Stephen Kinzer - Author & Veteran New York Times Correspondent | Chas Freeman - Former U.S. Ambassador to Saudi Arabia | Amy Myers Jaffe - Executive Director of Energy & Sustainability at UC Davis | Phyllis Bennis - Director of the New Internationalism Project at Institute for Policy Studies | Andrew Bacevich - Author & Professor of International Relations & History at Boston University. How will low oil prices and the inexorable shift to clean energy affect the Middle East, and how should America’s relationship with the region change in response?