This is a sad, sentimental song ,which listeners tell me, has made them cry. It’s my attempt to look at a subject from another point of view. It’s adapted from one of my early poems
The Vietnam war lasted for nearly 9 years ending in 1975, after five Presidents. Albeit the conflict started 10 years earlier. Ho Chi Minh ( a communist revolutionary in the north) rebelled against French Colonial Rule to demand independence for Vietnam, whilst the Americans feared the domino effect and the rise of communism.
About 1.4m Vietnamese soldiers died on both sides and 58,000 US soldiers. The total death toll rises to 2.5m if you include all sides and civilians.1968 saw a shift in US public support, with gaps between govt statements and news footage and with rising casualty numbers. The war was becoming personal for many US families. The Tet offensive and The My Lai Massacre, ( the murder of 500 civilians by US troops) , raised big questions about US involvement and led to an anti-war movement.
Nixon's expansion of the war into Cambodia and National Guard shootings at Kent and Jackson State Universities, galvanised the opposition. The war as seen as a ‘mistake’
Returning Veterans were greeted with hostility, spitting, verbal abuse and condemnation. They were called baby killers, murderers and war criminals. Many suffered from PTSD and Agent Orange exposure. The draft was mainly from poor, working class youth.
PS my favourite social protest song is Marvins Gay ‘What's going on’ – about his brother in Vietnam, family problems, and anti-war protests.
‘We can never ever, hope to feel the void. I still remember the day I was told’. The toughest job is to tell the parents’ is how the story is told. These are the words in the song of grieving US parents, told that their son is dead. It must have been much the same for the 1.4 m Vietnamese parents.
A long time afterwards the father says, ‘I sill cry and it’s been over 40 years. ‘I will never again celebrate Fathers' day.’ The parents hold on to ‘I think of the last night I was with you’ and ‘Your framed picture sits alongside the flag’
Finally, they ( like the US public) being to question the war and the reason for their son’s involvement and his death. He asks question like ‘‘When you went to war, did you kill anyone’. ‘God, why don’t I get any answers’ ‘ I don’t care about medals’
He also suggests ‘ Your Mother still thinks you will return’ – the pain must have been unbearable.
This is a song about unspeakable pain and a desperate plea from a father to try and make sense of events.
Through his thoughts I hoped to personify the war that killed millions. To show what it meant to a family in the USA and families in Vietnam at a very basic level.
The song is a lonely lament, a commentary that eventual asks questions, which I guess will never be answered.
It involves one lonely piano. Then more instruments are introduced ,rising and falling, with the man’s questions and his sadness. I guess its in the blues, pop genre.
‘He lights the candle and prays, but he’s gone’
That’s very little more you can say about this, other than we seem to be repeating the same awful chapter in the Ukraine and elsewhere.
To make a song out of these events is very risky and easy to get wrong.
I hope my song adequately describes the pain involved.