this assessment is worth remembering:
Social solidarity, in precise contrast, is the parasite’s friend. By cropping out all high-frequency feedback mechanisms (such as market signals), and replacing them with sluggish, infrared loops that pass through a centralized forum of ‘general will,’ a radically democratized society insulates parasitism from what it does, transforming local, painfully dysfunctional, intolerable, and thus urgently corrected behavior patterns into global, numbed, and chronic socio-political pathologies.
Translation?
When societies prioritize vague social solidarity and collective democratic decision-making over tight accountability loops, they make it easier for people to free ride. Small, fixable problems turn into big, chronic ones because the costs are delayed, diluted, and no longer felt by the people creating them.
Highly egalitarian or redistributive systems that reward dependency can turn free riding from an occasional vice into a way of life. Tighter feedback loops send faster, more accurate signals about value and contribution than centralized political processes do.
Of course, dignity and life-meaning come, in no small part, from contribution. If you think poor, poor developing-world puppies should be welcomed—but not be asked to contribute—don’t be surprised when many grow up to become wolves that roam in packs. And if you steep your elites in a strange mix of guilt and entitlement, don’t be surprised when they serve up what’s left of the West to feed the goddamn wolves.
Fight for It
The West is neither a rat race nor a feeding trough. It is a set of ideas—and some ideas are better than others. Yet the Red-Green alliance seeks to kill the very idea that some ideas are better than others. And they have been wildly successful.
Just look at all these wayward children.
But we have to fight again. We have to learn to defend the best of the West with confidence and ambition, even as we jettison some of its worst excesses. We also have to be prepared to make tough decisions and face a truth polite society would rather avoid: Some cultures and ideologies are incompatible with Western civilization. And some people have no intention of living by its code.
The West, like America, is not rooted in race. It’s based on a creed. And what’s in that creed? Let’s do a quick top ten:
* Hold the rights of others—their life, liberty, and property—as sacred, in reciprocity with your own.
* Recognize your fellow citizens as equals—not in the accidents of birth or the exercise of virtues and talents, but in the eyes of the law and of your Creator.
* Ground all law in the consent of the governed, and claim your rights of secession, establishment, and association through real social contracts (not theoretical ones).
* Practice personal, social, and civic virtues to excel in your pursuits, contribute responsibly, and be a good neighbor.
* Defend yourself, your family, and your neighbors against criminals, tyrants, and anti-Western iconoclasts, taking up arms if necessary—to guard freedom and civilization.
* Be sovereign, creative, and industrious in your own way, so that society benefits from your service, and you benefit from your service.
* Prioritize your community over your country, because you must live among your neighbors—and the principle of subsidiarity should mirror that priority.
* Associate with others in compassion, charity, and free collaboration—lift your neighbors when they fall, and they will lift you.
* Refuse to be a slave to the mob, and refuse to be a slave to any victim mentality.
* Pledge loyalty to your creed and live by its code, which includes uniting with others in reciprocity.
Between Jesus and Nietzsche
Nietzsche called himself the Antichrist, then wrote that there had only ever been one Christian, and he died on the cross. The philosopher with the hammer could never stop orbiting the carpenter. So perhaps we should take the hint.
From Nietzsche, the New Western Man must take the hammer. He must learn to smell ressentiment, that sour stench on every mob that has torched a cathedral and called it justice. He will not make weakness a virtue or grievance a religion. He says amen to his fate, his labor, and his share of suffering. He sends no bill to his neighbor. Instead, he wills himself into something greater than he was.
From Jesus, he takes the basin and the towel. He kneels to wash the feet of those who walk away from him. He will cross the road to the stranger in the ditch, spending time and coin on wise and compassionate acts. He forgives those who wrong him, but he knows the difference between forgiveness and surrender.
Each falls short in isolation. Nietzsche without Jesus might inspire a strongman willing to climb on others’ necks to greatness. Jesus without Nietzsche—at least the Jesus of bureaucrats and moralists—gives us a pity party on a grand scale. Compulsion masquerading as compassion becomes policy. Guilt becomes a tax. The poor get paid to stay poor so the comfortable can feel upright with their “I Voted” stickers.
Europe tried that second coming. And look at all the fires.
The synthesis was hiding in Zarathustra. Nietzsche designated the gift-giving virtue the highest, the one that overflows. A soul full enough must give, the way a cup set under a fountain must spill. The Samaritan answered to no ministry and carried no guilt. He had oil, coin, and a strong back. He was the kind of man willing to spend them on a stranger. But never forget: Charity must come from prosperity and personal choice, not from guilt or grievance. Strength must serve love—but a love that expects the one it lifts to stand on his own. If the meek shall inherit the earth, meekness shall not be the absence of sovereignty. It will be our refusal to abuse the sovereignty we take when we answer power.
So the New Western Man is an Übermensch who kneels. He is a Templar Knight willing to f**k his woman. He kneels to lay foundation stones. He can fight, but he would rather plant. He is strong enough to destroy, yet chooses to build. And he gives because he is full. He asks his neighbor to contribute because he respects him too much to pity him. If his neighbor seeks to tear down what he has built, he must gird his loins and turn no cheek.
The New Western Man will rise from the ashes left by the iconoclasts, and we will take away their torches.
The New Western Man practices Human Respect first, but otherwise defends and retaliates against those who refuse to reciprocate it. So together, we will fight as we must. We will win. And our children will inherit the renaissance.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
Subscribe and support us at Underthrow.org.
Her utopia is impossible. His golden age is gone. What if neither the future we imagine nor the past we remember is available to us?
To see why, consider a window.
You’ve heard of the Overton Window. It’s the range of ideas the public will tolerate at a given moment. Inside it are the policies a politician can propose without losing the next election.
Outside lies the unthinkable.
Joseph Overton, a policy analyst in Michigan, sketched the idea in the 1990s. Activists on both sides have used it ever since. Shove it left. Shove it right. Try to make the radical sound reasonable, or the reasonable sound rabid.
But the window has a blind spot. It shows what people will accept politically. It tells us little about what we can build without waiting for politics.
Doors of Possibility
So let me introduce another piece of architecture. Call it Kauffman’s Doors.
Picture a door to a room. You walk through, and it shuts behind you. There’s no handle on this side, so you can never go back through that door. The only way out is through another door, into a room you’ve never seen.
Kauffman’s Doors are the adjacent possible applied to societies and how they evolve. So what’s the adjacent possible? And who is Kauffman?
Stuart Kauffman is a theoretical biologist. At the Santa Fe Institute, he spent years asking how life gets more complex—say, from proteins to people. His answer? Every system sits at the edge of what it can become next.
A primordial soup can’t just produce a human heart, much less a human. It can only make the molecules one catalytic reaction away. But each new molecule opens possibilities that did not exist a moment before. The biosphere grows as each new form of life opens possibilities for what comes next.
Kauffman calls this proximate frontier the “adjacent possible.”
No Way Back
Here’s what that means for us: We cannot restore the past. Whether the Fifties, the Founding, or the Gold Standard, there’s no going back. The open frontier was paved or protected, and today’s pioneers are looking at Mars. Our past rooms held different people with different motivations in different circumstances. And the door to each past room closed when we left it.
Any movement that promises former glory is selling a key to a rusty, antique lock. Any movement that promises a grand utopia is selling socialist snake oil.
Those who want a better future have to move forward, through one of Kauffman’s Doors. And forward means new circumstances. Some will be better. Some will be worse. We don’t get to pick the temperature in the next room. The doors are few, and from any new room, the possibilities are limited.
The Constrained Vision
Now, meet Thomas Sowell.
In his influential book A Conflict of Visions, Sowell described two ways of seeing the world. The constrained vision sees human beings as limited, and every policy prescription as a trade-off. The unconstrained vision places greater faith in moral and intellectual perfectibility, and in an unbounded will to overcome perceived social evils. It imagines elites can design a better society and install it for everyone.
The adjacent possible applies a constrained vision to societal evolution. You can’t skip rooms by designing and installing a perfect society. And you can’t return to the glories of the past, real or imagined.
You can only take the best next steps.
A to Z
Here’s the uncomfortable part. Freedom lovers like to think they get down with the constrained vision. They quote F. A. Hayek and warn about central planners. But too many are quick to draw up their own blueprints.
Abolish the Fed by Tuesday and privatize everything by Friday. We’ll all wake up Monday in Libertopia. They imagine we can get from A to Z without ever passing through B. That’s just the unconstrained vision wearing a Gadsden flag.
A free society won’t be crammed through the Overton Window. Nobody can argue a civilization into existence.
Criticize by Creating
We’ll have to step through Kauffman’s Doors, through things people can build, do, or join right now. Start a microschool. Join a mutual aid society. Use a stablecoin wallet. Project by project, with “ideas having sex,” we move toward our North Star while underthrowing the powerful.
No project is perfect, of course, but each creates possibilities that didn’t exist before. That’s how life did it over four billion years without a blueprint. And that’s how we’ll do it.
So stop looking for a way into the Glorious Past. And stop thinking you can design the Utopian Society of the Future. We must look for the doors before us and choose wisely.
Then we can walk through one and listen as it shuts behind us.
There’s no going back.
The only way forward is through.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
Subscribe and support us at Underthrow.org
Something’s not right. You’ve felt it. Maybe at a dinner-table conversation that went cold over politics. Maybe scrolling at 2 a.m., wondering why everyone seems furious, and nobody seems happy.
You’re not imagining it.
A civilization in decline shows symptoms like a sick body. And ours is running three fevers at once.
The first is ressentiment. That’s Nietzsche’s word for a bitter, impotent envy. When I feel powerless, I can muster the will to do the work and change my life. Or I can convert all that powerlessness into moral outrage at the world. Outrage is easier. It feels righteous. And it lets me off the hook. A culture soaked in ressentiment produces fewer and fewer people who take responsibility for anything.
The second is anomie. Durkheim saw it coming more than a century ago. When shared, sacred norms erode, the individual is left alone with his impulses. Feeling isolated and hyperreactive, he floats in a sea of nihilism with nothing to hold on to. To feel less isolated, he might join the mob or set out to make the world more like what’s inside him.
The third is spectacle. Debord and Baudrillard warned that we would come to live among images instead of in life. Reality gives way to performance. The territory gets lost under layers of maps. Identity becomes a costume, staged for an audience also wearing masks. We curate, we signal, and after a while we forget anything genuine ever existed beneath our thin avatars. Put simply:
People are growing more resentful, more adrift, and more fake.
And they know it.
So they go looking for a cure.
False Cures
Most reach for one of three modern curatives: politics, “spirituality,” or therapy. Each promises relief. Yet in its modern form, each makes the sickness worse.
Start with politics.
The instinct makes sense. Win power. Capture the institutions. Fix things from the top. But look at what those institutions run on. Ressentiment fuels the campaigns. Anomie fills the ranks. Spectacle is the whole show.
You cannot cure a society with heavy doses of the underlying pathology. The reformer who climbs inside a dying institution doesn’t change it. It changes him.
Then there’s spirituality—or what passes for it.
Perhaps it’s the California New Age variety: vibes without vows, bliss without discipline. Maybe it soothes you for an afternoon. Then it evaporates, because nothing was asked of you.
Then there’s contemporary therapy.
Some of it can help. But too much of the modern therapeutic industry has become iatrogenic. That is, the healer causes the harm. Therapy addictions keep wounds open. Bad therapists keep your locus of control outside of you, so the world is always to blame, and you are never responsible.
“That’ll be $150, please. See you next week.”
Trauma becomes the client’s identity. Dependency becomes the therapist’s business model.
None of that makes the client more self-possessed and sovereign.
The Games Beneath
The philosopher James Carse described two kinds of games.
A finite game is played to defeat others. It has a scoreboard, an ending, then winners and losers.
An infinite game is played to keep the play going. Its purpose is not victory but continued possibility and play.
Modern politics, spirituality, and therapy can hide finite games disguised as paths to fulfillment:
Win the election.Follow your bliss.Blame the world.
Different scoreboards—same trap.
There’s nothing wrong with playing finite games. The mistake is making them the point of life.
So the first important move is to stop believing that winning these games will make us whole. The board is all wrong, and the rules reward the rot.
So the second big move is to play a different game.
In an infinite game, adversity is part of the play. Obstacles appear. Challenges arise. We face them not merely to prevail, but to become more capable players, open more possibilities for cooperation, and keep the play going.
The Turn
So if modern politics is hollow, modern spirituality is empty, and modern therapy too often turns suffering into identity, what feeds a malnourished spirit?
A high-trust community of people living by a code, for starters.
But not just any code—one that helps us become the kind of people capable of building the next great civilization.
It must also help us become cultural, social, and psychospiritual counterpower—a growing fellowship of people who’ve stopped asking permission to build what comes next.
But a community doesn’t hold together on good intentions. Every enduring order has held something sacred, something its members would honor even at great personal cost.
That’s the code. And that’s where the real work begins.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
Subscribe and support us at Underthrow.org
-Nearly every time someone complains online about a crazy medical bill, it goes viral. We’ve all been there. Invariably, people in the comments say the same thing:
This is what happens when you leave healthcare to the free market.
It’s a tidy tale. The villain is greed, the cure is government, and the case for single-payer is closed.
There’s just one problem:
A free market in American healthcare doesn’t exist. It never has.
You can’t blame a villain that doesn’t exist. So let’s follow the money and find out what’s really going on.
Follow the Money
In 2026, Americans will spend more than 5.3 trillion dollars on healthcare. That’s eighteen cents of every dollar the economy produced.
Now ask who paid.
Medicare paid 21 percent. Medicaid paid 18 percent. Add CHIP, the VA, TRICARE, and Obamacare, and public insurance covers about half the total bill.
Now trace each dollar back to whoever finally writes the check, and the picture gets clearer. Washington sponsors 31 percent. State and local governments sponsor 16. So government pays for more than half of American healthcare.
Okay, so what about private insurance and out-of-pocket payments? Private insurers paid 31 percent, and households paid 11 percent out of pocket.
Those look like the free-market numbers. But we have to look closer.
The Private Sector That Wasn’t
Start with your employer insurance plan.
It’s a fossil from the Second World War. Wage controls barred companies from raising pay, so they competed with benefits instead. Congress never changed that, so the tax code froze that accident in place.
The problem is, premiums your employer pays are untaxed. That exclusion is worth hundreds of billions a year—to somebody. But it chains your coverage to your job. And it distorts the price, hiding it from the one person who ought to see it: you.
Next, we have the individual market. But the ACA (Obamacare) decides what every plan must cover, how much premiums may vary from person to person, and how much the taxpayer has to chip in.
Then prices. Medicare sets administered rates for hospitals and doctors, and private insurers bargain in Medicare’s shadow. The government price is the anchor.
What about supply? Licensing decides who may treat you. The FDA decides what you may take. EMTALA decides who must be treated.
And in many states, certificate-of-need laws require permission to start a new clinic. The entrepreneur has to get permission from a board where the hospitals already in town get to object.
Nothing fishy about that. Imagine opening a restaurant and needing sign-off from the competitor across the street.
It’s all anti-competitive. It drives up premiums and prices to benefit insurers, hospital systems, and the agencies that shield them. That arrangement has a name.
Call it the Care-tel.
The Expense-Account Effect
So what’s left of the healthcare market?
Out-of-pocket spending sounds like shopping. Mostly it’s deductibles and copays inside the insured system. You pay a slice of a true price you never saw.
So the real market is only a sliver: cosmetic surgery, LASIK, some dental and vision, direct primary care, and over-the-counter drugs. These are but a few percent of the healthcare sector.
But in that sliver, patients see real prices and providers compete for patients. LASIK has spent decades getting better while its real price has held steady or fallen.
Everything else in US healthcare runs on the expense-account effect.
When someone else pays for your blood test, you don’t care whether it costs fifty dollars or five hundred. But the lab does.
So an outrageous bill lands on the insurance risk pool. The pool raises premiums, but all the jacked-up prices stay hidden until you get your premium bill, which not everyone does. (Remember: only those who buy on the private market or pay fully out of pocket see it.)
Too few in that chain have a reason to ask what anything costs, so there is drastically reduced price competition.
The healthcare sector bloats, and we b***h about the final bill. Then people look at all the wreckage and blame “capitalism.”
What a Market Would Look Like
Here’s what reform looks like, starting with what matters most.
* Put the money back in the patient’s hands. Expand health savings accounts and pair them with real catastrophic coverage. Insurance is for a car wreck or a cancer diagnosis. Prepaying for sniffles, stitches, visits, and labs is how a policy becomes an expense account.
* Treat every health dollar the same in the tax code, no matter who pays it. End the wartime tax privilege on employer coverage, and your insurance follows you from job to job.
* Make prices transparent by law. If routine care comes out of our accounts, we’ll all start to care what the blood test costs. You’ll need the number before you agree to pay it.
* Break the supply cartel. Repeal certificate-of-need laws. Speed safe drugs to market. Let more trained people practice.
* Let insurers compete across state lines. If your carrier earns a reputation for denying claims, you should be free to buy a plan from New Hampshire. And forge a clear path to form new mutuals and healthcare associations.
* Help the poor with ownership. Replace Medicaid with means-tested deposits into poor folks’ health savings accounts. Money that belongs to someone gets watched.
* Price the hardest cases honestly. Fund high-risk pools for people with preexisting conditions, with premiums capped at a multiple of the standard rate. Introduce reinsurance programs for crazy-high interventions, but only after getting rid of guaranteed issue and community rating.
Most of this was obvious fifteen years ago, when a certain party shoved Obamacare down our throats. But none of the reforms ever happened, because every item on that list takes something from the Care-tel.
Now the self-same party is whining for Medicare for All, as if CanadaCare and the British NHS are running just splendidly.
No one in those countries has to wait months for treatment, and of course it’s all “free.”
Make Them Compete
Those who want CommieCare have a simple pitch: the market failed, so let the bureaucrats run it.
But it’s a lie. The free market they blame was never even allowed in the waiting room.
What failed is our Frankenstein system—half of it paid for by the state, the rest fenced in by the Care-tel.
Physicians swear an oath: First, do no harm.
It’s time that oath bound our government officials and their greedy corporate supplicants alike.
If you don’t like evil corporations providing your healthcare, don’t hand it over to a giant monopoly. Subject them to more competition. That’ll make them serve us better for far less of our money.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
Subscribe and support us at Underthrow.org--A quick quiz. No wrong answers, just interesting results.
What is the proper role of government?
Pick the answer closest to your gut:
* The Helper. Government ought to solve social problems and help people.
* The Guardian. Government should make moral laws, preserve tradition, and keep order.
* The Referee. Government should just protect your rights to life, liberty, and property.
* None. Government is a corruptible monopoly.
Okay—got your answer? Hold onto it.
We’re going to take each answer seriously. Then we’ll see which ones survive.
Answer A: The Helper
Let’s start with what is arguably the most popular answer. Call it The Department of Problem Solving, or The Helper of Last Resort.
Whether it’s poverty, addiction, housing, or the pothole on Elm Street, when something goes wrong, many think government officials should be responsible for fixing it.
It’s a nice idea. But it has a sorry track record.
First, government officials tend to do things poorly. The people who staff the government aren’t stupid. But they almost never pay the price of failure.
A restaurant that serves bad food closes. An agency that delivers bad outcomes asks for a bigger budget. And it almost always gets one.
So problems don’t get solved. They get displaced, or they metastasize. The War on Poverty is approaching retirement age, yet poverty showed up at its last birthday party.
Moreover, the Helper government changes us.
When there’s a department for every problem, we stop seeing the problems as ours to solve. Responsibility gets outsourced to a faraway bureaucracy with a phone tree. Neighbors who might once have organized a meal train or a mutual aid society can barely muster a thumbs-up on social media.
The Helper helps people, all right. It helps them forget how to help each other while the bureaucrats help themselves to ever-expanding budgets.
And don’t forget: programs almost never die. If no customer can walk away, then no one is accountable. The program hoards resources. The mission creeps.
Have you ever known a government agency to solve a problem and then immediately shut itself down?
I’ll wait [drums fingers].
Answer B: The Guardian
Here, government’s job is to keep us civilized. Enforce decency. Protect our culture. Keep law and order. Many people think government is the body responsible for making us good.
The trouble is, you can’t legislate morality. The state can only legislate punishment or require recompense. If it tries to police a victimless vice, that vice goes underground.
Prohibition didn’t end drinking, after all. It gave us Al Capone. The Drug War didn’t end drug use. It gave us cartels and products laced with fentanyl.
And here’s another problem with Answer B: culture doesn’t need a warden.
Families, congregations, fraternal orders, and schools have carried traditions for millennia without a ministry supervising them. Once the state appoints itself keeper of a tradition, it has to decide whose tradition counts. And your peaceful neighbor, with his different gods and different holidays, becomes a problem to be managed.
Finally, order matters. Nobody wants chaos. But order comes in two major kinds.
Emergent order grows. Language. Markets. Common law. A crowded sidewalk where nobody collides.
Imposed order arrives wearing a badge. No doubt we need policing. We just need to be careful about what we police. Imposed order has a habit of turning intolerant. Then violent.
As Yale law professor Stephen L. Carter reminds us:
Law professors and lawyers instinctively shy away from considering the problem of law’s violence. Every law is violent. We try not to think about this, but we should. On the first day of law school, I tell my Contracts students never to argue for invoking the power of law except in a cause for which they are willing to kill.
Answer C: The Referee
This one’s popular with my audience.
It’s government as a humble night watchman. And if something happens, it’s the fair-minded arbiter who decides who injured whom. Government, on this view, should keep the game fair—not by ensuring equal outcomes, but by applying rules equally.
We can grant that premise. We do need people willing to protect life, liberty, and property.
The trouble is, the Referee—watchman and arbiter—will be tempted by power. Give one faction exclusive power to judge disputes, including those over the extent of its own power, and see what happens.
To avoid such problems, the American founders wrote the most careful referee’s manual in history. A few pages of enumerated powers.
Two and a half centuries later, the referee owns the league, sells the tickets, rewrites the rulebook, and bilks the players. The Referee who started out calling fouls now commits them routinely.
So even if you believe protection and adjudication are core functions every society needs, a harder question lingers:
Is a monopoly government the right body to perform them?
Answer D: None
Which brings us to the fourth answer, the one for outliers:
Government is a corruptible monopoly.
Weigh each word carefully.
A monopoly government is a single provider of governance services, over a vast territory, backed by the threat of force. Corruptible means it is run by people who are vulnerable to temptation and drawn to power.
Combine corruptible and monopoly, and you get the most dangerous arrangement a society can allow: power you can’t refuse, held by people you can’t trust.
We already know how monopolies behave. Higher prices. Worse service. Contempt for the customer. Why do we expect better when the monopoly carries guns, takes no accountability, and is willing to throw its customers in jail?
Well, most people just can’t imagine the alternative.
But there is one.
Competition. In governance itself.
Governance, after all, is a bundle of goods and services: security, dispute resolution, rule-making, safety nets. Each can be provided by entities that have to earn your participation—and keep earning it.
Unhappy? You have recourse.
Over it? You can exit.
Otherwise, people owe a strong moral justification for why you must accept the monopoly bundle.
But here’s the twist. Choosing “None” doesn’t mean rejecting the Helper, the Guardian, or the Referee. It means we all get to choose them according to our ideals.
Want a community with generous mutual aid?
Join one.
Want strict moral codes and deep tradition?
There’s a covenant for that.
Want a bare-bones night watchman and nothing else?
Sign here, please.
The first three answers become menu options. Nobody gets to impose their choice on you.
That’s what ending the monopoly buys us. Lower prices. Higher quality. And more ways to live and self-organize than any capital could ever conceive.
Coda
Go back to your original answer.
If you picked Helper, Guardian, or Referee, you weren’t wrong about what people need. But you might have been wrong about who ought to supply it—and whether you really get a say in the matter.
So maybe the question isn’t “What is the role of government?” Maybe it’s why we let a single institution be the monopoly provider of some of the most important things in life.
Turns out a few of us are done waiting for permission to build the alternative.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
Human Respect Labs presents: “The Spell That Made Everyone Good” —a short animated parable on force, freedom, and the power of human respect.Please watch and share so we can make more!Got a creative project idea about human liberation? Visit Human Respect Labs to see if you qualify for funding.
There once was a city both ancient and great, Whose greatness gave way to a terrible fate.
The city of Uz, its people once proud, Now lived in the dark of a terrible cloud.
Around every corner, a mugger, a thief,Their victims left standing in stunned disbelief.
Brigands besieged from beyond the high wall, And a TYRANT ruled harshly within the great hall.
The tyrant sent goons to collect all because, He thought of himself as much better than Uz.
The people now lived in perpetual fears, Of the Takers whose taking brought nothing but tears.
An Old Wizard said, “I’ve had quite enough! Of thieves, and tyrants, and brigand-y stuff.”
He worked through the night to craft a spell right, Then cast that spell down upon Uz at first light.
The Makers of Uz noticed nothing at first, So wary of Takers, they planned for the worst.
They hustled, traded, and worked the whole day, And the Takers retreated in total dismay.
The pickpockets picked but couldn’t quite poach; The brigands found out that they couldn’t approach.
The goons of the tyrant grew weak at the knee, Then smashed into shields that no one could see.
Makers could make, but Takers were thwarted. “Everything’s changed!” the people reported.
The city now bustled with commerce and peace.So harmony, joy, and abundance increased!
The Takers grew weary from trying to plunder, Foiled every time, and left there to wonder…
Unable to pilfer a pound or a pence; They couldn’t compel, so they had to convince.Forbidden to take, they had to do good, So life kept improving, just as it should. The Spell had permitted no harm, not a jot, So better and better and better things got. No candy would vanish from innocent hands. The brigands gave up on their plundering plans. The tyrant came down to everyone’s level. No power to dictate, cow, or bedevil. Folks worked and traded, and gave from the heart. And mutual aid played a critical part. After working long days, the Uzites rejoiced; As Uz was now buzzing with compassion and choice.Uz became known as a City of Gold, Where everyone wanted to live and grow old. Till one day, a Dark Mage discovered the Spell. He said, “These Makers don’t give quite enough of themselves.”
“The Old Wizard’s magic is no good for the needy. It lets all the townfolk be selfish and greedy!”
So the Dark Mage incanted with black magic, strong, To cancel the spell that had righted the wrongs. By dawn’s gentle light—the Old Wizard was weak. Only pallor remained on his once-rosy cheeks. The thieves found pockets to pick and purloin. The brigands went back to plundering coin… The Tyrant’s big goons were all taxing by eight. And Uz slid back down to a desperate state. The moral, the lesson, to take, if you could; There’s not enough magic to make us all good.
Yet each of us carries the power to care; So we should try Human Respect everywhere.
Credits
Written by Max BordersStory Editor: Christopher CookSound & Score: James S. BordersVoice Artist: Andrew ChisholmAnimation: Alexandra MurhaStudio: Hound Studio
Please share and discuss this with others—especially younguns. The more eyeballs and interest we get on this, the more likely we are to secure funding for more creative projects.
Subscribe and support Underthrow.org--
Something strange has happened to the American economy. Ask people whether life has become less affordable, and you’ll probably hear the same story.
The middle class is disappearing. Wages can’t keep up. Our parents had it better. Everything costs too much.
Slivers of that story are true. But then you encounter a chart like this one from the Master of Killer Charts, Mark Perry.
In 1967, adjusted for inflation, about 30 percent of American households earned less than $35,000. Today it’s about 19 percent.
Okay. So where did everybody go?
They got richer.
In 1967, only 16.5 percent of households earned the equivalent of $100,000 or more in today’s dollars. Today? Nearly 45 percent. The middle-income group really has shrunk—from 54 percent of households to 36 percent.
But look where it went… Up.
The disappearing middle class didn’t simply tumble into poverty. Millions of households graduated into higher real incomes, despite persistent inflation. And the percentage at the bottom fell, too.
So America has this weird problem: we’re still getting richer, but we don’t feel richer.
The Great Divergence
Another Mark Perry chart helps explain why. Look at what happened to prices between 2000 and 2025.
TVs became almost unbelievably cheaper. Computer software plunged in price. So did cellphone services and toys. Clothing barely budged. Household furnishings and new cars increased far less than wages.
These are sectors in which competition, technology, globalization, automation, and scale have been allowed to perform their strange magic. Companies figure out how to make more with less. Competitors copy them. New entrants undercut them. Technology improves. And consumers benefit.
Now look at the other end of the chart.
* Hospital services: up 281 percent
* College tuition and fees: up 197 percent
* Childcare: up 159 percent
* Medical services: up 147 percent
* Housing: up 111 percent
Something very different is happening in these industries. And unfortunately, these aren’t trivial.
You can postpone buying a new flat screen, but you can’t postpone appendicitis.
You can keep using your old laptop, but you still need a place to live. And if your kid needs childcare while you work, Amazon can’t ship you a cheaper substitute tomorrow morning.
Such is the paradox of American prosperity. We’re richer. Many of the things we buy have become dramatically better and cheaper. But some of the things we cannot easily do without have become painfully expensive.
So instead of asking “Why is everything unaffordable?” we should ask: What’s different about the things that are?
Follow the Red Lines
Start with housing. Why don’t developers just build more homes where people want them? Often because it’s illegal.
Zoning restrictions and building codes are costly. Minimum lot sizes consume land. Parking requirements increase costs. Permitting adds delays. NIMBY opposition prevents construction. Then we all express shock that restricting the supply of something makes it more expensive.
Or consider health care.
Whatever else American health care is, it is not some laissez-faire free-for-all. It’s a labyrinth of government subsidies, third-party payments, occupational licensing, insurance regulation, patent protections, insurance mandates, in-state monopolies, and restrictions on competition.
Some states even maintain Certificate-of-Need laws, which can require government permission before a provider builds or expands a medical facility. The Federal Trade Commission and Justice Department have criticized such laws for restricting competition.
And then there’s college.
For decades, our solution to expensive higher education has been to give people more money with which to buy increasingly expensive higher education.
This has created a tuition spiral: Loans. Grants. Subsidies.
But subsidizing demand without proportionately increasing supply almost never makes something cheaper. Some of our increased purchasing power becomes higher tuition. Meanwhile, universities compete with amenities, facilities, administration, and prestige — costs that don’t necessarily translate into more learning.
Cost Disease
There is another force at work here, too. Economists call it Baumol’s cost disease.
Some industries become dramatically more productive. One farmer can feed vastly more people than his ancestor could. One factory worker can produce vastly more goods.
But a string quartet still requires four musicians. A nurse practitioner still needs a certain amount of time with a patient. A teacher still needs time with students. A caregiver can only watch so many children.
As wages rise in productive sectors, these labor-intensive sectors have to raise wages too, even though they can’t increase output at anything like the same rate.
So not every red line on this chart is caused by government. But officials can make an intrinsically expensive problem considerably worse.
The Wrong Diagnosis
This is why the standard story matters.
If your diagnosis is that “capitalism” has made ordinary life unaffordable, your solution will probably be more subsidies, more controls, and more regulation.
But what if the diagnosis is backward?
What if competitive markets are actually doing remarkably well in much of the economy—and our worst affordability crises are concentrated in sectors where competition, supply, and productivity are tightly regulated and unusually constrained?
If that’s true, the prescription changes.
For housing: Let people build.
For health care: Create transparent prices and remove barriers to entry and competition.
For higher education: Never assume subsidizing students will discipline prices.
When Baumol’s cost disease is the real culprit, recognize the trade-off instead of pretending there’s a regulatory magic wand that makes labor-intensive services cheaper and more widely available.
This isn’t an argument that every regulation is bad. It isn’t an argument that every subsidy is useless. And it certainly isn’t an argument that Americans who feel squeezed are imagining things.
It’s an argument that we need to identify where the squeeze is actually coming from.
The Affluence Paradox
America isn’t a country steadily sinking into poverty — though it risks it by sinking into ever more debt.
In inflation-adjusted terms, far more households earn six-figure incomes than did two generations ago. Far fewer live at the bottom. And technological progress has delivered goods our grandparents could scarcely imagine at prices they could hardly believe.
Yet we’ve constructed bottlenecks to accessing some of the most important things in life. Housing. Health care. Education. Childcare.
Because those expenses loom so large in a household budget, they can sap all the gains in prosperity.
A 70-inch television for $400 doesn’t help much when your rent just went up another $400 a month.
So maybe the great economic question of our time isn’t “Why doesn’t capitalism work anymore?”
The question is: why do the things exposed to vigorous entrepreneurial competition keep getting better and cheaper — while so many of the things we’ve insulated from it keep getting more expensive?
We need to follow the red lines. They’re trying to tell us something.
I’m Max Borders. Let’s criticize by creating.
From the publisher's feed