​​19 year old Tara Leigh Calico (born February 28, 1969) is an American woman who disappeared near her home in Belen, New Mexico, on September 20, 1988. She is widely believed to have been kidnapped. In July 1989, a Polaroid photo of an unidentified young woman and boy, gagged and seemingly bound, was televised to the public after it was found in a convenience store parking lot in Port St. Joe, Florida. Family friends thought the woman resembled Calico and contacted her mother, who then met with investigators and examined the Polaroid. She believed it was her daughter after taking “time, growth and lack of makeup” into consideration, and noted that a scar on the woman’s leg was identical to one that Calico had. Scotland Yard analyzed the photo and concluded that the woman was Calico, but a second analysis by the Los Alamos National Laboratory disagreed. An FBI analysis of the photo was inconclusive.

This is a part of Unsolved Mysteries Rewind’s Missing Segment Series of Podcasts.  I am unsure why this particular segment was removed but if you have some ideas please email me at [email protected]

Please join Mark and Amy as we discuss this unsolved and shocking case. 

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

On the morning of August 18, 1987, Todd McAfee has not unlocked the gates of the sprawling 300-acre tomato farm he manages to let his workers in for the day. A short time later, Todd’s assistant Adam opens the gates and it is immediately apparent that something is very wrong. His truck isn’t parked behind his car, as it usually is. His home is in complete disarray, and his gun collection is missing. Upon further inspection of Todd’s truck, the keys are still in the ignition, last night’s groceries still lying there, and Todd’s glasses are in the bed of the truck…covered in blood.

A few miles away, a truckload of Todd’s employees are at a drainage ditch, looking for water for their overheated truck. There, they find Todd McAfee lying in the drainage ditch. He was shot 4 times.

Join Mark & Amy in their first “missing segment” episode of Unsolved Mysteries Rewind. This will be our last episode of 2021, and you will NOT want to miss what we have in store in 2022!

We wish you Happy Holidays & a very Happy New Year! We will see you in 2022!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

Imagine all the joy & excitement of moving your family into the house of your dreams. As you and your children move about the house, doing renovations and exploring…you find out you are all being watched. This is what happened to Derek & Maria Broaddus. They would find threatening notes in their mailbox for years, never knowing who was watching, and how they knew all about this family.

Join Mark & Amy as they take the small East Coast town of Westfield, New Jersey to dive in to the Case of The Watcher.

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

Was it suicide, or was it murder?

Travel back to British Columbia with Mark & Amy as we take a look at Cindy James. A woman who was either severely mentally ill, or who was being wrongly accused by the RCMP.

Join us, as we attempt to unravel the case that has been aptly named…Scared To Death, episode below!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

In 1996, Blair Adams began acting strangely. A construction foreman in Surrey, British Columbia who has always been known for his clear-minded levelheadedness, he was suddenly paranoid. Convinced he was being hunted down and soon to be murdered, he tried unrelentingly to cross the border into the United States. After being refused entry twice, he finally was able to make it across the Canadian border into the United States. His behavior increasingly erratic, he quickly made his way to Knoxville, TN, all the while, his mental state deteriorating. Six days after his journey began, he was found dead in a parking lot half-naked and beaten. With virtually no clues to lead investigators to what caused Blair’s tragic demise, the investigation came to a screeching halt. Still an open case, cold case investigators are still striving for any clue that would create leads for them to follow.

Join Mark & Amy (in her first UMR episode) as they take a deep dive into the tragic, mysterious death of Blair Adams. A story entitled “Journey to Murder”

A link to Journey to Murder which is presented in Unsolved Mysteries Season 9 Episode 17 is below

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

Mark is joined by Laura all the way from South Australia to discuss the complicated and heartbreaking case of Greg Webb and the murder of Anna Anton. Unsolved Mysteries did a pretty good job covering this case and you can find a link to the Season 2 Episode 4 below – the segment is named “Bad Chief”

Laura, you did a great job and I can’t thank you enough – I hope you return to the show to discuss many cases in the next weeks and months!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

Chaim Weiss, 15, was a student in the Yeshiva of Long Beach, New York. On November 1, 1986, his body was found by a dorm counselor after he was late to Shabbat morning prayers. His murder remains unsolved, though investigators believe the murderer was a student or faculty member of the yeshiva.

The Daily News called it “one of New York’s most baffling unsolved mysteries”

Join Mark and Lindsay as they discuss this baffling case!

Lindsay and Mark are currently working on another true crime podcast which focusses on The Crimes of Long Island. Please give us listen!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

In 1981, Su Young and Su-Ya Kim were married and soon moved to the United States from Korea. By 1991, they both lived in New York with their two sons and owned two successful stores. However, their happy life was ruined on June 29. Su-Ya dropped her two sons off at their grandmother’s house and went shopping. When her husband came home later, she had not returned, and he later found her car parked in their parking garage with the engine stone cold. The next day, police identified the remains of a young woman has Su Ya’s. She had been murdered by nine stab wounds from a unknown man; her remains coldly dumped in a trash dumpster. Police determined that she had been the victim of random violence, but were able to find a witness. Before her body was found, a security guard witnessed an unidentified man early in the morning acting strangely around the garbage can that was later found to have contained Su Ya’s remains. The man soon left and the security guard began looking through the garbage and found her body. He hailed a passing ambulance, but Su-Ya had been dead for several hours. The security guard gave a description of the man and the license plate, which was later found to belong to a Taiwanese college student who had nothing to do with the case. Police began looking at the security guard as a suspect, until a lie detector test proved he had nothing to do with the murder either. The police are now looking for leads in her murder. For nearly two years, husband Su-Young Kim stayed in the United States, but the memories of his wife proved too painful to bear. In April of 1993, he shut down his business and returned with his two little boys to South Korea, his wife’s killer’s identity still a mystery.

Join Dr. Lindsay Weisner and Mark Jeacoma as we look back at this tragic case which took place in 1980’s around Long Island!

Unsolved Mysteries covered this story in their Season 6 Episode 5 episode linked below!

Lindsay and Mark are currently working on another true crime podcast which focusses on The Crimes of Long Island. Please give us listen!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

Lindsay and Mark discuss the very mysterious murder of Jamie Santos on October 27th 1991.

Unsolved Mysteries covered this story in their Season 9 Episode 9 episode linked below!

Lindsay and Mark are currently working on another true crime podcast which focusses on The Crimes of Long Island. Please give us listen!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g

Mark and Catharine cover the first of what Unsolved Mysteries fans know as a, “Missing Segment”.

In February 1987, Mark and Debbie Tallman bought a second hand bunk bed to use for their growing family. Shortly after they brought the bunk beds home, all hell broke lose. Join us for a deep dive!

Thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g